IV. Radiative Transfer Models The radiative transfer modeling procedure is the same procedure used in Shirley et al. (2002) except that the visibility.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Francesco Trotta YERAC, Manchester Using mm observations to constrain variations of dust properties in circumstellar disks Advised by: Leonardo.
Advertisements

Basics of mm interferometry Turku Summer School – June 2009 Sébastien Muller Nordic ARC Onsala Space Observatory, Sweden.
High Resolution Observations in B1-IRS: ammonia, CCS and water masers Claire Chandler, NRAO José F. Gómez, LAEFF-INTA Thomas B. Kuiper, JPL José M. Torrelles,
Estimate of physical parameters of molecular clouds Observables: T MB (or F ν ), ν, Ω S Unknowns: V, T K, N X, M H 2, n H 2 –V velocity field –T K kinetic.
Ammonia and CCS as diagnostic tools of low-mass protostars Ammonia and CCS as diagnostic tools of low-mass protostars Itziar de Gregorio-Monsalvo (ESO.
Studying circumstellar envelopes with ALMA
Jeong-Eun Lee Kyung Hee University University of Texas at Austin.
From Pre-stellar Cores to Proto-stars: The Initial Conditions of Star Formation PHILIPPE ANDRE DEREK WARD-THOMPSON MARY BARSONY Reported by Fang Xiong,
Low-Mass Star Formation in a Small Group, L1251B Jeong-Eun Lee UCLA.
Dust and Stellar Emission of Nearby Galaxies in the KINGFISH Herschel Survey Ramin A. Skibba Charles W. Engelbracht, et al. I.
1mm observations of Orion-KL Plambeck, PACS team, Friedel, Eisner, Carpenter,...
SMA Observations of the Binary Protostar System in L723 Josep Miquel Girart 1, Ramp Rao 2, Robert Estalella 3 & Josep Mª Masqué 3 1 Institut de Ciències.
Mini Workshop on Star Formation and Astrochemistry. Barcelona, 2006 November 23 1 Robert Estalella, Aina Palau, Maite Beltrán (UB) Paul T. P. Ho (CfA),
Ge/Ay133 SED studies of disk “lifetimes” & Long wavelength studies of disks.
Radio Astronomy And The Spiral Structure Of The Milky Way Jess Broderick Supervisor: Dr George Warr.
A Molecular Inventory of the L1489 IRS Protoplanetary Disk Michiel R. Hogerheijde Christian Brinch Leiden Observatory Jes K. Joergensen CfA.
Constraining TW Hydra Disk Properties Chunhua Qi Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Collaborators : D.J. Wilner, P.T.P. Ho, T.L. Bourke, N. Calvet.
Modelling the Broad Line Region Andrea Ruff Rachel Webster University of Melbourne.
STAR FORMATION STUDIES with the CORNELL-CALTECH ATACAMA TELESCOPE Star Formation/ISM Working Group Paul F. Goldsmith (Cornell) & Neal. J. Evans II (Univ.
Modeling of Deep Submillimeter Images of the Pre-protostellar Core L1498 Miranda K. Nordhaus 1,2, Yancy L. Shirley 2, Neal J. Evans II 3, & Jonathan M.
M ORPHOLOGY OF G ALACTIC O PEN C LUSTERS Thirty six open clusters were selected from the 2MASS database on the basis of the latest open cluster catalogue.
Structure of circumstellar envelope around AGB and post-AGB stars Dinh-V-Trung Sun Kwok, P.J. Chiu, M.Y. Wang, S. Muller, A. Lo, N. Hirano, M. Mariappan,
Submillimeter Astronomy in the era of the SMA, Cambridge, June 14, 2005 Star Formation and Protostars at High Angular Resolution with the SMA Jes Jørgensen.
IRAC/MIPS view of the ISM: PAHs dominate in IRAC Li & Draine (2001) dust emissivity model; only very strong (> 10 3 x avg.) radiation fields contribute.
Á L V A R O S Á N C H E Z M O N G E B A R C E L O N A - N O V E M B E R 23, 2006 Centimeter and Millimeter Emission from Selected High-Mass Star-Forming.
Star Formation Research Now & With ALMA Debra Shepherd National Radio Astronomy Observatory ALMA Specifications: Today’s (sub)millimeter interferometers.
TURBULENCE AND HEATING OF MOLECULAR CLOUDS IN THE GALACTIC CENTER: Natalie Butterfield (UIowa) Cornelia Lang (UIowa) Betsy Mills (NRAO) Dominic Ludovici.
Multiwavelength Continuum Survey of Protostellar Disks in Ophiuchus Left: Submillimeter Array (SMA) aperture synthesis images of 870 μm (350 GHz) continuum.
Initial Conditions for Star Formation Neal J. Evans II.
