NSR Update The Big Picture Federal NSR Reform 2002-2006 PA NSR Reform –(724) 940-4000.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
New Source Review NSR Reforms Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality Air Quality Council Presented by Matt Paque, Attorney, ODEQ - AQD April 20,
Advertisements

Proposed Effluent Guidelines For the Concentrated Aquatic Animal Production Point Source Category by Janet Goodwin.
Clean Water Act Permitting and Operational Discharges from Vessels An Overview February 2007.
Ms. Sonty American Government September 10 th, 2014.
Chapter 8, Section 2 How Federal Courts Are Organized
State Implementation of Risk-Based MACT Exemptions Region 4 Permit Managers Meeting Rhonda B. Thompson, P.E., Director Engineering Services Division SC.
Variations and Timelines in the Federal Appeals Process Robert Mathes, Bjork Lindley Little PC.
CAFO Rule Update and Region 4 CAFO NPDES Program Implementation by Wayne J. Aronson Chief, PGTA Branch Ag Meeting December 06, 2005.
1 Indiana NSR Reform Training Presented by the Office of Air Quality NSR Reform Team.
New Source Review Reform Vera S. Kornylak, Associate Regional Counsel EPA Region 4 Office of Regional Counsel and Gregg Worley, Chief, Air Permits Section,
Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation (CAFO) Regulations - Update Meg Collins Colorado Livestock Association & Landon Gates Colorado Farm Bureau Water.
Supreme Court Cases Continued Civics. Furman V Georgia 1972 William Henry Furman convicted on Murder and Sentenced to Death – Supreme Court hears his.
Air Quality Beyond Ozone and PM2.5 Sheila Holman North Carolina Division of Air Quality 6 th Annual Unifour Air Quality Conference June 15, 2012.
Chapter 8.3 The United States Supreme Court. The Supreme Court Justices The main job of the nation’s top court is to decide whether laws are allowable.
NEW SOURCE REVIEW REFORM/SIMPLIFICATION JOHN A. PAUL STAPPA/ALAPCO MAY, 2002.
UTILITY NSR REFORM TIMEFRAMES EARLY 90’SBEGIN CAAA IMPLEMENTATION MID 90’SNSR REFORM DEVELOPMENT - S/A Principles - EPA Proposals.
Change picture on Slide Master EPA Regulation of Greenhouse Gases Industrial Energy Consumers of America November 16, 2009 PRESENTED BY Peter Glaserargaret.
Mississippi Air Update Mississippi Dept. of Environmental Quality September 12, 2012.
Proposed Rulemaking 25 Pa. Code Chapter 121. General Provisions Chapter 127 Subchapter E. New Source Review John Slade, Chief Division of Permits Bureau.
Kimberton, PA | Kennesaw, GA | Strategic Air Planning: Is the Time for a PAL Here? Mark Wenclawiak, CCM|
Copyright ISO Claims Partners retains sole ownership and copyright rights to this presentation. Any use or reproduction of this presentation without.
Chapter 8 Section 3 The United States Supreme Court.
Presentation to the HELLENIC MEDITERRANEAN PANEL HELLENIC MEDITERRANEAN PANEL (Athens, Greece - 23 October 2008)On US DISCHARGE STANDARDS -The NPDES Program-
1 Public Involvement, Access, and Petitions DJ Law EPA Region 8.
Supreme Court Cases -Highest Court in the Nation -All Decisions are Final -Usually Appellate Jurisdiction Only -Only hears about of thousands of.
Recent PSD Experiences in SWRO Regulatory & Statutory Requirements Relationship with EPA Federal Land Managers - FLAG Appeals.
Jessica Montanez Environmental Protection Agency NEW SOURCE REVIEW (NSR) PROGRAM.
The United States Supreme Court
New Source Review Rules Update Jessica Montanez U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Air Quality Policy Division.
 A court of appeals decides appeals from the district courts within its federal judicial circuit, and in some instances from other designated federal.
Step Therapy State Legislation Update AK HI CA AZ NV OR MT MN NE SD ND ID WY OK KS CO UT TX NM SC FL GAALMS LA AR MO IA VA NC TN IN KY IL MI.
Judicial. JUDICIAL BRANCH BASIC INFORMATION Types of Cases Civil – involves a lawsuit filed (plaintiff), and (defendant) court decides responsibility.
8.3 The Supreme Court. Jurisdiction The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction in only two instances: cases that involve diplomats from foreign countries.
NSR and Title V Activities WESTAR Business Meeting May 2005.
2005 NSR Regulation Changes Dwight Wylie. Old Units vs. New Units  There is a broad disparity between air pollution control requirements and emissions.
New Source Review Reform & the PAL Tom Wood September 18,2003.
Supreme Court In a flash. Justices of the Court Supreme Court Justices Composed of 9 justices – Chief Justice and 8 Associate Justices Duties have developed.
Air Quality Technical Advisory Committee Meeting September 27, 2006 Virendra Trivedi Chief, New Source Review/Title V Section Division of Permits Bureau.
Rules and Exceptions - The Costs of “Cheap” Coal.
Federal and State Courts. Jurisdiction The types of cases a court can hear. Two types of jurisdiction: Original/Appellate. Original: The first step in.
OAQPS Update WESTAR April 3,  On March 12, 2008, EPA significantly strengthened the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for ground-level.
Senate Bill 288- Limits Changes to Air Districts’ New Source Review Rules Beverly Werner, Manager Stationary Source Division California Air Resources Board.
THE FEDERAL JUDICIAL BRANCH. JUSTICES  Presidential appointment, Senate approval  No term length limit  Can be impeached  No qualifications needed.
1 Update on New Source Review (NSR) Activities and Priorities for Information Transfer and Program Integration Division April 7, 2004.
Regional Haze, PM, and Permits Update WESTAR Fall Meeting September 26, 2006.
1 New Sources in Nonattainment Areas: Citizens Against Refinery’s Effects Action to review EPA approval of Virginia SIP SIP included: Permit for refinery.
A MERICAN GOVERNMENT HOLT HOLT, RINEHART AND WINSTON The Federal Court System 1 Section 2: The Supreme Court Objectives: Explain what Judicial Review is;
Deciding Cases at the Supreme Court
The United States Supreme Court
UPDATE ON US LEGAL ISSUES NORTH AMERICAN PANEL MEETING 24 OCTOBER 2006
Kristin Leighty, Government Affairs Coordinator, NAHU
Final Rulemaking Nonattainment Source Review 25 Pa. Code, Chapter 121
Chapter 8, Section 3 The United States Supreme Court
Deciding cases at the Supreme Court 8.4
Section Update: Monitoring & Planning
Status of State Medicaid Expansion Decisions
Deciding cases at the Supreme Court
WESTAR Fall Meeting October 2, 2008
Why did the Clean Power Plan fail?
90-Day NSR Study and NSR Improvements
Chapter 7 The Judicial Branch
Chapter 8, Section 2 How Federal Courts Are Organized
The Projected Actual Emissions test & the “Could have Accommodated”/ “Demand growth” Exclusion david Lloyd, States/Local programs/EPA enforcement workshop.
New Source Review Update
PASFAA 2016 SPRING TRAINING:
8.3 The Supreme Court.
Implementation of New Source Review Changes
Status of RMRR or learning the definition of “routine”…
NACAA Response to EGU MACT Vacatur
Supreme Court at Work.
Presentation transcript:

NSR Update The Big Picture Federal NSR Reform PA NSR Reform –(724)

The Big Picture: (Any yahoo can kill any project) Plan Approvals Last 18 months Plan Approvals – Appeal to EHB (16-36 months to decide) EHB dispositions Right of Appeal to PA Commonwealth Court (6-18 months for decision)

Big Picture, Part 2: Aggravating Factors Anyone has “standing” in EHB EHB bias to “little guy” Free Lawyers provided by Anti- development groups Financing not available during Appeal

What to Do Expect Appeal of all Approvals Move fast – any delay can kill you Influence those bankrolling appeals? Change the Regulations –Life of permit –standing

Federal NSR Reforms 1 December 31, 2002 “NSR Improvements’ Challenged by NE States NY vs. EPA 413 F.3d3(D.C. 2005) Actual to PF Actual, 10 year PCP, Clean units, vacated Effective Now! PA-PSD, OH, WV

Federal NSR Reforms 2 October 23, 2003 RMRR Routine Maintenance & Repair Exemption Case-by-case, using 1980 IRS (2 to 18%) Vacated, NY vs. EPA (D.C. 03/17/06) “Old Rules” continue

Federal NSR Reforms 3 September 14, 2006 – –Debottlenecking –Aggregation –Project netting 71 FR (10/23/06) Public Hearing 11/06/06 Written comments 11/13 or 12/6 Lawsuits

Feedback: Privacy Policy Feedback
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
About project: SlidePlayer Terms of Service

© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc. All rights reserved.