National Performance of High Recycled Mixtures. 2 Outline Trends in RAP and RAS usage and practices Motivations for higher recycled contents Barriers.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Pre-eminent Supplier– Our People MAKE IT HAPPEN PAPA 54th Annual Paving Conference Hershey, PA January, 30th 2014 RAS Best Practices.
Advertisements

Background: Hot mix asphalt (HMA) is a mixture of aggregate and asphalt binder. The asphalt is a petroleum based substance and, since the oil embargo of.
Advanced Asphalt Technologies, LLC “Engineering Services for the Asphalt Industry” WHRP Project Effect of Recovered Binders from Recycled Shingles.
1Volumetric Analysis of HMA Mixtures VOLUMETRIC ANALYSIS OF HMA MIXTURES.
In the United States, there are an estimated 250 million registered vehicles traveling on four million miles of public roads. With such a large volume.
North East Asphalt User/Producer Group Steering Committee Meeting Monday March 26, 2012 Presented by: Jo Sias Daniel, University of New Hampshire © Thorndyke.
Recycled Asphalt Program & Environmental Stewardship Program (Post Consumer Content) Robert C. Rea Nebraska Department of Roads WASHTO – Omaha, Nebraska.
Office of Infrastructure R&D U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration High Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement Use in Asphalt Mixtures Canadian.
Steve Jackson, PE Technical Manager NB West Contracting As seen on shinglerecycling.org 6 th Asphalt Shingle Recycling Forum Denver, CO With Solutions.
Recruitment of the New LTPP SPS-10: Warm Mix Asphalt Experiment Gabe Cimini LTPP NCRSC Project Manager.
Chelsea Hanson  (Advisor: Eshan V. Dave  Department of Civil Engineering, University of Minnesota Duluth INTRODUCTION.
Asphalt Issues AASHTO SCOC Virginia Beach, Va. By Victor (Lee) Gallivan FHWA August 2, 2011.
Greening the Blacktop Going Green with Sustainable Asphalt RAP, Recycling, Energy and the Carbon Footprint.
John A. D’Angelo US Federal Highway Administration CUPGA 2008 Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.
Perpetual Pavements Concept and History Iowa Open House
Asphalt Rubber Asphalt Concrete Friction Course Overlay as a Pavement Preservation Strategy K. Kaloush, K. Biligiri, M. Rodezno, M. Belshe Arizona State.
Evaluation of Cracking Resistance of Superpave Mixtures Using Texas Overlay Test Syeda Rubaiyat Aziz Mustaque Hossain Greg Schieber Department of Civil.
WMA TWG December NCAT WMA Research 2007 Andrea Kvasnak.
High Recycle with WMA Fatigue Cracking Experiment AFD40(2) - April 11, 2013 Nelson Gibson, Ph.D., P.E. FHWA Office of Infrastructure R&D.
APAM Spring Conference 4/21/15 Aaron Price – Pete Capon – Rieth-Riley Construction Co. NAPA Scan Tour - Japan.
Recycled Asphalt Shingles in Texas Dale Rand, P.E.
Activities as Turner-Fairbank Highway Research Center Jack Youtcheff Materials & Construction Team Federal Highway Administration
1 Green Roadway Design from a Pavements Perspective Rene’ Renteria, P.E. ODOT Pavement Design Engineer April 13, 2010.
RAP and RAS At DelDOT Karl Zipf, Chief Chemist DelDOT 2014.
Reclaimed Asphalt Pavements “RAP” Pete Coffman. RAP ◊Uses ◊Mix Methods ◊Cost Savings ◊Concerns ◊Case Studies ◊Uses ◊Mix Methods ◊Cost Savings ◊Concerns.
Characterization of Alaskan Hot-Mix Asphalt containing RAP
Pavement Maintenance II
Saving Your Asphalt! 36 th Annual Rocky Mountain Asphalt Conference & Equipment Show February 18-20, 2009.
AAPA 2010 Study Tour – Recycled Asphalt Pavement Recycled Asphalt Pavement Trevor Distin | Cassandra Simpson.
Research Findings from the NCAT Test Track APAI Winter Conference Indianapolis, December 14, 2010.
1 Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement in Arizona - Application and Verification October 3, 2008 Arizona Association of County Engineers.
Session #3 Asphalt 103- Materials: Basics of RAP, Usage and Specifications.
Mix Designs with RAS Dr. Richard Willis National Center for Asphalt Technology at Auburn University Asphalt Shingle Recycling Forum November 8 th, 2013.
National Cooperative Highway Research Program. Superpave Mixture and Aggregate Expert Task Group Las Vegas, Nevada 16 – 18 September 2003.
A Guidance, Parameters & Recommendations for Rubblized Pavements July 2006.
Development of An Advance Overlay Design System Incorporating Both Rutting and Reflection Cracking Requirements Rick Collins TxDOT.
Warm Mix Asphalt & Recycled Asphalt Pavements
1 Hot-Mix Asphalt and Flexible Pavement Design: the MEPDG Kevin D. Hall, Ph.D., P.E. Professor and Head, Dept. of Civil Engineering University of Arkansas.
SMA South of the Border Alexander (Sandy) Brown, P.Eng. Technical Director, Ontario Hot Mix Producers Association Canadian Regional Engineer, Asphalt Institute.
Paving the way for over 60 years Presentation at the January 10, 2007 NCAUPG Technical Conference By Dusty Ordorff Bituminous Roadways, Inc.
Asphalt Concrete Mix Design
STH 21 Adams County Project # Project Specifics Project Specifics Asphaltic Pavement Milling Asphaltic Pavement Milling Pulverizing Shoulders.
Using Reflective Crack Interlayer-
Volumetric Properties of High RAP Mixtures Based on Calculated Bulk Specific Gravities of RAP and Constituent Aggregates Nassim Sabahfer Mustaque Hossain,
RE-USE and RECYCLING of CONSTRUCTION WASTES in FRANCE By Jean Paul Michaut.
Russian Engineers Training March 2011
Use of RAP in Asphalt Mixtures. 2 Outline Why Recycle? Economics of HMA Recycling Current Practices for Using RAP Sources and Processing of RAP Sampling.
Asphalt Technology Course
At Auburn University National Center for Asphalt Technology Accelerated Pavement Testing Facilities “APT”
PROJECT SELECTION RIGHT TOOLS, RIGHT TIME, RIGHT PROJECT Presented by Joe Ririe, PE PAVEMENT ENGINEERING INC. September 9, 2015.
Marshall & Superpave Mix Design
Alabama Asphalt Pavement Association
Critical Factors Affecting Asphalt Concrete Durability
Evaluation of Cracking Resistance and Durability of 100% Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement Mixtures Hesham Ali, PhD, PE. Mojtaba M. Afzali.
Barriers to Implementation of In-Place Recycling
Research Implementation WHRP Flexible Group
Presenters: Sumon Roy1 and Badrul Ahsan1
Update on the current APT Project in Texas
NCAT Pavement Test Track
Recycled Asphalt Pavement
2018 Pavement Workshop May 23-24, 2018
2018 Pavement Workshop May 23-24, 2018
Performance Assessment of 100% Recycled Hot Mix Asphalt
Best Practices on the Use of RAS
Dr. Randy West, P.E. Director / Research Professor
NCAT Pavement Test Track
Effect of Recovered Binder From Recycled Shingles
Superpave5 Superpave Design at Five Percent Air Voids
Warm Mix Asphalt & Recycled Asphalt Pavements
Warm Mix Asphalt & Recycled Asphalt Pavements
Presentation transcript:

National Performance of High Recycled Mixtures

2 Outline Trends in RAP and RAS usage and practices Motivations for higher recycled contents Barriers to higher recycled contents Research and future directions

3 Estimates of RAP Usage NAPA surveys estimate that the national average RAP content increased from 16.2% in 2009 to 20.4% in RAP contents tend to be higher in commercial projects compared to government projects. RAP usage varies considerably from state to state.

4 NAPA IS 138, 2015 Average RAP contents by state

5 Motivations for Higher RAP Contents Environmental & Sustainability benefits Economic savings

6 Conservation of Materials At an average RAP content of 20%, we conserve over 66 million tons of aggregate and 9 million barrels of asphalt each year.

7 The average RAP content in Japan is 47%

9 Current RAP Practices In most (not all) places across the USA… Project millings become property of contractor Urban contractors have excess supplies of RAP Processing options for RAP no additional processing for single source milling stockpiles blending & crushing: multiple source stockpiles fractionating: RAP contents >30%

10 Reasons why Contractors use less RAP than allowed Availability of RAP Requirement to use a softer virgin binder Limited availability and/or tankage issue Requirement to recover and Test RAP binder Ability to control the quality of the mix Moisture Amount of material passing no. 200 sieve Workability RAP variability

11 Barriers to Higher RAP Contents History and Perceptions Performance of high RAP content pavements Concerns about quality and consistency of RAP Technology Limitations Current mix design system Relies on VMA & therefore aggregate bulk specific gravities Does not adequately consider composite binder properties Need reliable performance tests

12 LTPP SPS-5 pavement sections 18 U.S. states and Canadian provinces Eight 500 ft. test sections Rehabilitated sections compared 2” vs 5”overlay thickness RAP (30%) vs virgin mixes Milled vs unmilled surface preparation Projects range in age from 6 to 17 yrs

