Testing of Unknown Foundation: A Case Study with Comparison of Different NDT Methods Present at Ohio Transportation Engineering Conference Oct 23-24, 2007 Bill X. Yu Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Case Western Reserve University, OH, USA, ,
Acknowledgements Jian Fang, Josh Adams, Guoming Lin, WPC, Inc., 2201 Rowland Avenue, Savannah, GA 31404, Bin Zhang, Case Western Reserve University
Introduction Project Background St. Joseph hospital expansion
NDT Testing Plan After WPC Inc. Report, 2006
Impact Echo: Testing Schematic
Impact Echo: On-site Photos
Impact Echo: Examples of Analyzed Signals
Parallel Seismic Testing Schematic Borehole SCPT
Parallel Seismic Test: Photo During Test
Parallel Seismic Testing: Ground Conditions by SCPT
Parallel Seismic Testing: Recorded Signal
Parallel Seismic Testing: After Signal Processing
Parallel Seismic Testing: Wave Train Determination
Parallel Seismic Testing: Wave Train
Parallel Seismic Testing: Wave Train Validation
Parallel Seismic: Sensitivity Analyses
Magnetometer Method: Principle
Magnetometer: Validation of Concept 1 ft Vertical motion
Magnetometer: Validation of Concept Vertical cyclic motion of rodSlow vertical motion of rod At distance of 1 ft
Magnetometer: Validation of Concept
Magnetometer Method: Recorded signal
Magnetometer: Signal Analyses for Pile Length
Design Recommendations Based on Testing Results 50 Ton
Advantages and Pitfalls Impact Echo Fast, easy Challenge in signal interpretation Influence of internal reflection (due to geometry, crack etc) Signal attenuation with depth Wave modes Source of error: assumption of wave speed
Advantages and Pitfalls (cont.) Parallel Seismic Method Requires borehole Less influenced by pile integrity Requires careful signal interpretation Wave trains Inflection point
Advantages and Pitfalls (cont.) Magnetometer Method Fast, easy Requires borehole Can be influenced by soil strata
Summary of Experience Geophysical methods are important tools to supplement engineering decisions Different testing methods can serve Properly applied Properly interpreted Geotechnical complexity needs to be considered
Thank you !