3rd Stage Review: Lead Reviewers Experience Outline: –Objectives –Overview of technical findings –Lessons Learned/Confirmed –Value of 3 rd Stage –Lead.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Data needs in future GHG emission control regimes Technical Workshop on Emissions from Aviation and maritime Transport Oslo 4/5 October 2007 Jakob Graichen.

Advertisements

Introductory presentation by the UNFCCC secretariat Workshop on emissions projections from Annex I Parties Bonn, 6-8 September 2004 Stelios Pesmajoglou,

Climate Change Committee WG1 QA/QC terminology and requirements from the IPCC Good Practice Guidance and the Guidelines for National Inventory Systems.

EUROPEAN TOPIC CENTRE ON AIR AND CLIMATE CHANGE Priorities and Recommendations for EEA and its ETC/ACC 3th joint TFEIP and EIONET Workshop May 7, 2002.

Guidebook and “MIP” Actions Recommend acceptance of GB (all chapters) to EMEP SB. –Opportunity to make minor editorial changes after May. Collation of.

Task Force on National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Tier 3 Approaches, Complex Models or Direct Measurements, in Greenhouse Gas Inventories Report of the.

1 Emission data needs for international reporting and assessments Joint UNECE and EIONET workshop on emission inventories and projections 6-8 May 2002,

Review of UNECE Informative Inventory Reports (IIRs) in 2011 Justin Goodwin: ETC-ACC Supported by EEA TFEIP Meeting Stockholm 2 – 3th May 2011.

Review of the Gothenburg Protocol – Emission quality Kristin Rypdal, TFEIP Chair.

1 Workshop on Quality Control and Quality Assurance of Greenhouse Gas Inventories and the Establishment of National Inventory Systems 2-3 September 2004.

1 Introduction, reporting requirements, workshop objectives Workshop on greenhouse gas and ammonia emission inventories and projections from agriculture.

WMO UNEP INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGE NATIONAL GREENHOUSE GAS INVENTORIES PROGRAMME WMO UNEP IPCC Good Practice Guidance Simon Eggleston Technical.

National circumstances and inventories of GHG emissions Mirja Kosonen UNFCCC WS, Dublin.

Revisions of the protocols Potential elements for strengthening emission reporting.

Air Quality Governance in the ENPI East Countries Training on emission inventories The EMEP/EEA Guidebook General chapters January, 2014, Chișin.

Stage 3 Review: TFEIP/ETC-ACC Karin Kindbom, Martin Adams & Justin Goodwin.

UNDP-GEF Adaptation 0 0 Impact of National Communications on Process of Integrating Climate Change into National Development Policies UNFCCC Workshop on.

CLRTAP co-operation project seminar Karin Kindbom, 16 April 2013  Black carbon emission inventory  Emission inventory and emission inventory system.

1 Planning of the Stage 3 In-depth Review 2008 Joint TFEIP/EIONET air emissions meeting Tallinn, May 2008 Martin Adams Expert Panel on Review European.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU. Quality Assurance José Viegas Ribeiro IGF, Portugal SIGMA.

GAINS, air emission inventories and data completeness Karin Kindbom IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute Russian-Swedish bilateral cooperation.

Quality assurance / Quality control system for the Greek GHG emissions inventory Yannis Sarafidis, Elena Georgopoulou UNFCCC Workshop on National Systems.

INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGE NATIONAL GREENHOUSE GAS INVENTORIES PROGRAMME WMO UNEP Volume I General Guidance and Reporting Bonn, 18 may 2006.

Agenda and introduction to the session Alexander Romanov SRI Stefan Åström IVL.

Managing Quality in the Finnish Greenhouse Gas Inventory Leena Raittinen, Statistics Finland Q2008 Conference, Rome 10 July 2008.

Draft Format for an Inventory Report to LRTAP. Why? One important conclusion from the review activities in 2003 and 2004 is that it is difficult to make.

1 Upgrading of the Framework Requirements for the Development of VQS in Bulgaria Dr Cloud Bai-Yun May 2006, Sofia EuropeAid/120164/D/SV/BG.

Stocktaking Exercise UNFCCC Workshop, Manila Ravi Sharma United Nations Environment Programme – Global Environment Facility.

Review of the Gothenburg Protocol: WGSR Conclusions Review of the Gothenburg Protocol: WGSR Conclusions 8th Joint TFEIP/EIONET Meeting Dublin, October.

UNFCCC secretariat Ruta Bubniene, Programme officer, Reporting and Review unit, Mitigation and Data Analysis programme Overview of the synthesis report.

Current situation concerning national inventory system in Ukraine 1. Previous national inventories Up to date 3 national inventories were prepared and.

Recommendation 2001/331/EC: Review and relation to sectoral inspection requirements Miroslav Angelov European Commission DG Environment, Unit A 1 Enforcement,

Overview of the previous work of the CGE First meeting of reconstituted Consultative Group of Experts on National Communications from Parties not included.

The links to global problems Presentation at the 25 th anniversary special event of the Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution “Past successes.

The Swedish air emission inventory system Karin Kindbom IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute Russian-Swedish bilateral cooperation project: “Development.

Towards a National Alliance against Chronic Respiratory Diseases Nikolai Khaltaev, MD, PhD March 2006, GARD General Meeting, Beijing, China.

The Swedish air emission inventory system Karin Kindbom IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute Russian-Swedish bilateral cooperation project: “Development.

