1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Midwest ISO from a Transmission Owner Perspective.
Advertisements

WECC/TEPPC Response to DOE Funding Opportunity Status Update June 29, 2009 Bradley Nickell Renewable Integration and Planning Director.
2007 Goals. Introduction Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) will be primarily defined throughout the 2007 year by Electric Reliability.
March 26, 2014 Transmission Coordination and Planning Committee 2014 Q1 Stakeholder Meeting.
Evaluating the Benefits of the SPP EHV Buildout Moving forward on policy for funding 765 KV Larry Holloway CAWG Meeting February 25, 2009.
Wind Energy and Transmission South Dakota Legislative Briefing Pierre, South Dakota January 18, 2006 Beth Soholt Director Wind on the Wires.
Transmission Transporting Electricity by Wire Darcy Neigum Montana-Dakota Utilities Co.
Queue Reform at the Midwest ISO NARUC February, 2008.
Citizens League Electrical Energy: Affordability and Competitive Pricing Working Team Electric Transmission.
THE POWER OF POSSIBILITY Electric Transmission System Development in Alberta Neil J. Brausen, P. Eng., Director System Planning APEGGA Calgary Branch Luncheon.
Highway-Byway Cost Allocation: What it Offers MISO January 2010 Presented to the Organization of MISO States CARP and the Midwest ISO RECB Task Force Meeting.
NWPP MC Initiative WECC Update March 25th, 2015 Kathy Anderson
Jeffery J. Gust IOWA INDUSTRIAL ENERGY GROUP FALL CONFERENCE Tuesday, October 14, 2014 MidAmerican Energy Company.
Electric Power Infrastructure: Status and Challenges for the Future Mark Lauby Director, Reliability Assessments and Performance Analysis.
RenewElec October 21, 2010 Robert Nordhaus, David Yaffe Van Ness Feldman 1050 Thomas Jefferson Street, NW Washington, DC (202) FERC’s.
The Transmission Imperative November 3, 2011 Jay Caspary.
Transmission Incentives P. Kumar Agarwal Acting Director, Division of Reliability & Engineering Services Federal Energy Regulatory Commission U.S. DOE,
PacifiCorp Participation in the California ISO. 2 Full participation provides significant benefits beyond those of the Energy Imbalance Market EIM BenefitsFull.
The Value of Electric Transmission NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 25, 2012.
PJM© PJM Confidential PJM Generation Interconnection Overview Virginia Offshore Wind Conference Virginia Beach June 22, 2011 Paul McGlynn General.
Need for Transmission Investment 2010 Mid-American Regulatory Conference AEP.
Integration of Variable Generation Task Force Preliminary Conclusions and Actions.
Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People Performance Targets for the Customer Interconnection Process January, 2008.
10/03/ Report on Existing and Potential Electric System Constraints and Needs Within the ERCOT Region October 3, 2002.
Kansas Renewable Energy Conference September 26th, 2007.
OSC Meeting April 27, Transmission Cost Allocation Overview.
Overview of WECC and Regulatory Structure
Sec. 5 RE-REGULATION- EPAct 1992 FERC Orders 888 and 889 (1996) EPAct 2005 In short these three laws move the power industry towards an increase in competition.
Mandatory Electric Reliability Standards and Transmission Expansion Suedeen G. Kelly Commissioner Federal Energy Regulatory Commission The Canadian Institute.
WECC Response to DOE Funding Opportunity on Regional Planning Northwest Wind Integration Forum Steering Committee January 6, 2010 Tom Schneider Managing.
CWAG ENERGY CONFERENCE BIG SKY, MT Collaborative Efforts to Find Solutions: A Case Study – The Mountain States Transmission Intertie (MSTI) Presented by.
Integration of Variable Generation Task Force (IVGTF) & Emerging Issues Mark Lauby Manager, Reliability Assessments
Iowa State University Ames, IA July 5, 2011 Wind on the Wires – Wind and Transmission Issues Beth Soholt Wind on the Wires
Updated 1/28/2011. Cost Allocations and Affordability of Tariffs March 8, 2011 Jay Caspary ·
Integrating More Renewable Energy in the Grid Bert Garvin Vice President, Regulatory Affairs July 21, 2008 NARUC Summer Meeting July 22, 2008.
APS Overview Richard Nicosia. APS Snapshot Largest and longest serving electric utility Operations dating back to th largest employer headquartered.
Icfi.com © 2006 ICF International. All rights reserved. Wyoming Collector and Transmission System Project – Status Report Presented to: Wyoming Infrastructure.
Updated 1/28/2011.
Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People Transition of Authoritative Documents – Information Session September 2009 Doyle Sullivan Evelyn Kelly.
Transmission Issues & Renewables Perspectives of a Wind Developer.
What do we mean by “Energy?
Congestion Management in a Market Environment David Nevius Senior Vice President North American Electric Reliability Council.
SPP.org 1 SPP Mission Helping our members work together to keep the lights on – today and in the future. Updated
Designing Energy Solutions without Borders National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners.
1 NAUSCA Summer Meeting Boston June 30, 3009 David W. Hadley Vice President State Regulatory Relations Midwest ISO.
Order 1000 Implementation in PJM – Challenges and Opportunities Jodi L. Moskowitz Senior Director – Transmission Development & Strategy October 13, 2015.
FERC Staff’s Report on Demand Response and Advanced Metering.
Lauren Azar Senior Advisor to the Secretary U. S. Department of Energy May 31, 2013 – WI Public Utilities Institute 1 Transmission Planning – A National.
Overview of the Grid Clean Power Plan and Tribes October 15, 2015 webinar.
SPP.org 1. Status Update for Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting September 16, 2008 Austin, TX.
SPP.org Transmission Expansion and Cost Allocations for FERC SPP-Entergy CBA 1.
SPP.org 1. Final Report: Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting December 1, 2008 Austin, TX.
Overview of the Grid Randy Manion, Western Area Power Admin. EPA Clean Power Plan Workshops Farmington, NM, December 7 and 8, 2015 Tuba City, AZ, December.
Updated 1/28/2011. Renewables Integration Plans and Challenges March 8, 2011 Jay Caspary ·
© 2000 PACIFICORP kV LINE WALLA WALLA – WALLULA – Mc NARY 500 kV LINE HEMINGWAY – CAPTAIN JACK – REGIONAL PLANNING MEETING REGIONAL PLANNING PROJECT.
TRANSMISSION INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS — Current Projects — The Center for the New West “ The Sun Valley Energy Roundtables 2006” November 30 – December.
Lessons Learned from Existing RTOs John Moore January WCEA Meeting January 7 th, 2016.
Kansas City Power & Light and KCP&L Greater Missouri Operations – Suggestions for Chapter 22 Revisions Missouri Public Service Commission Meeting Aug 31,
Regional Transmission Expansion Project Staff Council Briefing Tom Kaiserski (MT) Program Manager February 15, 2011 Governor’s Office of Economic Development.
4/16/2010 Regional Planning Group Meeting Long-Term Planning Study of the ERCOT Interconnection Warren Lasher Manager, System Assessment.
EE590 Transmission Planning Projects and Cost Allocation Ming NI Economic Studies, Midwest ISO.
EI-WECC Seams Study Needed
Nebraska Wind Conference Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Massachusetts Electric Restructuring Roundtable
Updated October 17, 2017.
Lorenzo Kristov, Ph.D. Principal, Market & Infrastructure Policy
Massachusetts Electric Restructuring Roundtable
Transmission As Enabler
Access Capacity Upgrades Larry Holloway Chief of Energy Operations
Gordon van Welie, President & Chief Executive Officer
Presentation transcript:

