Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0 March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 802-11 Proposed PAR Review March 2014 Date: 2014-03-18 Authors:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PAR Review – July 2014 Date: Authors: July 2014
Advertisements

Doc.: IEEE /0085r2 Submission July 2011 Gerald Chouinard, CRCSlide Response to Comments received on the proposed a PAR and 5C Date:
Submission doc.: IEEE /0230r1 March 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 PAR Review SC – Closing Report – March 2015 Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0271r4 Submission March 2015 Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)Slide 1 Comments on TGay PAR and CSD Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE /0229r1 March 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide PAR Review March 2015 Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 11-10/0897r0 July 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide PAR Review – July 2014 Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE r PAR Review July 2015 Date: July 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 11-13/0333r1 March 2013 Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.Slide Review of March 2013 Proposed Pars Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 22-13/0168r1 March 2014 Apurva N. Mody, BAE SystemsSlide Response to Comments on the Revision PAR Date:
Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r1 March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide Proposed PAR Review March 2014 Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0498r0 Submission April 2008 Eldad Perahia, Intel CorporationSlide 1 Modifications to the 60GHz PAR & 5 C’s Proposal Date:
Consolidated comments on LASG 802c PAR and CSD Stephen Haddock March 11,
1 privecsg ecsg IEEE 802 EC Privacy Recommendation SG Comments on Privacy PAR/CSD March, 2015 Juan Carlos Zuniga, InterDigital Labs (EC SG Chair)
Doc.: IEEE /139r4 Submission November 2011 M. Azizur Rahman (NICT)Slide 1 Response to Comments on P802.22b PAR and 5C Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE r PAR Review SC November 2015 Date: November 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSR-QualcommSlide 1 Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 14-22/0098r0 July 2014 Slide 1 P PAR and CSD Comment Resolution Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /1220r0 Submission November 2009 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 WG11 Comments on PARs submitted Nov 2009 Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE leci SGLECIM November 2010 Slide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPAN) Submission Title:
Submission doc.: IEEE r PAR Review SC November 2015 Date: November 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSR-QualcommSlide 1 Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0904r1 Submission July 2012 Jon Rosdahl (CSR)Slide Review of July 2012 Proposed Pars Date: Authors:
IEEE mban SubmissionSlide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title:Resolution.
Doc.: IEEE /1197r0 Submission November 2009 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 Review 802 PARS under consideration for Nov Plenary Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE r PAR Review SC November 2015 Date: November 2015 Jon Rosdahl, CSR-QualcommSlide 1 Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/1339r1 November 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide PAR Review November 2014 Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 14-22/0098r0 July 2014 Slide 1 P PAR and CSD Comment Resolution Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE 11-13/0789r0 July 2013 Jon Rosdahl, CSR Technology Inc.Slide Review of March 2013 Proposed Pars Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE sru Submission 11 November 2013 M Ariyoshi, S Kitazawa (ATR)Slide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal.
Doc.: IEEE /0356r0 Submission March 2009 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 New WG PARs that WG11 must consider in March 2009 Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0860r0 Submission July 2010 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 Comments for p New PAR – July 2010 Date: Authors:
Submission doc.: IEEE r3 PAR Review - Agenda and Meeting slides - March 2016 Date: March 2016 Jon Rosdahl (Qualcomm) Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0236r0 Submission November 2009 Wendong Hu, STMSlide 1 Responses to Comments on PAR Modification IEEE P Wireless RANs.
Doc.: IEEE /1373r1 Submission November 2008 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 Feedback received on Revision PAR Date: Authors:
PAR Review - Agenda and Meeting slides - March 2016
Comments on WUR SG PAR and CSD
PAR Comment Responses Date: Authors: November 2016
China MM-Wave (CMMW) Study Group Comments on aj PAR & 5C
PAR Review - Meeting Agenda and Comment slides - Vancouver 2017
PAR Review - Meeting Agenda and Comment slides - San Antonio 2016
Nov 2010 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: Resolution of PAR and 5C Comments for MBAN Study.
Review of March 2013 Proposed Pars
VHT SG PAR Feedback from Individuals
Mar Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [Draft PAR & CSD Comment Responses] Date Submitted:
January 2014 doc.: IEEE /0084r0 January 2016
March 2018 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: z PAR/CSD Comments Responses Date.
Response to Comments Received on the a PAR and CSD
Submission Title: [SGLECIM PAR & 5C comment resolution November 2010]
July 2017 Response to comments on 802.1ACct - Amendment: Support for IEEE Std  PAR and CSD July 2017 Thomas Kürner, Chair TG3d .
Submission Title: [SGLECIM PAR & 5C comment resolution November 2010]
March 2017 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: f PAR/CSD Comments Responses Date.
doc.: IEEE <492> <month year> November 2015
Consolidated comments and Resolutions on 802
Submission Title: [SGLECIM PAR & 5C comment resolution November 2010]
January 2014 doc.: IEEE /0084r0 March 2014
March 2018 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: z PAR/CSD Comments Responses Date.
Feedback received on Revision PAR
Jan Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [PAR and CSD document discussion] Date Submitted:
Response to Comments on P802.22b PAR and 5C
Comments on Sub 1 GHz license-exempt operation
comments on Pending 802 PARs – July 2011
July doc.: IEEE /0997r0 July Response to Comments received on the proposed a PAR and 5C Date: Authors: Gerald.
March 2018 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: z PAR/CSD Comments Responses Date.
Comments for p New PAR – July 2010
PAR Review - Meeting Agenda and Comment slides - Vancouver 2017
PAR Review - Agenda and Meeting slides - March 2016
IEEE Comments on aq PAR and 5C
March 15, 2015 Kunal Shah SG4v Chair
Comments for Nov 2010 EC PAR proposals.
March 2012 doc.: IEEE /0368r1 March 2012
WG11 review of Proposed PARs - March Plenary
Comments for Rev PAR – July 2010 Plenary
Presentation transcript:

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0 March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide Proposed PAR Review March 2014 Date: Authors:

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0 March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 2 Abstract PARS under consideration: Mar , 2014, Beijing, China: bp - amendment: 1 Gb/s Operation over Single Twisted Pair Copper Cable, PAR modification request and unmodified CSD responses (grandfathered 5 Criteria responses)PAR modification requestunmodified CSD responses bs - amendment: 400 Gb/s Ethernet, PAR and CSDPARCSD HEW (High Efficiency WLAN), PAR and CSD (not covered here)PARCSD d 100Gbps wireless switched point-to-point physical layer, PAR and CSDPARCSD r Radio based Distance Measurement Techniques, PAR and CSDPARCSD Revision PAR for , PAR and CSDPARCSD Qcd PAR modification

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0 No comment from bp - amendment: 1 Gb/s Operation over Single Twisted Pair Copper Cable, PAR modification request and unmodified CSD responses (grandfathered 5 Criteria responses)PAR modification requestunmodified CSD responses bs - amendment: 400 Gb/s Ethernet, PAR and CSDPAR CSD Slide 3Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r d 100Gbps wireless switched point-to-point physical layer, PAR and CSDPARCSD 5.2.a and 5.2.b The scope is not bounded sufficiently. 5.2a and 5.2b Stakeholders will not be able to determine if this is a project if of interest with the scope as written. 5.2a and 5.2b It would seem that this project may overlap other projects. 5.2.b – The scope is not defined to a range that is definitive. Remove “or more” as a start, but the scope would need to be defined more crisply. 5.5 The last sentence is not true. (i.e ad) 5.5 “guaranteed” is not possible when using unlicensed wireless bands. Slide 4Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r d PAR (cont) 5.1 Would you check the number that is actively involved? 100 seems high (only 20 people from 11 organizations attended the Study Group in January) 7.1 – There would seem to be some projects of similar scope – i.e c, ad, Transferjet, etc. General Question – Is this the project that is getting the.1AC MAC address space correction? General: The CSD includes a suggested range of “up to several 100m” Slide 5Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r d CSD (cont)CSD a) “guaranteed” – this is not possible – reword sentence a) The use cases seem too broad to be believable – Is 48-bit addressing required to be conformant with 802.1AC, if so, is this PAR proposing to use 48-bit addressing? Is the proposed application consistent with modern data centers? Does this apply more to older deployed data centers for retro upgrade? If the data center is wired up, the change of configuration is typically done via software. So does this wireless technology provide a benefit given the wired connectivity? Slide 6Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide r Radio based Distance Measurement Techniques, PAR and CSDPARCSD 5.5 – expand RTLS the first instance it is used. CSD – The first sentence does not parse well. Consider rewording This statement does not seem to indicate a distinct identity, but rather a change to the radio being used. “needs of IEEE ” - the standard has not the “need” but rather the users of the standard. Could this statement simply be that you are adding ranging to your radio?

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide Revision PAR for , PAR and CSD PARCSD General – This seems to be a word document that does not capture the correct PAR format. Please put into myProject and allow it to generate the proper output file to give the correct change bars and edit changes. 2.1 Title – dropping the TV from the “TV bands” leaves the title without bound of the frequencies being used. Suggest add “bands between 1300 MHz to 1750 MHz, 2700 MHz to 3700 MHz and 54 MHz to 862 MHz. “ to the title to ensure people know what this standard is covering af should be lower-case.

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r Revision PAR (Cont) 8.1 the text there does not belong – it does not indicate which section it is giving extra explanation to. Delete all the text in 8.1 – consider adding to CSD or to section 5.5 Need for project. Use approved CSD form: CSD – missing template or question…not from the approved template? CSD missing template or question…not from the approved template? CSD af should be lowercase letters. Change all instances. CSD last sentence does not parse correctly. Look at how this “ (Wi-Far)” is described. Slide 9Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r Qcd Par Modification 5.2b – this section does not read correctly. The “Minor addition” seems like an editorial instruction or an informative word that should be removed. Are you changing the scope of the project as shown in both paragraphs in 5.2b? Is the scope change just the addition of the new text. It seems to be a summary for the scope of the project (potentially) or if it is the incremental addition to the scope, then just rewrite the scope of the project as such PAR modification form requires a statement of what and why (rationalization) the PAR is being changed be included in 8.1. Please add. Slide 10Jon Rosdahl, CSR March 2014

Submission doc.: IEEE 11-14/0319r0March 2014 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 11 References PARS under consideration are listed here: