Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /241 PRELIMINARY FINDINGS FROM INSTABILITY MEASUREMENTS DURING THE 75ns AND 50ns.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Electron-cloud instability in the CLIC damping ring for positrons H. Bartosik, G. Iadarola, Y. Papaphilippou, G. Rumolo TWIICE workshop, TWIICE.
Advertisements

Elias Métral, COULOMB’05, Senigallia (AN), Italy, September 12-16, /29 OBSERVATION OF OCTUPOLE DRIVEN RESONANCE PHENOMENA WITH SPACE CHARGE AT THE.
MD#2 News & Plan Tue – Wed (19. – 20.6.) DayTimeMDEiCMP Tue06: GeV  4 TeV: Ramp for chromaticity - missed A 08:00Ramp down 10: GeV: Large.
Elias Métral, 1st ICE meeting, 14/07/2010 /191 STATUS OF THE LHC INSTABILITIES E. Métral, N. Mounet and B. Salvant E. Métral, N. Mounet and B. Salvant.
Giovanni Rumolo, G. Iadarola and O. Dominguez in LHC Beam Operation workshop - Evian 2011, 13 December 2011 For all LHC data shown (or referred to) in.
25-26 June, 2009 CesrTA Workshop CTA09 Electron Cloud Single-Bunch Instability Modeling using CMAD M. Pivi CesrTA CTA09 Workshop June 2009.
AB-ABP/LHC Injector Synchrotrons Section CERN, Giovanni Rumolo 1 Final results of the E-Cloud Instability MDs at the SPS (26 and 55 GeV/c) G.
LHC Scrubbing Runs Overview H. Bartosik, G. Iadarola, K. Li, L. Mether, A. Romano, G. Rumolo, M. Schenk, G. Arduini ABP information meeting 03/09/2015.
H. Bartosik, K. Cornelis, A. Guerrero, B. Mikulek, G. Rumolo, Y. Papaphilippou, B. Salvant, E. Shaposhnikova June 16 th, 2011.
PS (electron cloud?!) instability at flat top Mauro Pivi Gianni Iadarola, Giovanni Rumolo, Simone Gilardoni, Hannes Bartosik, Sandra Aumon 27/06/2012 ICE.
G. Rumolo, G. Iadarola, H. Bartosik, G. Arduini for CMAC#6, 16 August 2012 Many thanks to: V. Baglin, G. Bregliozzi, S. Claudet, O. Dominguez, J. Esteban-
Elias Métral, APC meeting, 02/02/2006 1/35 E. Métral, G. Arduini and G. Rumolo u Observations of fast instabilities in the SPS (1988 and 2002/3) and PS.
Elias Metral, CERN-PS seminar, 12/04/20001 u Introduction, observations and motivation u Theory u Experiments u Conclusion STABILISING INTENSE BEAMS BY.
LSWG day: Impedance and beam induced heating Nicolas Mounet *, Daria Atapovych, Nicolò Biancacci, Elias Métral, Tatiana Pieloni, Stefano Redaelli, Benoit.
Update of the SPS transverse impedance model Benoit for the impedance team.
Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 08/06/2010 /191 SINGLE-BUNCH INSTABILITY STUDIES IN THE LHC AT 3.5 TeV/c Elias Métral, N. Mounet.
Wolfgang Hofle BE/RFSPS Studies WG - November 17, 20091/23 reported by Wolfgang Hofle CERN BE/RF/FB Transverse feedback to cure electron-cloud induced.
1 Transverse Mode Coupling Instability in the CERN SPS: Comparing HEADTAIL Simulations with Beam Measurements Benoit Salvant (EPFL / CERN Switzerland)
Status from the collimator impedance MD in the LHC Collimation team:R. Assmann, R. Bruce, A. Rossi. Operation team:G.H. Hemelsoet, W. Venturini, V. Kain,
Lessons from SPS studies in 2010 E. Shaposhnikova Chamonix’11 session 09: LHC injectors upgrade.
E-cloud studies at LNF T. Demma INFN-LNF. Plan of talk Introduction New feedback system to suppress horizontal coupled-bunch instability. Preliminary.
Some ideas for/from the SPS LIU-SPS team. Scrubbing (only) for ecloud in SPS? aC coating remains baseline..... –but scrubbing has many potential advantages.
CERN, LIU-SPS ZS Review, 20/02/ Brief review on electron cloud simulations for the SPS electrostatic septum (ZS) G. Rumolo and G. Iadarola in LIU-SPS.
Elias Métral, ICFA-HB2004, Bensheim, Germany, 18-22/10/ E. Métral TRANSVERSE MODE-COUPLING INSTABILITY IN THE CERN SUPER PROTON SYNCHROTRON G. Arduini,
Instability rise-time far above the TMCI threshold: Comparison between simple theory, MOSES and HEADTAIL E. Benedetto, E. Metral Acknowledgements: G. Rumolo,
Elias Métral, SPSU Study Group and Task Force on SPS Upgrade meeting, 25/03/2010 /311 TMCI Intensity Threshold for LHC Bunch(es) in the SPS u Executive.
CERN F. Ruggiero Univ. “La Sapienza”, Rome, 20–24 March 2006 Measurements, ideas, curiosities beam diagnostics and fundamental limitations to the performance.
News on TMCI in the SPS: Injecting high intensity bunches Benoit for the MD team: T. Bohl, K. Cornelis, H. Damerau, W. Hofle, E. Metral, G. Rumolo, B.
Ion effects in low emittance rings Giovanni Rumolo Thanks to R. Nagaoka, A. Oeftiger In CLIC Workshop 3-8 February, 2014, CERN.
Proposal to change bunch length during physics fills to assess beam induced heating after LS1 M. Barnes, P. Baudrenghien, A. Burov, S. Claudet, S. Jakobsen,
Elias Métral, LHC collimation working group meeting, 17/07/061/26 E. Métral for the RLC team LATEST ESTIMATES OF COLLIMATOR IMPEDANCE EFFECTS u Reminder:
Three examples of application of Sussix 1)Data from simulations  sensitivity 2)Data from measurements  frequency resolution.
Progress on e-cloud effects (PS and SPS) G. Iadarola, H.Bartosik, G. Rumolo, M. Taborelli, C. Yin Vallgren Many thanks to: G. Arduini, T. Argyropoulos,
Transverse Stability Simulations with Linear Coupling in PyHEADTAIL X. Buffat, L. R. Carver, S. Fartoukh, K. Li, E. Métral, T. Persson, B. Salvant, M.
Elias Métral, LIS meeting, 29/01/2008 1/26 GAMMA TRANSITION JUMP FOR PS2 W. Bartmann, M. Benedikt, E. Métral and D. Möhl u Introduction with the case of.
Summary of ions measurements in 2015 and priorities for 2016 studies E. Shaposhnikova 3/02/2016 Based on input from H. Bartosik, T. Bohl, B. Goddard, V.
Benchmarking Headtail with e-cloud observations with LHC 25ns beam H. Bartosik, W. Höfle, G. Iadarola, Y. Papaphilippou, G. Rumolo.
AB-ABP/LHC Injector Synchrotrons Section CERN, Giovanni Rumolo 1 Preliminary results of the E-Cloud Instability MDs at the SPS G. Rumolo, in.
Elias Métral, CERN-GSI bi-lateral working meeting on Collective Effects – Coordination of Theory and Experiments, GSI, 30-31/03/06 1/15 TRANSVERSE LANDAU.
A preliminary overview on the 2014 Scrubbing Run II The scrubbing team, i.e. H. Bartosik, G. Iadarola, K. Li, L. Mether, A. Romano, G. Rumolo, B. Salvant,
LIU Day 2014 – M.Bodendorfer - LEIR model. LEIR model A plan for understanding/upgrading the LEIR performance limitations M.Bodendorfer BE/ABP & LEIR.
Beam Instability in High Energy Hadron Accelerators and its Challenge for SPPC Liu Yu Dong.
Transverse Damping Requirements
Cryo Problem MD Planning Tue (1.11.) C B Day Time MD MP Tue 01:00
LEIR IMPEDANCE AND INSTABILITY MEASUREMENTS
The HEADTAIL Development Working Group (HDWG)
Longitudinal beam parameters and stability
Proposals for 2015 impedance-related MD requests for PSB and SPS
Sergey Antipov, Nicolo Biancacci, and david amorim
Saturday 21st April 00:33 Interlock during ramp on BLM HV
MD2490 Measurement of the TMCI threshold at flat-top
Benchmarking the SPS transverse impedance model: headtail growth rates
MD2490: Measurement of the TMCI Threshold at Flat-Top
LHC at 7 TeV/c: comparison phase 1 / IR3MBC
Wednesday Morning 8: :30 end of fill study - octupole polarity inversion (Elias, Tatiana, Alexey, Georges, …): Goal: study the effect of the.
G. Arduini, R. Calaga, E. Metral, G. Papotti, G. Rumolo, B. Salvant, R
E. Métral, G. Rumolo, R. Tomás (CERN Switzerland), B
Status from the collimator impedance MD in the LHC
Beam-Beam Interaction in Linac-Ring Colliders
Explanation of the comment I made at the 06/07/06 APC
W. Bartmann, M. Benedikt, E. Métral, D. Möhl, G. Rumolo and B. Salvant
LHC impedance: Comparison between phase 1 and IR3MBC – follow-up
News on TMCI in the SPS: Injecting high intensity bunches
STABILISING INTENSE BEAMS
Observation of Transverse Mode Coupling Instability at the PS and SPS
SPS collective effects Hannes, Gianni, Giovanni, Benoit, Yannis
Collective effects in the SPS and LHC (longitudinal plane)
CERN-SPS horizontal instability
LHC collimation review follow-up Impedance with IR3MBC option & comparison with phase 1 tight settings N. Mounet, B. Salvant and E. Métral Acknowledgements:
Tuesday 6th April 8:00 Injection studies 16:00 RF studies
Presentation transcript:

