BTA Seminar The benefits and costs of liberalisation : how to go about liberalisation in Africa Bill Wigglesworth Gaborone, 31 January 2005.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Gender Perspectives in Introduction to Regulation Gender Module #1 ITU Workshops on Sustainability in Telecommunication Through Gender & Social Equality.
Advertisements

Gender Perspectives in Introduction to Competition Policy Gender Module #6 ITU Workshops on Sustainability in Telecommunication Through Gender & Social.
OHR/OECD Conference on Regulatory Governance and Network Industries OHR/OECD Conference on Regulatory Governance and Network Industries Sarajevo, April.
The role of operators in broadband infrastructure and services David Souter ict Development Associates EACO, Munyonyo, 16 April 2013
Challenges for EU competitiveness
ROLE OF THE GOVERNMENT.
© Copyright Ovum The role of the BTA and competition law A presentation to the Stakeholders’ Forum on further liberalisation David Lewin.
UK Spectrum Management Strategy: tomorrow’s challenges today Chris Woolford Director, International Spectrum Policy Radcomms 2014.
1 ATUG Forum ACS Telecommunication Society of Australia (ACS-TSA) National Broadband Network Reference Model.
1. 2 A Smarter Supply Chain Using Information & Communications Technology to Increase Productivity in the Australian Transport & Logistics Industry Rocky.
PROJECT FINANCE INITIATIVE and PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS Simon Par Keeling, Société Générale Paris.
AS Economics and Business How size affects market power Unit 2B By Mrs Hilton for revisionstation.
Competition Commission comments to Parliament on Broadband Infraco Bill 1 August 2007.
Contribution since August,2008 National MSME Conclave 19 November, 2014 Use of ICT to make MSME more competitive and sustainable Tapan K. Patra Director.
UNDP & the Business SectorBureau for Resources and Strategic Partnerships Business, sustainable development and the MDGs: A changing landscape.
Adriaan DIERX International workshop on "Opportunities for growth, trade and investments after the crisis" 9 – 10 November 2012, Cluj-Napoca The contribution.
“Equal and open access to the market in terms of economic integration and increased competition ” Astana Forum, 24 May 2013 Presented by Hassan Qaqaya,
Basic Definitions and Drivers (Sustainability Reporting) Introduction and scene setting.
1 National Electronic Commerce Strategies The Malaysian Experience Ho Siew Ching Ministry of International Trade and Industry Malaysia Expert Meeting on.
International Seminar on ICT Policy Reform and Rural Communication Infrastructure, Keio University, Japan Rethinking telecom reform model: the case of.
Australian Water Summit Sydney March 2006 Is privatisation of water infrastructure and services the answer? Phillip Mills Director of Water Services, Water.
RUSSIAN GAMING WEEK CONGRESS Maximising the value of your casino license
Interface between Competition Policy and Sectoral Regulation in the Namibia’s Telecoms Sector Rehabeam Shilimela NEPRU.
BT Transformation Working with the CWU. Defend Traditional Calls decline - 5 main factors Dial IP - Market declines, driven by Broadband Price - Market.
5.1 Understand the process and value of conducting a feasibility analysis for your business Key Terms: Industry Target customers Competitive grid Prototype.
Liberalisation of the Australian telecommunications industry Richard Home Senior Manager – Strategic Analysis & Development, Communications Group Australian.
Spectrum: a scarce resource Chris Woolford Director, Spectrum and International Policy 2 December 2008.
Regulation and the Governance Agenda in the 21 st Century Josef Konvitz, Public Governance Directorate.
Infrastructure for eInclusion – Regulation and Policy Initiatives Marianne Røgeberg Ministry of Transport and Communication Norway.
CompassRose International, Inc. Seminar on Further Liberalization Prepared for the Stakeholders’ Forum on Further Liberalisation of Telecommunications.
Industrial competitiveness in the context of the EU climate and energy policy framework - Chatham house rules - 23 June 2014 Albert PRECUP European Commission.
TELECOMMUNICATIONS POLICY IN A RAPIDLY EVOLVING MARKET CTO conference on implementing the WSIS Action Plan, NAIROBI, th March,2004. Presented by.
Page 1 Vodafone presentation to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Communications Convergence Bill [B9-2005] 17 August 2005.
Internet Policy Day 3 - Workshop Session No. 5 The impact of telecomms regulation Prepared for CTO by Link Centre, Witwatersrand University, South Africa.
Consumer Education and Information (Session Ib: Tools to empower consumers) Edin Zametica Advisor to SERC, Bosnia and Herzegovina Chair of the ECRB Customers.
Organizations and Information Systems – Economic Effects MIS 2000.
1 Liberalization & The Telecommunications Sector In the Caribbean Presented by Regenie F. Ch. Fräser SECRETARY GENERAL CANTO.
TOWARDS BETTER REGULATION: THE ROLE OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT COLIN KIRKPATRICK IMPACT ASSESSMENT RESEARCH CENTRE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER, UK UNECE Symposium.
Making the Internal Energy Market work Tudor Constantinescu DG Energy
The development of the market infrastructure for payment and securities handling Ramzi Hamadeh Group 2 Frankfurt am Main,
1.2 The Importance of Marketing MARKETING MR. PAVONE.
1 Introduction to Competition Policy and Law National Training Workshop on Competition Policy and Law Gaborone, Botswana: 25 – 27 July 2007 Presenter:
MOBILE PHONES AND EXPANDING HUMAN CAPABILITIES Matthew L. Smith, Randy Spence and Ahmed T. Rashid.
1 COMPETITION LAW FORUM Paris 21 June 2006 Competitiveness versus Competition Presentation by Humbert DRABBE Director for Cohesion and Competitiveness,
Regional Integration: Implications for Agriculture in South- Eastern Europe Garry Christensen.
SCAN-ICT: the INDICATORS by Makane Faye Senior Regional Adviser for ICTs Regional Workshop on ICT indicators October 2004 Gaborone (Botswana)
This section examines the relationships between organisations and their external environment. Candidates should understand the opportunities and threats.
1 Romania: Achieving Sustainable Growth and the Role of the Labor Market Jeffrey Franks European Department International Monetary Fund Bucharest January.
ITCILO/ACTRAV COURSE A Capacity Building for Members of Youth Committees on the Youth Employment Crisis in Africa 26 to 30 August 2013 Macro Economic.
Mec1224 EETT: From Telecommunications to Electronic Communications Athens, 28 March 2005 “Investment and competition in electronic communications services.
New Growth Model John Evans, TUAC. 2 Summary Purpose of the TUAC/ETUI/ITUC task force Summary of the policy approach Priorities: what is economic growth.
Information Society and Development Applying Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in the Finnish development co-operation.
Growth and Non-Traded Sectors: The Scope of India’s Infrastructure An NRE’s Take on …
SIMMONS & SIMMONS An international law firm London Paris Brussels Lisbon Milan Rome Abu Dhabi Hong Kong Shanghai New York Workshop on a new Telecom Policy.
Policymaker Perspective: Delivering Inclusive Financial Development
Managing the (Traffic) Managers
Michael Maphosa and Patrick Mabuza
Next topic: Policies for Growth and Development
Next topic: Policies for Growth and Development
How ICT Regulation Creates a Framework to Enhance Economic Development
Benefits of Liberalized CRS to Kenya
EESC work on aviation: Numerous opinions on all major issues:
Content ICT ecosystem - challenges of national public policy and regulation in competitive global markets Linkages between regulatory environment and.
27 November 2014 Mantas Sekmokas
The Competition Assessment Framework (The CAF)
Sustainable Gaming – Saving the sector from itself
Business Sustainability in the age of exponential change PART 4
The Swedish Model Government Offices of Sweden, Ministry of Finance
Multimedia Training Kit
Modernising Regulatory Frameworks
Presentation transcript:

