Meteorite Analogs for Phobos and Deimos: Unraveling the Origin of the Martian Moons P. Vernazza 1, F. Cipriani 1, C. Dukes 2, D. Fulvio 2, K. T. Howard.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The nebular hypothesis
Advertisements

Mantle composition 1800s meteorites contain similar minerals to terrestrial rocks Hypothesis that meteorites come from asteroid belt and originate from.
Properties of the NEO Population: The ACM 2005 View Richard P. Binzel (MIT) Dmitrij Lupishko ( Kharkov Observatory)
Physical Properties of Decameter-scale Asteroids Andrew Rivkin (JHU/APL) Target NEO 2 Workshop Washington DC.
Interplanetary bodies: asteroids asteroid-- rocky object in orbit around the sun includes: Main Belt asteroid Hilda and Thule asteroid near-Earth asteroid.
Some Short Topics AS3141 Benda Kecil dalam Tata Surya Prodi Astronomi 2007/2008 B. Dermawan.
Depletion and excitation of the asteroid belt by migrating planets Kevin J. Walsh, Alessandro Morbidelli (SwRI,OCA-Nice) Sean N. Raymond (Obs. Bordeaux),
Surface Chronology of Phobos – The Age of Phobos and its Largest Crater Stickney 1 N. Schmedemann 1, G. Michael 1, B. A. Ivanov 2, J. Murray 3 and G. Neukum.
Clark R. Chapman Southwest Research Inst. Boulder, Colorado Clark R. Chapman Southwest Research Inst. Boulder, Colorado Solar System Remote Sensing Symposium.
Olivine Transformation in SAH 293: Constraints on Shock Conditions C. Fudge, J. Hu and T. G. Sharp ASU/NASA Space Grant.
Geophysics of Icy Saturnian Satellites Torrence V. Johnson Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Caltech.
Space Weathering By Maxwell Justice. What is it? What is Space Weathering? – It is like erosion on earth but in space What causes Space Weathering? –
Deconvolving Terrestrial Alteration Mineral Signatures from Meteorite Reflectance Measurements …to derive a precise and accurate spectrum of a weathered.
Cosmic spherules are micrometeorites that melted when they plunged through Earth’s atmosphere. Thousands.
TERRESTRIAL PLANET FORMATION & THE FORMATION OF A WATER-RICH EARTH
Wee Rocky Droplets in Comet Dust Comet dust collected by the Stardust mission Small samples (10-40 microns)
1 Spectral and mineralogical diversity among the M-asteroids P.S. Hardersen 1, M.J. Gaffey 1, P.A. Abell 2, E.A. Cloutis 3, V. Reddy 1, S.K. Fieber-Beyer.
Asteroids Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 15.
Asteroids Not just for kids anymore..
Interiors of Terrestrial Planets. Mercury MEAN RADIUS: km MASS: (Earth=1) DENSITY: 5.43 (g/cm^3) GRAVITY: (Earth=1) ORBIT PERIOD:
The MIT-IRTF Joint Campaign For NEO Spectral Reconnaissance R.P. Binzel (MIT), A.T. Tokunaga (Univ. of Hawaii)
3B Solar System Debris Asteroids, Comets, Meteors, Oh My!
Meteorites: Rocks from space. Leonid meteor shower, 1998 European Fireball Network image Meteoroid Meteor (fireball) Meteorite.
GEOL3045: Planetary Geology Lysa Chizmadia Mercury From Mariner 10 to Messenger Lysa Chizmadia Mercury From Mariner 10 to Messenger.
“ PHOBOS - SOIL ” Phobos Sample Return Mission 1. goals, methods of study A.Zakharov, Russian academy of sciences Russian aviation.
Dawn: Exploring Dichotomies across Space and Time DAWN Mission Speaker’s Kit Dawn EPO Teams.
Mars-Moon Exploration, Reconnaissance, and Landed Investigation Andrew Rivkin, Scott Murchie, Nancy Chabot, Albert Yen, Raymond Arvidson, Justin Maki,
Asteroids (minor planets) Bode’s Law suggests a planet between Mars and Jup. at 2.8 AU: –1801 – Piazzi (It.) discovers Ceres –1804 – Juno disc. –1807 –
What Dawn did learn at Vesta? 1. Outline Vesta and the Dawn mission Goals of the mission What Dawn did learn at Vesta? Giant impact basins Protoplanetary.
Introduction and Key Terms
Deconvolving Terrestrial Alteration Mineral Signatures from Meteorite Reflectance Measurements …to derive a precise and accurate spectrum of a weathered.
Chapter 7: Asteroids and Comets. Review: asteroids Mostly rocky bodies Found in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter  Also the Trojans at the Jupiter.
The first Moscow Solar System Symposium (1MS3) Session 2: Phobos (science) October 12 th 2010 – Moscow, Russia The internal structure and the origin of.
PHOBOS - GRUNT Phobos Sample Return Mission 1. Basis for choice, goals and methods of study.
Most meteorites that fall on Earth are fragments of broken-up asteroids which orbit the Sun mostly between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. This is indicated.
1 Inner or Terrestrial Planets All the inner planets formed at the same time. Their composition is also very similar. They lack the huge atmospheres of.
Asteroids Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 15.
Planets Symbol Name From Greek God Ares, the god of war Also Called the “red planet,” which derives from its color Mars is red because of the iron oxide.
Water in Laboratory J.R. Brucato INAF-Arcetri Astrophysical Observatory, Firenze Italy Water in Asteroids and Meteorites Paris.
Catastrophic Events in the Solar System There are records in the surface and interior of the planets and their satellites that indicate the occurrence.
EART160 Planetary Sciences. Meteorites, Asteroids, and Minor Bodies.
WATER ON EARTH Alessandro Morbidelli CNRS, Observatoire de la Cote d’Azur, Nice.
MODELING THE NEOs ORBITAL DISTRIBUTION AND NEO DISCOVERY STRATEGIES A. Morbidelli (OCA) R. Jedicke (Spacewatch) W.F. Bottke (SWRI) P. Michel (OCA) P. Tanga.
Comets, Asteroids, and Meteors 1)Introduction 2)Meteors 3)Asteroids 4)Comets 5)Doomsday Asteroid October 2, 2002.
Chapter 10 Mars. Mars’s orbit is fairly eccentric which affects amount of sunlight reaching it 10.1 Orbital Properties.
How do habitable planets acquire carbon? PAHs in Protoplanetary Disks
Space Weathering on Phobos and Deimos
Astronomy 340 Fall October 2005 Class #???
GEOL3045: Planetary Geology Lysa Chizmadia Earth-Crossing Asteroids Lysa Chizmadia Earth-Crossing Asteroids.
Comets, Asteroids, and Meteors
Lunar Mineralogy Kaylan Meinecke ASU NASA Space Grant Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Office Mentor: Samuel Lawrence 18 April 2009.
Origin of Earth and Moon PA STEM monthly meeting CCIU September 15, 2015.
Asteroids.
Chapter 4 The Solar System.
Theories of Formation for the Moon
E-type asteroids and related meteorites
Overview of the Solar System
Dr. Paul S. Hardersen University of North Dakota
The Planets Ali Nork.
Taking a Look at a Trojan Asteroid
Water in Asteroid 4 Vesta
The Moon 28.2.
Section 5: Comets, Asteroids, and Meteors
Asteroids Not just for kids anymore..
Comets, Asteroids, and Meteors
Small Solar System Bodies
Small Bodies Asteroids, Meteoroids and Comets
Comets, Asteroids, and Meteors
SATISH PRADHAN DNYANASADHANA COLLEGE,THANE
Future Didymos Observing Strategy
Presentation transcript:

