Abstract Research with youth faces particular challenges, including potential confusion about researchers’ intentions and vulnerabilities related to power.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Qualitative Study Initial Thinking Impact of Learning Environments on Well being of Children.
Advertisements

Polokwane, WORKING WITH CHILDREN World Health Organisation (2011) Cognitively ready for disclosure 8-11 years Children of school going age should.
Predicting Youth Engagement: The Role of Initiating and Sustaining Factors Linda Rose-Krasnor 1, Kelly Campbell 1, Lisa Loiselle 2, Mark Pancer 3, Michael.
Introduction I would like to investigate the extent to which both young people and adults feel that young people also can and should have a say in the.
Robin L. Donaldson May 5, 2010 Prospectus Defense Florida State University College of Communication and Information.
Maternal Psychological Control: Links to Close Friendship and Depression in Early Adolescence Heather L. Tencer Jessica R. Meyer Felicia D. Hall University.
Impact of Migration on Older Age Parents A Case Study of Two Communes in Battambang Province, Cambodia Paper presented at Mekong Workshop, Salt Lake City.
Chapter 2: INTRODUCTION TO CORRELATES OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY THINGS THAT MIGHT BE RELATED TO BEING ACTIVE.
Welcome to MindLab’s Tele-Training Self-Paced Tutorial for the Coping & Stress Profile ®
PEER: Exploring the lives of sex workers in Tyne and Wear The PEER Research Team: The GAP project, Northumbria University and Peer Researchers.
Research Ethics Levels of Measurement. Ethical Issues Include: Anonymity – researcher does not know who participated or is not able to match the response.
Study 1: Method Demographics 346 men and 299 women 41.1% Dating, 18.2% Cohabiting, 4.2% Engaged or 18.9 Married Mean age of sample was 31.7 years Procedure.
Perception of possessions and personality traits among urban children Kara Chan, Professor Fan Hu, Ph.D. student School of Communication Hong Kong Baptist.
Developing a Questionnaire. Goals Discuss asking the right questions in the right way as part of an epidemiologic study. Review the steps for creating.
Evaluating the Use of Bright Futures Educational Materials with Parents of Young Children with Special Needs Janel D. Lauer, OTR/L Health Services MPH.
By Sanjay Kumar, Ph.D National Programme Officer (M&E), UNFPA – India
Sara Xiong & Rebecca Radle, Advisor: Dr. Susan Wolfgram, University of Wisconsin-Stout Research Question & Hypothesis What resources do young single parents.
WHAT ARE DEVELOPMENTAL ASSETS?  Assets usually signify financial resources. In our context, assets mean valuable resources of another kind.  The Search.
The My World Survey (MWS): The Twin Track- Alcohol and mental health in young people today Amanda Fitzgerald 1 & Barbara Dooley 1,2 UCD School of Psychology.
Positive Emotion in Language Production: Age Differences in Emotional Valence of Stories Elise Rosa and Deborah Burke Pomona College The Linguistic Inquiry.
Families as Partners in Learning Principals and teaching staff Why are partnerships important?
Chapter 5: MOTIVATION THROUGH FEELINGS OF COMPETENCE AND CONFIDENCE I think I can, I know I can …
The Quality of Teacher-Student and Home-School Relationships in Black and White Students in West-Central Wisconsin Paula Hoffert, M.S.E. and Barbara Lozar,
Domain 1: Preparation and Planning. ElementUnsatisfactoryBasicProficientDistinguished Knowledge of content and the structure of the discipline In planning.
Social-Emotional Development Unit 3 - Getting Ready for the Unit
IMPACT OF BLANTYRE TEEN CLUB( BTC) ON THE LIVES OF HIV- POSITIVE TEENS AND THEIR GUARDIANS. Munkhondya, B., Kapito, E., Chamanga, R., Chadza, E., Bwazi,
WCSD Student Climate Survey: What do students have to say about our schools?
Method Participants Participants were 68 preschoolers, between the ages of 29 and 59 months of age. The sample was comprised of 32 male participants and.
Educational Psychology Chapter 3 – Personal, Social and Emotional Development.
Printed by Parent-Adolescent Relationship Quality and the Development of Romantic Values Jessica K. Winkles, Joseph P. Allen University.
Attitudes towards Active Travel to School among schoolchildren in Scotland Jo Kirby and Jo Inchley Child and Adolescent Health Research Unit (CAHRU), University.
Promoting good practice in tackling poverty and disadvantage INSET materials for primary schools.
Chapter 12 – Social Cognition Self-Concept Distinguish self from world months Self-recognition & knowledge months - refer to selves.
Problem-Solving Abilities and Feelings of Control: A Work in Progress Emily M. Kaiser, Department of Communication Studies, College of Arts and Sciences.
Seminar on Theories in Child Development: Overview Dr. K. A. Korb University of Jos.
Adolescent Romantic Relationships and Depressive Symptoms: The Importance of Emotion Regulation and Close Friendships Introduction David E. Szwedo
Symposium: Social Justice and Lifelong Learning in Europe The Challenges of conducting surveys with adults who have experienced ‘educational disadvantage’
Personal Values and Youth Involvement S. Mark Pancer, Wilfrid Laurier University and The Centre of Excellence for Youth Engagement Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation P11 Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation Assessing children’s.
Students’ perceptions on using blogs for reflective learning in higher educational contexts Presenters : Irshad Ali and Dr Kevin Byard.
Multiple Regression Results Standardized beta weights are shown in the prediction of community involvement (CI) and next year intentions (NYI) – controlling.
Early Adolescent Behaviors in Disagreement with Best Friend Predictive of Later Emotional Repair Abilities Lauren Cannavo, Elenda T. Hessel, Joseph S.
GPs and Bereavement – survey and findings Donal Gallagher – Bereavement Development Programme Manager Sridevi Singh – End of Life Care Project Officer.
ABSTRACT Recent studies have examined the association of singular adolescent attitudes to particular age periods (Schnirer, 2001). We analyze the relationship.
Janis L. Whitlock Cornell University.   Previous research show that human beings develop in multiple social ecologies but school connectedness and the.
Personal Control over Development: Effects on the Perception and Emotional Evaluation of Personal Development in Adulthood.
NEW FOCUS nf nf 1 Research Strategy and Implementation Telephone: Facsimile: ACN: 066.
Attachment and Development in Adolescent Romantic Couples’ Relationship Quality Sharon C. Risch University of Tennessee.
Chapter 14: Affective Assessment
General and Feeding Specific Behavior Problems in a Community Sample of Children Amy J. Majewski, Kathryn S. Holman & W. Hobart Davies University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.
Perceptions of Barriers to Services (PBS): The development of a new scale Matt Owens, Valerie Dunn, Mischa Gwaspari, Kelly Harris, Megan Ryan, Sonya Tsancheva.
From Managing Emotions to Improving Relationships: Higher Quality Best Friendships Predicted from Earlier Emotion Regulation. Elenda T. Hessel, Megan M.
College Students’ Behaviors, Perceptions, Beliefs, and Attitudes Regarding Tanning Bed Use Fawna M. Playforth, BS; Laurie J. Larkin, PhD; & Laurel A. Mills,
Sociology. Sociology is a science because it uses the same techniques as other sciences Explaining social phenomena is what sociological theory is all.
The Psychological Effect of Exposure to Gang Violence on Youths: A Pilot Study The Psychological Effect of Exposure to Gang Violence on Youths: A Pilot.
Prejudice formation in children Dr Louisa Jones Birmingham Educational Psychology Service.
Comparing Year 9 and Year 10 May, Background Assessment and Action Record Interviews (AAR’s) are completed annually with all children and youth.
School-based Social Interactions of Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorders Renee Hawkins, Ph.D., Laura Nabors Ph.D., Andrew Yockey, Stephanie Booker,
Examining difference: chi-squared (x 2 ). When to use Chi-Squared? Chi-squared is used to examine differences between what you actually find in your study.
Discussion Results Introduction From Lateral to Leader: A Study of Preschoolers’ Relationships with Peers Erin Podgorski & Dr. Carin L. Neitzel, The University.
Emotion Knowledge in Maltreated Preschoolers
Introduction paragraph – what looking to investigate.
Friends’ Perspective: Friendship Changes Following Serious Illness Onset in Adolescence Eva C Igler, MA, Ellen K Defenderfer, MS, Gina A Erato, BS, Karley.
Writing your reflection in Stage 1 & 2 Indonesian (continuers)
Peer Support and Respite Improves Individual and Family Wellbeing in Young People Caring for an Adult with a Mental Health Problem Ailsa Grant, Rasa.
Laura M. Sylke & David E. Szwedo James Madison University Introduction
Lauren A. Barlotta & David E. Szwedo James Madison University
Korey F. Beckwith & David E. Szwedo James Madison University
Kristin E. Gross & David E. Szwedo James Madison University
Introduction Results Discussion Hypotheses Method
Presentation transcript:

Abstract Research with youth faces particular challenges, including potential confusion about researchers’ intentions and vulnerabilities related to power differentials between youth and adults. To better understand these challenges, we explored youth responses to a “typical” research experience. After completing a questionnaire as part of a larger study of youth engagement, 192 youth (76% female; M = 16.64) were asked for perceptions of their research participation. 87% of the 143 youth responding to a question about how the questionnaire made them feel indicated that they were emotionally affected, either positively (64%) or negatively (24%). Younger participants were more negatively affected than older youth. The extent of emotional involvement in research experiences suggests a need to better understand youth perceptions of participation and to make the research environment “youth friendly”. Introduction There is little research available on how youth perceive their experience as research participants. However, young participants may be particularly vulnerable to age-related ethical issues, lack ability to understand researchers’ intentions and use of the information collected, and be unfamiliar with the language and methodology of commonly used measurement tools. The goal of this research was to explore youth perceptions of the research process and examine the possible age and sex differences. Participants and Procedures 192 youth (76% female; M = 16.64, years old) participated as part of a larger project on youth engagement. Youth completed a 30-min. questionnaire measuring youth engagement; values of self, parents, and peers; social support; relationship quality, self-description; self-esteem; and demographics information. Six questions on research participation were included at the end of the questionnaire: how filling out the questionnaire made the youth feel, which questions they enjoyed answering the most and the least, which questions they would and would not have included, and what comments they had about research participation or youth engagement. Responses to each question were coded into the categories displayed in the graphs below. YOUTH PERCEPTIONS OF RESEARCH Iva Zovkic 1, Mark Pancer 2, Michael Busseri 1, Linda Rose-Krasnor 1, and The Centre of Excellence for Youth Engagement 1 Brock University, 2 Wilfrid Laurier University Results The Centres of Excellence are a Health Canada-funded program. The opinions expressed in this document do not necessarily reflect those of Health Canada. Discussion and Conclusions Overall, a majority of respondents had a positive response to the survey. Many indicated that the questions gave them insight into their own feelings. Youth reported that questions about their involvement and their personal characteristics and beliefs were enjoyed most. Almost as many youth (31% vs. 23%), however, found the latter questions to be least enjoyable. Answering relationship questions were more enjoyable for older youth. Perhaps the older respondents were more focused on their relationships than younger youth or felt more competent to make assessments in this domain. Almost a quarter of the youth had a negative experience reaction to the survey. Specifically, youth reported that the questions made them feel bad about their situations or found the survey boring or impersonal. Many considered the questions about other people’s values difficult to answer and presumptuous. Demographic questions sometimes were seen to be more intrusive than investigators often assume and some youth considered these questions to reduce their individuality by categorizing them. Younger participants were more likely to report negative responses than older youth. Perhaps they were less likely to understand the goals of the research or had more difficulty with the format or language. Overall, researchers need to provide more context for survey questions, in order for youth to understand their purpose. Further, researchers need to be aware of the potential negative consequences they may have for youth – consequences that may not be readily apparent from an adult perspective. Future research should focus on finding ways to make young people’s experience with research as positive as possible. One method is to include youth in the planning stages of research projects, in order to benefit from their perspective on research goals and methods. Such consultation also would help researchers to anticipate possible negative consequences and make the research environment more “youth friendly”. Youth-adult research partnerships are a promising strategy to achieve these goals. Figure 1. How did answering these questions make you feel? Figure 4. What questions would you have included? Figure 2. What questions did you enjoy answering the most? Figure 3. What questions did you enjoy answering the least? Figure 5. What questions would you have not included? Figure 6. Please give us any comments you have about the research. Individual Differences Analyses Chi-Square analyses were used to assess age and sex differences in categorical responses Age groups were formed using a median split: “Younger” youth were yrs. (n=72) of age and “older” youth were yrs. old (n=120). Categories were selected for each analyses based on cell frequency and content How did answering these questions make you feel? Categories combined to include “positive”, “negative” and “neutral” 64% of respondents had positive reactions, 24% had negative, and 13% had neutral reactions No sex differences Trend for age, Chi-Square(2)=4.78, p<.091 Younger participants were less positive about the research than older youth (51% vs. 70% respectively), more negative (32% vs. 20%), and more neutral (17% vs. 10%) What questions did you enjoy answering the most? Categories for analyses included “none”, “all/no”, “friends/family”, “self/skills”, “involvement” No age or sex differences What questions did you enjoy answering the least? Categories for analyses included “all/most”, “myself”, “relationships”, “principles” No sex differences Significant age differences, Chi-Square(3)=8.65, p<.034 Younger participants were more likely to mention “all/most” questions than older youth (53% vs. 29% respectively) and less likely to mention relationship items (5% vs. 23%) Selected References Dorn, L. D., Susman, E. J., & Fletcher, J. C. (1995). Informed consent in children and adolescents: age, maturation and psychological state. Journal of Adolescent Health, 16, Fisher, C. B., Higgins-D’Alessandro, A., Rau, J. B., Kuther, T. L, & Belanger, S. (1996). Referring and reporting research participants at risk: views from urban adolescents. Child Development, 67, Thompson, R. A. (1990). Vulnerability in research: a developmental perspective on research risk. Child Development, 61, 1-16.