Small Firms in the Credit Crisis: Evidence from the UK Survey of SME Finances* Presentation to CBI SME Council 7 th July 2009 Dr. Stuart Fraser Centre.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Innovation, Disruptive Technologies, and SMEs: Constraints and Policy Alan Hughes Centre for Business Research University of Cambridge Presentation at.

Advertisements

The Financing of SME:The model of Confidi for the Districts. Dott. Luciano Consolati coordinatore Fedartfidi Progetto GIFIP Novi Sad 29/09/2008.

Banking, money supply and the instruments of monetary policy Lecture 22 – academic year 2014/15 Introduction to Economics Fabio Landini.

Small Business Survey 2012 Focus on New Businesses May 2013.

Leasing to European SMEs ALB | November 2012 Tanguy van de Werve Leaseurope Director General.

MODULE 1 AS Marketing and Accounting and Finance COMPANY ACCOUNTS Sources of Finance.

Private or Public? Financing Japan’s SMEs Ford Foundation Conference on Finance, Business Models, and Sustainable Prosperity Kay Shimizu Columbia University.

1 PUBLIC BANKING IN SPAIN: GONE WITH THE WIND José Viñals Banco de España RES Panel IDB Annual Meeting in Lima, Peru March 28, 2004.

BRC Quarterly Credit Conditions Monitor Q July - September 2009.

Roundtable: SME Growth Opportunities & How Policies and Banks Miss Them Belgrade, , National Bank of Serbia.

Sources of Business Finance

BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL LITERACY FOR YOUNG ENTREPRENEURS: EVIDENCE FROM BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA Miriam Bruhn and Bilal Zia (World Bank, DECFP)

THE VALUE CHAIN FRAMEWORK, RURAL FINANCE, AND LESSONS FOR TA PROVIDERS AND DONORS Bob Fries – ACDI/VOCA 3/15/07.

BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com Clive Lewis, Head of Enterprise SME Access to Finance Introduction.

FOSTERING SMEs AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP FINANCING AFTER THE CRISIS FOSTERING SMEs AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP FINANCING AFTER THE CRISIS Confindustria - OECD – MiSE.

CHAPTER FOUR – SOURCES OF FINANCE. SOURCES OF FINANCE  Internal Sources  Refers to funds that are generated from within the firm itself – from owner’s.

Tara Humston Assistant Vice President August 19, 2011 Small Business Lending and Regulatory Perspectives.

Credit Guarantees and Loan Contracts Cowling: The Role of Loan Guarantee Schemes in Alleviating Credit Rationing in the UK Columba, Gambacorta and Mistrulli:

© Copyright YFM Group Limited 2006 Learning from Experience – Venture Capital Fund Models for Phil Cammerman YFM Group Development Director.

Business in Contemporary Society Factors Affecting the Operation of Business.

Eng. Osama Al-Mobarak Director of Kafalah Financing Guarantee Program, SIDF (K.S.A)

BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com Clive Lewis, Head of Enterprise THE ICAEW SME Funding Adviser scheme.

Review of the previous lecture Shortcomings of GDP Factor prices are determined by supply and demand in factor markets. As a factor input is increased,

1 Garantiqa Hitelgarancia Zrt. dr. Márton Vadász director „Guarantee Systems in European Countries- Searching for the Best Model” Warsaw, February 9, 2011.

Macroeconomics Lecture 5.

Dr. Ninko Kostovski UACS Importance of Availability of Sources of Finance for Small and Medium Enterprises Ninko Kostovski,PhD University American College.

Business Community and Guarantee Funds How guarantee funds are used to enhance entrepreneurship: An Italian Case Study.

Financing Franchising Business DR. HATEM ZAKI Board Member – EFDA Board Member – EFDA November 6-7, 2013 Abu Dhabi, U.A.E.

Chapter 11 FINANCING A BUSINESS.

Slide Eastern Finance Association Annual Meeting 2009Andreas Dietrich SME Credit Availability Around the World: Evidence from the World Bank’s Enterprise.

Guarantee Schemes response to the financial crisis APEC Symposium on SME strategies to manage the impact of the Global Financial Crisis – Session II: Managing.

The Incidence of Taxation. The incidence of taxation Indirect taxes.