Meteorite Analogs for Phobos and Deimos: Unraveling the Origin of the Martian Moons P. Vernazza 1, F. Cipriani 1, C. Dukes 2, D. Fulvio 2, K. T. Howard 3, O. Witasse 1, R. Brunetto 4, G. Strazzulla 5, R. P. Binzel 6, P. A. Bland 7, R. Baragiola 2, P. Rosenblatt 8 1 ESA, ESTEC, NL 2 Univ. of Virginia, USA 3 NHM London, UK 4 ESA, ESAC, Spain 5 Obs. of Catania, Italy 6 MIT, USA. 7 IRAC, Imperial College London, UK. 8 Observatoire Royal de Belgique

Current knowledge ESA NASA ESA Phobos: - Albedo: / Density: / g/cm 3 Deimos: - Albedo: / Density: / g/cm 3 Spectra: CRISM/MRO

Origin of the Martian moons Three possible scenarios: 1) Capture of two distinct outer main belt asteroids 2) Formation in place 3) Origin as Mars impact ejecta

1) Capture of two distinct outer main belt asteroids Every observable physical property (albedo, VNIR reflectance, density) indicates that the Martian satellites are similar to outer main belt bodies (~3 AU), suggesting the objects must be captured However, dynamicists argue that the present orbits of Phobos and Deimos could not be produced following capture, and so they must have originated near Mars at 1.5 AU

Class Albedo Density Mineralogy E, M, S 0.1 – metal, silicates, sulfides C 0.03 – hydrated silicates, silicates P, D 0.02 – hydrated silicates Gradie and Tedesco, ) Formation in place Compositional gradient seen in the asteroid belt does not favor this scenario !

3) Origin as Mars impact ejecta Such scenario has not been modeled yet, but if correct one should keep in mind that: Dynamical constraints suggest that the satellites formed early in Martian history => The composition of the moons would be representative of the ancient composition of the Martian crust

constrain the composition of both moons which hasn’t been done yet ! To solve the problem of the origin, one needs to

Search for plausible meteoritic analogs for Phobos and Deimos using the RELAB spectral database Step 1

Tagish Lake & WIS 91600: Phobos/Deimos analogs ? Spectra: CRISM/MRO

S-type asteroid Ordinary chondrite [Gaffey et al., 1993] Space Weathering

Modal composition of Tagish Lake and WIS Tagish Lake (Bland et al. 2004) WIS (this study; performed by K.T. Howard) Olivine 7.0 Fe-Mg carbonate11.7 Sulfide5.6 Magnetite4.5 Saponite-serpentine71.2 Olivine15 Enstatite1.5 Sulfide3.5 Magnetite6.5 Saponite73.5 Vol (%)

Step 2 Simulation of the space climate on Tagish Lake (both solar wind and micrometeorite bombardment)

Laser irradiation to simulate Micrometeorite bombardment Hiroi & Sasaki

Ion irradiation to simulate the Solar wind bombardment

Moreover: Recent density measurements make a Tagish Lake-Phobos/Deimos association difficult Bulk density of TL : / g/cm 3 (from Hildebrand et al. 2006) Density of Phobos: / g/cm 3 (Andert et al., 2010) Density of Deimos: / g/cm 3 Assuming a usual macroporosity of 20-40%, the density of the Tagish Lake parent body should be in the g/cm 3 range.

Phobos and Deimos are unlikely parent bodies of the Tagish Lake meteorite (and WIS 91600). If Phobos and Deimos are captured asteroids, we currently have no meteorite sample in our collection that fits Phobos and Deimos’ physical properties The composition of the moons has to be addressed by searching for minerals that match Phobos and Deimos’ spectra and densities The latter search will require to reproduce the effects of the space climate on the inferred composition Conclusion