Guidelines for non-Annex I National Communications Implications for Assessment of Impacts of, and Adaptation to Climate Change Asia-Pacific Regional Workshop.

Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.

Quality of current PM emission inventories Kristin Rypdal, Chair of Task Force on Emission Inventories and Projections With input from Zbigniew Klimont.

The Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution: Emission reporting obligations and outputs Brinda Wachs Secretary, Task Force on Emission Inventories.

European Union emission inventory report 1990–2011 under the UNECE Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution (LRTAP) EU LRTAP inventory team.

The Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution: Revision of the Emission Reporting Guidelines Brinda Wachs Secretary, TFEIP, UNECE The Convention.

UNDP Guidance for National Communication Project Proposals UNFCCC Workshop on the Preparation of National Communications from non-Annex I Parties Manila,

UNITED NATIONS ECONOMIC COMMISSION FOR EUROPE EMISSION DATA REPORTING UNDER LRTAP Task Force on Emission Inventories and Projections: Oct. 2004,

Tinus Pulles, Jeroen Kuenen & Justin Goodwin What has been achieved? The draft Revised Guidebook.

Informal Summary of LULUCF Technical Briefing: SBSTA 39 Overview of presentations and discussion.

European Topic Centre Air and Climate Change (ETC/ACC) Priority EIONET data flows and EEA reference centre Manfred Ritter 10 May 2001.

1 Emission data needs for assessments and international reporting Joint UNECE and EIONET workshop on emission inventories and projections 9-11 May 2001,

Impact analysis during the harmonisation process with the EU and effects on Lithuanian economy Giedrius Kadziauskas, Senior Policy analyst 23 rd Fabruary.

Combustion & Industry, Transport, Agriculture & Nature Panels Expert Panels Panels are ad hoc. Currently three ‘sector’ panels: –Combustion and Industry.

A Quick Review of IIRs in 2010 Justin Goodwin: ETC-ACC Supported by EEA.

Draft meeting conclusions From the chairs. Focus next year HM/POPs –Scientific –Review PM follow up –Updates –Task group, ancillary data –Possible link.

. Steering Group on Climate Change-Related Statistics Purpose and objective Expert Forum for producers and users of climate change-related statistics 2-3.

Cambodia National Work Plan

The Quality of an Emission Inventory

Global Climate Change Alliance: Intra-ACP Programme

Revision of the Emission Reporting Guidelines

Recommendations from the Stage 3 Trial Review

CAFE SG 23 November Brussels

Guidance on Natura 2000 and Forests – Scoping Document

Guidance on Natura 2000 and Forests – Scoping Document

Experiences from the 2006 Stage 3 trial centralised review

Task Force on Target Setting and Reporting TFTSR

Energy Statistics Compilers Manual

Mandate & Outputs expected for 2004

Outline of the EU greenhouse gas emission trend report

Revised emission reporting Guidelines – Projection issues

TFEIP Methods and Procedures

Presentation transcript:

3rd Stage Review: Lead Reviewers Experience Outline: –Objectives –Overview of technical findings –Lessons Learned/Confirmed –Value of 3 rd Stage –Lead Reviewers Proposals for the Future

Objectives: Produce technical and informative review reports for reviewed Parties Contribute to the development of UNECE/NEC review Evaluate the opportunities for Harmonisation with UNFCCC

Review Report Based on UNFCCC template

Technical findings Trends, dips and jumps in the inventory time- series. Methods, emission factors and assumptions used for sectors in the inventory. Some time-series inconsistency, methodology based changes in the inventory. Quality and professionalism Limited resources.

Lessons Learned/Confirmed Harmonisation with UNFCCC process? –Completeness of review (Pollutants, sectors) –Science vs compliance –Practices and procedures Streamline and focus outputs –Highlight good practice –Make recommendations for improvement Number of Parties reviewed Mandate to review against Good practice basis for methods IIRs difficult to interpret Need for more review procedures and training

Policy oriented quality Science oriented quality Do We Verification or Validation? True ? verification Guidelines applied ? validation Real world emissions Emission inventory ?

Differences between UNFCCC and LRTAP conventions Greenhouse gasesAir pollutants Limited problems with abatement numerous technological and other controls complicates time-series analysis Relatively stable reporting format regular revision of the reporting format in the past Targets set as relative decrease Targets set as absolute levels Limited number of gasesLong list of pollutants Limited number of sector / gas combination extensive variety of possible changes in emission factors and combination of pollutants / sources / technologies

Value of 3 rd Stage Review Understand, prioritise and solve the real issues with reported inventories. –Brings together the many issues identified in Stage 1 & 2 opportunity for inventory experts to exchange ideas and learn from each other (strengthen the “Community”) profile to attract attention from high up in Parties organisations and get support from ministries for quality inventory compilation. –Reaches the political agenda Essential follow up to stage 1 & 2…….?

Review next step proposals 1: Establish a clear driver and purpose for review –continuous inventory improvement and/or compliance assessment linked to the explicit and implicit requirements of the protocols and the EU directives (if appropriate) 2: To drive forward a stable review platform –Countries reporting enough detail in a transparent, consistent and timely way (Activity data & IIR) –Specific unambiguous mandatory requirements for detailed transparent and consistent reporting (The guidelines) –Clear technical guidelines (the Guidebook) 3: A Plan for 3 rd stage reviews –Format, resources, responsibilities, experts, material, training, scope (pollutants, sectors, parties, mandate), outputs, templates, guidance documents and timings.