Biotic and Abiotic Drivers of Seedling Survival in a Hurricane-Impacted Forest Liza S. Comita Columbia University
Tropical cyclone tracks from 1985 to 2005
Photo credit: Larsen & Torres-Sanchez, USGS
Photo credit: Timo Veijola Before….
Photo credit: Timo Veijola And after….
Hurricane Damage Abiotic environment – Open up forest canopy -> increased understory light levels & more heterogeneity Biotic environment – Increased light levels-> increased seedling densities -> density- dependent mortality
Hurricane Disturbance How does hurricane disturbance alter the biotic and abiotic environment? Which biotic and abiotic factors determine patterns of seedling survival in the understory? Does the importance of these factors change as the forest recovers?
Luquillo Experimental Forest, Puerto Rico 16 ha Forest Dynamics Plot 138 tree and shrub species Aseasonal, hurricane-impacted forest (Hugo 1989, Georges 1998)
Seedling census 2 x 1 m seedling plots 150 est. in added in 2004 Tree, shrub, palm seedlings ≥10 cm tall Tagged, measured, identified to species in 2000, 02, 04, 07, 08 Hemispherical photos taken over each plot to quantify light levels
Hurricane Disturbance How does hurricane disturbance alter the biotic and abiotic environment?
Light levels (at 1 m above ground) Significantly higher light levels after the hurricane Sharp drop within 3 yrs due to canopy closure
Seedling density (m -2 ) Higher seedling densities for several years post-hurricane
Hurricane Disturbance How does hurricane disturbance alter the biotic and abiotic environment? Which biotic and abiotic factors determine patterns of seedling survival in the understory? Does the importance of these factors change as the forest recovers?
Seedling survival as a function of: Abiotic factors – Light – Soil (5 soils types) – Topography (topo category & % slope)
Seedling survival as a function of: Biotic neighborhood – Density of conspecific seedlings heterospecific seedlings conspecific tree BA heterospecific tree BA Abiotic x Biotic interactions – Light x Neighbors
Generalized linear mixed effects model Logit(S)= TIME + LOG(HEIGHT) + LIGHT + LIGHT 2 + SLOPE+TOPO+SOILTYPE CONS + HETS + CONBA + HETBA+ LIGHT:CONS + LIGHT:HETS + LIGHT:CONBA + LIGHT:HETBA +SPECIES + PLOT FIXED EFFECTS RANDOM EFFECTS
‘lme4’ package lmer() function Binomial errors (survival 0/1) Standardized predictors – Divide by mean and subtract 1 sd – Makes it easy to directly compare effects for variables that are measured on different scales
TIME log (HT) CONS HETS CONBA HETBA LIGHT LIGHT 2 CONS x LIGHT HETS x LIGHT CONBA x LIGHT HETBA x LIGHT Coefficient estimates RESULTS
Effect of Light
Effect of Conspecific Seedling Neighbors
Hurricane Disturbance How does hurricane disturbance alter the biotic and abiotic environment? Which biotic and abiotic factors determine patterns of seedling survival in the understory? Does the importance of these factors change as the forest recovers?
Effects in each census interval LIGHT+000 CON Seedlings0--+ HET Seedlings0000 CON BA---- HET BA+000
Effects in each census interval LIGHT+000 CON Seedlings0--+ HET Seedlings0000 CON BA---- HET BA+000
Effects in each census interval LIGHT+000 CON Seedlings0--+ HET Seedlings0000 CON BA---- HET BA+000
Maria Uriarte Jill Thompson Jess Zimmerman Nick Brokaw Inge Jonckheere LFDP technicians & volunteers Acknowledgements
QUESTIONS?