Guidance for Targeted Observations during N-AMMA and data impact results: 3 studies 1. Sharanya Majumdar (RSMAS/U.Miami) 2. Jason Dunion & Sim Aberson.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Topic 3.3: Targeted observations and data assimilation in track prediction Rapporteur: Chun-Chieh Wu PSA Working Group: Sim Aberson, Brian Etherton, Sharanya.
Advertisements

Chapter 13 – Weather Analysis and Forecasting
The impact of targeted observations from 2011 Winter Storms Reconnaissance on deterministic forecast accuracy Tom Hamill NOAA Earth System Research Lab,
NOAA THORPEX Highlights John Cortinas Tom Hamill NOAA/OAR 1.
Munehiko Yamaguchi Typhoon Research Department, Meteorological Research Institute of the Japan Meteorological Agency 9:00 – 12: (Thr) Topic.
Something about DOTSTAR (Dropsonde Observations for Typhoon Surveillance near the Taiwan Region) Chun-Chieh Wu Department of Atmospheric Sciences National.
Operational Forecasting and Sensitivity-Based Data Assimilation Tools Dr. Brian Ancell Texas Tech Atmospheric Sciences.
Observing System Simulation Experiments to Evaluate the Potential Impact of Proposed Observing Systems on Hurricane Prediction: R. Atlas, T. Vukicevic,
Real-Time ROMS Ensembles and adaptive sampling guidance during ASAP Sharanya J. Majumdar RSMAS/University of Miami Collaborators: Y. Chao, Z. Li, J. Farrara,
Performance Characteristics of a Pseudo-operational Ensemble Kalman Filter April 2006, EnKF Wildflower Meeting Greg Hakim & Ryan Torn University of Washington.
1 THE WINTER STORM RECONNESSAINCE PROGRAM OF THE US NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE Zoltan Toth GSD/ESRL/OAR/NOAA Formerly at EMC/NCEP/NWS/NOAA Acknowledgements:
Improving High Impact Weather Forecasts by Adaptive Observing Methods Yucheng Song NOAA/NWS/NCEP/EMC Dave Novak NOAA/NWS/NCEP/HPC.
Ensemble-based adaptive sampling and data assimilation issues in tropical cyclones Sharanya J. Majumdar (RSMAS/U.Miami) Collaborators, present and future:
2.4 Some observations from the JET2000 experiment Thorncroft et al, 2003 BAMS Parker et al, 2005 QJRMS.
T-PARC (Summer Phase) Sharanya J. Majumdar (RSMAS/U. Miami) Christopher S. Velden (CIMSS / U. Wisconsin) Section 4.7, THORPEX/DAOS WG Fourth Meeting
The Impact of GPS Radio Occultation Data on the Analysis and Prediction of Tropical Cyclones Bill Kuo UCAR.
Analyses from the Final Two MDR Flights & Hurricane Edouard Jason P. Dunion 1, Ryan Torn 2, Gary Wick 3, Robbie, Hood 3, Mike Black 4 1 University of Miami.
Targeting strategies to improve hurricane track forecasts (JHT 03-05) PIs: Dr Sharanya J. Majumdar (University of Miami) Dr Sim D. Aberson (NOAA/AOML/HRD)
Ensemble-variational sea ice data assimilation Anna Shlyaeva, Mark Buehner, Alain Caya, Data Assimilation and Satellite Meteorology Research Jean-Francois.
1 Tropical cyclone (TC) trajectory and storm precipitation forecast improvement using SFOV AIRS soundings Jun Tim Schmit &, Hui Liu #, Jinlong Li.
ECMWF Training Course 2005 slide 1 Forecast sensitivity to Observation Carla Cardinali.
Observing Strategy and Observation Targeting for Tropical Cyclones Using Ensemble-Based Sensitivity Analysis and Data Assimilation Chen, Deng-Shun 3 Dec,
Data assimilation and observing systems strategies Pierre Gauthier Data Assimilation and Satellite Meteorology Division Meteorological Service of Canada.
1 Precipitation verification Precipitation verification is still in a testing stage due to the lack of station observation data in some regions
30 November December International Workshop on Advancement of Typhoon Track Forecast Technique 11 Observing system experiments using the operational.
Perspectives on Targeting Sharanya J. Majumdar (RSMAS/U. Miami) Session 3.1, THORPEX/DAOS WG Fourth Meeting June 2011.
Climate Modeling LaboratoryMEASNC State University Predictability of the Moisture Regime Associated with the Pre-onset of Sahelian Rainfall Roberto J.
MPO 674 Lecture 22 4/2/15. Single Observation Example for 4D Variants D. Kleist et al. 4DVAR H-4DVAR_AD  f -1 =0.25 H-4DENVAR  f -1 =0.25 4DENVARTLMADJ.
1 Rolf Langland Naval Research Laboratory – Monterey, CA Uncertainty in Operational Atmospheric Analyses.
Slide 1 Wind Lidar working group February 2010 Slide 1 Spaceborne Doppler Wind Lidars - Scientific motivation and impact studies for ADM/Aeolus Erland.
Center for Satellite Applications and Research (STAR) Review 09 – 11 March 2010 Image: MODIS Land Group, NASA GSFC March 2000 Improving Hurricane Intensity.
Can we Predict the Impact of Observations on 3 to 6 day Winter Weather Forecasts? Masters Thesis Defense May 10, 2007 Kathryn J. Sellwood University of.
Verification of Global Ensemble Forecasts Fanglin Yang Yuejian Zhu, Glenn White, John Derber Environmental Modeling Center National Centers for Environmental.
