Quark Matter ’05 Budapest Aug 3-9, 2005 Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN - TH J/  suppression.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Elliptic flow of thermal photons in Au+Au collisions at 200GeV QNP2009 Beijing, Sep , 2009 F.M. Liu Central China Normal University, China T. Hirano.

Advertisements

Physics Results of the NA49 exp. on Nucleus – Nucleus Collisions at SPS Energies P. Christakoglou, A. Petridis, M. Vassiliou Athens University HEP2006,

Initial and final state effects in charmonium production at RHIC and LHC. A.B.Kaidalov ITEP, Moscow Based on papers with L.Bravina, K.Tywoniuk, E.Zabrodin.

Quark Matter 2006 ( ) Excitation functions of baryon anomaly and freeze-out properties at RHIC-PHENIX Tatsuya Chujo (University of Tsukuba) for.

Di-electron Continuum at PHENIX Yorito Yamaguchi for the PHENIX collaboration CNS, University of Tokyo Rencontres de Moriond - QCD and High Energy Interactions.

Upsilon Production in Heavy Ions with STAR and CMS

Bielefeld, sept 05F. Fleuret - LLR 1 Heavy ions at RHIC The J/  adventure J/  simultaneously discovered in november 1974 Ting et al. at the Brookhaven.

1 Baryonic Resonance Why resonances and why  * ? How do we search for them ? What did we learn so far? What else can we do in the.

STAR Looking Through the “Veil of Hadronization”: Pion Entropy & PSD at RHIC John G. Cramer Department of Physics University of Washington, Seattle, WA,

Charmonia production at the SPS energies Marie-Pierre COMETS IPN Orsay, FRANCE SQM2006, UCLA, Los Angeles, USA, March 26-31, 2006.

IN-MEDIUM FORMATION OF QUARKONIUM (“RECOMBINATION”) R. L. THEWS UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA SQM2006 UCLA MARCH 26-31, 2006.

Heavy Flavors at FAIR Elena Bratkovskaya , WE-Heraeus-Seminar „Characterization of the Quark Gluon Plasma with Heavy Quarks‘‘, Bad Honnef (Germany)

5-12 April 2008 Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics STAR Particle production at RHIC Aneta Iordanova for the STAR collaboration.

Percolation & The Phase Transition 1 Bring your own Phase Diagram TIFR, Mumbai, India Dec , 2010 Brijesh K Srivastava Department of Physics West.

1 Statistical Models and STAR’s Strange Data Sevil Salur Yale University for the STAR Collaboration.

Charmonium Production in Heavy-Ion Collisions Loïc Grandchamp Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Texas A&M, Dec. 10 th 2004 w/ R. Rapp.

J/  production in In-In collisions at SPS energies Philippe Pillot — IPN Lyon for the NA60 Collaboration work 2005 June 16–20   Outline: Reminder.

IN-MEDIUM FORMATION OF J /y: PROBE OF CHARM QUARK THERMALIZATION R. L. THEWS UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA XXXV INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON MULTIPARTICLE DYNAMICS.

Measurements of the Charge Balance Function at RHIC from √s NN = 7.7 to 200 GeV Gary D. Westfall, for the STAR Collaboration (Michigan State University)

TIFR Mumbai India Feb Ágnes Mócsy at RBRC 1 Quarkonium as Signal of Deconfinement Ágnes Mócsy Thanks to Sourendu, Saumen, Rajeev, Rajiv!

Measurements of  Production and Nuclear Modification Factor at STAR Anthony Kesich University of California, Davis STAR Collaboration.

The J/  as a probe of Quark-Gluon Plasma Erice 2004 Luciano MAIANI Università di Roma “La Sapienza”. INFN. Roma.

Tomoaki Nakamura - Hiroshima Univ.16/21/2005 Event-by-Event Fluctuations from PHENIX Tomoaki Nakamura for the PHENIX collaboration Hiroshima University.

Quarkonium suppression at the SPS International Workshop on Heavy Quarkonium, DESY, Oct Carlos Lourenço or Are the SPS J/  and  ’ suppression patterns.

А.Б.Курепин – ИЯИ РАН, Москва Столкновение релятивистских тяжелых ядер и загадка чармония VI Марковские чтения 15 Мая 2008 г. ОИЯИ, Дубна.

N. Topilskaya, A.Kurepin – INR, Moscow Transverse momentum dependence of charmonium production in heavy ion collisions. 3rd INT. WORKSHOP ON HIGH-PT PHYSICS.

Matter System Size and Energy Dependence of Strangeness Production Sevil Salur Yale University for the STAR Collaboration.

R AA of J/ψ near mid-rapidity in RHIC at √s NN =200 GeV and in LHC Taesoo Song, Woosung Park, and Su Houng Lee (Yonsei Univ.)

Study of the QCD Phase Structure through High Energy Heavy Ion Collisions Bedanga Mohanty National Institute of Science Education and Research (NISER)

Istanbul 06 S.H.Lee 1 1.Introduction on sQGP and Bag model 2.Gluon condensates in sQGP and in vacuum 3.J/  suppression in RHIC 4.Pertubative QCD approach.

Kwangbok Lee, LANL for the PHENIX collaboration DIS 2011, Newport News, VA Heavy vector meson results at PHENIX 1.

Statistical Model Predictions for p+p and Pb+Pb Collisions at LHC Ingrid Kraus Nikhef and TU Darmstadt.

Do small systems equilibrate chemically? Ingrid Kraus TU Darmstadt.

EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE FOR HADRONIC DECONFINEMENT In p-p Collisions at 1.8 TeV * L. Gutay - 1 * Phys. Lett. B528(2002)43-48 (FNAL, E-735 Collaboration Purdue,

1 Jeffery T. Mitchell – Quark Matter /17/12 The RHIC Beam Energy Scan Program: Results from the PHENIX Experiment Jeffery T. Mitchell Brookhaven.

Energy Scan of Hadron (  0 ) Suppression and Flow in Au+Au Collisions at PHENIX Norbert Novitzky for PHENIX collaboration University of Jyväskylä, Finland.

Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model Victor Roy Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Collaborators.

Study of chemical potential effects on hadron mass by lattice QCD Pushkina Irina* Hadron Physics & Lattice QCD, Japan 2004 Three main points What do we.

Olena Linnyk Charm dynamics from transport calculations Symposium and 10th CBM Collaboration Meeting September 25 – 28, 2007.

J/ψ production and elliptic flow in relativistic heavy-ion collisions Taesoo Song (Texas A&M Univ., USA) Reference : T. Song, C. M. Ko, S. H. Lee and J.

Latest Charmonium Results from the PHENIX Experiment at RHIC Alexandre Lebedev (Iowa State University) For the PHENIX Collaboration Lake Louise Winter.

How To See the Quark-Gluon Plasma

Dynamical equilibration of strongly- interacting ‘infinite’ parton matter Vitalii Ozvenchuk, in collaboration with E.Bratkovskaya, O.Linnyk, M.Gorenstein,

Presentation for NFR - October 19, Trine S.Tveter Recent results from RHIC Systems studied so far at RHIC: - s NN 1/2 = 

Charged Particle Multiplicity and Transverse Energy in √s nn = 130 GeV Au+Au Collisions Klaus Reygers University of Münster, Germany for the PHENIX Collaboration.

Round Table Workshop on NICA Physics Dubna,September 9-12,20091 J/Ψ Production in Heavy Ion Collisions J/Ψ Production in Heavy Ion Collisions Pengfei ZHUANG.

Loïc Grandchamp Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory “Probing QCD with High Energy Nuclear Collisions” Hirschegg, Jan ’05 with H. van Hees, S.

Probing the properties of dense partonic matter at RHIC Y. Akiba (RIKEN) for PHENIX collaboration.

Robert Pak (BNL) 2012 RHIC & AGS Annual Users' Meeting 0 Energy Ro Robert Pak for PHENIX Collaboration.

1 J/, Charm and intermediate mass dimuons in Indium-Indium collisions Hiroaki Ohnishi, RIKEN/JAPAN For the NA60 collaboration XXXV International Symposium.

07/27/2002Federica Messer High momentum particle suppression in Au-Au collisions at RHIC. Federica Messer ICHEP th international Conference on high.

Heavy-Ion Physics - Hydrodynamic Approach Introduction Hydrodynamic aspect Observables explained Recombination model Summary 전남대 이강석 HIM

Olena Linnyk Charmonium in heavy ion collisions 16 July 2007.

R. Lednicky: Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia I.P. Lokhtin, A.M. Snigirev, L.V. Malinina: Moscow State University, Institute of Nuclear.

Mean Field Effect on J/psi Production in Heavy Ion Collisions Baoyi Chen Physics Department Tsinghua University Cooperators: Kai Zhou Yunpeng Liu Pengfei.

PHENIX results on J/  production in Au+Au and Cu+Cu collisions at  S NN =200 GeV Hugo Pereira Da Costa CEA Saclay, for the PHENIX collaboration Quark.

QM06 - S.H.Lee 1 1.Comments on J/  dissociation by partons 2.Progress in QCD calculations: LO and NLO 3. Dissociation due to thermal gluons and quarks.

Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook, ISMD, Kromĕříž, Roy A. Lacey What do we learn from Correlation measurements at RHIC.

Itzhak Tserruya Initial Conditions at RHIC: an Experimental Perspective RHIC-INT Workshop LBNL, May31 – June 2, 2001 Itzhak Tserruya Weizmann.

1 Cold and Hot nuclear matter effects on Charmonium production Kai Zhou (Tsinghua University,Beijing) In collaboration with: Baoyi Chen (Tsinghua University)

News from quarkonia Rencontres QGP Etretat 16/9/2014 Elena G. Ferreiro Universidad de Santiago de Compostela Spain.

Mass states of light vector mesons are considered to be sensitive probes of partial chiral symmetry restoration theoretically expected in high energy and/or.

Christina MarkertHirschegg, Jan 16-22, Resonance Production in Heavy Ion Collisions Christina Markert, Kent State University Resonances in Medium.

1/21 Carlos Lourenço, 4 th International Workshop on Heavy Quarkonium, June 27– Recent results from the CERN SPS on quarkonium production in p-nucleus.

24/6/2007 P.Ganoti, 1 Study of Λ(1520) production in pp TeV with the ALICE detector Paraskevi Ganoti University.

1 Joint meeting IPNO-LAL LUA9-AFTER Orsay, Novembre 2013 Roberta Arnaldi INFN Torino (Italy)

ICPAQGP 2010 Goa, Dec. 6-10, Percolation & Deconfinement Brijesh K Srivastava Department of Physics Purdue University USA.

Charmed hadron signals of partonic medium

Charmonium dynamics in heavy ion collisions

Charmonium dissociation and recombination at RHIC and LHC

Presentation transcript:

Quark Matter ’05 Budapest Aug 3-9, 2005 Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN - TH J/  suppression

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Outline Introduction Normal suppression in nuclear matter : preresonance absorption Anomalous suppression : –QGP (percolation, thermal dissociation) –Normal hadronic interactions (comovers) Discussion : SPS and RHIC Conclusions

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Normal suppression General definition : J/  suppression in p-A collisions is well described by a probabilistic formula z b p A

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, From a fit of experimental p-A data (NA38,NA50):  abs = mb ( hep-ex/ ) In S-U collisions the same suppression is observed The normal suppression is interpreted as the absorption, in the nuclear environment, of the c-cbar pair before the J/  (or  ’ or  ) formation : preresonance absorption.

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Anomalous suppression In peripheral Pb-Pb collisions the (J/  )/DY ratio is consistent with the normal suppression pattern In central Pb-Pb collisions (b< fm) a much stronger suppression is observed: Anomalous suppression New In-In data follow the same pattern ! (NA60) NA38/NA50

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, The anomalous suppression is the candidate as the signal for deconfinement. There are two ways to prove it : –compare to absorption in a hadronic gas: less trivial extrapolation of p-A and S-U. “Known” parameters. Negative approach. –formulate a reasonnable model for a deconfinement scenario: define critical variable(s). Unknown parameters. Positive approach. More difficult !

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Feed-down Only a fraction (~60%) of the observed J/  ’s are directly produced. The rest come from the decay of higher excited states (~30% from , ~10% from  ’). The feed-down has been studied in pN and  N interactions. The medium (confined / deconfined) affects differently the different charmonium states. Different properties (binding energy, size,…) implies different dissociation temperatures or different cross- sections for interactions with hadrons.

Models: suppression by hadron interactions Models: suppression by hadron interactions

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Comover interactions After the normal absorption in the nuclear environment, the survived J/  ’s interact with secondary hadrons: J/  +h->DD. Crucial parameter : J/  -hadron inelastic cross-section, (   h inel ) a very uncertain parameter ! Theoretical estimates :   h inel ~0.1-1 mb Common assumptions: isoentropic, longitudinal expansion of the hadron gas (Monte Carlo calculations include transverse expansion); the density decreases as 1/  ; the interactions stop at the freeze-out.

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, From p-A and S-U to Pb-Pb Constraints from p-A and S-U data : the cross- section is very small and/or the comover density in these systems is negligible. Can the comover density have such a strong increase in Pb-Pb collisions to produce the observed suppression ? ?

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Dual Parton Model [A.Capella et al.,Z.Phys.C3,329,(1980); Phys.Rep.236,225(1994) A.Capella et al.,nucl-th/ ; hep-ph/ ] The number of secondary hadrons at the initial (formation) time is given by the sum of two contributions, proportional respectively to the number of participants and to the number of binary N-N collisions (s=coordinate in the transverse plane) : The coefficients C 1 and C 2 are predicted in the DPM. RHIC : shadowing corrections (to moderate the increase of the produced secondaries)

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, DPM: results A.Capella,D.Sousa,nucl-th/ A.Capella,E.Ferreiro,hep-ph/ SPS: Pb-Pb SPS: In-In RHIC: Au-Au RHIC: Cu-Cu  abs =4.5 mb   h inel =0.65 mb (fitted to Pb-Pb)  abs =4.5 mb   h inel =0.65 mb (fitted to Pb-Pb)

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Comover absorption: problems To reproduce the observed suppression in Pb-Pb, the density of comovers must by very high : can a hadron gas exist in these extreme conditions ? Different approach by Maiani et al. [hep=ph/ ] : the density and temperature of the hadron gas is limited (T= MeV). The experimental suppression can not be reproduced.

Models: suppression by deconfinement Models: suppression by deconfinement

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Thermal dissociation Potential extracted from lattice results [Digal et al., hep-ph/ ; Phys.Rev.D64 ( 2001) ] below T c above T c

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Thermal dissociation/2 Solve Schroedinger equation to get binding energy (M i (T)) and binding radius r i (T) Below T c : no bound state if M i (T) > V lim (T) Above T c : No bound state if r i (T)>r 0 (T) [Digal et al., hep-ph/ ; Phys.Rev.D64 ( 2001) ]

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, T diss (  ’) ~ 0.2 T c T diss (  ) ~ 0.7 T c T diss (J/  ) ~ 1.1 T c To compare to the experimental data : introduce the T  b correlation introduce E T b One gets a curve qualitatively similar to the experimental pattern Thermal dissociation/3 J/  suppression pattern: 8%  ’ 57% dir. J/  35% 

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Recent lattice calculations ‡ found: ‡ Datta et al., hep-lat/ ; hep-lat/ ¶ Datta et al., hep-lat/ The threshold is lowered if the relative momentum is taken into account ¶. T dependence of the width ? Thermal Dissociation: new developments

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, New calculation of T diss [W. Alberico et al., hep-ph/ ; C.Y. Wong hep-ph/ ] Extract the internal energy from lattice results and use it in the Schroedinger equation : T diss (  ’) ~ T diss (  ) ~ 1.1 T c T diss (J/  ) ~ T c In good agreement with the dissociation temperatures given by lattice !

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Percolation critical phenomenon pre-equilibrium deconfinement prerequisite for QGP applicable to finite-size systems [First works: Baym, Physica (Amsterdam) 96A, 131 (1979) Celik et al., Phys. Lett. 97B (1980) 128]

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Circular surface of radius R and N small discs of radius r<<R randomly distributed. R The cluster size increase with increasing n=N/  R 2 s n Percolation/2 ncnc

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Cluster formation shows critical behaviour: in the limit of infinite R and N with constant n the cluster size diverges at a critical density n c. Onset of percolation : with  = 43/18 ; n c ~ Percolation/3

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, The transverse size r c of the percolating partons is determined by the condition (Q c =1/r c ) : the density of the largest cluster at the percolation point is : with  c =1.72 (local percolation condition) Percolation/2

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Percolation/3 For Pb-Pb at SPS: 1/r c ~ Q c ~ 0.7 GeV, N part = 150 (b ~ 8fm) [ S. Digal et al, hep-ph/ ]

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Percolation:results Q(  ) ~ 0.6 GeV Q(  ’) ~ 0.5 GeV  and  ’ are dissociated at the percolation (onset of deconfinement). Directly produced J/  ’s survive because Q(J/  )~1GeV; second threshold at N part = Results : Data: NA50 Coll.

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Percolation: results Predictions for In-In :Predictions for Au-Au :

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Regeneration [L. Grandchamp et al., Nucl.Phys.A715 (2003) 545; Phys.Rev.Lett.92 (2004) ] “Two component” model: suppression in hadronic and QGP phase + statistical production at hadronization. In the QGP phase: in-medium properties of open- and hidden-charm states as deduced from lattice calculations. The regeneration is very important at higher energies.

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Results At SPS energy the regeneration contribution is small; at RHIC it is the dominant one.

Comparison with new data !

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Experiment : SPS No direct J/  suppression at SPS, only  and  ’ at onset of the deconfinement !!!! No direct J/  suppression at SPS, only  and  ’ at onset of the deconfinement !!!! L. Ramello, R.Arnaldi

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Theory… Thermal model:Percolation :

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Experiment : RHIC H. Buesching : More data on p-A are needed to define the normal suppression ! Compatible with regeneration, but… Compatible with regeneration, but…

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Lattice and potential models : J/  dissolves at T~2Tc, the corresponding energy density is very high ! RHIC suppression is compatible with the one observed at SPS (?) RHIC data could be explained by the suppression of the  and  ’ components only, without recombination !!!

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Improving models… Generally, deconfinement models assume the complete suppression for the charmonium states inside the “QGP” bubble: this is a really extreme assumption ! Finite-size effects can modify the suppression pattern in small systems and in peripheral collisions.

Conclusions

Marzia Nardi Centro Fermi (ROME) / CERN-TH Quark Matter ’05 – Budapest Aug 3-9, Conclusions The observed J/  suppression at SPS is qualitatively very similar to the pattern expected by deconfinement models. None of the models so far is completely satisfactory in the comparison with data; new effects: finite size, life-time, surface… RHIC data : recombination or higher states suppression ? There is room for work and progress !