Supreme Court on 498 A Sushil Kumar Sharma Vs Union of India and Ors ( Writ Petition (civil) 141 of 2005 ) “The object of the provision is prevention of.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Civil & criminal law Civil Law.
Advertisements

November 19 th is International Mens Day. A good man, we are told, …puts women and children first …protects and provides …promotes womens empowerment.
Confidentiality and HIPAA
Domestic abuse is not gender specific.
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
MALAWI LAWS ON SEXUAL AND GBV & ROLES OF POLICE AND PROSECUTORS. Presented by EMMANUEL SOKO (ACP) MscLCM.
 Chapter 10 Faceoff (Young Offender or Adult)  Folder time  Folders being Checked Tomorrow.
Chapter 16 Lesson 1 Civil and Criminal Law.
The Great Debate / Take A Stand. ..
Chapter 14 The Trial.
The Investigation Phase Criminal Law and Procedure.
The Judicial Branch. Court Systems & Jurisdictions.
CRIMINAL LAW. Criminal lawmaking is the jurisdiction of the Federal government.
ELS BAIL. Bail Bail is the release from custody, pending a criminal trial, of an accused on the promise that money will be paid if he absconds. The decision.
Domestic Violence Division Order of Protection Pro Bono Representation Training 2013 Leslie Landis, J.D. Court Administrator Domestic Violence Division.
DOWRY PROHIBITION ACT 1. WHAT IS DOWRY Property or valuable security Given or agreed to be given Directly or indirectly By one party to the marriage to.
What are your rights? How many can you name?
THE LAW 8 Rights of a citizen accused of a crime: 1.Protection from ____________________(person can only be re-tried in case of a hung jury) 2.Right to.
Seminar on Misuse of 498a Nagpur Chapter.
Section 2.2.
Main title Subheading Human rights and healthcare Ellie Keen 6 th October 2011.
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
The Bill Of Rights The First Ten Amendments to the Constitution
Chapter 28.2 “The Judicial Branch of Texas”. The Judicial Branch is made up of courts and judges throughout the state.
Course: European Criminal Law SS 2009 Hubert Hinterhofer.
Section 2.2.
Courts at Work. Criminal cases An adult criminal case has many steps It usually is not completed in one day, especially felony cases The first step is.
Purpose and Scope of Juvenile Court Act
SS4H5 The student will analyze the challenges faced by the new nation.
The Judicial Branch of Georgia’s Government
Law Reform Commission Criminal Process Pre-Trial Procedures Pierre Rosario DOMINGUE Chief Executive Officer Wednesday, May 7,
JUDICIAL BRANCH. LEARNING OBJECTIVE I can describe the TYPES OF LAWS.
Chapter 4 Sentencing and punishment. In this chapter, you will look at the purposes and process of sentencing and the different factors affecting a sentencing.
Bill of Rights.
DV in Criminal Law in Hungary: a case in worst practice or just a long beginning of the road? Regional Conference on Domestic Violence Legal Reform February.
Happy Constitution Day!. The Basics The Constitution is the highest law in the United States. All other laws come from the Constitution. It says how the.
The Issues that Women Face in The Middle East By: Anna Arnold.
CHAPTER 13 Power and Violence in Families. Power Power is the ability to exercise one’s will. Personal power or autonomy – power exercised over oneself.
The Law Governing the Use of Force. The Use of Force The use of force on another is unlawful unless it is justified Justification requires a showing that.
Stalking Awareness And Prevention Francis A. Arenas, Esq.
What is the Law? Courts Service Pilot: Lesson 4. Learning Outcomes O To be able to work with your partner to formulate a definition of the law. O To understand.
Civil Liberties.  It is often said in the American justice system that it is better to allow ten guilty people to go free than to let one innocent person.
Which of the five types of crimes are shown in the pie chart? Bell Ringer.
Rights of the Accused Civil Liberties: Protecting Individual Rights Section 3 &4.
Violence against women in Syria
Marriage and Interdependent Adult Relationships in Canada Mel Lambert.
Article 1 Everyone under the age of 18 has all the rights in the Convention. Definition of the child.
Youth Criminal Justice Act. The Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) was passed by parliament in Applies to young people from the age of 12 to 17.
The Criminal Trial. Before the Trial Rights, Obligations and Procedure Chapter 8.
Adoption. jackman-on-adoption-in-australia-its-almost-like-they- try-to-put-you-off
AGENCY FOR STATISTICS OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA Geneva Switzerland.
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE Domestic violence is abuse that happens between members of the same family or persons involved in a close relationship: husband/wife;
I can understand that sources of law include The Constitution, The Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Treaties, statutes, and common law. I can understand.
Legal Studies * Mr. Marinello ARRESTS AND WARRANTS.
First 10 Amendments to the United States Constitution.
This guide simplifies the arrest-to-sentence process in New York County.
Canada’s Justice System Chapter 2 Review. No one, no matter how important or powerful, is above the law - not the government; not the Prime Minister;
Family Law Introduce the numerous ways in which laws and government affect them as individuals and as members of families In many ways, family life is.
WHAT IS THE PENALTY FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN NEW YORK CITY?
CRIMINAL PRE-TRIAL PROCEDURES. WHAT EXACTLY ARE CRIMINAL PRE-TRIAL PROCEDURES?  Processes and procedures that occur before a trial or hearing commences.
Article III: The Judicial Branch Chapters: 11,12
Breakdown of Relationships. Divorce o When marriage does not meet the expectations of 1 or both partners o Lack of marital satisfaction o Rates fluctuate.
POLICE REPORT.
Dr S. Muralidhar Judge, Delhi High Court 13th March, 2016
The Concept of Fundamental Justice
POLICE REPORT.
THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 1973
Lessons learned during the Country Analytical Report preparation
Procedures for Reporting Child Abuse
Section 2.2.
Presentation transcript:

Supreme Court on 498 A Sushil Kumar Sharma Vs Union of India and Ors ( Writ Petition (civil) 141 of 2005 ) “The object of the provision is prevention of the dowry meance. But as has been rightly contended by the petitioner many instances have come to light where the complaints are not bonafide and have filed with obligue motive. In such cases acquittal of the accused does not in all cases wipe out the ignomy suffered during and prior to trial. Sometimes adverse media coverage adds to the misery. The question, therefore, is what remedial measures can be taken to prevent abuse of the well-intentioned provision. Merely because the provision is constitutional and intra vires, does not give a licence to unscrupulous persons to wreck personal vendetta or unleash harassment. It may, therefore, become necessary for the legislature to find out ways how the makers of frivolous complaints or allegations can be appropriately dealt with. Till then the Courts have to take care of the situation within the existing frame work. As noted the object is to strike at the roots of dowry menace. But by misuse of the provision a new legal terrorism can be unleashed. The provision is intended to be used a shield and not assassins‘ weapon. If cry of "wolf" is made too often as a prank assistance and protection may not be available when the actual "wolf" appears.” Why hasn’t Government acted to prevent misuse even when Supreme Court asked them to ? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Supreme Court of India Term “Legal Terrorism” The Supreme Court with a Bench comprising Justices Arijit Pasayat and H K Sema has agreed with petitioner Sushil Kumar Sharma that Section 498A of Indian Penal Code, which seeks to protect women from being harassed for dowry, was being misused through frivolous cases filed by women to trouble their in-laws. By misuse of the provision a new “Legal Terrorism” can be unleashed, says Bench Merely because the provision is declared constitutional, it does not give license to unscrupulous persons to wreak personal vendetta. Justices Arijit Pasayat and H K Sema added a word of caution, saying, "Merely because the provision is constitutional, it does not give a license to unscrupulous persons to wreck personal vendetta or unleash harassment." The judges called upon the legislature to refine the Section and "find out ways how frivolous complaints or allegations can be appropriately dealt with". But till date our Government /legislature have not shown any concern to stop this “Legal Terrorism” is best Known to them. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Supreme Court of India Term “Legal Terrorism” "In such cases acquittal of the accused does not wipe out the ignominy suffered during and prior to trial. Sometimes adverse media coverage adds to the misery". Merely because the provision was declared constitutional and intra vires, it did not give license to unscrupulous persons to wreak personal vendetta or unleash harassment, the judges said. "The object is to strike at the root of dowry menace. But by misuse of the provision a new legal terrorism can be unleashed. The provision is intended to be used as a shield and not an assassin's weapon. If [the] cry of "wolf" is made too often as a prank, assistance and protection may not be available when the actual wolf appears", the Bench said. The investigating agencies could not follow a straitjacket formula in matters of dowry torture, deaths and cruelty. "The role of the investigating agencies and courts is that of a watchdog and not of a bloodhound. It should be their effort to see that an innocent person is not made to suffer on account of unfounded, baseless and malicious allegations," the Bench said. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Who Are We …Victims of Legal Terrorism in India We are working professionals( IIT/IIM/Engineer/Doctors/MBA/IT Engineers/Media Journalist/Judge/Police all except Politicians) and are were working for family harmony. We want Domestic Harmony Act, but Government refuse the same. We want gender Equal Law, men/women to be replace by the word Person and Wife/Husband to be replace by Spouse in all Indian IPC Law. Till Date no Politicians/Ministers had been arrested in 498A or DV act case, but common people arrested without any investigation and more than 98% face the money extortion the way a Terrorist do with Common people. When ever any Politician of Ministers accused of 498A or DV act, even women ministers also come out openly to give him Clean Chit. Why different law for Politicians/Ministers in India? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

