DAR ES SALAAM – TANZANIA, NOVEMBER 2015 RESULTS BASED FINANCING (RBF) EARLY IMPLEMENTATION RESULTS AND LESSONS LEARNT 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
21 July 2005 UNDG Policy Network On the MDGs UNDG Policy Network on the MDGs.
Advertisements

Lessons Learned in Social Protection in health Group 8.
Step by step guide.
COMMUNITY HEALTH FUND AS A COMPLEMENTARY FINANCING OPTION IN TANZANIA Presented at CHF Best Practice Workshop: 31 st Jan – 2 nd Feb Golden Tulip.
CDC Mozambique Transition Monitoring Approach 8 th Annual Track 1 meeting, August 12, 2010 Charity Alfredo CDC-Mozambique.
EFFORTS TO PREVENT MATERNAL AND NEWBORN MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY IN KISARAWE DR. M.O. KISANGA KISARAWE INTRODUCTION Kisarawe District is among the seven.
COMMUNITY HEALTH FUND Best Practices in Tanzania Workshop Singida District Council Juma H.Tantau CHF Coordinator.
Healthcare Waste Management Programme
1 KARAGWE DISTRICT COUNCIL Funding drug gaps by using CHF By Dr Ruta Thomas.
Recommendations and findings from RHMT training on PlanRep3 and CCHP Guidelines For DPG-H 03 September 2014 Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation.
Co-ordinator BRN star rating assessment of PHC-Facilities
PERFORMANCE AUDIT REPORT ON MANAGEMENT OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE (A CASE STUDY ON HEALTH CENTERS) 8/16/20151 Dr. Anna Nswilla CDHSMoHSW.
First, a little background…  The FIT Program is the lead agency for early intervention services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.
ESKOM SUPPLY CHAIN INITIATIVE. Eskom Supply Chain Initiative Pilot Project Presented by Thando Khaile ctober 2006.
Learning from RBF Implementation Dinesh Nair Sr Health Specialist.
February 2010 Petra Vergeer, Health Specialist RBF Team, World Bank At a glance… Verification of performance linked to financial incentives by Joe Naimoli.
Leaders Drive the Health System Results of Mentorship Approach in GIZ Focal districts National LMG Conference Intercontinental Hotel, Nairobi January 2013.
Debriefing for the Study Tour of the Malian and Senegalese Delegations to Rwanda October 25-30, 2009.
Health Planning and Implementation in post-conflict Afghanistan by Laurence Laumonier-Ickx, MD November 8, 2006.
MAISHA: Mothers and Infants, Safe Healthy Alive Dr Muthoni Magu-Kariuki Jhpiego Mbeya Region Advocacy Meeting JuLY 2011.
PEER LEARNING DISTRICTS INITIATIVE REPORT ON INITIAL ASSESSMENT OF MANAGEMENT AND DELIVERY OF HEALTH SERVICES Presentation to DPG-Health and SWAp-TWG1.
Performances Based Financing scheme in Rwanda INVESTING MORE STRATEGICALLY 1.
Introduction to Health Management Information System (HMIS) By Claud J. Kumalija Head HMIS 06 th November, 2008.
Primer on Monitoring and Evaluation. The 3 Pillars of Monitoring and Evaluation  Identifying the Performance Indicators  Collecting information using.
Training Provider Briefing Session 2.00pm Welcome 2.10pm Walsall Works 2.40pm Q&A session 3.00pm Networking 3.30pm Close.
Presentation Content 2005/2006 Poverty Analysis Country Poverty Alleviation Strategy Koudemain Ste Lucie Programme - Brief Description -
Promoting CARICOM/CARIFORUM Food Security (Project GTFS/RLA/141/ITA) (FAO Trust Fund for Food Security and Food Safety – Government of Italy Contribution)
Usafi wa Mazingira Tanzania (UMATA) Country Programme Proposal Thursday 19th April 2012 Dr Khalid Massa - Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, Government.
Rapid Assessment of District and Community HIV and AIDS Response Challenges, Constraints and Prospects Technical Review 2008 Rapid Assessment of District.
Regional Health Management Report on FY2012/13 and Plan 2013/ R.D. Mutagwaba, Regional Health Services Coordinator, MOHSW.
USE AND MANAGEMENT FUND Dr. Winfred Philemon Kyambile District Medical Officer HANANG CHF BEST PRACTICE WORKSHOP DAR ES SALAAM 02/02/2007.
Tanzanian German Programme to Support Health The Health Financing Component Supporting Social Health Protection and Health Financial Management in Tanzania.
