1 Automatically Validating Temporal Safety Properties of Interfaces - Overview of SLAM Parts of the slides are from

2 Checking API Usage Application C lib | DLL | COM |… API Does an application follow the “proper usage” rules of an API?

3 Temporal safety properties Something “bad” does not happen –Eg. A lock is never released without first being acquired Unlocked Locked Error U LL U

4 C program Boolean program c2bp bebop Fail, p Pass newton SLIC Instrumented C program predicates Error Spec. predicates Big picture of SLAM process

5 SLIC spec for Spinlock enum { Unlocked=0, Locked=1 } state = Unlocked; KeAcquireSpinLock.call { if (state==Locked) abort; else state = Locked; } KeReleaseSpinLock.call { if (state==Unlocked) abort; else state = Unlocked; } Unlocked Locked Error U LL U

6 Target program to validate do { KeAcquireSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); nPacketsOld = nPackets; request = devExt->WriteListHeadVa; if(request && request->status){ devExt->WriteListHeadVa = request->Next; KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); irp = request->irp; if(request->status > 0){ irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_SUCCESS; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } else{ irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_UNSUCCESSFUL; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } SmartDevFreeBlock(request); IoCompleteRequest(irp, IO_NO_INCREMENT); nPackets++; } } while (nPackets != nPacketsOld); KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); Question: Is locking protocol respected?

7 Safety to Reachability Program P SLIC spec S SLIC Program P satisfies specification S  Label ERROR is not reachable in P’ Instrumented Program P’

8 do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); KeAcquireSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); nPacketsOld = nPackets; request = devExt->WriteListHeadVa; if(request && request->status){ devExt->WriteListHeadVa = request->Next; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); irp = request->irp; if(request->status > 0){ irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_SUCCESS; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } else { irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_UNSUCCESSFUL; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } SmartDevFreeBlock(request); IoCompleteRequest(irp, IO_NO_INCREMENT); nPackets++; } } while (nPackets != nPacketsOld); KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); enum { Unlocked=0, Locked } state = Unlocked; void slic_abort() { ERROR: } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if(state==Locked) slic_abort(); else state = Locked; } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if(state==Unlocked) slic_abort(); else state = Unlocked; } Question: Is locking protocol respected? Equivalently: Is label ERROR reachable? Instrumented Program

9 C program Boolean program c2bp bebop Fail, p Pass newton SLIC Instrumented C program predicates Error Spec. predicates Big picture of SLAM process

10 Predicate abstraction by C2BP Instrumented program P’ Boolean program BP(P’,E0) C2BP Initial predicates E0 state==Locked, state==Unlocked

11 do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; } else { skip; } skip; } } while (*); KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; decl {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; void slic_abort() { ERROR: } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if({state==Locked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := T,F; } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if({state==Unlocked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; } Question: Is locking protocol respected? Equivalently: Is label ERROR reachable? Initial boolean Program

12 Model-check by BEBOP do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; } else { skip; } skip; } } while (*); KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; decl {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; void slic_abort() { ERROR: } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if({state==Locked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := T,F; } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if({state==Unlocked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; } {state==Unlocked}Æ :{state==Locked} :{state==Unlocked}Æ{state==Locked} reached ERROR label

13 The execution path to blame! do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); KeAcquireSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); nPacketsOld = nPackets; // s1 request = devExt->WriteListHeadVa; // s2 if(request && request->status){ // s3 devExt->WriteListHeadVa = request->Next; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); irp = request->irp; if(request->status > 0){ irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_SUCCESS; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } else { irp->IoStatus.Status = STATUS_UNSUCCESSFUL; irp->IoStatus.Information = request->Status; } SmartDevFreeBlock(request); IoCompleteRequest(irp, IO_NO_INCREMENT); nPackets++; } } while (nPackets != nPacketsOld); // s4 KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); KeReleaseSpinLock(&devExt->writeListLock); enum { Unlocked=0, Locked } state = Unlocked; void slic_abort() { ERROR: // s6 } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if(state==Locked) slic_abort(); // s5 else state = Locked; // s0 } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if(state==Unlocked) slic_abort(); else state = Unlocked; } s0: state = Locked; s1: nPacketsOld = nPackets; s2: request = devExt->WriteListHeadVa; s3: assume(!request); s4: assume(nPackets != nPacketsOld); s5: assume(state==Locked); s6: ERROR:

14 Time for NEWTON s0:state = Locked; s1:nPacketsOld = nPackets; s2:request = devExt->WriteListHeadVa; s3:assume(!request); s4:assume(nPackets != nPacketsOld); s5:assume(state==Locked); s6:ERROR: LocationValueDependencies 0. stateLocked() 1. nPackets  () 2. nPacketsOld  1 3. devExt  () 4.  ->WriteListHeadVa  3 5. request  3, 4 ConditionsDependencies !(  )5 (  !=  )1, 2 New predicate! nPackets==nPacketsOld

15 C program Boolean program c2bp bebop Fail, p Pass newton SLIC Instrumented C program predicates Error Spec. predicates Big picture of SLAM process

16 do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); skip; b := T; // nPackets = nPacketsOld; skip; if(*){ skip; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; } else { skip; } skip; b := b ? F : *; // nPackets++; } } while(!b); // while (nPackets!=nPacketsOld); KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; Variable b represents (nPackets==nPacketsOld) decl {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; void slic_abort() { ERROR: } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if({state==Locked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := T,F; } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if({state==Unlocked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; } Question: Is locking protocol respected? Equivalently: Is label ERROR reachable? The second boolean Program

17 Model-check again by BEBOP do { KeAcquireSpinLock_call(); skip; b := T; skip; if(*){ skip; KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; if(*){ skip; } else { skip; } skip; b := b ? F : *; } } while(!b); KeReleaseSpinLock_call(); skip; * decl {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; void slic_abort() { ERROR: } void KeAcquireSpinLock_call () { if({state==Locked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := T,F; } void KeReleaseSpinLock_call () { if({state==Unlocked}) slic_abort(); else {state==Locked},{state==Unlocked} := F,T; } {state==Unlocked}Æ :{state==Locked} :{state==Unlocked}Æ{state==Locked} reached ERROR label * T T T F

18 C program Boolean program c2bp bebop Fail, p Pass newton SLIC Instrumented C program predicates Error Spec. predicates Big picture of SLAM process

19 C2BP Automatic predicate abstraction of C What is the predicate language? –Pure C boolean expressions Input: a C program P and set of predicates E Output: a boolean program C2BP(P,E) that is –a sound abstraction of P –a precise abstraction of P Difficulties –procedures –pointers

20 BEBOP  Reachability analysis of boolean programs  Symbolic version of [Reps-Horwitz-Sagiv, POPL’95] interprocedural data flow analysis  Explicit representation of control flow  Implicit representation of reachable states via BDDs

21 NEWTON Symbolically executes (interprocedural) path in C program Checks for path infeasibility using decision procedures (theorem provers: Simplify, Vampyre) If infeasibility detected –Find weak(est) condition implying the infeasibility –Obtains new predicates

22 Contributions Use of boolean programs for program abstractions C2BP : the first automatic predicate abstraction tool for a full-scale language BEBOP : the first model checker to handle procedure calls using inter-procedural DFA Global analysis only on the boolean program abstractions : scalable…?

23 Defects Defects of SLAM –Uses a logical memory model Assumes for all i,j : p[i] = p[j] –No guarantee on the termination of iterative refinement Defects of the paper –No experimental results (describes their experiences only)