United Nations Report on Elder Abuse In India Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

NRI Journalist Kulbhushan stated …. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life NRI Journalist Kulbhushan stated "Filing a non-bailable dowry case under IPC 498A is easier than ordering a meal. But while a restaurant can refuse service, the police normally arrest the groom and the in-laws. While the Indian media is flooded with reports of dowry-related bride torture, it hardly mentions the horrific cases of suffering husbands at the hands of unscrupulous wives."

Warning from the US State Dept stated …. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life CRIMINAL PENALTIES: While in a foreign country, a U.S. citizen is subject to that country's laws and regulations, which sometimes differ significantly from those in the United States and may not afford the protections available to the individual under U.S. law. Persons violating Indian laws, even unknowingly, may be expelled, arrested or imprisoned. Furthermore, since the police may arrest anyone who is accused of committing a crime (even if the allegation is frivolous in nature), the Indian criminal justice system is often used to escalate personal disagreements into criminal charges. This practice has been increasingly exploited by dissatisfied business partners, contractors, estranged spouses, or other persons with whom the U.S. citizen has a disagreement, occasionally resulting in the jailing of U.S. citizens pending resolution of their disputes.

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Kiran Bedi says: "Laws had been provided for the welfare of women. The police need not assist those who misuse or abuse the law meant for the protection of women."

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Men are being Harassed, says women panel : Times of India front Page NewsMen are being Harassed, says women panel : Times of India front Page News (Publication:Times Of India Delhi; Date:Sep 19, 2007) There are dozens of cases of husbands and in-laws getting thrown into the slammer on the basis of mere accusations of torture for dowry and a complaint under Section 498A of the IPC, according to Orissa’s State Commission for Women. ‘‘This is only the tip of the iceberg. The number of such atrocities against men by women is rising in Orissa. Since May 2007, the Commission has registered 38 such cases,’’ chairperson Namita Panda said.

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Justice J D Kapoor Says: ‘‘There is a growing tendency among women, which is further perpetuated by their parents and relatives, to rope in each and every relative, including minors and even school going children of distant relatives.’’

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Kolkatta High Court Justice S.P. Talukdar said the “dangerous” practice of misusing Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (cruelty on housewives by husbands and in-laws) should be immediately stopped.

Even Some Indian Views Are Same…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

498A Misuse

Total Statistics of 498A Cases These are statistics Published in CNN-IBN News and were obtained from the home ministry for “According to data provided by Ministry of Home Affairs, there were 58,319 registered cases and 134,757 people underwent arrest under 498A and Dowry Prohibition Act. That is on average 2.3 people were arrested in every complaint by Wife, let it be false or true. 339 children Arrested. 4,512 senior citizens arrested-( 1,434 are age old women.) 27, 145 Women Arrested. The number acquitted (24127) were more than four times the number convicted (5739). Out of 129,655 people, approximately 18 per cent (23,337) were not even charge sheeted, but arrested and hence suffered only because these acts are non- bailable”. Rest more than 90% cases, it is the wives family done the Legal extortion of money from Husbands family start from Lacks to Cores. A Criminal Law for earring the money or Giving the punishment to Criminal? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Violation of Supreme Court Judgment by Police This is what former Chief Justice Of India, M.N. Venkatachalliah says (JOGINDER KUMAR Vs. STATE OF U.P.25/04/1994) in this landmark judgment that defined the powers of the police to arrest a person. This judgment is especially applicable in the case of a cognizable offence such as 498A: “No arrest can be made because it is lawful for the police officer to do so. The existence of the power to arrest is one thing. The justification for the exercise of it is quite another. The police officer must be able to justify the arrest apart from his power to do so. Arrest and detention in police lock-up of a person cause incalculable harm to the reputation and self –esteem of a person. No arrest can be made in a routine manner on a mere allegation of commission of an offence made against a person. It would be prudent for a police officer in the interest of protection of the constitutional rights of a citizen and perhaps in his own interest that no arrest should be made without a reasonable satisfaction reached after some investigation as to the genuineness and bona fides of a complaint and a reasonable belief both as to the person’s complicity and even so as to the need to effect arrest. Denying a person of his liberty is a serious matter.” The Unanswered Question : Then why in all the 498A cases the accused had been arrested by Police even Child and Women forget about men? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Violation of High Court Judgment by Police Justice JD Kapoor, in this judgment (Delhi High Court CRLMM 3875/ Court on its own motion Versus Central Bureau of Investigation), says: “For instance it is the experience of this court that in offences under Sections 498A/406 IPC which are much abused provisions and exploited by the police and the victims to the level of absurdity and are of such nature which can be investigated without arrest and do not fall under the aforesaid category viz. being of highest magnitude and prescribing severest punishment or minimum punishment, every relative of husband, close or distant, old or minor is arrested by the police. By arresting such relatives whose arrest may not be necessary for completing the investigation as it can be completed by other witnesses, police assumes the role of breaker of homes and not the maker as once any relative of he husband is sent to jail, the marriage ends for all practical purposes and divorce and other miseries are bound to follow. Unless the allegations are of very serious nature and highest magnitude arrest should always be avoided.” Reward Given the Judge: So called Women activist Broken the Judges Chair and Chief Justice of India till date failed to Punish those Criminals and still they are moving Freely in our Society. When Chief Justice can’t even save guard the Judges Chair, how they will Protect the Common People’s Save guard? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Why Bail refused on failure to agree the Money demand ( 498A/406 Cases) The Supreme Court also said that (Moti Ram and Others v State of M.P. (AIR 1978 SC 1594)): “Fixing an excessively high amount of bond, keeping in consideration the facts and circumstances of the case and economic condition of the accused, violates the constitutional norms.” Still, at the time of Bail in 498A/406 cases, the wives family openly demand the Huge money from Husband's family in front of Judges in Lacks and on failure of the same bail application had been rejected. The Simple argument we witness,Pay the money to get the bail or go to Jail. !!! Is this not Legal Extortions of Money and Violation of Article 21? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Supreme Court Snap “Domestic Violence Act” This judgment of the Supreme Court (Batra Vs Batra. Mar 2007) the Domestic Violence Act : No doubt, the definition of 'shared household' in Section 2(s) of the Act is not very happily worded, and appears to be the result of clumsy drafting, but we have to give it an interpretation which is sensible and which does not lead to chaos in society. It is quite possible that the husband and wife may have lived together in dozens of places e.g. with the husband's father, husband's paternal grand parents, his maternal parents, uncles, aunts, brothers, sisters, nephews, nieces etc. If the interpretation canvassed by the learned Counsel for the respondent is accepted, all these houses of the husband's relatives will be shared households and the wife can well insist in living in the all these houses of her husband's relatives merely because she had stayed with her husband for some time in those houses in the past. Such a view would lead to chaos and would be absurd. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Supreme Court Snap “Domestic Violence Act” If our LAW makers do not have honesty, good intention and knowledge to make a Law, why they do not review the same by Retired Supreme Court Judges? Why there is no Judges kept in the LAW Review Committee? If we go through the definition of “Domestic Violence” as described in the Act: like Verbal Abuse, Economical Abuse, Mental harassment, sexual harassment etc.not only women, more than 98% Indian Husbands also face the same at least once in 3 years of a relationship, study by Save Indian Family and My nation. Then why the “Domestic Violence Act” is not Equal for both Men and Women, like all other developed Country? Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Women-protection laws or “Legal Terrorism”? There are no laws to protect men from domestic abuse and marital cruelty Women-protection laws unfairly assume: victims of marital cruelty are always 498A type wives Wives are always honest victims, never lie the accused Husband and his family are assumed guilty until proven innocent…. IPC 498A/DV act and other women-protection laws are being blatantly misused to extrote the Money from Husbands Family as a FREE ATM Machine in front of Court, Police and even in public Media. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

And The Male Suicide Rate is Raising…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Male suicide rate Rising since 1996 at rapid Speed.