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /241 PRELIMINARY FINDINGS FROM INSTABILITY MEASUREMENTS DURING THE 75ns AND 50ns BUNCH SPACING OPERATION Elias Métral (for the collective effects team with ABP, OP, BI, RF etc.). Elias Métral (for the collective effects team with ABP, OP, BI, RF etc.). Many thanks to Benoit, Nicolas, Riccardo and Tatiana for the data analysis u Introduction u Reminder on some predictions as concerns ecloud-induced coherent instabilities u 1 st measurements in the LHC with 50 ns => 02/11/10 and 20/11/10 u 1 st measurements in the LHC with 75 ns => 18/11/10 u Conclusions

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /242 INTRODUCTION u Reminder with a single-bunch: An instability (from the machine impedance) is predicted and observed with octupoles OFF above 1-2 TeV/c (depending on beam parameters) => Famous “Christmas tree”, reproduced with HEADTAIL (Benoit Salvant): head-tail instability m = -1 + subsequent loss (revealing all the other modes). No problem during the last months when the octupoles were ON (K3 = -6 at top) u With many bunches (not discussing beam-beam):  Transverse coupled-bunch instability expected. Prediction of a rise-time of ~ 50 ms for the 25 ns operation (0 chromaticity, equidistant bunches etc.) and should be damped by the feedback. Chromaticity can help  With bunch trains and chromaticities, it is being looked at (N. Mounet, extension of HEADTAIL code)  Ecloud recently observed => It represents a “generalized impedance” and the beam can also become “coherently” unstable

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /243 PREDICTIONS FOR ECLOUD-INDUCED COHERENT INSTABILITIES (1/5) u See for instance G. Arduini et al., Present understanding of electron cloud effects in the Large Hadron Collider, PAC2003:  Observation in the SPS with LHC beams (train of 72 b, 25 ns): Horizontal coupled-bunch instability  Wave-length of ~ a 72 b train  Rise-time ~ 1 ms (50 turns), ~ independent of Nb  Transverse damper can damp it Vertical single-bunch instability => TMCI-like  Rise-time ~ 2 ms (100 turns) for Nb = 1.15E11 p/b and heavily depends on Nb  High chromaticity needed (up to 20 units in Qy’ quoted. Since several years xiy ~ 0.4, i.e. Qy’ ~ 10 units) => Explained by the 2 vertical stripes in dipoles (depending on Nb)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /244 PREDICTIONS FOR ECLOUD-INDUCED COHERENT INSTABILITIES (2/5) From Elena Benedetto’s PHD thesis

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /245 PREDICTIONS FOR ECLOUD-INDUCED COHERENT INSTABILITIES (3/5)  Extrapolation to the LHC using scaling laws: Horizontal CBI rise-time  In the SPS  In the LHC => This number is comparable to the LHC feedback damping time Assuming the same e- density

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /246 PREDICTIONS FOR ECLOUD-INDUCED COHERENT INSTABILITIES (4/5) Vertical SBI intensity threshold or as in saturation Chamber cross section Above the threshold, instability rise-time of the order of (or smaller) than T s are foreseen for low chromaticity (TMCI- like)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /247 PREDICTIONS FOR ECLOUD-INDUCED COHERENT INSTABILITIES (5/5)  In the SPS  In the LHC => 1E11 p/b is quoted in the paper… To be checked ~ 3E11 p/b from HEADTAIL simulations (cf. FZ’s talk)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 02/11/2010 (1/4) u Beams dumped at ~ 00:26:12: B1 was already circulating with bunches (~ 1E11 p/b) and we injected the (12+) 36 bunches of B2 => Coherent instability in H of B2 (see on the BBQ). Then it was re- observed in V essentially… Rise-time of ~ 1 s

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 02/11/2010 (2/4) u B1, (starting at slot 1501), ~ 1E11 p/b u Qprime ~ 10 (H&V, both planes) u Instability in V seen on plates of the Transverse feedback Head of batch Middle Tail “Optical fit” => ~ 4000 turns ~ 0.4 s

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 02/11/2010 (3/4) 24b Batch spacing: 3 micros

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 02/11/2010 (4/4) u The transverse instability seems to move from the tail to the head of the batch, as mentioned in G. Arduini et al., The Electron Cloud Instability of the LHC Beam in the CERN SPS, PAC2003 u Conclusions:  Could really come from the ecloud  The H instability initially seen should be coupled-bunch…  The V one could be the “TMCI-like” instability. Rise-time ~ 0.4 s with Qprime ~ 10. Could be stabilized with Qprime ~ 18 (beneficial effect seen on the transverse emittances), as predicted in Elena Benedetto’s PHD thesis (see FZ’s talk)  Difficult to disentangle from coupled-bunch instability induced by the machine impedance (more precise estimates needed from the simulations point of view. Ongoing)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /2412 u B2, 9 batches of 12 bunches (50 ns), see pattern on next slides u 3.5 TeV/c, Qprime ~ 4 u Transverse feedback OFF => Beam still stable u Reducing the octupoles => At some point the beam is unstable in H 50 ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (1/7)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (2/7)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (3/7)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (4/7)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (5/7) Rise-time of ~ 30 s?

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (6/7)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 3.5 TeV/c on 20/11/2010 (7/7) u Conclusion => Certainly coming for the machine impedance (as already observed in the past. Analysis still ongoing for the threshold stabilization from the octupoles)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 18/11/2010 (1/5) u Before increase in chromaticity (Qprime ~ 10 in H&V) 11 batches, 2 * 24 b spaced by 225 ns (batch spacing 1.85 micros)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 18/11/2010 (2/5) Low-order coupled-bunch modes observed

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /2421 Subtracting the constant part (analysis ongoing) 75 ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 18/11/2010 (3/5)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 18/11/2010 (4/5) u Conclusions:  Significant motion on B1 only (both H and V), but nothing on B2  Started to be observed after ~ 3-4 batches  No growing coherent oscillations (but losses observed)  Transverse feedback was ON, no octupoles  Motion seems to be coupled between bunches, low-order mode  Intra-bunch motion also observed (|m| = 1?)  Increase of chromaticity at ~ 15:30 (from ~ 10 to ~ 20 units) seems to have instantly killed this motion and the losses disappeared Origin of this observation not yet known (1 possibility discussed on next slide)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 / ns beam at 450 GeV/c on 18/11/2010 (5/5) The transverse CBI from machine impedance could explain all the features qualitatively (~ same in H and V) for B1 => Analysis ongoing (picture shown here for nominal 25 ns bunch) B2 could be in fact stabilized by the TF if the chromaticities were small (however, they were the same as B1…)

Elias Métral, LHC Beam Commissioning Working Group meeting, 30/11/2010 /2424 CONCLUSIONS u Difficult to conclude at this stage on the origin of all the observed instabilities u More simulations needed to make more precise estimates in the conditions of the experiment u Then, redo some controlled MDs u In the case of transverse coupled-bunch instabilities from (impedance and/or ecloud), they should be damped by the TF, and it is better to have the smallest chromaticity u One should not have TMCI from the machine impedance, therefore there is no reason to increase the chromaticity for that u The only reason to increase the chromaticity could come from the ecloud-induced vertical single-bunch “TMCI-like” instability, which was most probably observed during the 1 st MD with 50 ns beam on 02/11/10 …