Malraux’s view seems to have been confirmed in much of the world today: Western Europe excepted, religion has made a strong comeback.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Enlightenment A movement of intellectual change that swept throughout Europe and North America during the 18th century.
Advertisements

Class Discussion Question Define or give examples of Islamic Fundamentalism. Can you think of any other fundamentalist groups ?
GENDER EDUCATION IN MUSLIM CONTEXTS: BUILDING MOVEMENTS THROUGH BORDERS AND RELIGIONS Central Asia and Caucasus.
Pseudoscience in the Periphery: The History of Islamic Creationism in Turkey Taner Edis Department of Physics, Truman State University Amy Sue Bix Department.
Islam & the West: Testing the ‘Clash of Civilizations’ Thesis Al johara M. Almutiri.
A Brief History of Islamic Creationism in Turkey
Handbook of Language & Ethnic Identity Chapter 18: The Celtic World Colin H. Williams.
LEARNING OUTCOME RIGHTS ARE ESSENTIAL IN A DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT
Terrorism.
Chapter 10: Challenging Liberalism
Identity Crisis of Muslims: “ A Religious Minority in Nepal” By: H. M. Zahid Parwez (Researcher, CERID, TU)
Understanding Postmodernity Pre-modernity, Modernity & Postmodernity.
Zionism: a movement (mid 1800’s) by Jews worldwide – to get back their “homeland” Balfour Declaration: The Balfour Declaration was an official.
Lecture 22: Failed States May 17, Extra Credit Opportunity! Challenges and Opportunities for Human Rights in Russia Lara Iglitzin Executive Director,
Comparative Approaches:
Islam Outcome: Islam Today. Islam in the world today…
Religious Freedom in the World Today: Paradox and Promise by by Allen D. Hertzke The Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences XVII Plenary Session: Universal.
Bellringer-Name the countries The diverse cultural characteristics of the people who live in Southwestern Asia Georgia Performance Standards.
Political Directions Chapter 27, Sec. 1.
POSC 2200 – The State, Decision Making and Foreign Policy Russell Alan Williams Department of Political Science.
Iranian Political Culture: a brief overview Legitimacy of the State Characteristics of Iranian Political Culture.
The End of Empire: Experiments with Freedom Spring 2015.
Last class Strategies for Consolidating Power Cases: Turkey, Iran, Egypt Today  Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon in brief (see readings for comprehensive.
Standard The Enlightenment and Democratic Revolution
History of the Middle East. Ottoman Empire At one time the Muslim Ottoman Empire was six times the size of Texas. It stretched across what is now Turkey.
Age of Reason and the Enlightenment. Europe in the 18 th century Politics – countries ruled by divine right, people had little say in the government Politics.
1.The ____ empire included Turkey, Iraq, and much of the Arabian Peninsula. 2.Political and religious leader of Islam. 3.Holy city of Islam; home of the.
Religion and Politics R ELIGION AND P OLITICS. M ODERNIZATION AND S ECULARIZATION – P ERSPECTIVES OVER TIME 1960s:  “Once, the world was filled with.
MIDDLE EASTERN BORDERS NOW AND THEN By Christian Urice.
Arabs, Kurds, & Persians. This is a group of people who share a common culture. These characteristics have been part of their community for generations.
DEMOCRACY DEMOCRACY DEMOCRACY IS A FORM OF GOVERNMENT IN WHICH THE SUPREME POWER IS HELD COMPLETELY BY THE PEOPLE UNDER A FREE ELECTORAL SYSTEM. DEMOCRACY.
ASSOCIATIONS TO THE RELIGIOUS LANDSCAPE OF AUSTRALIA Claire Crighton.
 Key Concept 2.3, I, B: “Several factors promoted Anglicization in the British colonies: the growth of autonomous political communities based on English.
© Oxford University Press, All rights reserved. Goodhart: Human Rights: Politics and Practice Chapter 1: Normative and Theoretical Foundations of.
THE MIDDLE EAST IN TRANSITION. Pan-Arabism Pan-Arabism is a movement that sought to unite all Arabs based on a common language and culture and create.
Arabs, Kurds, & Persians. Standards SS7G8 The student will describe the diverse cultures of the people who live in Southwest Asia (Middle East). a. Explain.
Indian Independence Growing Unrest In 1919, new laws from Britain Limited freedom of the press and other rights Protested by nationalists Five.
Life in the Colonies. Immigration was important to the growth of the colonies. Immigration was important to the growth of the colonies. Between 1607 and.
IMPERIALISM - Effects AP World History. Imperialism- Cultural Effects  Education  Gaining Western education generated new identities for a small minority.
Muslim Leaders of Tomorrow 2006 Copenhagen, Denmark American Society for Muslim Advancement In partnership with Cordoba Initiative.
Lecture 20: Failed States February 23, Extra Credit Opportunity Dr. Melvyn Leffler, Edward Stettinius Professor of American History, University.
Islam and Women’s rights
Questions to think about for Friday  1. Michael Budde and Robert Brimlow :  “We think that military chaplaincies are indefensible compromises of Jesus’
Middle Eastern Independence Movements What types of governments form in Turkey, Iran, and Saudi Arabia?
Maurizio Ambrosini, università di Milano, Integration versus Multiculturalism: An outdated dichotomy.
Arabs, Kurds, & Persians. SS7G8 The student will describe the diverse cultures of the people who live in Southwest Asia (Middle East). a. Explain the.
Religion and Human Rights in Italy and in Europe: the Fate of National Identities.
What requirements should there be to vote? What will we learn today? What will we learn today? Standard The Enlightenment and rise of democratic.
THE CLASH OF CIVILIZATIONS? WEEK #12 THE CLASH OF CIVILIZATIONS?
The MENA region The region presents both similarities and differences with respect to its constituent parts. We will always have a ‘double-discourse’:
Focus 4/16 As Middle Eastern leaders like Turkey’s Ataturk and Iran’s Reza Khan Pahlavi attempted to modernize their countries, they came into conflict.
THE ENLIGHTENMENT Introduction and Overview If men were angels, no government would be necessary “If men were angels, no government would be necessary.”
Huntington’s Thesis It is my hypothesis that the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily economic.
Political and Economic Change in Iran
Chap 10, pp only Radical Political Islam pp
Enlightenment Element: Identify the major ideas of the Enlightenment from the writings of Locke, Voltaire, and Rousseau and their relationship to politics.
Conflicts in the Middle East CLOZE Notes 1
Contemporary Global Issues
The Middle East In Transition
Middle Eastern Independence Movements
WARM UP – December What is globalization?
Warm Up – May 8 1. What is globalization?
Michael Mann’s “IEMP” Model of Power
AP HUMAN GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER 13 CLASS NOTES
Failed States.
Middle Eastern Independence Movements
The Enlightenment.
The Enlightenment.
The Enlightenment - The Age of Reason
Middle Eastern Independence Movements
Presentation transcript:

Malraux’s view seems to have been confirmed in much of the world today: Western Europe excepted, religion has made a strong comeback.

“The reemergence of religious discourse,” writes Sara Maitland, “seems to have caught many of us on the hop: baffled, irritated and uncomprehending. For over 250 years, Western democratic thinking has argued, and even fought for, the secularization of the public domain and the political arena.

When religion is merged with the state, human rights suffer. Asma Jahangir writes that, in Pakistan, “the judicial institutionalization of Islam has taken a particularly heavy toll on the rights of women and religious minorities, and critics of discriminatory laws are branded un- Islamic or traitorous¡­. The creed of National Islamization has been used as a stick to beat all emancipatory and human rights movements”.

... By the second half of the last century, indeed, one might have thought the battle was won... What I see instead is a faltering, a loss of faith, in the whole Enlightenment project.”

The reasons for this religious comeback are manifold. It expresses both renewed individual quests for meaning in a secularized, materialistic world and a more collective search for identity in a world engaged in the uncertainties and insecurities of globalization and diversity

In the 1960s, when secularism was seen by many as inevitable, part of the unstoppable march of progress, and organized religious communities appeared to be sidelined as a political force, especially in the Western world, French writer and minister of Culture Andr¨¦ Malraux challenged that orthodoxy, declaring in oracular fashion that “the twenty-first century will be either religious or not be” (le 21e siecle sera religieux ou ne sera pas).

Malraux’s view seems to have been confirmed in much of the world today: Western Europe excepted, religion has made a strong comeback. “The reemergence of religious discourse,” writes Sara Maitland, “seems to have caught many of us on the hop: baffled, irritated and uncomprehending. For over 250 years, Western democratic thinking has argued, and even fought for, the secularization of the public domain and the political arena.

... By the second half of the last century, indeed, one might have thought the battle was won... What I see instead is a faltering, a loss of faith, in the whole Enlightenment project.”

While some have welcomed this development as a necessary counterbalance to the excesses of materialism and individualism, others have warned that this religious revival would subvert universal values, sow particularist and divisive attachments, and trigger a broader backlash. Many people have responded, in short, with the same alarm with which they greeted Samuel Huntington¡¯s controversial thesis on the lasting power of and inevitable ¡°clash¡± between the world¡¯s major civilizations.

The reasons for this religious comeback are manifold. It expresses both renewed individual quests for meaning in a secularized, materialistic world and a more collective search for identity in a world engaged in the uncertainties and insecurities of globalization and diversity

In Kemalist Turkey, Pahlavi Iran... secularism never permeated deep into society... and with little to show in the form of veritable development, the values that sustained these states came under attack.¡±1818 nly religious convictions, Malraux suggested, were capable of lifting our eyes to a nobler horizon of human possibility.

In some instances, the reemergence of religion also reflects in part the failure of the states, especially in the developing world, to provide and guarantee fundamental human rights for the majority of their populations. As political scientist Vali Nasr has phrased it: ¡°There is a direct correlation between the scope and nature of religious activism and the decline of the secular state as a functioning political system and as an intellectual construct....

In Kemalist Turkey, Pahlavi Iran... secularism never permeated deep into society... and with little to show in the form of veritable development, the values that sustained these states came under attack.¡±1818 The growing political influence of religious communities also has been linked to the ¡°theologization¡± of state power. In some countries, ruling elites have used particular religious interpretations to shore up their power and maintain the social and political status quo. Saudi Arabia and Iran are prominent examples.

In some instances, the reemergence of religion also reflects in part the failure of the states, especially in the developing world, to provide and guarantee fundamental human rights for the majority of their populations. As political scientist Vali Nasr has phrased it: ¡°There is a direct correlation between the scope and nature of religious activism and the decline of the secular state as a functioning political system and as an intellectual construct.... In Kemalist Turkey, Pahlavi Iran... secularism never permeated deep into society... and with little to show in the form of veritable development, the values that sustained these states came under attack.¡±1818 The growing political influence of religious communities also has been linked to the ¡°theologization¡± of state power. In some countries, ruling elites have used particular religious interpretations to shore up their power and maintain the social and political status quo. Saudi Arabia and Iran are prominent examples. When religion is merged with the state, human rights suffer. Asma Jahangir writes that, in Pakistan, ¡°the judicial institutionalization of Islam has taken a particularly heavy toll on the rights of women and religious minorities, and critics of discriminatory laws are branded un-Islamic or traitorous¡­. The creed of National Islamization has been used as a stick to beat all emancipatory and human rights movements.¡±1919 In Uzbekistan, the government has claimed a monopoly on the interpretation of Islam and has jailed those who diverge from its version of Islam on charges that such ¡°independent¡± Muslims are attempting to subvert or overthrow the constitutional order. Although the government has used the pretext that such individuals are colluding with terrorism, in the vast majority of cases the suspects have not been charged with terrorism or any other form of violence.2020

When religion is merged with the state, human rights suffer. Asma Jahangir writes that, in Pakistan, ¡°the judicial institutionalization of Islam has taken a particularly heavy toll on the rights of women and religious minorities, and critics of discriminatory laws are branded un-Islamic or traitorous¡­. The creed of National Islamization has been used as a stick to beat all emancipatory and human rights movements.

In Uzbekistan, the government has claimed a monopoly on the interpretation of Islam and has jailed those who diverge from its version of Islam on charges that such ¡°independent¡± Muslims are attempting to subvert or overthrow the constitutional order. Although the government has used the pretext that such individuals are colluding with terrorism, in the vast majority of cases the suspects have not been charged with terrorism or any other form of violence.2020

In some instances, the reemergence of religion also reflects in part the failure of the states, especially in the developing world, to provide and guarantee fundamental human rights for the majority of their populations. As political scientist Vali Nasr has phrased it: ¡°There is a direct correlation between the scope and nature of religious activism and the decline of the secular state as a functioning political system and as an intellectual construct.... In Kemalist Turkey, Pahlavi Iran... secularism never permeated deep into society... and with little to show in the form of veritable development, the values that sustained these states came under attack.¡±1818 The growing political influence of religious communities also has been linked to the ¡°theologization¡± of state power. In some countries, ruling elites have used particular religious interpretations to shore up their power and maintain the social and political status quo. Saudi Arabia and Iran are prominent examples. When religion is merged with the state, human rights suffer. Asma Jahangir writes that, in Pakistan, ¡°the judicial institutionalization of Islam has taken a particularly heavy toll on the rights of women and religious minorities, and critics of discriminatory laws are branded un-Islamic or traitorous¡­. The creed of National Islamization has been used as a stick to beat all emancipatory and human rights movements.¡±1919 In Uzbekistan, the government has claimed a monopoly on the interpretation of Islam and has jailed those who diverge from its version of Islam on charges that such ¡°independent¡± Muslims are attempting to subvert or overthrow the constitutional order. Although the government has used the pretext that such individuals are colluding with terrorism, in the vast majority of cases the suspects have not been charged with terrorism or any other form of violence.2020