1 Compliance Index – Environmental Compliance/Performance Measure Poor AverageHigh 0100 National Environmental Partnership Summit, Baltimore, Maryland.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

ISO EMS OVERVIEW FOR CONTRACTORS

Advertisements

GIS APPLICATIONS IN SELECTION OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL SITES

DEQ Mission By the end of the decade, Virginians will enjoy cleaner water available for all uses, improved air quality that supports communities and ecosystems,

Ready Mix Concrete Sector: Fisheries Act Compliance Environmental Stewardship Branch Rodger Albright Feb 17,

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act

1 Stakeholder Consultation Agency Department of Labor (DOL) DRAFT Strategic Plan FY Draft: February 22, 2010.

Operator Performance Appraisal Byron Tilly RS Unit Manager, SEPA.

Ⅱ Ⅱ Ⅲ Ⅲ Ⅳ Ⅳ Ⅰ Ⅰ Ⅰ Ⅰ To increase Efficiency for EIA implementation. 1.1 General purpose of Post-Project management To meet within the levels.

Ministry of Health and Long Term Care Performance Improvement and Compliance Branch Compliance Management Program Presentation to the North East Family.

Measuring Environmental Performance: Beyond the Beans – San Diego County’s EPIC Pilot Project 16 th ANNUAL CIHC CONFERENCE December 4, 2006 presented by:

ISO EMS CONTRACTOR OVERVIEW May /26/10ISO EMS CONTRACTOR OVERVIEW TRAINING ISO EMS OVERVIEW TRAINING Contents What is ISO

TRU Waste Processing Center Culture and Successful Implementation of an ISO Certified Environmental Management System Presented at the DOE ISM Conference.

Wenxin Zhang Department of Civic Design University of Liverpool

1 MEASURING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE NATION’S FOODSERVICE AND RETAIL FOOD PROTECTION SYSTEM.

XIX World Congress on Safety and Health at Work A Regulator’s Journey to Harmonisation 14 September 2011 John Watson General Manager Work Health and Safety.

Part of the BRE Trust Protecting People, Property and the Planet BREEAM In-Use: the international sustainability standard for existing buildings – quick,

1 Performance Track: Addressing EPA’s Significant Environmental Issues 2008 Performance Track State Conference Lisa Grogan-McCulloch Performance Track.

1 Inspection of LCPs: System for Inspection. ECENA Training Workshop Bristol, March 2008.

Life Cycle Overview & Resources. Life Cycle Management What is it? Integrated concept for managing goods and services towards more sustainable production.

1 Module 4: Designing Performance Indicators for Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Programs.

Workshop, 12/3/2004 Banska Bystrica – SLOVAC REPUBLIC “INTEGRATED LICENCE PROCEDURE (Greek case)” Katerina Iakovidou-Anastasiadou Hellenic Ministry for.

TRAINING SOLUTIONS SHERQMAT For more information contact Victoria: (Tel) (Fax) ( )

UMR’s Environmental Management System. What is an Environmental Management System? Development of an EMS is a voluntary approach to improving UMR’s environmental.

Presented to: By: Date: Safety Management Systems Oklahoma FFSHC Stephanie Schroeder, CSP November 14, 2013.

CDS Operational Risk Management - October 28, 2005 Existing Methodologies for Operational Risk Mitigation - CDS’s ERM Program ACSDA Seminar - October 26.

TRP Chapter Chapter 3.1 Regulatory approaches.

UNEP Training Resource Manual Topic 11 Slide 1 Aims of EIA implementation and follow up are to: F carry out conditions of approval F ensure they work effectively.

Environmental auditing

Emission control in Bulgaria The involved institutions at national and local (sub-national) levels in Emissions inventory are Ministry of Environment.

Nuclearsafety.gc.ca Joint Congress on Medical Imaging and Radiation Sciences May 28, 2015 e-Doc CNSC Administrative Monetary Penalties Overview.

Proximity Analysis Sector Compliance Branch, Ontario Ministry of Environment National Environmental Partnership Summit May 8, 2007.

Key issues of measuring the effectiveness of compliance assurance Eugene Mazur OECD Environment Directorate.

Organization and Implementation of a National Regulatory Program for the Control of Radiation Sources Inspection Part II.

ENCOURAGING BEYOND COMPLIANCE BEHAVIOUR Presentation to the Great Lakes Pollution Prevention Roundtable Daniel Cayen Ontario Ministry of the Environment.

From Strategy to Results Case Study on Integrated Planning from Ontario Ministry of the Environment Operations Division National Environmental Partnership.

The Use of Environmental Management Systems in Permitting Decisions National Environmental Partnership Summit 2006 May 10, 2006 Christine Steagall SC Department.

REDIA Analysis of the environmental inspections in different Autonomous Communities of Spain Jesús Angel Ocio REDIA Committee member Córdoba, 15th April.

Small Drinking Water Systems Program Overview Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care Public Health Protection and Prevention Branch Environmental Health.

Paul Leinster Director Environmental Protection. Overview Spearheads Regulatory & Charging Strategy Move towards Environmental Risk Based Regulation Integration.

