Cedric De Koker t. +32 9 264 69 48 f. +32 9 264 69 71 T HE E UROPEAN C OURT OF H UMAN R IGHTS ’ A PPROACH TO A RMED C ONFLICT Ivory.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SESSION 5: INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW
Advertisements

Promoting Cooperative Solutions for Space Security 1 Is Current International Humanitarian Law Sufficient to Regulate a Potential.
Human Rights Grave Violations
ATHA Specialized Training on International Humanitarian Law
Overview of International Humanitarian Law ATHA Specialized Training on International Humanitarian Law May 31, 2010 Stockholm, Sweden.
SOME HUMANITARIAN CONCERNS Armed conflict Other situations of violence Some weapon-related issues – humanitarian diplomacy perspective By Angela Gussing.
Acquisition and loss of citizenship: openings for European courts? Gerard-René de Groot (Maastricht University) Co-financed by the European Fund for the.
“Global Violence: Consequences and Responses” Deprivation of liberty in armed conflict and other situations of violence – Legal Aspects The Crime of Torture.
Chapter 3: Triggering the LOAC. Historical Background F Prior to 1949, the laws and customs of war applied to ‘war’ F War was (and remains) an international.
Occupation Law ATHA Specialized Training on International Humanitarian Law May 31, 2010 Stockholm, Sweden.
Irish Penal Reform Trust Reforming the Early Release System in Ireland.
The Privatisation of War The Law of Armed Conflict and Private Military Firms Dr Regina Rauxloh School of Law, University of Surrey, UK Surrey International.
JUS1730/5730 International Humanitarian Law (the Law of Armed Conflict), autumn 2014 Lecture 1, 28 August 2014 Kjetil Mujezinović Larsen
Non-State Actors and International Humanitarian Law Charlotte Ku Prepared for the International Humanitarian Law Workshop March 1, 2014.
ELEMENTS OF A PROPOSED DRAFT CONVENTION ON PMSC OPEN-ENDED INTERGOVERNMENTAL WORKING GROUP TO : CONSIDER THE POSSIBILITY OF ELABORATING AN INTERNATIONAL.
Human Rights Lecture 18.
The Human Rights Act 1998 Mechanism Sections 1 and 2 of the HRA 1998.
Putting the UN Disability Convention into practice Sara Brunet, Senior Lawyer and UNCRPD lead officer, EHRC.
International Human Rights General Issues Nature of protected rights Interpretation Derogations Reservations Non-discrimination Nature of protected.
Civil-Military Forum Protection of Civilians Kelisiana Thynne Research Manager Australian Civil-Military Centre.
Human Rights Act 1998 The European convention on human rights The European convention on human rights The Convention rights The Convention rights How does.
1 Critical issue module 6 Separated children in emergency settings.
International Human Rights The Prohibition of Slavery 1815: Congress of Vienna, Final Act Treaty between United States and Great Britain for.
HUMR5140, lecture # 10. This lecture 1.Picking up the thread from lecture # 4: Scope of application of human rights treaties 2.The relationship with other.
Providing Security to Forced Migrants and Humanitarian Operations Lydia Mann-Bondat.
Humanitarian Access ATHA Specialized Training on International Humanitarian Law June 1, 2010 Stockholm, Sweden.
Human security and international law (Borrowed from 2008 lecture by Professor Gro Nystuen, University of Oslo)
Situating International Humanitarian Law (IHL) ATHA Specialized Training on International Humanitarian Law May 31, 2010 Stockholm, Sweden.
Youth Justice Service Conference – 26 th January 2006 Youth Justice Reform An NGO Perspective from the Irish Youth Justice Alliance Jillian van Turnhout.
International Human Rights The Prohibition of Slavery 1815: Congress of Vienna, Final Act Treaty between United States and Great Britain for.
Lecture Notes on Concept of International Humanitarian Law Gyan Basnet
Legal Advisor to the Executive Director
The law of war: Humanitarian law THE STORY BEHIND THE STORY.
International Committee of the Red Cross Mandate and action in situations of violence under the threshold of armed conflict OAS Committee on Hemispheric.
The Principles Governing EU Environmental Law. 2 The importance of EU Environmental Law at the European and globallevel The importance of EU Environmental.
Lecture 3 Scope and Applicability of IHL. Scope of application PERSONAL scope of application (To which subjects does IHL apply?) MATERIAL scope of application.
Why is considering ethical issues so important?.  Jus ad bellum – rules before war to justify actions taken  Jus in bello – rules during war to justify.
MA “International Relations, Global Economy and Strategic Analysis” COURSE OUTLINE.
The International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement and Civil -Military Cooperation and Humanitarian Coordination.
Perception in working in conflict environments. Neutral, impartial and independent humanitarian organisation Mandated by the community of states, through.
THE PROSECUTOR V. SIMIC 27 JULY 1999 TRIAL CHAMBER OF THE INTERNATIONAL TRIBUNAL FOR THE PROSECUTION OF PERSONS RESPONSIBLE FOR SERIOUS VIOLATIONS OF INTERNATIONAL.
The Role Of The United Nations Organization To Ensure The International Protection Of Journalists In Non-International Armed Conflicts. Zeyad Jaffal Faculty.
C EDRIC D E K OKER t f e. D ETENTION DURING P EACE O PERATIONS A C OMPARATIVE L EGAL A NALYSIS.
OPAC Provisions and Scope. International law and standards related to child soldiers The government of Thailand has ratified:  Convention on the Rights.
Relevance of IHL in armed conflict situation in India : the question of rehabilitation as a form of reparation Babloo Loitongbam.
Karna Thapa Faculty of Law T.U
MODULE 1 – THE LAW OF WAR + REPORTING On completion of this module, participants will understand that the aim of the course is to introduce the law applicable.
The Geneva Conventions
Toward a Comprehensive Approach Challenges, Common Ground, Distinctions.
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW Ahmed T. Ghandour.. CHAPTER 9. HUMANITARIAN LAW.
1 International Humanitarian Law: Indian Perspectives Dr. Tasneem Meenai Associate Professor Nelson Mandela Centre for Peace and Conflict Resolution Jamia.
+ RIGHT TO LIFE Regina Valutyte Mykolas Romeris University.
Education and Training Centre for Children - Need for Minimum Standards.
Stephane Ojeda Legal Adviser ICRC Delegation to the United Nations The International Committee of the Red Cross & The challenges of contemporary.
History.... Right up until 1998 the UK did not have a bill of rights giving its citizens rights to certain basic freedoms. However, as early as 1950 the.
The EU Accession to the ECHR after Opinion 2/13: Reflections, Solutions and the Way Forward Dr Sonia Morano – Foadi and Dr Stelios Andreadakis European.
International Humanitarian Law (IHL). What is IHL? >A large body of law >Rules for behaviour in armed conflict situations >Protects victims and vulnerable.
Human security from a legal point of view
International Humanitarian Law
ACCA Conference – Louvain-la-Neuve
WHAT IS HUMAN SECURITY? I felt rich when I found a comrade.
The EU and International Environmental Law
Modern world today There are a lot of internal and international conflicts all over the world. Force methods are often used and have high effectiveness.
Chapter2 humanitarian law and international human rights law
war crimes and the Geneva conventions.
Chapter1 introcuction.
Human Rights Law and Armed Conflict
2nd Biennial conference on the STOP program
The Normative Framework of International Humanitarian Law Relating to Administrative Detention in Occupation.
Presentation transcript:

Cedric De Koker t f T HE E UROPEAN C OURT OF H UMAN R IGHTS ’ A PPROACH TO A RMED C ONFLICT Ivory Tower or Pas de Deux

researchpublicationsconsultancyconferences Cedric De Koker  In classic public international law, international humanitarian law and international human rights law (of which the ECHR forms part) were considered to be two distinct and mutually exclusive bodies of law, conceived for different situations and with different theoretical considerations in mind.  The ECHR, as part of human rights law, was primarily conceived to apply in times of peace  Regulation of the conduct of hostilities and protection of victims of armed conflict were considered to be the sole province of international humanitarian law and military lawyers  A changed legal landscape today – Three key developments have played a determinative role in eroding the strict separation between the law of war and the law of peace  Inadequacy of traditional IHL enforcement mechanisms  Acceptance of continued applicability ECHR in times of armed conflict  Gradual acceptance of extraterritorial application ECHR I NCREASED ENGAGEMENT WITH ARMED CONFLICT Human Rights Integration Conference – 10 december

researchpublicationsconsultancyconferences Cedric De Koker  The ECtHR has not been blind to the realities of armed conflict in interpreting and applying the Convention  Applying rights in a ‘practical and effective’, rather than ‘theoretical and illusory’  The Court is prepared to make reasonable allowances for the relatively difficult conditions in which the armed forces are required to work  Quid international humanitarian law and its possible impact on the application of the ECHR?  No competence to directly monitor international humanitarian law (IHL)  Nevertheless, hooks in the European Convention and general public international law to resort to IHL as an interpretative tool (Article 15 ECHR & Article 31, §3 (c) VCLT)  Bifurcated approach towards IHL – Different treatment of cases relating to international and non-international armed conflict A PPROACH TO CONFLICT AND HUMANITARIAN LAW Human Rights Integration Conference – 10 december

researchpublicationsconsultancyconferences Cedric De Koker  Evolution in the Court’s approach to IHL in cases stemming out of international armed conflict:  Initially, complete disregard for norms and standards of IHL  Later, reference to IHL as an interpretative tool for HRL  Discussion on IHL norms in ‘applicable law’ section, but little impact on decisions of the Court (see Al-Skeini v. UK & Varnava and others v. Turkey)  Most recently, explicit engagement with IHL and dual application of HRL and IHL in Hassan v. United Kingdom (2014)  ‘the grounds of permitted deprivation of liberty set out in subparagraphs (a) to (f) of that provision should be accommodated, as far as possible, with the taking of prisoners of war and the detention of civilians who pose a risk to security under the Third and Fourth Geneva Conventions’ (para. 104).  However, decision limited to international armed conflict and the deprivation of liberty A PPROACH TO CONFLICT AND HUMANITARIAN LAW Human Rights Integration Conference – 10 december

researchpublicationsconsultancyconferences Cedric De Koker  Different strategy with regard to cases stemming out of Non-international armed conflict:  Ample opportunity to apply IHL in armed conflict related cases (Northern Ireland, South-East Turkey, Chechnya), but no explicit attempts to do so  No references to Geneva Conventions or Additional Protocols  Argument that the ECtHR has implicitly applied IHL not convincing  Instead, use of a ‘law enforcement’-model in assessing the conduct of States (see McCann v. United Kingdom)  single regime of basic rules applicable to all situations ranging from riots and situations of violence falling just short of the armed conflict threshold, through relatively small-scale skirmishes in a low-intensity conflict, to cases of protracted and full-blown armed confrontations between State armies and/or non-state actors – see e.g. right to life cases  Reasons for doing so are arguably policy-based, rather than strictly legal A PPROACH TO CONFLICT AND HUMANITARIAN LAW Human Rights Integration Conference – 10 december

researchpublicationsconsultancyconferences Cedric De Koker A combination of legal developments has led to the introduction of conflict-related cases with the ECtHR 2. In examining these cases, the ECtHR has had regard for the relatively difficult conditions in which the armed forces are required to work and took these into account when applying the ECHR 3.Yet, ‘the parameters of the proper role of the European Court of Human Rights in relation to international humanitarian law is still work in progress’ (Madame Rosalyn Higgins).  Signs of improvement in relation to international armed conflicts  Longstanding ‘ivory tower’- mindset persists in non-international armed conflicts  has resulted in decisions that are likely to be received by specialists in humanitarian law with some disquiet  Transparant process of reasoning would be step forward C ONCLUSION Human Rights Integration Conference – 10 december

Contact Cedric De Koker t f IRCP Ghent University Universiteitstraat 4 B – 9000 Ghent