13 SPS-5 Project Locations

14 ANOVA: Rutting

15 ANOVA: Fatigue Cracking

16 ANOVA: Transverse Cracking

17 ANOVA: International Roughness Index

18 Conclusions on LTPP SPS-5 Based on a long-term performance analysis of a large number of projects across North America… Pavements using ≥ 30% RAP performed well, and in most cases, perform equal or better than virgin pavements Transverse and fatigue cracking were observed at higher percentages in pavements with RAP compared to pavements with all virgin materials. Higher percentages cracking did not impact overlay lives Mix designs on several projects indicate high dust contents and low asphalt contents for RAP mixes.

19 Barriers to Higher RAP Contents History and Perceptions Performance of high RAP content pavements Concerns about quality and consistency of RAP Technology Limitations Current mix design system Relies on VMA & therefore aggregate bulk specific gravities Does not adequately consider composite binder properties Need for reliable performance tests

NCAT Research on Using Recycled Materials NCHRP 9-46: high RAP content mix design Lab studies on how to improve cracking resistance for mixes containing RAP and RAS NCHRP 9-53: Combining RAS & WMA Test Track experiments in 3 rd, 4 th, 5 th, and 6 th cycles –High RAP contents –RAS –GTR

21 Method 1: Recover aggregate using a solvent extraction, then conduct AASHTO T84 and T85 on the fine and course fractions like any other aggregate. RAP Aggregate Bulk Specific Gravity Method 2: Recover aggregate by the ignition method, then conduct AASHTO T84 and T85 on the fine and course fractions like any other aggregate.

22 RAP Aggregate Bulk Specific Gravity Method 3: Estimated G sb from G mm & P ba 1. Determine G mm (w/ dryback) of RAP sample 2. Calculate G se using Eq. 1: 3. Estimate the absorbed asphalt, P ba, based on historical values for the plant location. 4. Calculate G sb using Eq. 2: Equation 1 Equation 2

23 Recommendations RAP Aggregate Gsb One method of determining RAP aggregate Gsb will not work for all material types. Agencies should evaluate options to find the best method for their materials. The method that gives the lowest Gsb will result in the lowest mix VMA. This is desirable since it will lead to higher asphalt contents and better durability.

24 Some Tests for Assessing Cracking Resistance SCB-LA Energy Ratio OT-NCAT Cantabro I-FIT OT-TX Nflex Factor BBF DCT SVECD

25 NCAT Test Track 2006: Moderate and High RAP Content Surface Mixes Mixes with 20% and 45% RAP performed very well 30 million ESALS over 8 years Minor differences in cracking support the use of softer binder for high RAP content mixes Lab Tests: Bending Beam Fatigue, Energy Ratio, Texas Overlay Tester Best correlation with top-down cracking in sections was IDT Creep Rate

26 NCAT Test Track 2009: Virgin versus 50% High RAP Content – All Layers Mixes with and without WMA All sections performed very well 50% HMA section – no distress through 20 million ESALS Lab Tests: BBF, Overlay Tester, SVECD Best correlation with observed fatigue cracking was OT results extrapolated to measured strain level

27 Cold Central Plant Recycling Sponsored by Virginia DOT Processed RAP 2% foamed asphalt and 1% cement Serves as base layer with overlays of 4 inches and 6 inches Objective: quantify the structural contribution (empirical and M-E) Performance has been outstanding – no distress 11 MESALs and counting

28 NCAT Test Track 2015: Cracking Group Experiment: Top-Down Focus 7 surface mixes with a range of expected cracking resistance Lab Tests: I-FIT, SCB-LTRC, Overlay Test, Energy Ratio, & others

MnROAD Thermal Cracking Experiment

30 Recycled Asphalt Shingles Usage Hansen and Copeland, Annual Asphalt Pavement Industry Survey on Recycled Materials and Warm-Mix Asphalt Usage:

31 Recycling Asphalt Shingles Currently used in about 37 states, but routinely for state DOT projects in only about a dozen states Typically 3 to 5% RAS by weight of mix Field performance has been mixed Mix design approaches continue to evolve

32 Performance of Mixes with RAS Virgin Mix PG SBS Virgin Mix PG GTR 20% RAP Mix PG SBS 20% RAP + 5% RAS PG SBS

33 Research and future directions Validation of mix cracking tests “Balanced” mix designs will replace volumetric-based mix designs Rejuvenator formulations will mature Much higher RAP content asphalt mixtures Cold recycled 100% RAP (with some minor additives) as base layer for heavy traffic roads and as a primary structural layer in light traffic pavements.

34 Thank You!