WORK MODEL IN STATE GUARANTEED FUNDS SME’ S ISRAEL MICHAEL TAVOR MARCH 2014 Tavor Economic Consultants Ltd. Zarchin 10, Ra'anana Israel

Randomized Controlled Trials in Rural Finance: An Example from India Michael Faye and Sendhil Mullainathan Harvard University March 2007

Data on Access to and Use of Financial Services: Regulator and Bank Surveys Asli Demirguc-Kunt DECRG WB- Brookings Conference on Access to Finance May.

© 2007 Thomson South-Western. In this section, look for the answers to these questions: Why does productivity matter for living standards? What determines.

The institute for employment studies The Role of Loan Guarantees in Alleviating Credit Rationing Marc Cowling.

SMALL BUSINESS CREDIT Traditionally, small businesses have been thought to face increased difficulties in accessing credit than do larger businesses. Lending.

Innovation in the Supply Chain: lessons from the CBI/QinetiQ Innovation Survey Hugh Morgan Williams Chairman, Canford Group Vice Chair, CBI SME Council.

The bank-firm relationship after Basel II: a survey of italian firms Chiara Bentivogli, Emidio Cocozza, Antonella Foglia, Simonetta Iannotti Bank of Italy.

1 Trade Credit in Japan: Relationship with Bank Loans November 2003 Iichiro Uesugi Research Institute of Economy, Trade and Industry and METI.

Kevin Chow Senior Manager Research Department Hong Kong Monetary Authority 9 October 2015 F INANCING D IFFICULTY OF S MALL F IRMS IN C HINA.

HGSMEs & Innovation “Access to Finance” Module A Proposal for a Pilot Survey Questionnaire (Draft)

On the Importance of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in Dubai Mohamed TRABELSI March 18 th, 2015.

Communication Temporary framework for State aid measures European Commission DG Competition 21 January 2009.

Presentation June a Community Interest Company (“CIC”) established in 2013 with support from Arts Council England offering finance based products.

Small and Medium Enterprises: Overcoming Financing Constraints Thorsten Beck, Leora Klapper, Soledad Martinez Peria DECRG-FI.

How have SME finances been affected by the credit crisis?* BERR/ESRC Seminar: SME Access to Finance Dr. Stuart Fraser Centre for Small and Medium Sized.

Banking Supervision and Credit Reporting Systems October 6, 2006 Regional Conference on Credit Reporting Systems in Africa Cape Town, South Africa Philip.

AECM and the Different European Guarantee Models Berlin, 5 May 2006M. Sousa Branca.

S + ad valorem tax S P Q O Effect of a tax on the supply curve.

Iowa State University Department of Economics Prof. Maureen Kilkenny Ms. Antara Jaitly Mr. Vitaly Pecharsky Ms. Rebecca Hooper Geography of Rural Financial.

NOV Choosing the right option: Debt v/s Equity Debt or Equity what would be the best option?  Deciding between equity financing or taking on a.

Funding Growth Audrey Metayer – Commercial Manager, HSBC Charlotte England – International Relationship Director, HSBC.

1 PUBLIC BANKING IN SPAIN: GONE WITH THE WIND José Viñals Banco de España RES Panel IDB Annual Meeting in Lima, Peru March 28, 2004.

Bellwork 1.What are the three functions of money? 2.What is the purpose of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation? 3.When was the Federal Reserve System.

FINANCIAL DILEMMAS OF SMES IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES YAO WANG.

Sources of Finance BUSINESS SUITABILITY You will Understand that the type of business organisation will determine the suitability of the source of finance.

Public Sector Partial Credit Guarantee Programs: What, Why, When and a little bit of How? Frank Nieder Lead Financial Markets Specialist Capital Markets.

Slide 1 / SMEs’ access to finance A commercial banking perspective.

Sources of Finance. Loan capital Money received by an organisation in return for the organisation’s agreement to pay interest during the period of the.

The Structural Transformation Story of Kenya’s Financial System

Public Sector Partial Credit Guarantee Programs: What, Why, When and a little bit of How? Ambitious for 10 minutes. summarize key issues, and allow.

Who Needs Credit and Who Gets Credit?

Impact Evaluation Terms Of Reference

Topic 3 Finance and Accounts

What’s holding back the private sector in MENA?

BMC Health Service Research 2015 By Gang Nathan Dong PERFORMING WELL IN FINANCIAL MANAGMGMENG AND QUALITY OF CARE.

Who Needs Credit and Who Gets Credit?

SME Credit Guarantee Mechanism in Taiwan

Presentation transcript:

Small Firms in the Credit Crisis: Evidence from the UK Survey of SME Finances* Presentation to CBI SME Council 7 th July 2009 Dr. Stuart Fraser Centre for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises Warwick Business School *This research was funded by ESRC grant no. RES and with support from Barclays Bank.

2Warwick Business School Introduction UKSMEF. Analysis. Demand and supply of finance. Changes since Effects of the credit crisis. Interpretation.

3Warwick Business School UKSMEF (aka ‘BIG’) Representative sample of 2,500 SMEs (<250 employees) interviewed in detail about: The business and its owner. Sources of finance. Financial relationships. UKSMEF 2008 a follow up to previous UKSMEFs in 2004 (WBS) and 2007 (Cambridge). Latest fieldwork 10 th Sept – 20 th Nov Analysis compares outcomes in (and among 2008 applicants in particular) with

4Warwick Business School Lower use of financial products in …

5Warwick Business School (…and greater use of internal finance…)

6Warwick Business School Partly due to lower capital demands…

7Warwick Business School …but also higher loan rejection rates… Compared to … Overdraft rejections up  3½ in 2008 (4.2%  15.3%) High risk: up  4 (5.8%  22.4%). Low risk: down  ¾ (3.8%  2.8%). High growth: up  4 (4.5%  19.2%). Term loan rejections up  2½ in 2008 (6.1%  16.3%) High risk: up  3½ (3.7%  13.5%). Low risk: down  ¾ (9.3%  7.2%). High growth: up  2½ (7.2%  19%) What underlies these increases?...

8Warwick Business School …SMEs are riskier in 2008.

9Warwick Business School Loan amounts Average size of overdraft facilities loans up by 30% in 2008 (£36.5K  £47.5K): High risk: down  ¼ (£58K  £14.5K). Low risk: up  6 (£23.5K  £145K). High growth: down  2/3 (£52K  £34K). Average size of term loans up 79% in 2008 (£102K  £183K): High risk: down  ½ (£153K  £71K). Low risk: up  3 (£86K  £262K). High growth: down 8% (£140K  £128.5K).

10Warwick Business School Margins and collateral Overdraft margins up 83% (2.4% points  4.4% points over base). Overdraft arrangement fees up 86% (£237  £442). Term loan margins up 68% (2.2% points  3.7% points over base). Term loan arrangement fees up 37% (£1,074  £1,468). No change in average incidences of collateral. But 78% increase (33.3%  59.4%) on overdraft collateral among low risk firms. Also notice an increase in rejections due to no/insufficient collateral…

11Warwick Business School

12Warwick Business School Interpretation Higher rejection rates consistent with anecdotal evidence at the end of 2008 (e.g., from FSB). UKSMEF 2008 shows high risk/high growth firms among the worst affected. Higher loan amounts is consistent with BBA statistics for UKSMEF 2008 shows that main beneficiaries of these increases were lower risk firms. Lower loan amounts among high risk and high growth firms. Credit has become increasingly concentrated in lower risk firms. Higher risk and growth firms more likely to be offered smaller amounts or denied loans altogether.

13Warwick Business School Interpretation All types of firm paying higher margins due to higher cost of capital. Hikes in arrangement fees seem less justified. Lower risk firms having to offer more collateral to maintain good supply of credit. And more firms report being denied loans due to no/insufficient collateral. By comparison rejection rates for leasing/hire purchase agreements are lower in 2008…

14Warwick Business School

15Warwick Business School Conclusions (credit boom) and 2008 (credit crisis) represent two extreme market states. Boom conditions not sustainable; depths of crisis not sustained. However UKSMEF 2008 points to an SME credit market in which credit will be less easily available. Even to creditworthy firms if they lack collateral. Stronger argument for the role of govt support Hard pressed to justify SFLGs in UKSMEF Not hard to justify EFGs at the current time. Further evidence on the new credit market ‘equilibrium’ required to assess the scale/role of future interventions. More fieldwork planned for start of 2010.

16Warwick Business School

17Warwick Business School

18Warwick Business School

19Warwick Business School

20Warwick Business School