On the detection of the tensor-to-scalar ratio r using the CMB B-modes

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CMB Power spectrum likelihood approximations
Advertisements

First results from QUIET Osamu Tajima (KEK) The QUIET Collaboration 1.
Planck 2013 results, implications for cosmology
CMB Decadal Study: What We Did Activities funded by NASA proposal: PI Steve Meyer + entire CMB community Workshops: The Path to CMBPOL: Upcoming Measurement.
Congratulations to Prof. Sato from CosPA Center 榮休 三十而立、 四十而不惑、 五十而知天命、 六十而耳順、 七十而従心所欲.
Systematic effects in cosmic microwave background polarization and power spectrum estimation SKA 2010 Postgraduate Bursary Conference, Stellenbosch Institute.
Subtleties in Foreground Subtraction Adrian Liu, MIT mK 1 K 100 mK.
Cosmic Microwave Background & Primordial Gravitational Waves Jun-Qing Xia Key Laboratory of Particle Astrophysics, IHEP Planck Member CHEP, PKU, April.
Photo: Keith Vanderlinde Detection of tensor B-mode polarization : Why would we need any more data?
Distinguishing Primordial B Modes from Lensing Section 5: F. Finelli, A. Lewis, M. Bucher, A. Balbi, V. Aquaviva, J. Diego, F. Stivoli Abstract:” If the.
Cosmological Information Ue-Li Pen Tingting Lu Olivier Dore.
Contamination of the CMB Planck data by galactic polarized emissions L. Fauvet, J.F. Macίas-Pérez.
Component Separation of Polarized Data Application to PLANCK Jonathan Aumont J-F. Macías-Pérez, M. Tristram, D. Santos
1 ACT  Atacama Cosmology Telescope  Funded by NSF  Will measure CMB fluctuations on small angular scales  Probe the primordial power spectrum and the.
Added science from improved measurements of T and E modes S. A. Bonometto, E. Branchini, C. Burigana, L. P. L. Colombo, J. M. Diego, R. Fabbri, F. K. Hansen,
CMB polarisation results from QUIET
Foreground limits on the detectability of the B-mode by Bpol Enrique Martínez-González (IFCA) Marco Tucci (IAC) Bpol Meeting, 27-October-2006, Orsay.
1 On the road to discovery of relic gravitational waves: From cosmic microwave background radiation Wen Zhao Department of Astronomy University of Science.
(Eisenstein et al., ApJ, 2005) Surveys of large scale structure will probe Dark Energy by measuring the BAO scale vs. redshift. Planned: DESI, Euclid,
CMB large angular scale, full sky polarization anisotropy has been measured moderately well, but not well enough – The value of reionization fraction derived.
1 The Inflation Probe Science Interest Group Jamie Bock (Caltech/JPL) PhysPAG Meeting, Chicago 19 August 2014.
Statistics of the Weak-lensing Convergence Field Sheng Wang Brookhaven National Laboratory Columbia University Collaborators: Zoltán Haiman, Morgan May,
Thoughts on Ground-based lensing measurements Chao-Lin Kuo Stanford/SLAC KIPAC.
Introduction to Power Spectrum Estimation Lloyd Knox (UC Davis) CCAPP, 23 June 2010.
Separating Cosmological B-Modes with FastICA Stivoli F. Baccigalupi C. Maino D. Stompor R. Orsay – 15/09/2005.
Simulating the Interferometer In order to simulate the performance of an interferometer, 20 by 20 degree sections were extracted from the simulated CMB.
The CMB and Neutrinos. We can all measure the CMB T CMB = \ K CMB approx 1% of TV noise! 400 photons/cc at 0.28 eV/cc.
P olarized R adiation I maging and S pectroscopy M ission Probing cosmic structures and radiation with the ultimate polarimetric spectro-imaging of the.
The Implication of BICEP2 : Alternative Interpretations on its results Seokcheon Lee SNU Seminar Apr. 10 th
Foreground subtraction or foreground avoidance? Adrian Liu, UC Berkeley.
Search for B-modes in CMB Polarization  QUIET and other experiments Osamu Tajima (KEK) The QUIET Collaboration Ultimate High Energy Physics QUIET collaboration.
Constraints on the neutrino mass by future precise CMB polarization and 21cm line observations Yoshihiko Oyama The Graduate University for Advanced Studies.
