DENR Rulemaking: Impact Analysis (formerly Fiscal Notes) The Keys  Statutory requirements  OSBM State Budget Manual  DENR guidance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AUDITING Systematic process of objectively obtaining and evaluating evidence Regarding assertions about economic actions and events; To ascertain the degree.
Advertisements

Metro Muncipal Agreement Program
Railway Grade Separations Issues. Railway Grade Separations 1.Introduction Qualifications/experience to undertake bridge planning for railway grade separations:
Introduction to EIS/EA Managing the Environmental & Project Development Process Presented by the Ohio Dept. of Transportation.
Summary of NEPA and SEPA Coastal Engineering and Land Use Issues in North Carolina Greenville, NC January 13, 2009 Sean M. Sullivan.
Agency Drafts Statement of Scope Governor Approves (2) No Agency Drafts: Special Report for rules impacting housing Fiscal Estimate.
From Cutting Red Tape to Maximizing Net Benefits Alexander T. Hunt U.S. Office of Management and Budget Challenges on Cutting Red Tape Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
TITLE OF PROJECT PROPOSAL NUMBER Principal Investigator PI’s Organization ESTCP Selection Meeting DATE.
1 Commonwealth of Virginia 2012 Strategic Planning Workshop The Executive Progress Report and National Rankings September 17 and 27, 2012 Office of the.
US Army Corps of Engineers Northwestern Division Northwestern Division 1 System Flood Control Review: Regional Agency Review Briefing Lonnie Mettler Northwestern.
Bureau of Land Management Regulations Washington State Association of Counties Cooperating Agency & Coordination Training November 22, 2013 – Vancouver,
Step 2 – Accepting the Grant Award EPA GRANTS 101 YOU DID IT! CONGRATULATIONS EPA has selected you to receive a Grant Award! Receiving the Award Agreement.
1 Use and content of the RFP  Request for Proposals (RFP) is similar to bidding documents and include all information of the assignment, selection of.
Legislative Rule-Making Process. Three Different Processes Higher Education 29A-3A-1 et seq State Board of Education 29A-3B-1 et seq All other state agencies.
1 SCORT 2010 September 21, 2010 David Valenstein Federal Railroad Administration State Rail Planning.
Grant Writing 101 – Part 2 Information and Tips for Preparing and Submitting a Grant Application Nancy Alexander, MBA Office of Sponsored Programs.
Rest of Course Proposals & Research Design Measurement Sampling Survey methods Basic Statistics for Survey Analysis Experiments Other Approaches- Observation,
Chapter 3: The Project Management Process Groups
Report Writing Three phases of report writing Exploratory phase (MAPS)
REPORT WRITING AND COST ESTIMATING CE 3372 Lecture 09.
SCOPING MEETING FOR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT REQUIRED BY PUBLIC RESOURCES CODE SECTION 3161 (b)(3) AND (4) (SENATE BILL 4) (PAVLEY) C ALIFORNIA D EPARTMENT.
WETLANDS and LOCAL PROGRAMS Environmental Services Oregon Department of Transportation.
What If I Must Go Beyond a Preliminary Assessment? (the example of a USAID EA under Reg. 216) [DATE][SPEAKERS NAMES]
Budget Integration to Governmental Accounting Reports.
Planning Grant Workshops August 30, 31 September 1, 2 Department of Water Resources.
Agency Drafts Statement of Scope Governor Approves Statement of Scope (2) No Agency Drafts: Special Report for rules impacting housing
CHAPTER 3 SCOPING AND AGENCY COORDINATION. Scoping - the procedure for determining the appropriate level of study of a proposed project/activity - process.
Notes from Instructor Regarding Term Papers. Howard Godfrey UNC Charlotte Fall, 2007.
Paragraph one - information about publisher, title of survey and main conclusions.(who, what, when, how, so what…) Remaining Paragraphs - state the figures.
Stakeholder consultations Kyiv May 13, Why stakeholder consultations? To help improve project design and implementation To inform people about changes.
Summary of Rulemaking in California for the Forensic Alcohol Laboratories Regulation Review Committee Cathy L. Ruebusch, RN, MSN Office of Regulations.
Implementing the Regulatory Flexibility Act. 2 Background The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601–612) requires Federal agencies to— –Consider the.
1 Business Communication Process and Product Brief Canadian Edition, Mary Ellen Guffey Kathleen Rhodes Patricia Rogin (c) 2003 Nelson, a division of Thomson.
Writing the IEE (EPTM Chapter 4). EA Training Course Tellus Institute 2 Writing the IEE IEE Review  Used when at least one screening outcome is “IEE.
Draft Transition Plan for the Transfer of the Drug Medi-Cal Treatment Program Fourth Series: Stakeholder Meetings Department of Health Care Services Department.
Reports & Proposals. Reports can either be Informational or Analytical Informational Reports Writers collect and organize data to provide readers information.
1 Permit Exemptions Rule Revisions North Carolina Division of Air Quality Permit Exemptions Rule Revisions North Carolina Division of Air Quality Air Quality.
2008 Community Development Budget Overview. 2 Introduction Changes to division structure Challenges and opportunities 2008 proposed budget.
Overview of Grant Agreements - Agreement Process - Roadmap to the Agreement Document - Agreement Requirements/ Compliance Issues - Timelines for Reporting.
Presentation to Board June 17, 2008 Presented by: J. A. Sabo, Associate Director – Leading Services & Treasurer of the Board BUDGET York Catholic.
Written Presentations of Technical Subject Writing Guide vs. Term paper Writing style: specifics Editing Refereeing.
CE 3372 WATER SYSTEMS DESIGN Lecture 09: Report writing and cost estimating.
1 Waste Discharge Authorization Application - British Columbia WG6 Application Process WG Document Review presented by Helga Harlander October x, 2008.
1 Responding to Comments Janet Cox TMDL/Planning Communications Region 2.
TABLE OF CONTENTS 2014 BasmahAlQadheeb. What is a report? A report is a clearly structured document that presents information as clearly as possible.
. Thematic Working Group 4 Possible Elements – Chapter VI: Constraints, gaps and related financial, technical and capacity needs CGE Workshop to exchange.
Training Module: APD Template County APD Process Training November 16, 2007 California Health and Human Services Agency - Office of Systems Integration.
Training: Fiscal and Regulatory Impact Analysis Office of State Budget and Management December Office of State Budget and Management Balancing Needs.
Managing the Environmental & Project Development Process Presented by the Ohio Department of Transportation NEPA&CEQ.
P.R.I.M.E. Finance Panel of Recognized International Market Experts in Finance Expert Input in US Regulatory Rulemaking Presentation by Dr. Sharon Brown-Hruska.
1 1 CEQA Scoping Naomi Feger Planning TMDL Section Leader Region 2.
Rest of Course Proposals & Research Design Measurement Sampling
PowerPoint Presentation on
ISO Session 3 Environmental Management and Ethics in Management.
EIAScreening6(Gajaseni, 2007)1 II. Scoping. EIAScreening6(Gajaseni, 2007)2 Scoping Definition: is a process of interaction between the interested public,
The American Experience in Regulatory Review and Reform Dominic J. Mancini, PhD. Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs U.S. Office of Management.
Principal Investigator ESTCP Selection Meeting
Report Writing Three phases of report writing Exploratory phase (MAPS)
Principal Investigator ESTCP Selection Meeting
Division of Waste Management
PAD 505 Competitive Success-- snaptutorial.com
PAD 505Competitive Success/tutorialrank.com
PAD 505 Education for Service-- snaptutorial.com
PAD 505 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com
PAD 505 knowledge is divine-- snaptutorial.com. PAD 505 Assignment 1 The Operating Budget For more classes visit Assignment 1 The.
Michigan Dept. of Environmental Quality Water Resources Division
Final Year PROJECT REPORT FORMAT
TECHNICAL REPORT.
Principal Investigator ESTCP Selection Meeting
Principal Investigator ESTCP Selection Meeting
Presentation transcript:

DENR Rulemaking: Impact Analysis (formerly Fiscal Notes) The Keys  Statutory requirements  OSBM State Budget Manual  DENR guidance

Objective of Impact Analysis The objective of an impact analysis is to estimate change due to the proposed rules Content:  Identify affected parties  Estimate types and amounts of expenditures  Describe purpose and benefits  Explain estimation procedures and sources of data

An Impact Analysis is NOT a Benefit/Cost Study Impact analysis as practiced by NC standards  is usually limited to five years  focuses on increases or decreases in costs or revenues  affected parties summarize to local governments, state agencies, federal agencies, and the private sector  benefit estimation is recommended but not required

 The current condition is the Baseline  The proposed rules describe the future state  The analysis is prepared to estimate the difference or the increment  *Impact analysis explanations should be simple yet complete enough so a lay person can follow your methods, logic, assumptions, and data*

Data Tips  Surveys to collect data are not required  Consult field staff or regulated parties for cost estimates  Examine division data bases to characterize affected parties  Borrow federally developed data, making it NC specific  Best Professional Judgement is acceptable  *Admit inability to estimate an impact rather than ignore it*  Prepare a summary table that transfers directly to the DENR Rulemaking Impact Analysis Form

Organizing the Analysis  Can be organized around affected parties or by rule  My preference: use the paragraph format with headings –Basic Information –Introduction –Purpose of Rule –Affected Parties –Estimate Costs –Describe Benefits –Summary Table –Substantial Impact Declaration

Points of Emphasis  DOT, DOT, DOT! For Environmental Permitting Rules: –Recognize DOT as a separate affected party –Insert the heading “DOT Impacts” in the cost estimation section –Maintain DOT identity in the summary table  Fee Increases and Gov Ops: –90 day option: safety valve for EVERY fee –Prepare and submit fee information form via BPA at the time of filing

What’s New?  OSBM Guidelines effective July 1, 2007  Requires added analysis for rule sets judged to be “significant”  Small business impacts  Suggests analysis of alternatives  Emphasizes quantifying benefits when feasible  Less scrutiny of small, routine, not significant filings  Section 7.0, page 174 of the State Budget Manual

Two Final Points Concerning Fiscal Notes  Submissions must be in electronic format; impact analysis, DENR Impact Analysis Form, and any attachments  Start the fiscal note as soon as you have the rules drafted. Call me to set up a consultation/training meeting. –Doug Lewis