Some observations from chilean experience that could affect CDM methodologies by Alfonso Olea (TÜV- SÜD external auditor) APLE Consultores Chile.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Paulo Manso CDM EB September, 2011 Proceeder for Submission & Approval Standardized Baselines.
Advertisements

Practitioners Workshop: Standards for Baseline Scenario Identification and Baseline Emission Calculations - DOE Viewpoints DOE/AE Forum | Werner Betzenbichler.
. Melanie Eddis ERM Certification and Verification Services (ERM CVS) CDM Coordination Meeting UNFCCC, Bonn March 2012 Materiality in the CDM Experiences.
4th Module: Information Systems Development and Implementation:
Development and Prospects for JI UNFCCC Side Event November 30, 2005 Hiroshi YAMAGATA Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry JAPAN.
© Craig McDonald 2005 UC Ethics and Systems Quality Craig McDonald School of Information Sciences and Engineering University of Canberra
1 Validation and registration Verification and issuance Technical Workshop on CDM Paramaribo, 20 June 2008 Adriaan Korthuis.
Validation and Verification of CDM Projects Climate Change Kiosk on CDM/DNA, COP9 December 6, 2003 Marco van der Linden SGS Climate Change Programme.
ICAO Symposium on Aviation and Climate Change, “Destination Green”, 14 – 16 May 2013 Destination Green Overview of the United Nations’ offset mechanisms.
Capacity Development for CDM - National Workshop on PDD, Cairo June Capacity Development for CDM Fourth National Workshop Cairo, June.
Ensuring Effective Monitoring, Certification and Verification of Emissions by Jed Jones Lloyd’s Register.
Verification of Forest-based Carbon Projects Sebastian Hetsch Carbon Management Service TÜV SÜD Industrie Service GmbH Roundtable on Validation and Verification.
Glenn S. Hodes UNEP Risø Center CDM Project Screening & PIN Development.
SDM programme UNFCCC secretariat Session 2: The CDM project cycle Monitoring, Verification and CER issuance Training-Workshop to support the “Uganda Municipal.
Joint Implementation & Gas Flaring Reduction Projects Alexandrina Platonova-Oquab Carbon Finance Unit, World Bank.
Accreditation of Independent entities under JI - Status of JISC work Georg B ø rsting UNFCCC Technical Workshop on Joint Implementation, 9-10 March 2006.
Learning Objectives LO1 Distinguish between management and auditor’s responsibilities regarding an auditee organization’s internal controls. LO2 Explain.
REVIEW AND QUALITY CONTROL
Quality Management in Business and Manufacturing Sectors.
Introduction to ISO New and modified requirements.
IAOD Evaluation Seminar “Demystifying Evaluation in WIPO- Best Practices from Initial Evaluations” Geneva November, Validation of Program Performance.
PDD Preparation Cairo, June 14 th -15 th, 2004 TIMS/EEAA CD4CDM- Third National Workshop (Phase II) UNEP RISO / APEXPDD Preparation Process and Format.
TÜV SÜD Industrie Service GmbH Workshop on PoA under the CDM: challenges and the road ahead - Bonn 8/9 May 2011 Session 9.1 „Application of Sampling in.
Software Quality Assurance Activities
READING A PAPER. Basic Parts of a Research Paper 1. Abstract 2. Introduction to Technology (background) 3. Tools & techniques/Methods used in current.
Workshop on CDM Methodologies and Technical Issues Associated with Power Generation and Power Saving Project Activities Review of approved and proposed.
CDM - PDD- Thu duc Plant Sep., 11, 2003 Preliminary findings of PDD– CDM model project for Thuduc fuel switching plant Master Nguyen Thi Kim Lien International.
Good Practice for monitoring plans Viewpoint of a DOE Marco van der Linden, SGS Climate Change Programme
Validation of Scenario Analysis and Control Group Baselines World Bank/PCF Workshop Delhi, Oct. 22, 2002 Trygve Roed-Larsen Det Norske Veritas (DNV)
Software Quality Assurance Lecture # 6 By: Faraz Ahmed.
Verification from PPs perspective Round table on A/R CDM projects Carbon Finance Unit – World Bank August 24&25, 2009 Walter Oyhantçabal A/R WG.
CD4CDM Review of Workshop 1 ….innovating energy solutions…. KITE, SSN & UNEP.
ITU Green Standards Week, Rome, Italy, September 5 – 9, 2011 Jean-Manuel Canet, Orange Business Services Jean-Manuel Canet Senior Manager, Orange Business.
The Scientific Method. The Basic Steps l State the problem l Form a hypothesis l Test the hypothesis l Draw conclusions.
Conclusions Buenos Aires, – December 5 th, 2004 CDM Methodologies and Project Design Workshop for CDM Project Developers.
Guatemala: El Canada Hydroelectric Project Meth Panel decision on its proposed baseline methodologies May 2003.
Regional Workshop to disseminate Water Supply and Sanitation Standards of Service, adapted to LDCs Préparation to the ISO TC 224 Drafts Standards test.
Validation and Verification of CDM projects SGS Climate Change Programme Shivananda Shetty Business Manager – SGS India Syed Khursheed Zaidi Operation.
TÜV SÜD Industrie Service GmbH CDM JCW Bonn 12 March 2011 Module 1.2 „existing barriers within the current PoA rules” An analysis from a DOEs perspective.“
METHODOLOGY AM0031: BRT BOGOTÁ (COLOMBIA): TransMilenio PHASE II - IV MAIN PROBLEMS.
Fundamentals of Governance: Parliament and Government Understanding and Demonstrating Assessment Criteria Facilitator: Tony Cash.
The system PROBLEM 1 FEIO Poor loading Insufficient number of facilities Small number of parameters Unaccountable methodology for taxes calculation Poor.
Project Management Processes for a Project
Validation Audits: +5 Program Summary Of the 57 audits: –37 (65%) - score of 100 –17 (30%) - score of 80 or 60 –2 (3.5%) - score of 40 or 20 –1.
Introduction to the Project Cycle Jane Ebinger Senior Energy Specialist Sustainable Development Department The World Bank.
Determinations / verifications under JI – Experience to date UNFCCC Technical Workshop on Joint Implementation Bonn, February 13 th, 2007 For the benefit.
Understanding Standards: Nominee Training Event
Clean Development Mechanism
Project Planning: Scope and the Work Breakdown Structure
Project Quality Management
Monitoring and Evaluation Systems for NARS Organisations in Papua New Guinea Day 3. Session 9. Periodic data collection methods.
Presentation to the Canadian Evaluation
Validation of Forest-based Carbon Projects
Determination / Verification under JI - Challenges and Pitfalls
Overview of Project Management
Joint Implementation A Parties and Buyers Perspective
READING A PAPER.
ולידציה מול כיול-השונה והדומה
Session 1 Guidelines for projects under Article 6 of the Kyoto Protocol First UNFCCC workshop on implementation of Article 6 projects under the Kyoto Protocol.
Conformity of Production (COP)
Quality Management in Business and Manufacturing Sectors
How to conduct Effective Stage-1 Audit
Small-Scale Projects Under JI
Taking the STANDARDS Seriously
Commission Regulation (EC)
CDM Activity Cycle under the Marrakech Accords
Figure:
Overview of Project Management
The Scientific Method.
Presentation transcript:

