Grouting Effectiveness Construction QA/QC of Post Grouted Shafts Gray Mullins, Ph.D., P.E.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR Practice Questions Next.
Advertisements

JP Singh and Associates in association with Mohamed Ashour, Ph.D., P.E. Gary Norris, Ph.D., P.E. March 2004 COMPUTER PROGRAM S-SHAFT FOR LATERALLY LOADED.
Engine & Transport Integrated Cooling Systems. © Alfa LavalSlide 2 Alfa Laval Integrated Cooling Systems, ALICS Integrated marine cooling.
Lab T1: Compression Ignition (Diesel) Engine Lab Instructor: M
Failure Case Study of Construction at a Solid Waste Site K. Madhavan, Ph.D., P.E., Dept. of Civil & Env. Engineering Christian Brothers University Memphis,
1 Application and Analysis of Helical Piers in Frozen Ground He Liu, Ph.D., P.E. Daniel Schubert, P.E. Hannele Zubeck, Ph.D., P.E. Sean Baginski.
LRFD Design of Shallow Foundations
Course : S0705 – Soil Mechanic
INTRODUCTION Session 1 – 2
Designing Piles for Drag Force
Session 25 – 26 DRILLED SHAFT And CAISSON FOUNDATION
Prepared by J. P. Singh & Associates in association with
Lecture 8 Elements of Soil Mechanics
1 Scoggins Dam Overview of Seismic Risk July 18, 2012.
Civil Engineering The best kind!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
Crystal Structural Behavior of CoCu₂O₃ at High Temperatures April Jeffries*, Ravhi Kumar, and Andrew Cornelius *Department of Physics, State University.
Soil Pile Group Interaction in FB-MultiPier
Engineering Properties of Soils Soil Types
AN INTRODUCTION TO MICROPILES CIVL 141 Spring 2011.
HYDRUS_1D Sensitivity Analysis Limin Yang Department of Biological Engineering Sciences Washington State University.
UTSW Thermal Energy Plants, Power Generation and Electrical System What do we do to meet the Emission Reduction, Energy usage Reduction and Electrical.
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF DEEP FOUNDATION WEEK 9 FRICTION AND END BEARING PILES BEARING CAPACITY ANALYSIS OF PILES USING EMPIRICAL AND DYNAMIC FORMULAE.
1 THERMAL & MECHANICAL PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS ELM COIL ALTERNATE DESIGN Interim Review July 26-28, 2010 In-Vessel Coil System Interim Review – July 26-28,
1 Field Approach A Test pile of required dimensions is constructed in the field and a load test is conducted to assess the capacity of the pile. This approach.
Soil-Pile Interaction in FB-MultiPier
Updated March LAPS ( LOCAL ASSISTANCE PAYMENT SYSTEM) Instructions for Accessing Local Programs Invoice Register on the Internet.
The Future of Commissioning for Sustained Building Performance Birmingham, AL SERBCA Fall Conference Proposed LEED Requirements for Commissioning.
Broadway Street Viaduct Improvement, Pre-Load Testing and Geotech Report Workshop Consultant Presentation Iowa DOT 2 nd April 2007.
Location Surveys I. Traditional Highway Location: 1. field-oriented work 2. *Procedures 1) The first step: Reconnaissance of the area using available topographic.
TenCate TM Mirafi ® Geosynthetics Bruce A Lacina, P.E. Roadway Reinforcement Technical Manager.
Reference Manual Chapter 9
1 Interpretation and Visualization of Model Test Data for Slope Failure in Liquefying Soil Bruce L. Kutter Erik J. Malvick R. Kulasingam Ross Boulanger.
Results Based Management: Logical Framework Matrix (LFM) December 30 th, 2009 Abeer Shakweer, Ph.D., Planning and Monitoring Manager Science and Technology.
CAISSON FOUNDATION.
WELL DRILLING AND CONSTRUCTION Ken Bousfield, P.E. Utah Division of Drinking Water.
TRENTON Casing Filler Presentation
AFT STATNAMIC Load Testing of High Capacity Marine Foundations
Retaining Walls I. *Introduction
FRAMING SEMINARS 2012 PRESENTED BY KW ENGINEERING 1.
PRACTICE AND RESEARCH ON MICROPILE GROUPS AND NETWORKS Prof. François SCHLOSSER ENPC - CERMES 2 nd LIZZI lecture Tokyo IWM August 2004.
Contractor Alternate Design Serving the Public’s Best Interest.
Safety-related Issues for the Disposal of Intermediate Level Waste (ILW) Dr. Jürgen Wollrath Federal Office for Radiation Protection (BfS) Department Safety.
Jan. 28, 2014W. Bertl, PSI BPIX Cooling Status W. Bertl, PSI.
Two loading Conditions
BEARING CAPACITY OF SOIL Session 3 – 4
Latest Developments in Equipment and QA/QC systems in Driven Pile and Drilled Shaft Systems By George Piscsalko, PE Pile Dynamics Inc.
Soil Stress and Pore Water Pressure
Leads Institute of Technology & Engineering Subject Code : Name Of Subject :Building Construction Name of Unit : Soil Foundation Topic : Bearing.
Lecture 8 Elements of Soil Mechanics
GLE/CEE 330: Soil Mechanics Introduction to Foundation Engineering
CAISSON FOUNDATION.
Pile Foundation Reason for Piles Types of Piles
Brian T. Malec, Ph.D. Professor of Health Administration Department of Health Sciences California State University, Northridge Northridge, CA
Lay-On Gable Frame Connection Overview. Introduction A lay-on gable frame is typically connected from the top during truss placement, but after sheathing.
Anhydrous Ammonia Storage and Handling Original Power Point Created by Brandon Ritter Modified by Georgia Agricultural Education Curriculum Office June.
Development of Seismic Design Approach for Freestanding Freight Railroad Embankment Comprised of Lightweight Cellular Concrete Cell-Crete Corp. Steven.
Optimum Pump Performance for Process Applications
FE: Geotechnical Engineering
Bridge Pile Foundation Evaluation for a Soil Remediation Project
Evaluation of Cracking Resistance and Durability of 100% Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement Mixtures Hesham Ali, PhD, PE. Mojtaba M. Afzali.
UPDATE ON FHWA’S IN-SITU SCOUR TESTING DEVICE (ISTD)
CT Reinforced Earth Structures
Soil Mechanics-II Earthen Dames
UNIT-4 BLACKBOX AND WHITEBOX TESTING
Box-and-Whisker Plots
Box-and-Whisker Plots
Soil Mechanics-II Earthen Dames
Designing and Manufacturing of a hand operated plastic injection moulding machine envisioned for the mesoscale range. Freddy Travieso
Factors to Consider in Foundation Design Chapter # 02
UNIT-4 BLACKBOX AND WHITEBOX TESTING
Presentation transcript:

Grouting Effectiveness Construction QA/QC of Post Grouted Shafts Gray Mullins, Ph.D., P.E.

Problem Statement  Post grouted drilled shaft tips have amazing benefits: increased end bearing, reduced foundation cost, increased design confidence, etc.  However, grouting must be effectively performed requiring field monitoring measures to aid both quality control and verification.

Grouting Processes  Single stage Grout pressure is achieved in first application.  Multi-stage (stage grouting) Grout pressure is not achieved in first application requiring subsequent cycles/stages to achieve design pressure

Design Options (Conservative)

Design Options (Empirical) Mullins et al. 2006; Dapp and Brown 2010

Design Methods  Methods depend on achieving a specified design grout pressure  Require grouted area to fully form beneath shaft tip.

Present Quality Control Measures  Must achieve and hold design grout pressure.  Must place a minimum net grout volume to indicate sufficient grout area (soil dependent)  Should stay within safe uplift limits (soil dependent; wide range of acceptability)  Present methods do not verify effectiveness

Effective Grouting  Should show increase in pressure with increase in volume  Should show increase in uplift (or strain) with increased pressure  If both above are true, then increases in volume are registered as increases in uplift Large amounts of scourable or liquefiable overburden make strain more appropriate than uplift measurements

Grouting Concept

Mullins and Winters 2004 Grout Pressure (psi) Grout Pressure (cu ft) Uplift (in) Grout Pressure (psi)

NOTE: (1) All graphs should demonstrate a diagonal trend away from the center. (2) If any one of the graphs demonstrates a horizontal or vertical trend confirmed by a second graph, the post grouting process has become ineffective for the reason shown Winters 2014

Example 1 Mullins 2015 Example 1

Increased Volume w/o pressure or displacement Mullins 2015

Increase Pressure w/o volume or displacement Mullins 2015

Example 2

Toe Strain Gages

N Bottom of Shaft Thermal Integrity Profiling Confirmed more grout on one side Before GroutingAfter Grouting

Grout Criteria Multi-Stage Grouting  Note change in P-V slope  Original grout bulb acts to distribute shaft tip pressure to a lesser value at soil  Second Stage produces pressure to shaft tip but no new pressure to soil  No further soil improvement is achieved  Second Stage DOES PROOF LOAD to that level (e.g. P grout A tip )

Conclusions  Field monitoring and plotting of P,V, and U as shown can directly confirm effective grouting  However, grout should be pumped into as many lines as practical (at least opposing sides)

Conclusions  Uplift is the strongest indication of global force emanating from grout pressure  However, unbalanced designs with large amounts of scour-able or liquefiable overburden need an alternate measurement as top of shaft uplift may not be detectable

Conclusions  Multi-stage grouting is not the same as single stage grouting.  Supported by lower TCM value derived for stage grouted shafts (Dapp and Brown 2010)  Design should account for the use of stage grouting (if used) at design phase or effects should be shown by test shaft

Conclusions  Where possible grouting should be performed on cool shafts to prevent flash-set grout line blockages  For test programs on fast track schedules, use chemical retarders or larger grout lines less prone to blockage.  Chilled water or grout in small grout lines cannot offset heat capacity of shaft.

References Dapp, S. and Brown, D. (2010). “Evaluation of Base Grouted Drilled Shafts at the Audubon Bridge,” GeoFlorida 2010: Advances in Analysis, Modeling & Design, ASCE (GSP 199). Mullins, G., (2015). “Constructin QA/QC of Post Grouted Shafts.” ASCE Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, In Press. Mullins, G., Winters, D., and Dapp, S. (2006). “Predicting End Bearing Capacity of Post Grouted Drilled Shafts in Cohesionless Soils” ASCE Journal of Geotechnical and GeoEnvironmental Engineering, Vol. 132, No. 4. pp Mullins, G. and Winters, D. (2004). "Post Grouting Drilled Shaft Tips - Phase II Final Report." Final Report submitted Florida Department of Transportation, June. Mullins, G. and O’Neill, M. (2003). “Pressure Grouting Drilled Shaft Tips - A Full-Scale Load Test Program.” Research Report, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, May. Winters, D. (2014). “Selected Topics in Foundation Design, Quality Assurance, and Remediation,” Ph.D. Dissertation, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL.

Questions   (813) (office)  (813) (mobile)