1 Protocol Clarification: Section 9.14.4.2, Resolution of Dispute Notification of Financial Impact of Granted and Granted with Exception Disputes COPS.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

SAS 70 Third Party Report on Controls Overview and Timetable Finance / Audit Committee Meeting Austin, Texas January 14, 2003/ February 18, 2003.

Advertisements

9/13/2007 Nodal COMS Extracts & Reports Market Requirements Review SDAWG Jackie Ashbaugh ERCOT ***NOTE: All information contained in this presentation.

May 18, 2009 SEWG Dispute due dates when extracts are delayed Art Deller.

Concerns with RUC Capacity Short Charge and Energy Trades.

Zonal ADR Resettlement & Data Retention ERCOT CSWG 04/20/2015.

Chad V. Seely Assistant General Counsel Tab 6.2: User Fee – Digital Certificate Fee Finance & Audit Committee Meeting ERCOT Public November 12, 2012.

Draft Dispute NPRR and NPRR 75 A comparison for COPS.

Retail Market Update June 5, New meter is requested for a specific customer’s location. 2.Application is filed by customer and/or the customer’s.

Protocol Revision Subcommittee Sandy Morris August 5, 2010.

NPRRs NPRR680 Allow QSEs to Self-Arrange AS Quantities Greater Than Their AS Obligation. This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) proposes to allow.

Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Exemption Proposals for Settlements and Billing Changes COPS June 14, 2011 Cheryl Yager, Mandy Bauld, Leslie.

7/15/2013 CSWG CSWG – ERCOT Update ERCOT Matthew Tozer.

NPRR 209 Presentation Adrian Pieniazek – NRG Texas Technical Advisory Committee May 6, 2010.

December 18, 2007 TPTF How ERCOT Websites and Applications Handle MIS Public, MIS Secure and MIS Certified Information Kate Horne.

July 30, 2015 TAC Meeting Update to COPS Michelle Trenary August 12, 2015.

COMMUNICATIONS AND SETTLEMENTS WORKING GROUP (CSWG) April 2015 Update to COPS.

January 14, New logic and invoices used in January 2015 when closing out December 2014 New Bill Determinants: CRRBAFA- CRR Balancing Account Fund.

Lead from the front Texas Nodal 1 External Web Services Update Nodal Implementation Team Presentation July 7, 2009.

NPRR514, Seasonal Generation Resource Wholesale Market Subcommittee April 12, 2013 Amanda Frazier.

1Texas Nodal Texas Nodal Commercial Systems COMS CSD Presentation By ERCOT Wednesday, 1/10/2007.

Real Time Settlement Timeline Workshop Debrief To TAC 11/29/2012 Evaluation and consideration of reducing the RT Settlement Timeline Jim Galvin- CSWG Chair.

Texas Nodal Section 9: Invoicing ERCOT, Settlements & Billing SDAWG - August 2007.

ERS Update Plus Revisions to Proposed Changes for ERS Time Periods Presented to: Demand Side Working Group November 5, 2014.

User Fee - ERCOT Digital Certificate Fee Chad V. Seely Assistant General Counsel ERCOT November 1, 2012 Technical Advisory Committee (TAC)

Nodal Settlement Delta Calculations and Statements – 7/11/06 Workshop  Objective: Describe design concepts of nodal settlement delta calculations and.

Nodal Program Update and SEWG Update COPS 1/11/2011 Jim Galvin.

COMS Nodal Commercial Systems Project Update COPs Meeting May 2007 By Bill Barnes and Justin Rasberry.

ESI IDs Retired in Error! RMS – August 10, 2005 Discussion.

Commercial Operations Sub-Committee Update to TAC December 4, 2008.

12/6/2015 ERCOT Production Issues Update ERCOT Matthew Tozer.

January 21, 2008 TPTF 168 Hour Test Initial Approach Discussion.

Texas Nodal © Electric Reliability Council of Texas, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Commercial Systems Market Data Transparency Business Requirements.

QMWG Update to WMS S. Looney December 3, Assignments from WMS ERCOT Market Operations Report – Two SASMs in October, no AS insufficiency – Two unique.

MARS Taskforce RMS Update November 10, Conference Call concerning Settlement Estimates TDSPs held a conference call on October 28, 2010, where we:

9/17/2012 CSWG CSWG – ERCOT Update ERCOT. 2 Settlements Project & Operational Updates February 27, 2012 NPRR 347: Combined Daily Invoice –Still on track.

Texas Nodal © Electric Reliability Council of Texas, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Settlement Invoices Business Requirements Settlements and.

1 Next Steps to Reduce the RTM Settlement Timeline COPS Workshop August 29, 2013 Mandy Bauld ERCOT Director, Settlement & Retail Operations (512)

1 Business Integration Update to PRS Troy Anderson ERCOT Enterprise Project Portfolio Management May 19, 2011.

Nodal Short Pay and Uplift Process CWG Meeting May 28, 2008.

1 RMS Update By Don Bender January 9, RMS Approved Resolution Upon TAC approval, suspend further True-up settlements for True-up resettlement.

1 ERCOT Pricing and Dashboard Updates NATF Sept 30, 2010.

Market Credit Working Group Update to WMS Wed. Oct 20, 2010.

Nodal Market Settlement and Invoicing Timeline ERCOT COPS Meeting January 9, 2006 Eric Woelfel, Formosa Utility Ventures Jim Galvin, Tenaska Power Services.

Texas Nodal © Electric Reliability Council of Texas, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Nodal Dispute Management System Business Requirements ERCOT.

QSE Managers Working Group Report to WMS, April 8, 2011 S. Looney, Luminant.

October 13, 2009 NOIE DRG Settlements TF update to COPS Settlement Discussion for ALL DG < or = 1 MW Don Tucker on behalf of the NOIE DRG Settlements Task.

CCWG April 28 th Meeting CCWG Update to COPS May 12,

© CONSTELLATION ENERGY GROUP, INC. THE OFFERING DESCRIBED IN THIS PRESENTATION IS SOLD AND CONTRACTED BY CONSTELLATION NEWENERGY, INC., A SUBSIDIARY.

1 NPRR 484/554 Phase 2 Suresh Pabbisetty, ERP, CQF, CSQA Lead Technical Analyst, Credit CWG / MCWG May 20, 2015 ERCOT Public.

COMET Working Group Progress Report. Contents of Report Provide COMET Recommendations, with May 6 revisions (Vote) –Competitive Meter Approval Process.

COPS DECEMBER 2013 UPDATE TO RMS 12/18/2013 Harika Basaran, Chair Jim Lee, Vice Chair.

Real Time Settlement Timeline Workshop Evaluation and consideration of reducing the RT Settlement Timeline Harika Basaran- COPS Chair Jim Galvin- CSWG.

COPS JULY 2013 UPDATE TO TAC 07/02/2013 Harika Basaran, Chair Jim Lee, Vice Chair.

PWG Demand Response Follow Up Jackie Ashbaugh October 23, 2007.

Nodal Settlement Delta Calculations and Statements  Objective: Describe the recommended design of nodal settlement delta calculations and statements.

Protocol Revision Subcommittee Sandy Morris May 5, 2011.

Lead from the front Texas Nodal 1 Texas Nodal EDS4 - Approach 11/28/2007.

MISUG Meeting Materials ERCOT 7/26/ MISUG Agenda 1.Antitrust AdmonitionJ. Lavas9:30 a.m. 2.IntroductionsJ. Lavas9:30 a.m. 3.Market Data Transparency.

Technical Advisory Committee Commercial Operations Subcommittee Update to TAC Debbie McKeever COPs Chair 2011.

1 Commercial Operations Working Group Update to TAC April 7, 2005.

TAC Update Kyle Patrick. 2 Nodal ERCOT Program Update –Nodal Market Go-Live (Vote)- vote passed in which TAC certified full nodal systems for Dec 1, 2010.

Texas Nodal © Electric Reliability Council of Texas, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Settlement Statements and Calendar Business Requirements Settlements.

Protocol Revision Subcommittee Presentation to the ERCOT Technical Advisory Committee June 05, 2008.

ERCOT Websites Content Management Corporate Standard

Settlement Update Austin Rosel ERCOT February 27, 2017.

Nodal COMS Additional Items Update

Ancillary Service Trades and Ancillary Service Settlement

Settlement Update Austin Rosel ERCOT October 11, 2017.

Market Operations Presentation Board of Director’s Meeting

CCWG September 29th Meeting

Presentation transcript:

1 Protocol Clarification: Section , Resolution of Dispute Notification of Financial Impact of Granted and Granted with Exception Disputes COPS ERCOT Public October 8, 2013

2 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes ERCOT’s Perspective of Issue Current protocol language and actual practice may not be in sync: Nodal Go-Live Design deployed a daily dispute summary report on MIS Secure ERCOT’s review of language questions whether this MIS report meets the protocol requirement ERCOT asks COPS to discuss this language and make recommendations to meet the requirements Work towards an NPRR to document the changes and implement.

3 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes Protocol Language Granted When ERCOT determines that the disputed Settlement Statement or Invoice are in error as alleged in the Settlement and billing dispute, ERCOT shall grant the Settlement and billing dispute and notify the Settlement Statement or Invoice Recipient of the resolution and provide it the reasons and supporting data for resolution, while maintaining the confidentiality of Protected Information. ERCOT shall notify all other Settlement Statement or Invoice Recipients of the financial impact of granted disputes. Upon resolution of the issue, ERCOT shall process the dispute’s resolution on the next available Settlement Statement for the affected Operating Day.

4 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes Granted with Exceptions (2)If a Settlement Invoice or Statement Recipient rejects the outcome of a dispute “Granted with Exceptions,” ERCOT must investigate the dispute further. ERCOT must include the granted portion of the dispute on the next Settlement Statement for the affected Operating Day and notify all other Settlement Statement or Invoice Recipients of the financial impact of the granted portion of the dispute. After further investigation, if ERCOT subsequently grants the Settlement and billing dispute, ERCOT must process the dispute on the next available Settlement Statement for the affected Operating Day. ERCOT shall notify all other Settlement Statement or Invoice Recipients of the financial impact of the granted portion of the dispute. If exceptions to the dispute still exist, the Settlement Statement or Invoice Recipient may either accept the dispute for resolution as “Granted with Exceptions” or begin ADR according to Section 20, Alternative Dispute Resolution Procedure. Protocol Language

5 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes Current Solution ERCOT Processing of Disputes (3)On each Business Day, ERCOT shall issue an aggregated Settlement and billing dispute resolution report on the MIS Secure Area containing information related to all disputes that are not yet closed or that have been closed recently. Additionally, on each Business Day and for each Settlement Statement Recipient or Invoice Recipient, ERCOT shall issue a report on the MIS Certified Area containing details about each dispute that is not yet closed or that has been closed recently.

6 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes Current Solution ERCOT Summary Dispute Report

7 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes Current Solution ERCOT Summary Dispute Report OPERATING DAY MARKET TYPESUB TYPESTATUSRESOLUTION SUMMED DOLLAR AMOUNTTOTAL COUNT 16-Nov-10CRRCRR AuctionClosedDenied Aug-13CRRCRR AuctionOpenDenied Sep-13DAMAncillary Services-DAMOpen Sep-13DAMEnergy-DAMOpen Oct-12DAMEnergy-DAMADRDenied Aug-13DAMMake-WholeClosedDenied Mar-13RTMAncillary Services-RTMOpenGranted with Exceptions Apr-13RTMEnergy-RTMOpenGranted May-11RTMEnergy-RTMADRDenied Sep-13RTMEnergy-RTMOpen Apr-13RTMEnergy-RTMOpenGranted Oct-12RTMEnergy-RTMADRDenied Aug-13RTMGene. Res. Base Pt DeviationOpenGranted Jun-13RTMGene. Res. Base Pt DeviationOpen Dec-10RTMReliability Unit CommitmentADRDenied May-13RTMReliability Unit CommitmentOpen Jan-11RTMReliability Unit CommitmentADRDenied

8 ERCOT Public Notification of Financial Impact of Settlement Disputes NEXT STEPS Current protocol language and actual practice may not be in sync: ERCOT asks COPS to discuss this language and make recommendations to meet the requirements Work towards an NPRR to document the changes and implement.

9 DISCUSSIONS ERCOT Public