1 UST Stakeholders Meeting Compliance & Enforcement “C/E 101” MassDEP January 2012.

Joint European Commission – IMPEL Seminar on Environmental Inspections Wednesday 17 November 2010 Hotel Le Meredien, Brussels 1.

PhRMA Perspective on FDA Final Report FDA Advisory Committee on Pharmaceutical Sciences October 20, 2004 G.P. Migliaccio, Pfizer Inc.

Module 3: Using Statistics for Benchmarking and Comparison Common Measures Training Chelmsford, MA September 28, 2006.

TWM ® Waste and Resource Tracking System Entech Industries Pty Ltd November 3, 2005 Presented by: Dr Karl Baltpurvins.

Ontario Public Health Standards and Protocols APHEO Core Indicators Strategic Planning December 5, 2008 Joanne Thanos Public Health Standards Branch.

Implementation and follow up Critically important but relatively neglected stages of EIA process Surveillance, monitoring, auditing, evaluation and other.

Compliance Promotion Formalizing an Approach to Support Stakeholder Compliance.

Measurement and Targeting – Design and Implement Programs to Track Results and Accountability National Environmental Partnership Summit 2006 Wednesday,

Waste Auditing: A Practical Overview and Guide. What is a Waste Audit ?

MOHLTC Audit Review Process Payment Accountability Unit Presentation to Independent Diagnostic Clinics Association September 25, 2015 Health Services Branch.

LEA Conference, October 18, CIWMB Proposed Compliance Strategy Lorraine Van Kekerix Division Chief Compliance Evaluation & Enforcement Division.

DOE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION PROGRAM WORKSHOP BIOTA PROTECTION Stephen L. Domotor (202)

1 Please read this before using presentation This presentation is based on content presented at the Mines Safety Roadshow.

Presentation to Association Municipalities of Ontario Implementation of Management of Excess Soil - A Guide for Best Management Practices Ministry of the.

Bjørn Bauer Manager of PlanMiljø Danish Inspection Guidelines IMPEL Management Reference Book AC IMPEL Project – Training and institutional analyses Support.

Smooth Sailing Ahead Partnering With Sustainability and Waste Compliance & Mitigation Fernando Berton, CIWMB.

Cross Media Inspections of Solid Waste Facilities Jerry Henderson CDPHE Solid Waste and Material Management Unit.

Payment Integrity Program Independent Health Facilities Unit Presentation to IDCA Presented by: George Clarke Diagnostic Services & Planning Branch Date:

1 Indiana Department of Environmental Management Budget Presentation FY

MICHAEL E. SCOTT, DEPUTY DIRECTOR DIVISION OF WASTE MANAGEMENT Available Information on the Beneficial Reuse of Coal Combustion Products 1.

Improving performance, reducing risk Dr Apostolos Noulis, Lead Assessor, Business Development Mgr Thessaloniki, 02 June 2014 ISO Energy Management.

Learn Integrated Management System Documentation Process with Ready-to-use EQHSMS Documentation Kit

1 Workers’ Compensation Compliance Presentation Andrew Sabolic, Chief Bureau of Compliance Division of Workers’ Compensation Phone: (850)

Safety Management Systems Session Four Safety Promotion APTA Webinar June 9, 2016.

1 PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON MINERAL RESOURCES DISCUSSION ON THE MINERAL RESOURCES 2014 / 15 STRATEGIC PLAN 8-9 July 2014 Programme 3 – Mineral Regulation.

“Engaging Compliance”: Attempting to improve engagement with Dairy Effluent Compliance in the Waikato Region Scott Cantley Proactive Monitoring programme.

COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITIES HIGHVELD AND VAAL PRIORITY AREAS – MINIMUM EMISSION STANDARDS (MES) PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE MEETING 14 JUNE 2017 Chemicals.

First Nation Waste Management Initiative

Introduction Last comprehensive review was undertaken in 2012/2013

PRTR data application for local environmental management

Presentation transcript:

1 Compliance Index – Environmental Compliance/Performance Measure Poor AverageHigh 0100 National Environmental Partnership Summit, Baltimore, Maryland May 20th, 2008

2 Compliance Index – Overview Present Ontario’s experience in conducting an inspection & enforcement program Discuss compliance performance indicator Present methodology and actual results Benefits of Compliance Index

3 Some Details…. Ontario is a province just over 1 million square kilometres (400,000 sq mi) Ontario could cover as many as 13 states

4 Sector Compliance Branch…. Conducts province-wide inspections of industrial sectors, to ensure that they are in compliance with Ontario’s environmental laws, in order to reduce the threat to human health and environment Undertakes education and outreach initiatives to help promote compliance Publicly reports compliance performance and trends to encourage proactive compliance Committed to continuous improvement in compliance programs

5 Risk Based Approach….. SCB employs a risk assessment method to assess the relative environmental risks of industrial and commercial sectors for the purposes of prioritizing planned inspections Conducts a proximity analysis to rank the facilities in a specific industrial sector according to distance to their sensitive receptors 120 m 65 m

6 Select High-Risk Sectors Conduct Risk Assessment Sector Planning Provincial Inspection Sweep Enforcement Action Undertake Sector Diagnostics Measure Compliance Levels Public Reporting Sector Outreach Internal *Compliance Assistance *Gaps / Issues Compliance Improvement Activity SCB Business Model…..

7 Why Compliance Index….. Provide Ministry with an outcome based performance measurement for facility and sector compliance levels Provide a real-time compliance assessment methodology Facilitate effective decision-making when targeting sectors and facilities Provide an effective tool to evaluate results and provide comparisons

8 Compliance Index….. The Compliance Index is a measure of relative compliance levels, based on types of legislative violations (e.g., exceedance of a regulatory limit, non-compliance with permit or CofA conditions, etc.) CI Formula:  Vw +  Cw Vw = weighted legislative violation Cw = weighted CofA conditions violation

9 Steps in CI Development….. Identify the number of potential legislative violations that may result from an inspection Categorize violations into four contravention categories (e.g, reporting and record keeping) Assign weights to each contravention category that reflect level of environmental significance Provide weights to each violation Vw Repeat steps for C of A condition violations Cw Determine CI value (by Company, by media, by program)

10 CI score represents a baseline numerical value for a facility environmental compliance levels Higher the score, the lower the compliance with environmental legislation Facility Score…..

11 Facility Score within Haz. Waste Sector….. Company NamePass/FailVwCwCI Score __________A Fail33235 __________B Fail42731 __________C Fail72330 __________D Fail22830 __________E Fail __________F Fail81927 __________G Fail52126 __________H Fail026 __________I Fail61824 __________J Fail91423 __________K Fail41923 __________L Fail021 __________M Fail31720 __________N Fail9918 __________O Fail41418

12 CI score provided relative compliance level of facilities within different media inspections. Higher the score, the lower the compliance with environmental legislation Company NameMedia Pass/ FailVwCwCI A……. WasteFail 020 B…… WaterFail41418 C…… WastePass11516 D…… AirFail8715 E…… AirFail4711 F…… WasteFail4711 G…… WasteFail4711 H…… AirFail4711 I…….. WaterFail4711 J…… AirFail4711 K…… WasteFail6410 L…… AirFail279 M…… AirFail448 N…… WasteFail178 O…… WaterPass 088 P…… WasteFail8 08 Q…… WasteFail448 Score for All Media inspections…..

13  The CI score provided relative compliance level of facilities within air media inspections. Company NameMedia Pass/ FailVwCwCI A AirFail015 B AirFail4711 C AirFail088 D AirFail077 E AirFail7 0 7 F AirFail077 G AirFail077 H AirFail077 I AirPass077 J AirFail077 K AirFail606 L AirPass606 M AirPass606 N AirFail606 O AirFail606 P AirFail202 q AirFail202 Score for Air Media inspections…..

14 SECTORInspections Total CI Score Sector Avg CI MaxCI MinCI SDCI Var Hazardous Waste Auto wrecking/recycling Primary Metals Used Tire Sites Score for Sector…..

15 TIMMINS Fiscal 2004/05 Fiscal 2005/06 (till Aug 06) Company NameProgramModule TypePass/FailCIPass/FailCI Compliance Performance A Waste - Hazardous & Liquid industrialSubject Waste GeneratorFail7 7 No Change B Waste - Solid/Non-hazardous Solid Non-Hazardous Waste Disposal SiteFail15Fail15 No change C Waste - Hazardous & Liquid industrialSubject Waste GeneratorPass0 0 No change D AirAir FacilityFail4Pass2 - 2 E AirAir FacilityFail F Waste - Solid/Non-hazardousClosed Waste Disposal SiteFail7Pass6 - 3 G AirAir FacilityFail10Pass0 Total Compliance H Waste - Solid/Non-hazardous Solid Non-Hazardous Waste Disposal SiteFail2Pass0 Total Compliance I Waste - Solid/Non-hazardous Solid Non-Hazardous Waste Disposal SiteFail j Waste - Hazardous & Liquid industrialSubject Waste GeneratorFail5Pass0 Total Compliance Change in numerical value indicates compliance performance status: (-)improvement /(+)decline Comparison of CI Score on re-inspection…..

16 All Sector inspectors are required to enter violations information in CAMEO for all inspections that have been conducted. Officer identifies non- compliance (Y/N) Score is calculated in the background How to in System (Cameo)…..

17 Provides performance measurement for facility, sector and media/program compliance levels Increases the objectivity in compliance ratings that will help avoid different facilities being ranked at the same levels (Fail/Pass) of non-compliance Improves determination of inspection targets, and also provides an indicator to gauge the level of compliance improvement Reduces subjectivity and provides provincial consistency when ranking facilities based on risk Component of larger risk assessment framework for the division Key indicator of compliance improvement as well as program success Benefits of Compliance Index…..

18 Rajeev Narang Ministry of the Environment Sector Compliance Branch Continuous Improvement Unit 305 Milner Avenue, Suite 1000 Scarborough, Ontario M1B 3V4 Tel: (416) Contact…..