The Influence of Age on Morbidity in Primary High Grade Sarcoma of the Extremity K. Alektiar, M. Brennan, S. Singer Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
Introduction: STS & Age Wibmer C et al. Ann Oncol 2009
Local Recurrence & Age Cahlon O et al. ASTRO 2008
Use of RT and Older Age: MSKCC Data (n = 1459) Odds Ratio 95% CI p value Limb sparing surgery < High grade < Deep tumor < Size ≥ 5 cm < Positive margin Age ≥ Ashman et al. ASTRO 2006
Purpose To determine whether older age, defined as ≥ 70 years, influences morbidity in pts with primary HG extremity STS who received adjuvant RT at MSKCC
Patient Population # of pts: 433 Period: 8/82- 02/06 Presentation: Primary, N0M0 Mean age: 53 (range: 16-89) Grade: High only Deep: 89% (n = 387) Size > 5 cm: 74% (n = 322) Lower extremity: 72% (n = 310)
Extent of Surgery All pts had limb-sparing surgery at MSKCC n % Bone manipulation ♠ Nerve manipulation ♦ Tissue transfer 31 7 ♠: Periosteal stripping/bone resection ♦: Neurolysis/nerve resection
RT Type All pts had their RT MSKCC n (%) Dose (Gy)* BRT 239 (55%) 45 EBRT 159 (37%) 63 BRT+EBRT 35 (8%) Adjuvant chemotherapy: 139/433 (32%). *: Median dose
Sex Female Male 159 (47%) 180 (53%) 41(44%) 53 (56%) 0.5 Size (cm) ≤ 5 > 5 85 (25%) 254 (75%) 26 (28%) 68 (72%) 0.6 Depth Superficial Deep 33 (10%) 306 (90%) 13 (14%) 81 (86%) 0.25 Site Upper extremity Lower extremity 94 (28%) 245 (72%) 29 (31%) 65 (69%) 0.5 Adjuvant CT Yes No 127 (38%) 212 (62%) 12 (13%) 82 (87%) < 70 ≥ 70 p Distribution of Variables
Extent of Surgery & Age Groups < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94)p Bone manipulation ♠ 63 (18%)20 (21%)0.5 Nerve manipulation ♦ 97 (29%)18 (19%)0.06 Tissue transfer 28 (8%)3 (3%)0.2 ♠: Periosteal stripping/bone resection ♦: Neurolysis/nerve resection
RT Type & Age Groups: For the purpose of this analysis, BRT and BRT+EBRT were combined < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94)p BRT/BRT+EBRT 220 (65%)54 (57%) EBRT 119 (35%)40 (43%) 0.18
RT “Conventional” Dose & Age Groups Conventional: BRT 45 Gy EBRT Gy BRT+EBRT and Gy < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94)p BRT* 200 (91%)50 (93%)0.15 EBRT 108 (91%)35 (88%)0.2 *: BRT and BRT+EBRT
Morbidity Median F/U: 53 months n (%) Wound re-operation 33 8 Fracture 17 4 Stiffness Edema Nerve Damage ♠ 27 7 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Morbidity & Age < 70 ≥ 70 p Wound re-operation 7% 12% 0.09 Fracture 4% 3% 0.6 Stiffness 11% 15% 0.3 Edema 9% 18% 0.01 Nerve Damage ♠ 8% 4% 0.13 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Joint Stiffness n (%) Grade Grade Grade Grade 3 5 1
Grade of Stiffness & Age Groups < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94) Grade (89%)80 (85%) Grade 119 (6%)7 (7%) Grade 2 14 (4%)6 (6%) Grade 3 4 (1%)1 (1%)
Edema n (%) Grade Grade Grade Grade 3 5 1
Grade of Edema & Age Groups < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94) Grade (91%)79 (84%) Grade 113 (4%)4 (4%) Grade 2 15 (4%)9 (10%) Grade 3 3 (1%)2 (2%)
Grade of Nerve Damage: (n = 377/433) ♠ n (%) Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Grade of Nerve ♠ Damage & Age Groups < 70 (n = 291)≥ 70 (n = 86) Grade (92%)83 (97%) Grade 19 (3%)2 (2%) Grade 2 6 (1.5%)1 (1%) Grade 3 1 (0.5%)0 (0%) Grade 48 (3%)0 (0%) ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Conclusion Older age (≥ 70 years) is not associated with increased morbidity from treatment with the exception of edema Strategies to minimize the risk of edema are warranted Withholding adjuvant RT solely based on older age, for fear of potential morbidity doesn’t seem to be justified
Influence of Age on BRT Morbidity < 70 ≥ 70 p Wound re-operation 9% 11% 0.7 Fracture 2% 0.8 Stiffness 5% 6% 0.8 Edema 6% 11% 0.2 Nerve Damage ♠ 8% 2% 0.2 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Influence of Age on EBRT Morbidity < 70 ≥ 70 p Wound re-operation 3% 13% 0.03 Fracture 8% 5% 0.8 Stiffness 22% 28% 0.6 Edema 14% 28% 0.09 Nerve Damage ♠ 10% 6% 0.7 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Morbidity & Type of RT in < 70 BRT EBRT p Wound re-operation 9% 3% 0.05 Fracture 2% 8% 0.03 Stiffness 5% 22% Edema 6% 14% Nerve Damage ♠ 8% 10% 0.7 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
Morbidity & Type of RT in ≥ 70 BRT EBRT p Wound re-operation 11% 13% 0.9 Fracture 2% 5% 0.7 Stiffness 6% 28% Edema 11% 28% 0.07 Nerve Damage ♠ 1% 6% 0.7 ♠:Those with nerve resection were excluded
RT Type & Age Groups < 70 (n = 339)≥ 70 (n = 94)p BRT 188 (56%)51 (54%) EBRT 119 (35%)40 (43%)0.18 BRT + BRT 32 (9%)3 (3%)