BTA Seminar The benefits and costs of liberalisation : how to go about liberalisation in Africa Bill Wigglesworth Gaborone, 31 January 2005

Themes Benefits of liberalisation: –Prices, market share, customer service; Costs of liberalisation: –Investment duplication; –Infrastructure versus service competition; Impact on the economy Impact of additional mobile operators and/or virtual mobile operators Lessons from experience relevant to liberalisation in Africa and Botswana

Benefits of liberalisation Improved efficiency: low cost production; commercial pricing Downward pressure on prices: better value for money Faster innovation: new and better services Responsiveness to customers: availability of services Market growth: lower unit costs An efficient and prosperous sector contributing strongly to the economy

Costs of liberalisation Investment duplication: –Two networks more expensive than one –Costs can be minimised, and benefits maximised, by allowing full range of technologies on any network –Investors will be cautious, if allowed to be Infrastructure versus service competition: –“Build or buy” option should be kept neutral –So competitors can build if existing networks fail to perform

Impact on the economy Growth of the telecommunications sector Fiscal benefits of prosperous companies Economic welfare benefits of cost oriented pricing: usage no longer distorted Expanded usage of communications across the economy Availability of ICTS for other sectors: eg Botswana cattle farmers; high class tourist operators; craft industries; support sectors

More mobile operators? The wrong question: mobile capability one aspect of convergence of services on high speed packet switched IP networks Cost profile of radio based services allows proliferation on more limited core networks Cost savings through facilities sharing Competition possible at service level only Three players looks sustainable in most environments: demand is clear

Lessons of experience Strong independent regulation essential Openness and transparency indispensable Regulatory independence not absolute: manage relationship of confidence and trust with Ministry; no surprises Government’s policy role central to success: informed and realistic Set practicable goals that will allow investors to create a prosperous sector

How to go about it in Africa Develop clear policy aims that relate to actual costs and benefits of current technology If in doubt, opt for competition Allow competing network operators to provide services using wire line or radio: Seychelles, South Africa and Uganda are showing the way Move to full services competition as soon as possible: due in South Africa tomorrow Ensure that the regulator has the powers, resources and government support to do the job effectively with minimum political intervention