Casualty Actuarial Society Hurricane Landfall Probabilities from Proxy Data David Malmquist Risk Prediction Initiative Bermuda Biological Station for Research, Inc.
Preview Risk Prediction Initiative Need for Proxies Proxy Methods and Results Future Directions
The Goal of the RPI To create links between the climate science and insurance communities so that the science of climate forecasting is available, understandable, and usable by insurers
RPI Information Flow Risk Prediction Initiative INSURERS Commercial Risk Modelers AcademiaGovernment
RPI Corporate Sponsors X.L. Mid Ocean Re General Re Renaissance Re ACE Limited Centre Solutions Employers Re AIG/IPC Re
RPI Activities Facilitate working groups Fund novel research Develop and distribute research products
Catastrophe Risk Model landfall probability maximum sustained winds peak wind gust radius of maximum winds forward speed and direction decay rate latitude longitude elevation topography construction type surrounding structures physical damage repair costs Damage terms of coverage Insured Loss Hazard
RPI Activities Facilitate working groups Fund novel research extend historical records via proxies –improve hurricane forecasts –climate variability –wind-field dynamics –develop public models Develop and distribute research products
≥ < > > 18 Minimal Moderate Extensive Extreme Catastrophic Saffir/Simpson Scale Pressure (inches) Wind (mph) Surge (ft) Damage
US Tropical Cyclone Damage ( ) Pielke & Landsea, 1997 $ = Millions of 1995 US dollars
Tropical Cyclone Observation NOAA, 1993 Satellites Land observations Ship logs Aircraft reconnaissance
Intense US Landfalls ( ) data from NOAA
Cat 5 US Landfalls ( ) data from NOAA
Extend Historical Records Via Proxies RPI Funded Research
Hurricane Proxies: Storm Surge Barrier Island Sand Mud OceanLake
from K.-B. Liu
sand layers Depth (cm) Lake Shelby, Alabama Lake Shelby, Alabama , 2.6, 2.2, 1.4, 0.8 ka , 2.6, 2.2, 1.4, 0.8 ka ~ 600 year return period ~ 600 year return period Category 4 or 5 Category 4 or 5 Lake Core Analysis data from K.-b. Liu
A Climate Diagnostic Proxy: Oxygen Isotopes Mean Sea Water H 2 16 O > 99.7% H 2 18 O ~ 0.2%
Texas Summer Precipitation Lawrence & Gedzelman, Rainfall Events Oxygen Isotope Values n = 208 Summer Rain Tropical Cyclones
- 9.35‰ ‰ Proxy Tape Recorder 18 O Time
Growth of Cave Deposits stalactite stalagmite column H 2 O + CO 2 + CaCO 3 Ca HCO 3 - dissolution precipitation
Stalagmite Cross-Section 18 O Fidelity Sampling Interval
Tree Growth
Suppressed vs. Released Rings
What are the Potential Proxy Signals? Within-tree differences in ring width Between-tree differences in ring width –local (cohort) –regional (intersite) Isotopic Signals
Hurricane Camille (1969) Louisiana Mississippi Pass Christian Slidell
Single -Tree Analysis Hurricane Wind
Single -Tree Analysis Standardized Ratio Doyle & Gorham, 1996 Hurricane Camille
Cohort Analysis Hurricane Wind A AB B
Cohort Analysis Growth Ratio Doyle & Gorham, Hurricane Camille
Inter-Site Analysis LAMS LA MS
Inter-Site Analysis Growth Ratio Doyle & Gorham, Hurricane Camille
Hurricane Proxies: U.S. Geography Lake cores Tree-rings Caves
Facilitate working groups Fund novel research Develop and distribute research products