Probing fundamental physics with CMB B-modes Cora Dvorkin IAS Harvard (Hubble fellow) Status and Future of Inflationary Theory workshop August 2014, KICP.
Wei-Tou Ni Department of Physics National Tsing Hua University [1] W.-T. Ni, (MPLA 25 [2010]
Forthcoming CMB experiments and expectations for dark energy Carlo Baccigalupi.
The CMB TE Cross Correlation and Primordial Gravitational Waves Nathan Miller CASS Journal Club 11/6/07.
Cosmology : Cosmic Microwave Background & Large scale structure & Large scale structure Cosmology : Cosmic Microwave Background & Large scale structure.
Cosmic Microwave Background Carlo Baccigalupi, SISSA CMB lectures at TRR33, see the complete program at darkuniverse.uni-hd.de/view/Main/WinterSchoolLecture5.
Joint analysis of Archeops and WMAP observations of the CMB G. Patanchon (University of British Columbia) for the Archeops collaboration.
Determination of tensor spectral index in the CMB Wen IHEP
Hemispherical Power Asymmetry 郭宗宽 昆明 anomalies in CMB map the quadrupole-octopole alignment power deficit at low- l hemispherical asymmetry.
EBEx foregrounds and band optimization Carlo Baccigalupi, Radek Stompor.
Daisuke Yamauchi ICRR, U Tokyo Weak lensing of CMB from cosmic (super-)strings 9/28/2011 Tohoku U with A. Taruya (U Tokyo, RESCEU), T. Namikawa.
The Planck Satellite Hannu Kurki-Suonio University of Helsinki Finnish-Japanese Workshop on Particle Cosmology, Helsinki
3rd International Workshop on Dark Matter, Dark Energy and Matter-Antimatter Asymmetry NTHU & NTU, Dec 27—31, 2012 Likelihood of the Matter Power Spectrum.
Analysis of Need to go to Space J. Bartlett, R. Battye, F. Bouchet, A. Challinor, K. Ganga, A. Jaffe, R. Stompor.
Observational constraints on inflationary models Zong-Kuan Guo (ITP, CAS) CosPA2011 (Peking Uni) October 31, 2011.
Blind Component Separation for Polarized Obseravations of the CMB Jonathan Aumont, Juan-Francisco Macias-Perez Rencontres de Moriond 2006 La.
CMB, lensing, and non-Gaussianities
150GHz 100GHz 220GHz Galactic Latitude (Deg) A Millimeter Wave Galactic Plane Survey with the BICEP Polarimeter Evan Bierman (U.C. San Diego) and C. Darren.
Carlos Hernández-Monteagudo CE F CA 1 CENTRO DE ESTUDIOS DE FÍSICA DEL COSMOS DE ARAGÓN (CE F CA) J-PAS 10th Collaboration Meeting March 11th 2015 Cosmology.
Investigating dark energy with CMB lensing Viviana Acquaviva, SISSA, Trieste Lensing collaborators in SISSA: C. Baccigalupi, S. Leach, F. Perrotta, F.
Dominic Galliano Supervisors: Rob Crittenden & Kazuya Koyama UK Cosmo, Tuesday 13 September 2011.
Cheng Zhao Supervisor: Charling Tao
Technology Requirements for Large- Angular-Scale CMB Science John Ruhl (Case Western) Brad Benson (Fermilab / U. Chicago) CPAD, 10/5/2015 Science Goal:
BICEP2 Results & Its Implication on inflation models and Cosmology Seokcheon Lee 48 th Workshop on Gravitation & NR May. 16 th
The cross-correlation between CMB and 21-cm fluctuations during the epoch of reionization Hiroyuki Tashiro N. Aghanim (IAS, Paris-sud Univ.) M. Langer.
Detecting the CMB Polarization Ziang Yan. How do we know about the universe by studying CMB?
PLANCK TEAM of the DISCOVERY Center. The most mysterious problems.
EGEE-III INFSO-RI Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE and gLite are registered trademarks Constraints on primordial non-Gaussianity.
Planck working group 2.1 diffuse component separation review Paris november 2005.
Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization
Towards the first detection using SPT polarisation
Testing Primordial non-Gaussianities in CMB Anisotropies
12th Marcel Grossman Meeting,
A Measurement of CMB Polarization with QUaD
Laurence Perotto; LAL Orsay
Abstract Observed CMB polarization maps can be split into gradient-like (E) and curl-like (B) modes. I review the details of this decomposition, and the.
David Spergel, Paul Bode and Chris Hirata
Separating E and B types of CMB polarization on an incomplete sky Wen Zhao Based on: WZ and D.Baskaran, Phys.Rev.D (2010) 2019/9/3.
Presentation transcript:

On the detection of the tensor-to-scalar ratio r using the CMB B-modes Agnès Ferté In collaboration with: Julien Peloton, Julien Grain, Radek Stompor Based on: arxiv:2506.06409

CMB B-modes caused by tensor perturbations and lensing of E-modes (Q,U) maps E and B modes power spectra Tensor-to-scalar ratio r

CMB B-modes at low-l probe the primordial Universe Lensing B modes: 1st direct detection by Polarbear (arxiv:1403.2369) Primordial B modes: r<0.12 (Bicep2/Keck + Planck)

Estimation of B modes power spectrum on a masked sky: the E-to-B leakage  Function of the mask Mode counting variance Standard estimation of B-modes 1 % of the sky From Grain et al, 2009

Pure pseudo spectrum method (x2pure code) + optimisation of the window function 1 % of the sky pure mode counting Other methods Smith, 2006 Grain et al, 2009 Ferté et al, 2013 From Ferté et al, 2013

Pure pseudo spectrum method (x2pure code) + optimisation of the window function 71 % of the sky Other methods pure mode counting Smith, 2006 Grain et al, 2009 Ferté et al, 2013

Impact of leakage on the forecasts of CMB B modes detection? 1st investigation: ideal experiments 2nd investigation: 3 selected realistic experiments

Signal-to-noise ratio computed using Fisher matrix Error on r Covariance matrix computed using: Mode counting variance = Pure method = pure estimation + MC simulations

1st approach: ideal small scale experiments 1% r=0.1

Mode-counting variance for optimal sky coverage Optimal sky fraction

2nd approach: 3 realistic experiments Spec. Small scale Array of telescope Satellite Sky fraction 1% 36% 71% Noise (muK-arcmin) inhomogenesous (average of 5) 1 2 Beam (arcmin) 8 3 Dire que array de télescopes =study of window functions cause reach a limitation (in the noise)

Uncertainties on the power spectrum

Accessible r at 3σ detection Example of satellite xp mode counting pure Small scale xp Telescopes array Satellite mission Mode counting r > 0.038 r > 0.0011 r > 0.0009 Pure method r > 0.11 r > 0.0051 r > 0.0026

Foreground impact on the detection of r Remove the first bin: 2 < l < 20 Example of satellite xp Small scale xp Telescopes array Satellite mission Mode counting r > 0.04 r > 0.0016 r > 0.0013 Pure method r > 0.11 r > 0.0053 r > 0.0028

TO TAKE AWAY The pure estimation of B modes is awesome The mode-counting approach is enough to state on optimal sky coverage The pure method is mandatory to perform realistic forecasts on r detection Potential future satellite mission: r ≥ 10-3 Stage 4 array of telescope: r ≥ 10-2 Current ground-based or balloon borne: r ≥ 10-1 Side ‘personal’ note: the CMB TB and EB correlations hold information on fundamental physics (e.g. : parity breaking, birefringence, primordial magnetic field…)

From NASA

Effect of binning

Optimised window functions

SNR on r Small scale Array of telescopes