1 The Assessment of the DAOS WG on Observation Targeting Talk presented by Rolf Langland (NRL-Monterey) DAOS Working Group THIRD THORPEX International.
1 A Pacific Predictability Experiment - Targeted Observing Issues and Strategies Rolf Langland Pacific Predictability Meeting Seattle, WA June 6, 2005.
1 Results from Winter Storm Reconnaissance Program 2008 Yucheng SongIMSG/EMC/NCEP Zoltan TothEMC/NCEP/NWS Sharan MajumdarUniv. of Miami Mark ShirleyNCO/NCEP/NWS.
1 Results from Winter Storm Reconnaissance Program 2007 Yucheng SongIMSG/EMC/NCEP Zoltan TothEMC/NCEP/NWS Sharan MajumdarUniv. of Miami Mark ShirleyNCO/NCEP/NWS.
1 Scott Zaccheo AER, Inc ASCENDS End-to-End System Performance Assessment: Analysis of Atmospheric State Vector Variability.
Development and Testing of a Regional GSI-Based EnKF-Hybrid System for the Rapid Refresh Configuration Yujie Pan 1, Kefeng Zhu 1, Ming Xue 1,2, Xuguang.
1 Using water vapor measurements from hyperspectral advanced IR sounder (AIRS) for tropical cyclone forecast Jun Hui Liu #, Jinlong and Tim.
POTENTIAL THESIS TOPICS Professor Russell L. Elsberry January 26, 2006 Graduate School of Engineering and Applied Sciences Department of Meteorology, Naval.
1 Rolf Langland NRL-Monterey Plans for Evaluation of Lidar Wind Observations at NRL-Monterey Working Group on Space-Based Lidar Winds 05 Feb 2008.
Yucheng Song & Zoltan Toth 1 Yucheng Song and Zoltan Toth EMC/NCEP/NWS/NOAA Update on the Winter Storm Reconnaissance Program Meeting of the working group.
The Application of Observation Adjoint Sensitivity to Satellite Assimilation Problems Nancy L. Baker Naval Research Laboratory Monterey, CA.
Munehiko Yamaguchi, Sharanya J. Majumdar (RSMAS/U. Miami) and multiple collaborators 3 rd THORPEX International Science Symposium 14 Sep Coordinated.
F. Prates/Grazzini, Data Assimilation Training Course March Error Tracking F. Prates/ F. Grazzini.
Assimilating Moisture Information from GPS Dropwindsondes into the NOAA Global Forecast System A NOAA/Joint Hurricane Testbed Project Jason P. Dunion 1.
AMS Annual Meeting - January NRL Global Model Adaptive Observing During TPARC/TCS-08 Carolyn Reynolds Naval Research Laboratory, Monterey, CA OUTLINE:
Predictability of High Impact Weather during the Cool Season: CSTAR Update and the Development of a New Ensemble Sensitivity Tool for the Forecaster Brian.
Studying impacts of the Saharan Air Layer on hurricane development using WRF-Chem/EnKF Jianyu(Richard) Liang Yongsheng Chen 6th EnKF Workshop York University.
Preliminary results from assimilation of GPS radio occultation data in WRF using an ensemble filter H. Liu, J. Anderson, B. Kuo, C. Snyder, A. Caya IMAGe.
NOAA G-IV AIRCRAFT TRACK AROUND HURRICANE IVAN. ETKF PLANNED FLIGHT ACTUAL G-IV FLIGHT.
Influence of Assimilating Satellite- Derived High-resolution data on Analyses and Forecasts of Tropical Cyclone Track and Structure: A case study of Sinlaku.
NCAR April 1 st 2003 Mesoscale and Microscale Meteorology Data Assimilation in AMPS Dale Barker S. Rizvi, and M. Duda MMM Division, NCAR
Doppler Lidar Winds & Tropical Cyclones Frank D. Marks AOML/Hurricane Research Division 7 February 2007.
Adaptive Observations at NWS Lacey Holland, SAIC at EMC/NCEP/NWS Zoltan Toth, EMC/NCEP/NWS Acknowledgements:
NCEP CMC ECMWF MEAN ANA BRIAN A COLLE MINGHUA ZHENG │ EDMUND K. CHANG Applying Fuzzy Clustering Analysis to Assess Uncertainty and Ensemble System Performance.
Examination of Observation Impacts Derived from OSEs and Adjoint Models Ron Gelaro and Yanqiu Zhu NASA Global Modeling and Assimilation Office Ricardo.
High impact weather nowcasting and short-range forecasting using advanced IR soundings Jun Li Cooperative Institute for Meteorological.
1 Current and planned research with data collected during the IFEX/RAINEX missions Robert Rogers NOAA/AOML/Hurricane Research Division.
Juliane Schwendike and Sarah Jones The Interaction between Convection and African Easterly Waves:
Tropical Jets and Disturbances. African Easterly Waves (Figure obtained from Introduction to Tropical Meteorology, 2 nd Edition, © 2011 COMET.)
Jianyu Liang (York U.) Yongsheng Chen (York U.) Zhiquan Liu (NCAR)
Assessing the Impact of Aircraft Observations on Model Forecasts
Hui Liu, Jeff Anderson, and Bill Kuo
Science Objectives contained in three categories
Impact of Assimilating AMSU-A Radiances on forecasts of 2008 Atlantic TCs Initialized with a limited-area EnKF Zhiquan Liu, Craig Schwartz, Chris Snyder,
Impact of aircraft data in the MSC forecast systems
Results from the THORPEX Observation Impact Inter-comparison Project
Recent Forecast Impact Results from WSR and ATREC
Presentation transcript:

Guidance for Targeted Observations during N-AMMA and data impact results: 3 studies 1. Sharanya Majumdar (RSMAS/U.Miami) 2. Jason Dunion & Sim Aberson (NOAA/AOML/HRD) 3. Rolf Langland (NRL Monterey) Acknowledgments: NASA N-AMMA, NOAA THORPEX, NOAA JHT, ONR TCSP/N-AMMA Workshop, Baltimore, May

1. Targeted Wind Observations In order to improve a 2-day forecast of 700 hPa winds offshore of west Africa, in which locations should we collect supplementary observations? titi toto tvtv Ensemble Initialization time Observing timeVerification time t 2-3 days2 days

Targeted observing method: Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (ETKF) Theory: Bishop et al. (MWR 2001) Application to winter storm reconnaissance: Majumdar et al. (MWR 2002, QJRMS 2002) Comparison with other methods for tropical cyclones: Majumdar et al. (MWR 2006) Need to account for: –Observation variables, operators, error (co)variance –Data assimilation scheme –Forward propagation of error variance between observation and verification times

Daily Guidance Predictions made 48 hours prior to observing time. 145-member NCEP, ECMWF and CMC ensembles Guidance was available daily by 1400 UTC on EXAMPLE OF GUIDANCE: AEW that developed into Helene, 9/11/06-9/15/06

AA AA

AA

Target areas: local uncertainty in wind field (1) Easterly Wave (2) Anticyclone to north (3) African Easterly Jet region behind wave A

Future Work 1.Qualitative understanding of ETKF guidance. 2.Identify average ‘sensitive regions’ over season. 3.Evaluate ability of ETKF to predict (in)sensitive areas for assimilation of observations. a.Larger ensemble => better ETKF (use THORPEX TIGGE?) b.Sensitivity to variables? (winds, T, mixing ratio?) 4.Data-impact experiments.

2. Importance of Relative Humidity Saharan Air Layer Experiment (SALEX) NOAA G - IV Mission n SAL 3 SAL 2 SAL 1 AEW 1 Irene Polar Satellite (SSMI/AMSR-E) imagery of TPW may or may not capture dry air over the ocean that affects hurricane intensity. Dry air is sometimes concentrated in a narrow mid-low level jet that is not visible in TPW. Compare 2 SALEX dropwindsondes …

21 RH21 WIND Thin SAL between hPa. Strong narrow dry jet missed by satellite. 16 RH16 WIND Broad SAL between hPa. Consistent with satellite.

Numerical model may fail to capture local RH structure and dry air intrusion into hurricane. Drop #17 Drop #

Potential for Targeted Humidity Observations: Helene 2006 Location of highest ensemble spread (uncertainty) is in area of high RH gradient. These locations are also where satellite and in-situ observations disagree with each other and with models.

LEFT: Influence of relative humidity (RH) data from dropwindsondes on NCEP GFS Track forecast. AVHM=with RH. T254=no RH. BEST=best track. Assimilation of RH dissipates Irene! ONE DAY LATER: RH maintains Irene! ABOVE: Assimilation of RH data in the dropwindsondes acted to dry the lower troposphere to the north-east of Irene.

Summary SALEX data identified a narrow jet of dry air, not found in satellite data. Jet may modify hurricane intensity. Investigate further using N-AMMA data. Thermodynamic data altered NWP forecasts of hurricane track in a few cases. Interaction between dry air and hurricane may be better predicted by assimilating RH in high-resolution hurricane models (e.g. HWRF), leading to improved forecasts of intensity change. Targeted observing strategies identify locations of high RH gradient in which RH observations ought be assimilated. Can generalize dry air intrusion beyond SAL: mid-latitude troughs; dry air advected in inflow (e.g. Hurricane Rita)

NRL-Monterey: Marine Meteorology Division What is the impact of observation data in this region ? 1-30 September 2006: observations assimilated at 00UTC in NOGAPS-NAVDAS (3d-Var) – data received in real-time 3. AMMA Data Impact on NOGAPS

NRL-Monterey: Marine Meteorology Division Methodology: The impact of each observation can be quantified in terms of how much it reduces (or increases) the short range forecast error on the new analysis trajectory vs. the old background trajectory. The forecast error metric is the 24hr forecast error in the global domain, energy-weighted to combine temperature, moisture, and winds from the surface to near tropopause level: forecast error units = J kg -1 Tools required: adjoint versions of the global forecast model and the data assimilation procedure Refs: Langland and Baker (Tellus 2004), Langland (MWR 2005)

NRL-Monterey: Marine Meteorology Division RESULTS: (negative numbers = error reduction = good!) Observation TypeImpact (J kg -1 ) # of Obs Radiosondes ,353 Land-surface ,089 Ship-surface ,607 Geo-sat winds ,874 Aircraft ,246 Scatterometer winds AMSU-A radiances ,697 SSM/I precip. water ,372 Total Obs ,628 Results for observations assimilated at 00UTC 1-30 Sept 2006 in the region 0°N-30°N, 30°W-30°E – using data received in real-time

NRL-Monterey: Marine Meteorology Division Ranking of 8* most-valuable central African radiosonde stations – in terms of 24hr forecast error metric – NOGAPS-NAVDAS Station Lat LonImpact (Jkg -1 ) #profiles Station Name N15.03E Ndjamena, Chad N7.95W Bamako, Mali N2.38E Cotonou, Benin N16.38W Tenerife, Canaries N7.98E Agadez, Niger N5.43E Tamanrasset, Algeria N 2.17E Niamey, Niger N17.5W Dakar, Senegal Results for observations assimilated at 00UTC 1-30 Sept 2006 in the region 0°N-30°N, 30°W-30°E - using data received in real-time * The combined impact of all 20 radiosonde stations in the selected region = J kg -1, and the impact of all in-situ and satellite observation data = J kg -1