A hot topic: the 21cm line III Benedetta Ciardi MPA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Future 21cm surveys and non-Gaussianity Antony Lewis Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge work with Anthony Challinor & Richard Shaw.
Advertisements

CMB and cluster lensing Antony Lewis Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge Lewis & Challinor, Phys. Rept : astro-ph/
21cm cosmology T. Chang, UP, J. Peterson, P. McDonald PRL 100, (2008) UP, L. Staveley-Smith, J. Peterson, T. Chang, MNRAS, 394, 6 (2009)
Probing the End of Reionization with High-redshift Quasars Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona Mar 18, 2005, Shanghai Collaborators: Becker, Gunn, Lupton,
First Stars, Quasars, and the Epoch of Reionization Jordi Miralda Escudé Institut de Ciències de l’Espai (IEEC-CSIC, ICREA), Barcelona. Instituto de Astrofísica.
End of Cosmic Dark Ages: Observational Probes of Reionization History Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona New Views Conference, Dec 12, 2005 Collaborators:
ESO Recent Results on Reionization Chris Carilli (NRAO) LANL Cosmology School, July 2011 Review: constraints on IGM during reionization  CMB large scale.
Digging into the past: Galaxies at redshift z=10 Ioana Duţan.
Planck 2013 results, implications for cosmology
Suman Majumdar Department of Astronomy and Oskar Klein Centre Stockholm University Redshift Space Anisotropies in the EoR 21-cm Signal: what do they tell.
HI 21cm Signal from Cosmic Reionization IAU 2006, Long Wavelength Astrophysics Chris Carilli (NRAO) Ionized Neutral Reionized.
Hydrogen 21cm Cosmology Tzu-Ching Chang (ASIAA)
21cm Constraints on Reionization Benedetta Ciardi MPA T. Di Matteo (CMU), A. Ferrara (SISSA), I. Iliev (CITA), P. Madau (UCSC), A. Maselli (MPA), F. Miniati.
A hot topic: the 21cm line II Benedetta Ciardi MPA.
The Dark Age… before the stars, beyond the galaxies…
Epoch of Reionization Tomography with the CSO Wide-field C+ spectral mapping and correlation with HI Matt Bradford CSO NSF visit: October 12, 2011 CSO.
Nikolaos Nikoloudakis Friday lunch talk 12/6/09 Supported by a Marie Curie Early Stage Training Fellowship.
Cosmology with the 21 cm Transition Steve Furlanetto Yale University September 25, 2006 Steve Furlanetto Yale University September 25, 2006.
CMB as a physics laboratory
A Primer on SZ Surveys Gil Holder Institute for Advanced Study.
Ultraviolet Pumping of the 21-cm Line in the High Redshift Universe Leonid Chuzhoy University of Texas at Austin Collaborators: Marcelo Alvarez (Stanford),
Large Scale Simulations of Reionization Garrelt Mellema Stockholm Observatory Collaborators: Ilian Iliev, Paul Shapiro, Marcelo Alvarez, Ue-Li Pen, Hugh.
Inflation, Expansion, Acceleration Two observed properties of the Universe, homogeneity and isotropy, constitute the Cosmological Principle Manifest in.
Matched Filter Search for Ionized Bubbles in 21-cm Maps Kanan K. Datta Dept. of Astronomy Stockholm University Oskar Klein Centre.
Neutrinos in Cosmology Alessandro Melchiorri Universita’ di Roma, “La Sapienza” INFN, Roma-1 NOW-2004, 16th September, 2004.
A hot topic: the 21cm line I Benedetta Ciardi MPA.
Raman Research Institute, Bangalore, India Ravi Subrahmanyan (RRI, Bangalore) Ron Ekers & Aaron Chippendale (CAS) A Raghunathan & Nipanjana Patra (RRI,
Polarization-assisted WMAP-NVSS Cross Correlation Collaborators: K-W Ng(IoP, AS) Ue-Li Pen (CITA) Guo Chin Liu (ASIAA)
The redshifted 21 cm background and particle decays Evgenii O. Vasiliev & Yuri A. Shchekinov Tartu Observatory, Estonia South Federal University, Russia.
Moscow cm Cosmology Collaborators: Collaborators: Rennan Barkana, Stuart Wyithe, Matias Zaldarriaga Avi Loeb Harvard University.
Yi Mao, MIT Collaborators: Max Tegmark, Alan Guth, Matias Zaldarriaga, Matt McQuinn, Oliver Zahn, Tom Faulkner, Ted Bunn, Serkan Cabi Constraining cosmological.
130 cMpc ~ 1 o z~ = 7.3 Lidz et al ‘Inverse’ views of evolution of large scale structure during reionization Neutral intergalactic medium via HI.
130 cMpc ~ 1 o z = 7.3 Lidz et al ‘Inverse’ views of evolution of large scale structure during reionization Neutral intergalactic medium via HI 21cm.
Dark energy I : Observational constraints Shinji Tsujikawa (Tokyo University of Science)
The Cosmic Microwave Background Lecture 2 Elena Pierpaoli.
Constraints on the neutrino mass by future precise CMB polarization and 21cm line observations Yoshihiko Oyama The Graduate University for Advanced Studies.
How can CMB help constraining dark energy? Licia Verde ICREA & Institute of space Sciences (ICE CSIC-IEEC)
The 21cm signature of the First Stars Xuelei Chen 陳學雷 National Astronomical Observatory of China Xuelei Chen 陳學雷 National Astronomical Observatory of China.
Nick Gnedin (Once More About Reionization)
CMB Polarization from Patchy Reionization Gil Holder.
Atomic physics and the cosmological 21 cm signal Jonathan Pritchard (CfA) Collaborators: Steve Furlanetto (UCLA) Avi Loeb (CfA)
Andrea Ferrara SISSA/International School for Advanced Studies, Trieste Cosmic Dawn and IGM Reionization.
Low Frequency Background and Cosmology Xuelei Chen National Astronomical Observatories Kashigar, September 10th 2005.
Exotic Physics in the Dark Ages Katie Mack Institute of Astronomy / Kavli Institute for Cosmology, University of Cambridge.
SUNYAEV-ZELDOVICH EFFECT. OUTLINE  What is SZE  What Can we learn from SZE  SZE Cluster Surveys  Experimental Issues  SZ Surveys are coming: What.
the National Radio Astronomy Observatory – Socorro, NM
Radiation backgrounds from the first sources and the redshifted 21 cm line Jonathan Pritchard (Caltech) Collaborators: Steve Furlanetto (Yale) Marc Kamionkowski.
Mário Santos1 EoR / 21cm simulations 4 th SKADS Workshop, Lisbon, 2-3 October 2008 Epoch of Reionization / 21cm simulations Mário Santos CENTRA - IST.
The Distributions of Baryons in the Universe and the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium Baryonic budget at z=0 Overall thermal timeline of baryons from z=1000.
Reionisation and the cross-correlation between the CMB and the 21-cm line fluctuations Hiroyuki Tashiro IAS, ORSAY 43rd Rencontres de Moriond La Thuile,
MATTEO VIEL STRUCTURE FORMATION INAF and INFN Trieste SISSA - 3 rd March and 7 th March 2011.
From Avi Loeb reionization. Quest to the Highest Redshift.
Probing the First Star Formation by 21cm line Kazuyuki Omukai (Kyoto U.)
Dark Energy and baryon oscillations Domenico Sapone Université de Genève, Département de Physique théorique In collaboration with: Luca Amendola (INAF,
The Twilight Zone of Reionization Steve Furlanetto Yale University March 13, 2006 Steve Furlanetto Yale University March 13, 2006 Collaborators: F. Briggs,
Lyman Alpha Spheres from the First Stars observed in 21 cm Xuelei Chen (Beijing) Jordi Miralda Escudé (IEEC, Barcelona).
Jonathan Pritchard (Caltech)
FIRST LIGHT A selection of future facilities relevant to the formation and evolution of galaxies Wavelength Sensitivity Spatial resolution.
COLLABORATORS: Dale Frail, Derek Fox, Shri Kulkarni, Fiona Harrisson, Edo Berger, Douglas Bock, Brad Cenko and Mansi Kasliwal.
Probing the dark ages with a lunar radio telescope Chris Carilli, Feb 2008 Dark Ages 15 < z < 200 Reionization 6 < z < 15 last phase of cosmic evolution.
Big Bang f(HI) ~ 0 f(HI) ~ 1 f(HI) ~ History of Baryons (mostly hydrogen) Redshift Recombination Reionization z = 1000 (0.4Myr) z = 0 (13.6Gyr) z.
The Dark Age and Cosmology Xuelei Chen ( 陈学雷 ) National Astronomical Observarories of China The 2nd Sino-French Workshop on the Dark Universe, Aug 31st.
Lyα Forest Simulation and BAO Detection Lin Qiufan Apr.2 nd, 2015.
Cheng Zhao Supervisor: Charling Tao
The cross-correlation between CMB and 21-cm fluctuations during the epoch of reionization Hiroyuki Tashiro N. Aghanim (IAS, Paris-sud Univ.) M. Langer.
Cosmological Structure with the Lyman Alpha Forest. Jordi Miralda Escudé ICREA, Institut de Ciències del Cosmos University of Barcelona, Catalonia Edinburgh,
Reionization of the Universe MinGyu Kim
Images: M. Blanton. Images: M. Blanton Figures: M. Blanton & SDSS.
Recovery of The Signal from the Epoch of Reionization
Detection of integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect by cross-correlation of the
Presentation transcript:

A hot topic: the 21cm line III Benedetta Ciardi MPA

o Differential brightness temperature o Maps are difficult to obtain  statistical quantities o Power spectrum: o Angular power spectrum: Some terminology & quantities

o Differential brightness temperature o Maps are difficult to obtain  statistical quantities o Power spectrum: o Angular power spectrum: Some terminology & quantities depends on e.g.: - underlying density distribution - ionized fraction - Lyalpha distribution - …

(Loeb & Zaldarriaga 2004) Absorption of CMB flux prior to structure formation  density structure Absorption prior to reionization (Loeb & Zaldarriaga 2004; Ali, Bharadwaj & Panday 2005; Barkana & Loeb 2005a; Pillepich, Porciani & Matarrese 2007; Lewis & Challinor 2007) Angular power spectrum

(Loeb & Zaldarriaga 2004) Absorption of CMB flux prior to structure formation  density structure Pb. Observations at frequencies <50MHz are extremely challenging Absorption prior to reionization Angular power spectrum

Atmospheric visibility T. Wilson Spitzer Hubble Chandra Compton GRO

(Loeb & Zaldarriaga 2004) Absorption of CMB flux prior to structure formation  density structure Pb. Observations at frequencies <50MHz are extremely challenging Absorption prior to reionization Angular power spectrum

If density fluctuations dominate 21cm fluctuations  cosmological parameters Determination of cosmological parameters McQuinn et al Errors on cosmological parameter estimates at z=8

If density fluctuations dominate 21cm fluctuations  cosmological parameters Determination of cosmological parameters McQuinn et al Errors on cosmological parameter estimates at z=8

If density fluctuations dominate 21cm fluctuations  cosmological parameters Determination of cosmological parameters McQuinn et al Errors on cosmological parameter estimates at z=10, 12

Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations o Cosmological perturbations excite sound waves  acoustic peaks in CMB o Imprints also on the power spectrum of non relativistic matter  BAO Mao & Wu 2007 Pure baryons Pure CDM CMD + baryons z=6 Linear power spectrum Eistenstein & Hu 1998 Cooray & Sheth 2002

Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations o Cosmological perturbations excite sound waves  acoustic peaks in CMB o Imprints also on the power spectrum of non relativistic matter  BAO Mao & Wu 2007 Pure baryons Pure CDM CMD + baryons z=6 Linear power spectrum

Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations o Cosmological perturbations excite sound waves  acoustic peaks in CMB o Imprints also on the power spectrum of non relativistic matter  BAO o BAO has been observed in large galaxy surveys as SDSS and 2dF

BAO detection: galaxy surveys SDSS

BAO detection: galaxy surveys SDSS Eisentein et al Cole et al Ω m h²= no baryons

BAO detection: galaxy surveys 2dF

Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations o Cosmological perturbations excite sound waves  acoustic peaks in CMB o Imprints also on the power spectrum of non relativistic matter  BAO o BAO has been observed in large galaxy surveys as SDSS and 2dF o Measurements of BAO  information on cosmological parameters

BAO detection: 21cm observations Mao & Wu cmA LOFAR o BAO signature on matter power spectrum  21cm power spectrum Mao & Wu 2007; Wyithe, Loeb & Geil 2007

BAO detection: 21cm observations o BAO signature on matter power spectrum  21cm power spectrum o 21cm galaxy survey

Gravitational lensing o Mass deflect light  multiple images, magnification, de-magnification, distortion

Gravitational lensing o Mass deflect light  multiple images, magnification, de-magnification, distortion Turner 2002

Gravitational lensing o Mass deflect light  multiple images, magnification, de-magnification, distortion NASA

Gravitational lensing o Mass deflect light  multiple images, magnification, de-magnification, distortion o If distortions very small  statistical analysis o Measurement of distortion  reconstruction of the foreground mass

Gravitational lensing o Mass deflect light  multiple images, magnification, de-magnification, distortion o If distortions very small  statistical analysis o Measurement of distortion  reconstruction of the foreground mass o Measurements of LSS weak lensing done with galaxies as background sources o Use NIRB, CMB or 21cm as background sources (Cooray 04; Pen 04; Zhan & Zaldarraiga 06; Lu & Pen 07) o Advantage of 21cm: many more sources, many more z

Gravitational lensing Metcalf & White 2007

Gravitational lensing Metcalf & White 2008

Gravitational lensing Hilbert, Metcalf & White ' HI sources at z=12 Spaced based gal. survey z med =1.23 Redshifts and virial masses

Hilbert, Metcalf & White 2007 No noise Noise HI sources Spaced based galaxy survey Ground based galaxy survey

Redshift Evolution of HI density z=18z=16z=14 z=12 z=13 z=11.5 z=10.5 z=9.5 z=9 z=10 z=8.5z= (BC, Stoehr & White 2003)

Maps of brightness temperature K Distribution of (BC & Madau 2003)

Instrument sampling Instrument sensitivity Convolution with a Gaussian beam (  =3 arcmin) LOFAR-type telescope could be able to map the IGM reionization history & distinguish between reionization sources Expected response SimulatedSynthetic z=10.6, ν=122 MHz z=9.89, ν=130 MHz z=9.26, ν=138 MHz Valdes et al. 2006

Observation of HII regions of high-z QSOs Wyithe, Loeb & Barnes 2005 Additional tool to study the IGM at z~6; estimate of n HI (Zaroubi & Silk 2005; Chen & Miralda-Escude' 2006; Cen 2006; Rhook & Haehnelt 2007; Liu et al. 2007)

Late Early  CMB anisotropies are produced by free electrons  21cm line is emitted by neutral hydrogen CMB/21cm line correlation Late Early

Characteristic angular scale of the cross-correlation function Late Early Mpc/h The characteristic angular scale of the cross-correlation function gives an estimate of the typical dimension of the HII regions at redshift of the 21cm emission line. CMB/21cm line correlation We find an anti-correlation below a characteristic angular scale, θ 0, when the correlation function becomes < 0. (Salvaterra et al. 2005; Alvarez et al. 2006; Holder et al. 2006; Adshead & Furlanetto 2007) Also correlation with galaxies?

Late Early (BC & Madau 2003) Fluctuations of brightness temp. l Late/Early reionization show similar behaviour l The peak of the emission is ~10 mK l Early reion. 90MHz, late reion. 115MHz Planned radio telescopes should be able to detect such signal (Madau et al. 1997; Ciardi & Madau 2003; Furlanetto et al. 2004; Zaldarriaga et al. 2004; Mellema et al. 2006; Santos et al. 2007)

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs

Absorption features in high-z radio sources DLAs

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs o Proto-galactic disks and mini-halos

Absorption features in high-z radio sources Proto-galactic disks & mini-halos Furlanetto & Loeb 2002

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs o Proto-galactic disks and mini-halos

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs o Proto-galactic disks and mini-halos o IGM  21cm forest

Absorption features in high-z radio sources 21cm forest

IGM absorption from high-z radio source (Carilli, Gnedin & Owen 2002; Carilli et al. 2004) Additional information HI in the IGM (GRB's afterglow, Ioka & Meszaros 2004)

Absorption features in high-z radio sources o Luminous radio source  21cm absorption features o DLAs o Proto-galactic disks and mini-halos o IGM  21cm forest Pb. Are there bright enough sources of radio radiation at high-z?

High-z radio sources

Masers o Population inversion  masers statistical weight spin temperature

Masers o Population inversion  masers o A maser can boost the 21cm signal by order of magnitudes I(r) grows exponentially with r !!!

Masers o Population inversion  masers o A maser can boost the 21cm signal by order of magnitudes o

Masers o Population inversion  masers o A maser can boost the 21cm signal by order of magnitudes o If there are more photons with than with  maser! (Madau, Meiksin & Rees 1997)

Masers o Population inversion  masers o A maser can boost the 21cm signal by order of magnitudes o Dijkstra & Loeb 2007 Frequency shift: Doppler frequency width: Velocity dispersion:

Masers o Population inversion  masers o A maser can boost the 21cm signal by order of magnitudes o

SETI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence o SETI program started in the '60s o Typically radio frequencies are scanned o Big Ear Observatory, Arecibo, Jodrell Bank… o Current programs could detect: - powerful beacons - transmissions with more typical power levels at distances < 1pc no star within 1pc from the Sun  no detection! Signals detectable by SKA Tarter (2001); Lazio et al. (2004)

o Power spectrum & cosmological parameters (BAOs, WL, 21cm from very high z…) o Map the evolution of HI in the IGM  reionization history & sources o Absorption studies of high-z radio sources Future 21cm observations