Magnetic Fields Near the Young Stellar Object IRAS M. J Claussen (NRAO), A. P. Sarma (E. Kentucky Univ), H.A. Wootten (NRAO), K. B. Marvel (AAS),
Molecular Gas and Dust in SMGs in COSMOS Left panel is the COSMOS field with overlays of single-dish mm surveys. Right panel is a 0.3 sq degree map at.
The Evolution of Quasars and Massive Black Holes “Quasar Hosts and the Black Hole-Spheroid Connection”: Dunlop 2004 “The Evolution of Quasars”: Osmer 2004.
Deriving the Physical Structure of High-mass Star Forming Regions Yancy L. Shirley May 2003 Collaborators: Neal Evans, Kaisa Young, Dan Jaffe, Claudia.
Star Formation in our Galaxy Dr Andrew Walsh (James Cook University, Australia) Lecture 1 – Introduction to Star Formation Throughout the Galaxy Lecture.
Radio Interferometry and ALMA T. L. Wilson ESO. A few basics: Wavelength and frequency  -1 temperature max (mm) ~ 3/T(K) (for blackbody) Hot gas radiates.
Massive Star Formation: The Role of Disks Cassandra Fallscheer In collaboration with: Henrik Beuther, Eric Keto, Jürgen Sauter, TK Sridharan, Sebastian.
Great Barriers in High Mass Star Formation, Townsville, Australia, Sept 16, 2010 Patrick Koch Academia Sinica, Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics.
SUNYAEV-ZELDOVICH EFFECT. OUTLINE  What is SZE  What Can we learn from SZE  SZE Cluster Surveys  Experimental Issues  SZ Surveys are coming: What.
Basic Concepts An interferometer measures coherence in the electric field between pairs of points (baselines). Direction to source Because of the geometric.
CARMA Large Area Star-formation SurveY  Completing observations of 5 regions of square arcminutes with 7” angular resolution in the J=1-0 transitions.
Modeling Tools at Texas c2d Meeting Cambridge Dec
Seeing Stars with Radio Eyes Christopher G. De Pree RARE CATS Green Bank, WV June 2002.
Imaging Molecular Gas in a Nearby Starburst Galaxy NGC 3256, a nearby luminous infrared galaxy, as imaged by the SMA. (Left) Integrated CO(2-1) intensity.
A Submillimeter View of Protoplanetary Disks Sean Andrews University of Hawaii Institute for Astronomy Jonathan Williams & Rita Mann, UH IfA David Wilner,
The Effect of Escaping Galactic Radiation on the Ionization of High-Velocity Clouds Andrew Fox, UW-Madison STScI, 8 th March 2005.
Studying Young Stellar Objects with the EVLA
Infall rates from observations Joseph Mottram 1. Why is infall relevant? Infall must happen for star formation to proceed The rate of infall on envelope.
A-Ran Lyo KASI (Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute) Nagayoshi Ohashi, Charlie Qi, David J. Wilner, and Yu-Nung Su Transitional disk system of.
ALMA Timeline  Design and Development Phase Jun Dec 2001  International partnership established 1999  Prototype antenna contract Dec 99  ALMA/NA.
Observing Strategies at cm wavelengths Making good decisions Jessica Chapman Synthesis Workshop May 2003.
Masers Surveys with Mopra: Which is best 7 or 3 mm? Simon Ellingsen, Maxim Voronkov & Shari Breen 3 November 2008.
Submillimeter Array CH3OH A Cluster of Highly Collimated and Young Bipolar Outflows Emanating from OMC1 South. Luis A. Zapata 1,2, Luis.
Studying Infall Neal J. Evans II.
Methanol Masers in the NGC6334F Star Forming Region Simon Ellingsen & Anne-Marie Brick University of Tasmania Centre for Astrophysics of Compact Objects.
Fitting Magnetized Molecular Cloud Collapse Models to NGC 1333 IRAS 4A Pau Frau Josep Miquel Girart Daniele Galli Institut de Ciències de l’Espai (IEEC-CSIC)
Multiple YSOs in the low-mass star-forming region IRAS CONTENT Introduction Previous work on IRAS Observations Results Discussion.
GBT Future Instrumentation Workshop Fixing the frequency coverage hole in C-Band Jagadheep D. Pandian Cornell University.
Early O-Type Stars in the W51-IRS2 Cluster A template to study the most massive (proto)stars Luis Zapata Max Planck Institut für Radioastronomie, GERMANY.
Searching for massive pre-stellar cores through observations of N 2 H + and N 2 D + (F. Fontani 1, P. Caselli 2, A. Crapsi 3, R. Cesaroni 4, J. Brand 1.
Searching for disks around high-mass (proto)stars with ALMA R. Cesaroni, H. Zinnecker, M.T. Beltrán, S. Etoka, D. Galli, C. Hummel, N. Kumar, L. Moscadelli,
1 Radio – FIR Spectral Energy Distribution of Young Starbursts Hiroyuki Hirashita 1 and L. K. Hunt 2 ( 1 University of Tsukuba, Japan; 2 Firenze, Italy)
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Jes Jørgensen (Leiden), Sebastien Maret (CESR,Grenoble)
Submillimeter Observations of Debris Disks Wayne Holland UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh With Jane Greaves, Mark Wyatt, Bill.
LDN 723: Can molecular emission be used as clock calibrators? Josep Miquel Girart Collaborators: J.M.Masqué,R.Estalella (UB) R.Rao (SMA)
High Redshift Galaxies/Galaxy Surveys ALMA Community Day April 18, 2011 Neal A. Miller University of Maryland.
THE SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION OF LARGE AND SMALL DUST GRAINS IN TRANSITIONAL DISKS ELIZABETH GUTIERREZ VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY 2015 SOCORRO COHORT STUDENT ADVISOR:
1 SIMBA survey of southern high-mass star forming regions Santiago Faúndez (U. de Chile) Leonardo Bronfman(U. de Chile) Guido Garay (U. de Chile) Rolf.
Radio Continuum Observations of Low Mass Young Stars Driving Outflows Rachael Ainsworth (DIAS) Radio Stars and Their Lives in the Galaxy 3-5 October 2012.
SMA and ASTE Observations of Low-mass Protostellar Envelopes in the Submillimeter CS (J = 7-6) and HCN (J = 4-3) Lines Shigehisa Takakuwa 1, Takeshi Kamazaki.
Presentation transcript:

IV. Radiative Transfer Models The radiative transfer modeling procedure is the same procedure used in Shirley et al. (2002) except that the visibility amplitudes are also simulated (see flowchart above). By simultaneously modeling the SED, SCUBA intensity profiles, and BIMA visibility amplitudes, the shape and scaling of the density distribution with radius is constrained. Shirley et al. (2002) found that a single power-law density distribution, n(r) = 6.5x10 5 cm -3 ( r /1000 AU) -1.1, fit the SED (60  m to 1.3mm) and SCUBA 850 and 450  m intensity profiles; however, when this model is observed using the BIMA u,v tracks, the model does not reproduce the observed visibility amplitudes. There are two main discrepancies : there is a plateau in the observed visibility amplitudes at 40 mJy between  of [8,50] k indicative of an unresolved compact structure (e.g., a disk); and the model amplitudes are too low for the first 2 bins in u,v-distance (green model in Figure 3). If the unresolved structure observed in the BIMA amplitude-uv distance plot is a disk, then there may be an appreciable flux contribution within the central SCUBA beam. “Pure-envelope” radiative transfer models that ignore this contribution to the flux may overestimate the slope of a best-fit power law by up to 0.5 (see Young et al. 2003). Using the simple disk model of Young et al., we estimate the flux contribution at 850  m to be < 0.8 Jy. Adding this flux into the models results in a much flatter best-fit to the SCUBA profiles of n(r) ~ r -0.6 (blue model). This flatter, single power-law model also fails to produce enough flux for the first 2 bins in u,v-distance, but does fit the 3 rd bin. These results suggest that a broken power-law model with a flatter slope in the interior may be a good fit to both the SCUBA and BIMA data while accounting for the flux contribution from a disk. A broken power law model adds two additional free parameters: the slope of the inner region and the break radius. SCUBA observations will be insensitive to variations in the break radius within the central beam; therefore, we chose a maximal break radius of 2000 AU. Since the outer region of the envelope is well fitted by an r -1.1 power law, we keep the slope of the outer profile constant. A broken power law with r -0.6 in the inner region and a disk flux of 0.4 Jy at 850  m is the best fit to the SCUBA intensity profile and BIMA visibility amplitudes; however, this model over predicts the flux in a 120” aperture at 850  m by a factor of 2. It is not possible to simultaneously match the 850  m flux, SCUBA profile, and BIMA amplitudes. The BIMA amplitudes require enough mass to always over-predict the SCUBA 850 mm flux. This may indicate an opacity change in the inner envelope; the mass opacity for coagulated dust grains without ics mantle vs. grain with ice mantle is a factor of 2 at 850 mm (see Ossenkopf & Henning 1994). Alternatively, this may be a failure of the 1D model to properly describe the structure of the inner envelope. I. Introduction Current theoretical models of low-mass (M < few M sun ) star formation predict the evolution of the density, temperature, and velocity structure within the envelope of the core. In particular, the density profile as a function of radius is a strong discriminator between theories. Submillimeter and millimeter dust continuum is a powerful probe of the physical conditions in the envelopes of star-forming cores since the optically thin emission is sensitive to the density, temperature, and opacity structure along the line of sight. Recent surveys with the single-dish bolometer camera, SCUBA, have imaged the continuum emission on large scales (10 3 to 10 4 AU) towards more than 50 Pre-protostellar cores, Class 0, and Class I cores. State-of-the-art radiative transfer models account for heating from the interstellar radiation field (ISRF) and/or an internal source, beam convolution, and chopping. By simultaneously matching the observed continuum intensity profile (at multiple wavelengths) and the observed spectral energy distribution, the models constrain the physical structure of the core. However, the models are unable to place strong constraints on the conditions within the central beam, typically on scales less than 103 AU. Interferometric continuum imaging is vital for probing the inner envelope structure and constraining the emission properties of a disk. We have observed 4 Class 0 cores (L1527, B335, L483, & L723) with BIMA at 2.7 mm in four array configurations (A,B,C, & D). Integrated radiative transfer models of SCUBA 850 and 450 micron and BIMA 2.7mm observations of L1527 are presented in this poster. The combined models probe the physical structure on scales of 10 2 to 10 4 AU. L1527 is an embedded Class 0 source (IRAS ) associated with a near-infrared nebula (Eiora et al. 1994) located at a distance of 140 pc in the Taurus molecular cloud complex. The submm emission is extended in the NE-SW direction. The source appears to be a protobinary on a scale less than 1”. A strong molecular outflow is detected in the E-W direction (MacLeod et al. 1994, Bontemps et al. 1996). The core is rotating (Goodman et al. 1993) resulting in molecular line radiative transfer models of rotating collapse (Terebey-Shu-Cassen infall, Zhou et al. 1996). Combining Radiative Transfer Models of BIMA & SCUBA Continuum Observations Yancy L. Shirley 1, Lee G. Mundy 2, & Neal J. Evans II 3 1 – Jansky Postdoctoral Fellow at NRAO, 2 – University of Maryland, 3 – University of Texas at Austin II. BIMA Observations L1527 was observed and detected in 4 array configuration of BIMA with tracks during 8 days between 1997 and The digital correlator was setup with two bands of 700 MHz centered at 106 and 109 GHz (2.7 mm). Mars and quasars were used as absolute flux calibrators. We estimate a 20% uncertainty in the final amplitude calbration for each individual array configuration. The four configurations were combined into a data set with 252,957 visibility records. n d (r) T d (r) S  I (b) V (  ) Nearly orthogonal constraints: SED Mass x Opacity I(b), V(  )n(r) Iterate Physical Model n(r), L int, I isrf,  Observations  2 r Gas to Dust Radiative Transfer Simulate Obs. V. Conclusions We are unable to simultaneously match the SED and the SCUBA intensity profiles+BIMA visibility amplitudes. This may be indicative of an opacity change in the inner envelope or the failure of 1D modeling to account to the physical structure. The combined modeling of interferometric and single- dish continuum observations is necessary to constrain the physical structure throughout the envelope and to constrain the flux contribution from a disk. Observations and modeling at submm wavelengths with the next generation of interferometers (SMA, CARMA, & ALMA) will provide stronger constraints III. Interpreting Visibilities The specific intensity of a spherical dust shell at impact parameter, b, is given by (see Shirley et al. 2000) The observed visibilities, written in terms of the u,v-distance, , is the 2-dimensional Fourier transform of the specific intensity times the interferometric power pattern (see Looney 1998). If we assume that the source brightness distribution is smaller than the interferometer’s single dish primary beam, the integration over azimuthal angle results in the observed visibilities expressed as the Hankel transform of the specific intensity where J 0 is a zeroth order Bessel function. In general, these expressions must be solved numerically. The source structure observed by the interferometer may be modeled by simulating the visibility amplitude vs. u,v-distance using the same u,v tracks as obtained in the observations. Figure 3: Disk models adapted from Young et al. (2003) are plotted on the left. The contribution to the flux at 850  m is between 0.2 and 0.8 Jy within the central SCUBA beam. Results of radiative transfer models are plotted on the right. The green model is the best-fit r -1.1 power law from Shirley et al. (2002). The blue model is a r -0.6 power law with a disk flux of 0.8 Jy at 850  m. The red model is a broken power law with r -0.6 inside 2000 AU and r -1.1 in the outer envelope and a disk flux of 0.4 Jy.. Figure 2: u,v tracks for L1527 observations (left). BIMA images of L1527 with robustness = 2, 1, and 0 (left to right). Figure 1: SCUBA 850 (left) and 450 (middle) micron images of L1527 (Shirley et al. 2000) and the VLA 7mm image (right) observed during A configuration (Loinard et al. 2002).