1

Expansion Planning and Cost Allocations Topeka, Kansas March 8, 2010 2

SPP Mission Helping our members work together to keep the lights on – today and in the future. 3

Our Beginning Founded 1941 with 11 members Utilities pooled resources to keep Arkansas aluminum plant powered for critical defense Maintained after WWII for reliability and coordination 4

SPP at a Glance Incorporated in Arkansas as a 501(c)(6) non-profit corporation FERC - Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Regulated public utility Regional Transmission Organization NERC - North American Electric Reliability Corporation Founding member Regional Entity 5 5 5

Members in nine states: Arkansas Kansas Louisiana Mississippi Missouri Nebraska New Mexico Oklahoma Texas 6

56 SPP Members 7

Reliability Coordination Tariff Administration Market Operation Our Major Services Facilitation Reliability Coordination Tariff Administration Market Operation Standards Setting Compliance Enforcement Transmission Planning Key Elements of Services Regional Independent Cost-Effective Focus on Reliability 8

3 Interconnections / 8 NERC Regions 9 9 9

Independent System Operator (ISO) / Regional Transmission Organization (RTO) Map 10

Why expand the transmission system? SPP Today Minimum for Reliable Delivery to Customers Expand Transmission More Transmission Needed Less Investment More No Limits to Low Cost Delivery Customer Energy Cost Less Amount of Transmission More 11 11 11

Current SPP Transmission System 12

Upgrades From 2009 STEP Appendix B, Upgrades with NTCs or Upgrades Currently Under Construction – All Voltages 13

Planned Transmission over last 3 years 2009 STEP 2008 STEP 2007 STEP Upgrade Type $540 $320 $290 Transmission Service Request and Generation Interconnection Service Agreements $2,110 $880 $720 Reliability - Base Plan $660 $800 $640 Reliability - Other $620 $460 Sponsored Upgrades $770 Balanced Portfolio $60 $90 Interregional Coordinated Upgrades $4.46B $2.7B $2.2B Appendix A - TOTAL Has filed Service Agreement or is BOD-approved 14

Approved Balanced Portfolio of Projects

What is Integrated Transmission Planning? Goal: Design transmission backbone to connect load to the most reasonable generation alternatives Strengthen ties to Eastern and Western Interconnections Improve connections between SPP’s east and west regions Horizons: 20, 10, and 4 year Focus: Regional, integrated with local Resulting in: Comprehensive list of needed projects for SPP region over next 20 years With 40 year financial/economic analysis Underlying Value: Reliability and Economics are inseparable 16 16

Priority Projects Near-term opportunities while transitioning to Integrated Transmission Planning process “Readily apparent” projects that continue to appear in current planning processes Relieve grid congestion Improve access to transmission service Improve transfers between SPP’s east and west regions Economic projects up to 765 kV; across SPP region 17 17 17

18

19

“Transmission Superhighway” Facilitate addition of renewable energy to grid Improve reliability by reducing chance of high-cost outages Improve access to lower-cost generation and diverse mix of generation Create economic opportunities beyond electric industry 20 20

Regional State Committee – Key to SPP’s Success Retail regulatory commissioners – Arkansas, Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas Louisiana maintains active observer status Functions Cost allocation Ensure adequate supply Market cost/benefit analyses 21

Who pays for transmission now? Type Reliability Economic Purpose Keep lights on Reduce congestion with benefit/cost ≥ 1 Also Called Base Plan Funding Balanced Portfolio Funded By Region - 33% Impacted zone- 67% Shared regionally (postage stamp) Voltage All 345 kV+ Implemented 2005 2009 22

Need Simple and Fair Cost Allocation High-voltage “highway” funded with regional rate Lower-voltage “byway” funded with local rate Voltage Regional Zonal 300 kV and above 100% 0% 100 kV - 299 kV 1/3 2/3 Below 100 kV 23

Risks and Avoided Costs Hard to overbuild EHV transmission that is a product of regional planning - Relative to cost and potential stranded investment of underbuilding Avoided costs can be significant To avoid corridor fatigue where Rights of Ways are or will become a major issue, planners must consider: Land use impacts Wildlife fragmentation, etc. 24

SPP and other Regional Plans w/ HVDC Proposals 26

Other Opportunities In Process Merchant activities in/around SPP are noteworthy and may need to be part of long range plans While transmission projects are making headlines, all these proposed HVDC projects require robust EHV networks 27

Wind Integration Task Force (WITF) Study SPP initiated operational, not economic, analysis to assess impacts of 10, 20 and 40% wind integration levels Studies focused on 10 and 20% cases, with transmission expansion based on reliability needs Significant transmission expansion required to support 10 and 20% cases with both 345 kV and 765 kV lines in several key corridors, including Woodward District EHV - Comanche 28

WITF Study Wind 29 E Nebraska W Nebraska NE Kansas Mingo / NW Kansas Spearville Wichita Hitchland Amarillo Central Oklahoma South Panhandle / New Mexico 29

Total Transmission for 10% Case 30

More Transmission Additions for 20% Case 31

Total Transmission for 20% Case 32

Conclusion Wind Integration Task Force, Priority Projects and Integrated Transmission Planning are likely to conclude the need for major EHV transmission capability between Woodward District EHV in OK and Comanche in KS e.g. 345 and 765 kV lines in that critical corridor SPP planning decisions on timing and size of corridors and EHV lines will first require support and approvals regarding cost allocation Transmission Owners are responsible for details regarding line routes, permitting, etc. 33

Summary SPP studies show the need for significant transmission capability between EHV substations at Woodward District EHV in OK and Comanche in KS not considering wind plant collector or integration facilities Decisions regarding the timing and scope for those facilities will be forthcoming, but uncertainty about cost allocation must be resolved first Line routes and permitting are responsibility of Transmission Owners in SPP 34

Heather Starnes. Manager, Regulatory Policy. 501. 614. 3380 Heather Starnes Manager, Regulatory Policy 501.614.3380 hstarnes@spp.org