And The Male Suicide Rate is Raising…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Male suicide rate Rising since 1996 at rapid Speed.

And The Male Suicide Rate is Raising…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Male suicide rate Rising since 1996 at rapid Speed.

And The Male Suicide Rate is Raising…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Male suicide rate Rising since 1996 at rapid Speed.

Men Are Dying Faster Than Women…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

And The Male Suicide Rate is Raising…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life Overall male-female ratio is 73:27. Male suicide rate rising since 1996.

Introduction to Modern Indian Women( 498A type) She wants all your property in her name. Her father and brothers won’t give it to her, so she will take it from you. Wants all your salary and income in her account. Her father and brothers never used to give her enough money for her expenses. Wants you to throw your parents out of your home immediately after marriage. You better do it or she has a law to support her in throwing you and your parents out or they will land up in Jail. Anything you say to her is a torture to her. She can slap you, beat you, Cheat you, kill you, kill your child and there is no law for your to safeguard yourself, forget about your child, from this domestic violence. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Why You Should Not Marry A 498A Indian Women The Indian Wives have a desire to own all your assets/property and monies – which might be owned or shared by your other family members. To get the above desire fulfilled she keeps nagging, harassing and taunting you. Kills the family harmony. Even the draconian laws support her in her motive. Even if you want to get out of a marriage, she won’t let you, You will Be treated as free ATM Machine. Indian laws do not allow a men to get divorce. It depends on the mercy of wife. All above lead to a stressful life for husbands and they are not able to live peacefully – leading to increased cases of suicides( In 2005 more than married men end their life). Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Why You Should Not Marry A 498A Indian Women Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Married Men Are Dying Even Faster…. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Why You Should Marry A Foreigner You travel a lot and knows who can be best life partner for you after considering Indian women psyche and greed.They how to enjoy the lavish life style without even earning a Single penny by their hard work. Only well off people are implicated by greedy wives by misusing the Indian law, no rickshaw puller has ever been implicated – and you are the one who is well off and can give her a huge settlement amount. You have a wonderful life and can enjoy your life better when you do not fear dominating Indian wife – foreigners are generally more understanding and adjusting. They also have a respect for gender equality – which Indian women and laws don’t have. All channels show everyday some software engineer, engineer, NRI or corporate manager being implicated by wife and harassed by media. And….you are one of them. A foreigner wife will not do it to you. Indian laws do not allow a men to get divorce. It depends on the mercy of wife. They two option end the life in the form of suicide or became the victim of Legal Terrorism. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Who Are We …Victims of Legal Terrorism in India Over a period of time – after a lot of research and meeting up with all sections of society and authority, in spite of Supreme Court’s Caution to Stop the legal Terrorism, our Government are Sleeping and we are forced to take a decision to save our own Life and our future Child’s life : –Encourage Indian professionals to marry a foreigner. –Encourage live in relationships, marriage means you are a Free ATM machine. –Create awareness about all marital laws in India and its misuse, Marriage became a crime for not only to Indian men, it is crime for his mother/sisters/sister's child also. –Start funding and legal advise to fight against Indian 498A type wives to stop Legal Terrorism. –File appropriate criminal cases against Indian 498A type wives families. –Use more and more IPC sections to counter draconian Indian laws made for 498A type wives and start collecting evidence, stink operation. –Create awareness for prospective groom and advise them not to marry any Indian girl/women 498A type. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Government’s immediate Action Required to Stop this “Legal Terrorism” of India. Make Section IPC498A as Bailable Offence. Make Section 498A of IPC non-cognizable to prevent arrest of innocent citizens based on mere complaints unsubstantiated by evidence or investigation. Make IPC498A and Domestic Violence Law gender neutral and provide equal protection for Men and women form Domestic Violence. Impose heavy penalties by default on people for misusing IPC498A and Domestic Violence Law as weapons for settling personal scores in marital disputes. Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Government’s immediate Action Required to Stop this “Legal Terrorism” of India. Indian Men need protection too… …from domestic abuse …from misuse of women-protection laws and “legal terrorism” !!! Stop Legal Terrorism and Save your Life

Support Network – Internet &Other Groups Supported By : By : SIFF, Asha Kiran, My Nation, BPSSSIFF, Asha Kiran, My Nation, BPSS