OPTIMIZED COATINGS Juri Agresti, Giuseppe Castaldi, Riccardo de Salvo, Vincenzo Galdi, Vincenzo Pierro, Innocenzo M. Pinto * LIGO Lab / Caltech TWG / University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Detectors: Advancing toward a Global Network Stan Whitcomb LIGO/Caltech ICGC, Goa, 18 December 2011 LIGO-G v1.
Advertisements

1 An Adaptive GA for Multi Objective Flexible Manufacturing Systems A. Younes, H. Ghenniwa, S. Areibi uoguelph.ca.
Low temperature dissipative behavior in uncoated fused silica slabs Flavio Travasso Dip. Fisica – Università di Perugia and INFN Perugia Virgo - Perugia.
Derivation and Use of Reflection Coefficient
Work Package 4: Development of low loss dielectric coatings for advanced detectors Scientific motivation: Mechanical dissipation from dielectric mirror.
The Waves Group March LIGO- G R Non periodic dielectric mirror coatings Giuseppe CASTALDI TWG Riccardo DESALVO LIGO Vincenzo GALDI TWG.
Applying Genetic Algorithms to Decision Making in Autonomic Computing Systems Authors: Andres J. Ramirez, David B. Knoester, Betty H.C. Cheng, Philip K.
Non-Linear Problems General approach. Non-linear Optimization Many objective functions, tend to be non-linear. Design problems for which the objective.
Department of Engineering, Control & Instrumentation Research Group 22 – Mar – 2006 Optimisation Based Clearance of Nonlinear Flight Control Laws Prathyush.
Genetic Algorithms in Materials Processing N. Chakraborti Department of Metallurgical & Materials Engineering Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur.
Basic Concepts and Definitions Vector and Function Space. A finite or an infinite dimensional linear vector/function space described with set of non-unique.
Genetic Algorithms Nehaya Tayseer 1.Introduction What is a Genetic algorithm? A search technique used in computer science to find approximate solutions.
Laurent Itti: CS599 – Computational Architectures in Biological Vision, USC Lecture 7: Coding and Representation 1 Computational Architectures in.
Anti-reflection optical coatings Anti-reflection coatings are frequently used to reduce the Fresnel reflection. For normal incidence, the intensity reflection.
G Z TNI Progress and Status: Ring Dampers and Aperiodic Coatings Eric D. Black LSC Meeting Aug. 16, 2006 Kenneth Libbrecht, Dennis Coyne Grad.
Normalised Least Mean-Square Adaptive Filtering
Reliability-Redundancy Allocation for Multi-State Series-Parallel Systems Zhigang Tian, Ming J. Zuo, and Hongzhong Huang IEEE Transactions on Reliability,
Polarization-preserving of laser beam in Fabry Perot Cavity Accelerator center, IHEP Li Xiaoping.
Choosing Frequencies for Multifrequency Animal Abundance Estimation Paul Roberts AOS Seminar March 3, 2005.
International Technology Alliance In Network & Information Sciences International Technology Alliance In Network & Information Sciences 1 Cooperative Wireless.
Genetic Algorithm.
1 Basics of Microwave Measurements Steven Anlage
D EDICATED S PECTROPHOTOMETER F OR L OCALIZED T RANSMITTANCE A ND R EFLECTANCE M EASUREMENTS Laetitia ABEL-TIBERINI, Frédéric LEMARQUIS, Michel LEQUIME.
A Budget Constrained Scheduling of Workflow Applications on Utility Grids using Genetic Algorithms Jia Yu and Rajkumar Buyya Grid Computing and Distributed.
Overview of Research in the Optics Working Group Gregory Harry, on behalf of the OWG Massachusetts Institute of Technology July 25, 2007 LSC Meeting –
Alban REMILLIEUX3 rd ILIAS-GW Annual General Meeting. London, October 26 th -27 th, New coatings on new substrates for low mechanical loss mirrors.
1 / 12 PSLC Summer School, June 21, 2007 Identifying Students’ Gradual Understanding of Physics Concepts Using TagHelper Tools Nava L.
SOFT COMPUTING (Optimization Techniques using GA) Dr. N.Uma Maheswari Professor/CSE PSNA CET.
Coating Research Program Update Gregory Harry LIGO/Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Technical Plenary - August 15, 2005 LSC Meeting / Hanford.
Thermal Noise from Coatings Gregg Harry; Andri Gretarsson, Scott Kittelberger, Steve Penn, Peter Saulson; Marty Fejer, Eric Gustafson, Roger Route, Sheila.
Purdue University Optimization of Sensor Response Functions for Colorimetry of Reflective and Emissive Objects Mark Wolski*, Charles A. Bouman, Jan P.
LIGO-G Z TNI Progress and Status Greg Ogin LSC Meeting March 22, 2007 Eric Black, Kenneth Libbrecht, Dennis Coyne Grad students: Akira Villar,
A. Bunkowski Nano-structured Optics for GW Detectors 1 A.Bunkowski, O. Burmeister, D. Friedrich, K. Danzmann, and R. Schnabel in collaboration with T.
Thermal noise from optical coatings Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - on behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - 25 July
Motif finding with Gibbs sampling CS 466 Saurabh Sinha.
Genetic Algorithms Genetic algorithms imitate a natural optimization process: natural selection in evolution. Developed by John Holland at the University.
Overview of coating research Stuart Reid On behalf of the coating subgroup LSC/VIRGO meeting, September 2008, Amsterdam G R.
LIGO Coating Project Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT - On Behalf of the Coating Working Group - LIGO/Virgo Thermal Noise Workshop October 7, 2006 Pisa, Italy LIGO-G R.
Gravitational Wave Detection Using Precision Interferometry Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration.
G R LIGO R&D1 Wireless optical controls of LIGO static suspensions actuators Maria Paola Clarizia University of Sannio Mentor: Riccardo De Salvo.
G R Thermal Noise Interferometer Advisory Board Review Eric Black, Akira Villar, Greg Ogin, Tara Chelermsongsak, Riccardo Desalvo, and Kenneth.
Optical Coatings R&D Status Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the Coating Working Group - August, 2004 LSC Meeting Hanford.
Beams of the Future Mihai Bondarescu, Oleg Kogan, Yanbei Chen, Andrew Lundgreen, Ruxandra Bondarescu, David Tsang A Caltech - AEI - Cornell Collaboration.
Genetic Algorithms What is a GA Terms and definitions Basic algorithm.
LIGO- G Z Analyzing Event Data Lee Samuel Finn Penn State University Reference: T030017, T
Effect of Temperature on Coating Thermal Noise in Advanced LIGO
Coating Program Update Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT on behalf of the Coating Working Group March 22, 2006 LSC Meeting – LHO G R.
Space Time Codes. 2 Attenuation in Wireless Channels Path loss: Signals attenuate due to distance Shadowing loss : absorption of radio waves by scattering.
Coating Workshop, Caltech, March 21, 2008 G R 1 First Results from the Syracuse University Scatter Imaging Lab Joshua Smith, Matt West, Dave Evans,
Janyce Franc-Kyoto-GWADW1 Simulation and research for the future ET mirrors Janyce Franc, Nazario Morgado, Raffaele Flaminio Laboratoire des Matériaux.
D Nagesh Kumar, IIScOptimization Methods: M8L5 1 Advanced Topics in Optimization Evolutionary Algorithms for Optimization and Search.
The importance of Coatings for Interferometric Gravitational Wave Observatories Riccardo DeSalvo for the Coating group
LIGO-G R 1 Mexican Hat developments LMA cantilever measurements Riccardo DeSalvo LIGO Gravitational Wave Observatories California Institute of.
Coating Discussion Gregg Harry LIGO - MIT March 2008 LSC/Virgo Meeting March 19, 2008 LIGO-DCC Number.
N- Queens Solution with Genetic Algorithm By Mohammad A. Ismael.
Beams of the Future Mihai Bondarescu, Oleg Kogan, Yanbei Chen, Andrew Lundgreen, Ruxandra Bondarescu, David Tsang A Caltech - AEI - Cornell Collaboration.
March 9, Broadcasting with Bounded Number of Redundant Transmissions Majid Khabbazian.
Optical Coatings for Gravitational Wave Detection Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - August.
1 Comparative Study of two Genetic Algorithms Based Task Allocation Models in Distributed Computing System Oğuzhan TAŞ 2005.
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, E. Chalkley 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
Genetic Algorithm. Outline Motivation Genetic algorithms An illustrative example Hypothesis space search.
Evolutionary Computation: Advanced Algorithms and Operators
Ab Initio Property Prediction with Density Functional Theory (DFT) Relevant to Coating Thermal Noise Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory.
Genetic Algorithms.
constructive interference. destructive interference.
with Results from Mixture Theory
Overview of Advanced LIGO Coating Status
Maria Principe University of Sannio, Benevento, Italy
topics Basic Transmission Line Equations
Riccardo DeSalvo (Cal State LA)
Presentation transcript:

OPTIMIZED COATINGS Juri Agresti, Giuseppe Castaldi, Riccardo de Salvo, Vincenzo Galdi, Vincenzo Pierro, Innocenzo M. Pinto * LIGO Lab / Caltech TWG / University of Sannio at Benevento LIGO G R The Waves Group August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

Rationale Current mirror design: quarter-wavelength (QWL) alternating SiO 2 and Ta 2 O 5 layers. Yields largest reflectance among all stacked-doublet designs for any fixed no. of layers (or equivalently, smallest no. of layers at any fixed reflectance). Coating (structural) noise dominates thermal-noise budget in key spectral range. QWL coating does not yield mimimum noise for a prescribed reflectivity, hence not optimal August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory LIGO G R

Coating Design Optimization: Status & Work Plan ( ) August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Status/Directions Genetic optimization (running) Stacked-doublet (completed) Regular non-periodic (just started) The choice, for highest design flexibility and insight; Most obvious generalization of stacked quarter wavelength; getting closer to the “perfect mirror”; On top of this: new materials (e.g., JMM TiO 2 -doped Tantala) LIGO G R

Funding Proposal August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory INFN – COAT ( PI Innocenzo M. Pinto) Participants: TWG (algorithm and code), CALTECH LIGO-Lab (substrates & TNI), LMA Lyon, FR (prototyping; bare costs). Goal: prototyping four GA-optimized mirrors to be tested at CALTECH TNI. Time-span: 1 year (2006). Requested budget: 50 KEU (60 K$). Partnerships: ILIAS-Strega (S. Rowan/J. Hough), TAMA (Tsubono K.), VIRGO (F. Vetrano). LIGO G R

Genetic Optimization August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Educated ignorance attitude (almost no a-priori assumption on structure of sought solution - will shed light on it !); Effective & well established (e.g. microwave antenna and filter design)… -structural/rheology-related constraints; -multiple-wavelength operation; -several (> 2) materials, etc.… Available options include: Nice Features Multiple, heterogeneous mixed continuous/discrete constraints; Multi-objective and/or best tradeoff optimization; Robust. Status: PIKAIA-based Code-kernel developed. LIGO G R

Crossover+Mutation s -Problem unknowns  genes; -Point in search space  chromosome; -Set of points in search space  population; -Evolve random initial population according to an evolutionary schedule Genetic Algos in a Nutshell LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

Stacked Doublet Optimization August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Most obvious generalization of current stacked- /4-design. Coating reflectivity is a monotonic (increasing) function of Bloch characteristic exponent (BCE) of transmission matrix of basic doublet (true for any truncated-periodic); Coating noise is closely modeled by a simple (linear) law: LIGO G R  C  Tantala +  -1  Silica  total (physical) thicknesses  related to Young moduli, Poisson ratios & loss angles of both substrate & coating materials. In view of present measurement uncertainties  can be anything between 10 and 30.

Stacked Doublet Optimization z S +z T =1/2 zTzT zSzS Increasing doublet noise zTzT zSzS z S = optical length SiO 2 layer z T = optical length Ta 2 O 5 layer In units of August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory LIGO G R

BCE contour lines very thin: no sensible difference between exact and approximate (z T +z S =1/2) optimization August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Stacked Doublet Optimization: Approximation # 1 LIGO G R

12-17 August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Stacked Doublet Optimization: Approximation # 2 LIGO G R …both absorbed by large by uncertainty in 

Constructing Tradeoff Curves -Assign number N of doublets; -Assign noise upper-bound noise for whole coating; -Compute corresponding upper-bound for single doublet; -Determine z S and z T so as to maximize BCE; under tha above noise constraint; -Compute terminated N-doublet reflection coefficient. LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

LIGO G R Stacked Doublet Optimization Status: Transmissivity vs. Noise Tradeoff Curves Drawn Each point on any curve corresponds to a z T /z S value. 8.3 ppm Noise # doublets August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory  =10

Current LIGO design z T +z S =1/2 Tantala noise Silica noise LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Stacked Doublet Optimization optimum

GA Engineered Prototype SiO 2 layer # s s e n k c i h t [nm] Ta 2 O 5 layer# Goal: 1-|  | 2 < 15 ppm. L[Ta 2 O 5 ] < 2000 nm,  = . (after 10 5 generations) LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

GA Prototype, contd. QWL-1GeneticQWL-2 N (cap included) |  | 2 ppm L(Ta 2 O 5 ) nm L(SiO 2 ) nm L tot nm vs. nearest-neighbour quarter-wavelengths (QWL) LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

Stacked Doublets: Lesson from GA: Tweak End Layers to Improve Reflectivity ! z1z1 zNzN 1 -|  | 2 reflectance increased by ~ 10%, noise increased by ~ 1% (z 1 = , z N =0.0437, in units of  ) LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

l 0 nm G Mirror frequency response (normal incidence). Distribution of 1-|  | 2. Random uniform errors, 10 4 trials. GA Prototype Characterization LIGO G R August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory

Regular Non-Periodic Coatings August 2005, LIGO Hanford Observatory Status: just started Two main sub-classes: Fractal (e.g., Cantor); Substitutional (e.g. Fibonacci); Goal: large bandwidths (in frequency and wavenumber) [e.g., Optics Lett. 23 (1998) 1573]; Background: applications in antenna array synthesis [e.g., IEEE Trans. AP-53 (2005) 635] LIGO G R