Results-based financing Why? What? How?. Jagaman district just erected a new health center and the health workers have started work. What are health workers.
FEEDBACK FROM RMO/DMO MEETING HELD ON 8 th -12 th SEPTEMBER, 2014 IN MOROGORO Joint Annual Health Sector Review 6 th November 2014.
Evaluating Pay for Performance in Health Provincial Maternal -Child Health Investment Project in Argentina Sebastian Martinez HDNVP Presentation joint.
KILOSA DISTRICT COUNCIL Challenges of low CHF Enrolment CHF KILOSA Dr. Mapunjo Ag. DMO Kilosa.
Nigeria, January 2010 Petra Vergeer Health Specialist, RBF Team.
31st Jan- 2nd Feb, 2007CHF best practice WS, Golden Tulip Hotel, DSM 031st Jan - 2nd February Mtwara Mikindani Muncipal Council Preparing for the.
Intervention Strategy in Improving ART Adherence In Tanzania Salama Mwakisu-MSH, Dr D Sando-NACP, Dr R. Malele-MUHAS, Bernard Rabiel- NACP, Dr G. Somi-NACP,
Reaching the Informal Sector with SHI: A CHF for Small-Scale Tea Farmers in Rungwe District, Tanzania A Public-Private Partnership Dr Shaaban Sheuya Tanzania.
31st Jan-2nd February 2007CHF best practice WS, Golden Tulip Hotel, DSM0 CHF best practices workshop Igunga District Council Reaching the Informal Economy.
Tanzania National Family Planning Costed Implementation Program (NFPCIP)
Effective Referral System for the Utilization of Critical Maternal and Newborn Health at Rural Health Centers of Ethiopia APHA 143 rd Annual Conference.
CHF Best Practices MAKING FBO PARTICIPATE IN CHF OPERATIONS ROMBO DISTRICT COUNCIL Presenter: Dr. C.E. Nkya - DMO And Secretary CHSB - ROMBO DISTRICT COUNCIL.
International SBCC Summit
Introduction of outpatient care for DS-/MDR-TB patients in Tajikistan Cape Town, December 02-06, 2015.
Rombo District Experience 8 th Annual CDC/HRSA Track 1.0 Partners Meeting Dr. Criston Nkya District Medical Officer Rombo District, Kilimanjaro, Tanzania.
Objectives “To improve maternal and child health in Zimbabwe”. “by improving the availability, accessibility and quality of key reproductive and child.
Jeroen Van’t Pad Bosch, Technical Director Elizabeth Glaser Pediatric AIDS Foundation, Tanzania EGPAF PROJECT HEART STRENGTHENING HEALTH SYSTEMS THROUGH.
Knowledge sharing workshop on social protection for vulnerable Groups ILO STEP/SFP Programmes October 15 th,16 th &17 th 2007 Bangkok, Thailand By Ansgar.
TANZANIA MAINLAND NATIONAL HEALTH POLICY AND STRATEGY REPORT.
United Republic of Tanzania Ministry of Health & Social Welfare MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL WELFARE NATIONAL AIDS CONTROL PROGRAM HIV CARE AND TREATMENT.
Endris Mohammed Seid 1,2, Arjanne Rietsema 1 1: CORDAID-Zimbabwe 2: Ministry of Health and Child Care- Zimbabwe Improving Maternal, Neonatal and Child.
National stakeholders meeting on MNCH/HIV Giraffe Hotel, Sept 24 – 25 th,2014. HIV integration - experience from Shinyanga Region. Presenter.
NASARAWA STATE GOVERNMENT NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT (NSHIP) PROJECT PERFORMANCE REVIEW JANUARY TO JUNE 2015.
Integration of Family Planning: Case Study in Manyara Region National Family Planning MCH/HIV Stakeholders Meeting Giraffe Hotel, Dar Es Salaam September.
Coordinator of Project management Unit of Global fund and MAP projects
Cash Assistance to Improve Access to Maternal Health Services in an Urban Humanitarian Setting — Initial Findings From An Innovative Pilot Project Jordan,
Quality Improvement An Introduction
Star Rating System & Findings from Assessments
Improving Reproductive Health in Punjab
RBF IMPLEMENTATION PROGRESS
Maternal and Child Survival Program/JSI
IX- PREPARING THE BUDGET
Community of Practice Conference March 18-19, 2011 Saly (Senegal)
Pay for performance – a strategy for the indian context
Results-based Financing for Health in Tanzania
Monitoring Results Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates
Stocktaking of Early Childhood Development (ECD)
Direct Health Facility Financing as a practical approach for strengthening strategic purchasing in Tanzania Strategic purchasing for universal health coverage:
Presentation transcript:

DAR ES SALAAM – TANZANIA, NOVEMBER 2015 RESULTS BASED FINANCING (RBF) EARLY IMPLEMENTATION RESULTS AND LESSONS LEARNT 1

MAP OF TANZANIA & IMPLEMENTING REGION 2

TAKE-HOME MESSAGES Incentives to staff do not work without fundamental health systems strengthening initiatives The purpose of this pilot in Kishapu is to modify the P4P design on an ongoing basis The specific details of the verification process needed to be embedded in the design from the start We under-estimated the: 1. Independence of the verifiers, 2. Existence of National RBF team with enough members, 3

WHERE ARE WE? More needs to be done to improve newborn survival 4

MATERNAL MORTALITY RATIO: A LONG WAY TO GO Maternal mortality has declined by 21% between and Concerted efforts are required to achieve the 2015 target 5

Pilot Description in Kishapu (Shinyanga) 6

RBF KISHAPU PILOT IMPLEMENTATION  9 Month pre-pilot, 4 Quarterly cycles (April- Dec 2015)  Funded by the World Bank  Selected on the basis of social and economic characteristics among the other councils in the region (Shinyanga) which was also selected based on the criteria among the other regions Goal: To inform the Scale up in the following Regions 7

BACKGROUND INFORMATION: SHINYANGA REGION  Shinyanga is one of the 30 regions of Tanzaniaregions  Selected due to poor health outcome and high poverty index  The region is divided into 6 councils  The population is projected at 1,534,808 (NBS 2012)  There are a total of 212 health care facilities, of which: (74%) are public, - 19 (9%) are FBOs, - 37 (17%) are Private.  Kishapu has 55 Health Facilities in total: 45 are public, 4 are FBOs and 6 are private.  Shinyanga has one Regional Hospital and only one District Hospital which is Kahama Town Council. 8

INSTITUTIONAL SET UP 9 9

Quantity & Quality indicators are Selected and Payment is based on Achievements  Quantity Indicators are counted and have no limitation,  The fees generated by quantity indicators is based on the level of discrepancies with verified and DHIS2 Reported data,  Achievement of 100% of the quality assessment receives a full payment. Data Verification  Data Verification is done quarterly by comparing existing data in DHIS2 and data found in the source of data of the similar indicators  The Verifier was RAS who identified the pool of verifiers in the region.  The RAS and RHMT are assessed by National level Team. 10 IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PILOT

SELECTED INDICATORS 19 Quantity Indicators for Health Centres & dispensaries, 18 Areas of Quality assessment of the Dispensaries & HCs, 26 Areas of Quality assessment of the District Hospital & Upgraded Health Centres, 3 Areas of assessment for the Verifier, 10 Areas of assessment of RHMT, 12 Areas of assessment of CHMT, 6 Indicators for MSD Zonal, 4 Indicators for MSD Central. 11

Routine verification  Supportive supervision from CHMT and RHMT includes verification of HMIS data entry and records  Spot check verification is also performed by the PMT Specific Verifications to be conducted  Regional Identified Team of Verifiers Composed by members from RAS, NHIF, RHMT and Health NGOs operating in the region perform internal Verification Quarterly  Independent verifier – Controller Auditor General (separately contracted) has a mandate to assume the function of counter verification twice a year but this activity has not yet been done.  Payments to the Providers is made through an independent fund holder – NHIF after the verification STRUCTURAL FEATURES OF THE PILOT Data collection and verification 12

FIRST VERIFICATION (Q. APRIL-JUNE )RESULTS RESULTS KAHAMA DH: 46.4%; RHMT: 82.4%; KISHAPU CHMT: 59.1% & RAS: 100%

READNESS ASSESSMENT DONE FOR NEXT COUNCILS IN SHINYANGA & MWANZA REGIONS – USING BRN INITIATIVE The assessment has been conducted by the Big Results Now (BRN) star rating team. Each facility had to undergo readiness assessment before being enrolled to the RBF system; The minimum readiness criterion is to have one star with adequate staffing (at least one skilled personnel at a dispensary level) but also the following elements are considered in the assessment tool: Communication means, Conducive infrastructures for provision of quality health care, Emergency transportation arrangement for referral, Power supply, Availability of running water; Waste management facilities. 14

THE RATING MECHANISM IS DEVISED BASED ON THE CURRENT SITUATION OF HEALTH FACILITIES IN GENERAL Major Features Characteristics of Facility at Each Rating Score on Assessment Tool No Star 0-19% 1 Star 20-39% 2 Star 40-59% 3 Star 60-79% 4 Star 80-89% 5 Star % Source(s): BRN Healthcare (2014) 15

RESULTS: KISHAPU COUNCIL 16 HEALTH FACILITY HF OWNERSHIP STARSTOTAL 0123 DISPENSARIESLGA PRIVATE FBO HEALTH CENTERS LGA HOSPITALSPRIVATE TOTAL

RESULTS: ALL COUNCILS IN SHINYANGA HEALTH FACILITY HF OWNERSHIP STARSTOTAL 0123 DISPENSARIESLGA PRIVATE FBO MILITARY POLICE PRISON HEALTH CENTERS LGA PRIVATE FBO HOSPITALSLGA PRIVATE FBO TOTAL

TIMELINE & SCALE UP PLAN 18

ISSUES AND CHALLENGES IDENTIFIED DURING IMPLEMENTATION  Inadequate infrastructures which made some facilities to score 0-star during readiness assessment,  Shortage of basic essential equipment and supplies needed to provide Reproductive and Child Health Services beyond health facility control,  Irregular Supportive Supervision by management teams,  Delays in paying 1 st Verification Payment,  Difficulties in direct incentive payment to the Health Facilities from the fund holder 19

LESSONS LEARNT  Essential equipment and supplies are not available at all times in the facilities,  RBF can only work if supportive supervision visits are regularly conducted at facilities,  Direct payment from the fund holder to the provider is very important to avoid delays and any other risks that may occur,  There is an opportunity for correcting the identified issues 20

WAY FORWARD  Ensure incentive funds planned for facility improvement is used to procure missing essential equipment and supplies,  Use lesson learnt from the pilot phase to ensure the scale up is done smoothly. 21

SUSTAINABILITY OF RBF AS ENVISIONED BY HEALTH CARE FINANCING STRATEGY SNHI Other vertical or parallel programs or funding Remainder of general revenue budget & HBF Portion of OC Budget AIDS Trust Fund Employer Contribution Employee Contribution GOT subsidy for poor and vulnerable Community Contribution (CHF) Reimbursement to Facilities Matching Payment to MBP Based on Core Output-Based Payment Systems, Performance (RBF) and Star Rating (BRN) 22

RBF IS EVIDENCE BASED & WE PAY WHAT WE SEE THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION