Unit 9 Town Hall Seminar.  Which types of cases are considered civil in nature versus criminal in nature.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Law Studies.
Advertisements

Civil & criminal law Civil Law.
What is Law.
“Law! Huh, Good God ya’ll! What is it good for!”.
Please… Log into Moodle and complete today’s Bell Ringer.
16.2- Criminal Cases.
Chapter Two LAW and CRIME
© 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved Law A body of regulations that govern society and that people are obligated to observe Sources.
Chapter 16 Lesson 1 Civil and Criminal Law.
THE LAW 8 Rights of a citizen accused of a crime:
Today’s Agenda (4/16/15): 1)Go over “Weird Laws” assignment 2)Today’s Legal Question/Quick Case Study 3)Criminal & Civil Law: Similarities and Differences.
The Judicial Branch. Court Systems & Jurisdictions.
Criminal and Civil Court
 Civil Lawsuits  between people or groups of people (individuals, organizations or gov’ts) in which no criminal laws have been broken. ◦ the person.
Alaska Mock Trial Glossary of Terms. Laws Rules created by society to govern the behavior of people in society. Among other things, the laws are one formal.
Guided notes provided Chapter 16 Sections 1 & 2.  Courtrooms job is to provide a place for the plaintiff and defendant to resolve their differences.
The Law.
American Court System American Court System Apply laws to actual situations.
THE LAW 8 Rights of a citizen accused of a crime: 1.Protection from ____________________(person can only be re-tried in case of a hung jury) 2.Right to.
Chapter 16 Lesson 2 Civil and Criminal Law. Crime and Punishment crime  A crime is any act that harms people or society and that breaks a criminal law.
Civil vs. Criminal courts
Categories of law Civil-private wrong Criminal-public wrong.
Our Court System Terms, procedures, and ideas you need to know.
Chapter 4 Classification of the Law. 2 Substantive and Procedural Law o Substantive Law o Defines our legal rights and duties o e.g. we have a duty to.
Chapter 1 What is Law. I.What is Law? A. Jurisprudence 1. The study of law and legal philosophy. 1. The study of law and legal philosophy. B. Goals of.
Law and Society INTRODUCTION TO LAW-CHAPTER 1. What is Law? Historical Origins  Civil Law  Constitutions  Codes  Common Law  Precedent  Stare decisis.
Courts at Work. Criminal cases An adult criminal case has many steps It usually is not completed in one day, especially felony cases The first step is.
The Judicial Branch of Georgia’s Government
Criminal Vs. Civil Cases. Definition  Civil Law  Deals with disputes between individuals, organizations, or between the two.  Compensation is awarded.
Chapter 16 Sections Objectives: 4.05, 4.09, 6.02, 6.07, 6.08.
WHAT IS LAW? TM.
Chapter 5 The Court System
Criminal Courts may be State or Federal Government. Always involve the violation of some standing law. Unlike a civil case, if no law was broken, a Criminal.
Criminal & Civil Law Chapter 15. Where do our laws come from? The Constitution – Constitutional Law The Legislature – Statutory law The Decisions of Judges.
WHAT IS LAW? TM. Jurisprudence. The study of law and legal philosophy.
The Judicial Branch Unit 5. Court Systems & Jurisdictions.
TYPES OF LAW. CIVIL LAW Civil Law deals with wrongs against a group or individual. The harmed individual becomes the plaintiff in a civil law suit and.
Unit Five What is law? Who makes law? Unit Five Jurisprudence – –The study of law Law – - A set of rules or regulations that by which a government regulates.
Unit 2 Chapter 5 Legal Environments of Business (LEB)
Balancing Rights & Responsibilities Major Criticism of U.S. = “too concerned with rights, while neglecting responsibilities” “Radical Individualism” Just.
CRIMINAL VS. CIVIL LAW. CRIMINAL LAW Laws that regulate our conduct and set out the duties owed to society.
Crime-Tort Jeopardy Business Related Crimes Elements of a Crime Classify Defenses Elements of a Tort Types of Torts Civil Procedure $100100$100100$100100$100100$100100$100100$
11/6/07 BR- Can you explain how OJ Simpson was found innocent of the murder of his wife but lost a $50 million dollar lawsuit suit to her parents? Today:
FINAL REVIEW. HELPS AFTER THE CRIME AIDING AND ABETTING HIDING THE CRIMINAL.
By: Gracie Guenther, Zach Eckels, Bethany Cobb, Hannah Cobb, and Makensie Cobb.
Criminal and Civil Court The Basics. Steps in a Criminal Case 1.Investigation and Arrest:  Either may happen first.  It depends upon the crime.
Wish I had the Doink, Doink sound clip!.  1yxw 1yxw  Hope it works…
 Eliseo Lugo III.  By the end of class today, students will be able to:  Distinguish between the two major groups of laws; criminal and civil.  Define.
Criminal Law. Objective: Students will be able to:  Evaluate info given during a civil law case and determine the award.  Explain what criminal law.
Article III: The Judicial Branch Chapters: 11,12
What is Law? Kinds of Laws.
Civics & Economics – Goals 5 & 6 Criminal Cases
ESSENTIAL QUESTION Why does conflict develop?
The American Legal System
Chapter 3: Defining & Measuring Crime
CRIMINAL VS. CIVIL LAW.
WHAT IS LAW? TM.
Balancing Rights & Responsibilities
Kinds of Law.
Medical Law and Ethics Chapter 2 The Legal System.
Criminal Justice Process
The American Legal System
Unit 2: The Court System Kinds of Laws
Law Chapter 15 and 16.
Bell Work Questions Where does the name “nor`easter” come from?
Chapter 15 Law in America.
WHAT IS LAW? TM.
The U.S. Judicial System.
Civil vs. Criminal Courts
Differences and similarities
Presentation transcript:

Unit 9 Town Hall Seminar

 Which types of cases are considered civil in nature versus criminal in nature.

 Civil cases usually involve private disputes between persons or organizations. Criminal cases involve an action that is considered to be harmful to society as a whole.

Criminal law  In criminal law, a guilty defendant is punished by either (1) incarceration in a jail or prison, (2) fine paid to the government, or, in exceptional cases, (3) execution of the defendant: the death penalty.  Crimes are divided into two broad classes: felonies have a maximum possible sentence of more than one year incarceration, misdemeanors have a maximum possible sentence of less than one year incarceration.

 In contrast, a defendant in civil litigation is never incarcerated and never executed. In general, a losing defendant in civil litigation only reimburses the plaintiff for losses caused by the defendant's behavior. So-called punitive damages are never awarded in a civil case under contract law. In a civil case under tort law, there is a possibility of punitive damages, if the defendant's conduct is egregious and had either (1) a malicious intent (i.e., desire to cause harm), (2) gross negligence (i.e., conscious indifference), or (3) a willful disregard for the rights of others. The use of punitive damages makes a public example of the defendant and supposedly deters future wrongful conduct by others. Punitive damages are particularly important in torts involving dignitary harms (e.g., invasion of privacy) and civil rights, where the actual monetary injury to plaintiff(s) may be small.

 In criminal litigation, the burden of proof is always on the state. The state must prove that the defendant is guilty. The defendant is assumed to be innocent; the defendant needs to prove nothing. (There are exceptions. If the defendant wishes to claim that he/she is insane, and therefore not guilty, the defendant bears the burden of proving his/her insanity. Other exceptions include defendants who claim self- defense or duress.)

 In criminal litigation, the state must prove that the defendant satisfied each element of the statutory definition of the crime, and the defendant's participation, "beyond a reasonable doubt." It is difficult to put a valid numerical value on the probability that a guilty person really committed the crime, but legal authorities who do assign a numerical value generally say "at least 98% or 99%" certainty of guilt.

 In civil litigation, the burden of proof is initially on the plaintiff. However, there are a number of technical situations in which the burden shifts to the defendant. For example, when the plaintiff has made a prima facie case, the burden shifts to the defendant to refute or rebut the plaintiff's evidence. In civil litigation, the plaintiff wins if the preponderance of the evidence favors the plaintiff. For example, if the jury believes that there is more than a 50% probability that the defendant was negligent in causing the plaintiff's injury, the plaintiff wins. This is a very low standard, compared to criminal law. A few tort claims (e.g., fraud) require that plaintiff prove his/her case at a level of "clear and convincing evidence", which is a standard higher than preponderance, but less than "beyond a reasonable doubt."

 A civil case begins when a person or entity (such as a corporation or the government), called the plaintiff, claims that another person or entity (the defendant) has failed to carry out a legal duty owed to the plaintiff. Both the plaintiff and the defendant are also referred to as "parties" or "litigants." The plaintiff may ask the court to tell the defendant to fulfill the duty, or make compensation for the harm done, or both.

 Civil suits are brought in both state and federal courts. An example of a civil case in a state court would be if a citizen (including a corporation) sued another citizen for not living up to a contract.

 For example, if a lumberyard enters a contract to sell a specific amount of wood to a carpenter for an agreed-upon price and then fails to deliver the wood, forcing the carpenter to buy it elsewhere at a higher price, the carpenter might sue the lumberyard to pay the extra costs incurred because of the lumberyard's failure to deliver; these costs are called damages. If these parties were from different states, however, then that suit could be brought in federal court under diversity jurisdiction if the amount in question exceeded the minimum required by statute ($75,000).

 Individuals, corporations, and the federal government can also bring civil suits in federal court claiming violations of federal statutes or constitutional rights. For example, the federal government can sue a hospital for overbilling Medicare and Medicaid, a violation of a federal statute. An individual could sue a local police department for violation of his or her constitutional rights--for example, the right to assemble peacefully.

 A person accused of a crime is generally charged in a formal accusation called an indictment (for felonies or serious crimes) or information (for misdemeanors). The government, on behalf of the people of the United States, prosecutes the case through the United States Attorney's Office if the person is charged with a federal crime. A state's attorney's office prosecutes state crimes.

 It is not the victim's responsibility to bring a criminal case. In a kidnapping case, for instance, the government would prosecute the kidnapper; the victim would not be a party to the action.  In some criminal cases, there may not be a specific victim. For example, state governments arrest and prosecute people accused of violating laws against driving while intoxicated because society regards that as a serious offense that can result in harm to others.

 When a court determines that an individual committed a crime, that person will receive a sentence. The sentence may be an order to pay a monetary penalty (a fine and/or restitution to the victim), imprisonment, or supervision in the community (by a court employee called a U.S. probation officer if a federal crime), or some combination of these three things.

 Gloria Allred represented Nicole Brown Simpson's relatives in their lawsuit against O.J. Simpson over her death. The former NFL player and movie star was acquitted in a criminal trial of killing his ex-wife and her friend Ronald Goldman, but a civil jury didn't believe him and awarded a total of $33.5 million to her family and Goldman's.  "You get testimony sometimes that you could never get out of a criminal case," Allred said in an interview.

 Unlike criminal cases, civil cases also give plaintiffs and defendants the right — before trial — to question each other under oath. And a plaintiff can call a defendant as a witness at trial, which a prosecutor cannot do; it's up to the defendant in a criminal case whether he or she wants to take the stand.

 Simpson, for example, didn't testify at his criminal trial. But he had to testify in the civil case, unable to assert Fifth Amendment protections against self- incrimination because he had been acquitted.

 After Joe Public lost his administrative appeal, he brings his case in court. Joe plans to base his arguments on the procedural due process and equal protection clauses of the 5 th and 14 th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. Look at these amendments and determine:  1) Where should Joe Public file his lawsuit  2) What grounds, if any, are there for federal jurisdiction?  3) Can you find a basis for federal jurisdiction in the statute or the regulations?  4) Can Joe make a claim in state court on any grounds?

 In a short essay, make an argument that Joe’s procedural due process rights and substantive due process rights have been violated. You may also wish to make an argument based on equal protection.  Should Joe file his case in state or federal court? Identify the statute that grants jurisdiction. What arguments should he make?  Focus on the 5 th and 14 th amendments.  Assume the state has sued the federal government about the mandate to implement a state health care program.  Does the state have a valid case? Why, or why not?  Does this mean Joe doesn't have a case?  Your essay should be 3-4 pages in length.

“Character is doing the right thing when nobody's looking. There are too many people who think that the only thing that's right is to get by, and the only thing that's wrong is to get caught.” - J. C. Watts

 system/civil-vs-criminal-cases.html system/civil-vs-criminal-cases.html   king-news/with-us-criminal-case-vs- strauss-kahn-uncertain-civil-court-could- be-an-avenue-for-accuser.html?thx=y king-news/with-us-criminal-case-vs- strauss-kahn-uncertain-civil-court-could- be-an-avenue-for-accuser.html?thx=y