Some observations from chilean experience that could affect CDM methodologies by Alfonso Olea (TÜV- SÜD external auditor) APLE Consultores Chile

One main question: ¿What should be understood under… QUALITY ASSURANCE PROCEDURES IN CDM CONTEXT?? QA in ISO 9000, or ISO scenarios is very clear But what does QA mean in CDM scenario? In Monitoring methodology, should it be included in a more detailed or explicit way? (at least as a reference to the Monitoring Plan and then to define the quality asurement (at least as a reference to the Monitoring Plan and then to define the quality asurement In a MORE detailed way within the Plan? Our recommendation: YES, IT SHOULD BE!! And it may be helpfull to include and define basic concepts as it is done in other PDD terms definitions. Terms as “procedure”, “record”, “findings”, “unconformities”, “unconformity tracking”, “record keeping”, “uncertainties”, should be included, defined, and evaluated by developers.

It may have Impact on… Validation: Validation: Should these detailed definitions (regarding quality asurement) be included in the monitoring methodology and to be also verified. Verification: Verification: in terms of quality asurance, the scope of verification “what to verify and what not to verify”, unless under the same strictness verification of figures of the project. For ex: Emission reductions and other objectives of the CDM project, like social benefits

Conclusions This additional initial work in developing stages will help a lot during validation, verification and hopefully in new methodologies approval by giving additional levels of certainty This additional initial work in developing stages will help a lot during validation, verification and hopefully in new methodologies approval by giving additional levels of certainty It can help us in solving what was being discussed before regarding data accuracy and conservativeness issues. It can help us in solving what was being discussed before regarding data accuracy and conservativeness issues.

THANK YOU!! Alfonso Olea (TÜV- SÜD external auditor) APLE Consultores Chile