LIGO-G030074-00-D LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Test Mass Material Selection Status GariLynn Billingsley LSC 20 March 2003.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
G R LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Research and Development David Shoemaker LHO LSC 11 November 2003.
Advertisements

Low Mechanical Dissipation in Fused Silica S. D. Penn, G. M. Harry, A. M. Gretarsson, S. E. Kittleberger, P. R. Saulson, J. J. Schiller, J. R. Smith, S.
Fused Silica Research for Advanced LIGO Alexander Ageev, Gregg Harry, Jim Hough, Steve Penn, Sheila Rowan, Phil Willems.
Thermal Compensation NSF David Ottaway LIGO Laboratory MIT.
G R LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Research and Development Update Dennis Coyne LSC Meeting at LLO 16 March 2004.
Thermal Compensation Review David Ottaway LIGO Laboratory MIT.
Absorption Studies in Sapphire
LIGO-G D Advanced LIGO Systems Design & Interferometer Sensing & Optics Peter Fritschel, LIGO MIT PAC 13 Meeting, 5 June 2003.
Substrate mechanical loss studies Sheila Rowan (Stanford University) for: LIGO Laboratory (Caltech, MIT, LLO, LHO) LSC Partners (University of Glasgow,
Overview of Research in the Optics Working Group Gregory Harry, on behalf of the OWG Massachusetts Institute of Technology July 25, 2007 LSC Meeting –
Alban REMILLIEUX3 rd ILIAS-GW Annual General Meeting. London, October 26 th -27 th, New coatings on new substrates for low mechanical loss mirrors.
Intermediate review - ERC – February 9, 2009 – L. Pinard 1 Mirrors Sub-System Overview  Introduction  Scope of the subsystem, main tasks  Job done since.
G R LSC Meeting, LIGO Hanford Observatory, August 18, 2004 LIGO R&D1 Test Mass Substrate Material Selection for Advanced LIGO: An Update from.
Thermal Noise from Coatings Gregg Harry; Andri Gretarsson, Scott Kittelberger, Steve Penn, Peter Saulson; Marty Fejer, Eric Gustafson, Roger Route, Sheila.
Conceptual Design for Advanced LIGO Suspensions Norna A Robertson University of Glasgow and Stanford University for the GEO suspension team +contribution.
G M LIGO Laboratory1 Responses to Review Questions David Shoemaker, Peter Fritschel NSF Review of Advanced LIGO 12 June 2003.
G M 1 Advanced LIGO Update David Shoemaker LSC/Virgo MIT July 2007.
Overview of coatings research and recent results at the University of Glasgow M. Abernathy, I. Martin, R. Bassiri, E. Chalkley, R. Nawrodt, M.M. Fejer,
Thermal noise from optical coatings Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - on behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - 25 July
G v5 1 Core Optics Components Technical Status NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Project April 2011 GariLynn Billingsley.
LIGO- G D The LIGO Instruments Stan Whitcomb NSB Meeting LIGO Livingston Observatory 4 February 2004.
Gravitational Wave Detection Using Precision Interferometry Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration.
LIGO-G M Major International Collaboration in Advanced LIGO R&D Gary Sanders NSF Operations Review Hanford February, 2001.
Thermal Noise in Initial and Enhanced LIGO Gregg Harry, Steve Penn, Peter Saulson, David Malling Massachusetts Institute of Technology Hobart and William.
DFG-NSF Astrophysics Workshop Jun 2007 G Z 1 Optics for Interferometers for Ground-based Detectors David Reitze Physics Department University.
LIGO-G D LIGO and Industry Capability/ProductCompany Ultra-high Vacuum TechnologyCB&I Passive Seismic IsolationHytec Inc. Active Seismic IsolationBarry.
LIGO- G D LSC Meeting, Hannover, GE August LIGO Scientific Collaboration1 Advanced LIGO Optics Status Report Dave Reitze University of Florida.
Optical Coatings R&D Status Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the Coating Working Group - August, 2004 LSC Meeting Hanford.
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, E. Chalkley 1 C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
LIGO-G Z Thermal noise in sapphire - summary and plans Work carried out at: Stanford University University of Glasgow Caltech MIT.
Effect of Charging on Thermal Noise Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Core Optics and Suspensions Working Groups - March 19, 2004 –
1st Advanced Virgo Review – November 3-4, 2008 – L. Pinard 1 Mirrors Sub-System Overview  Introduction  Scope of the subsystem, main tasks  Substrates.
LIG O HW S LIGO-G Z1 Fused Silica Research for Advanced LIGO Alexander Ageev, Garilynn Billingsley, David Crooks, Gregg Harry, Jim Hough, Steve.
ILIAS - GWA N5 - Strega JRA3 General Meeting Orsay - November 5th-6th, 2004 M1 Activities.
LIGO LaboratoryLIGO-G R Coatings and Their Influence on Thermal Lensing and Compensation in LIGO Phil Willems Coating Workshop, March 21, 2008,
Update on Activities in Suspensions for Advanced LIGO Norna A Robertson University of Glasgow and Stanford University LSC meeting, Hanford, Aug 20 th 2002.
Investigating Surface Loss in Fused Silica Steve Penn, Andri Gretarrson, Gregg Harry (MIT), Scott Kittelberger, Peter Saulson, Joshua Smith Syracuse University.
Parametric Instabilities In Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Detectors Li Ju Chunnong Zhao Jerome Degallaix Slavomir Gras David Blair.
Coating Program Update Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT on behalf of the Coating Working Group March 22, 2006 LSC Meeting – LHO G R.
Thermoelastic dissipation in inhomogeneous media: loss measurements and thermal noise in coated test masses Sheila Rowan, Marty Fejer and LSC Coating collaboration.
Studies of Thermal Loading in Pre-Modecleaners for Advanced LIGO Amber Bullington Stanford University LSC/Virgo March 2007 Meeting Optics Working Group.
TCS and IFO Properties Dave Ottaway For a lot of people !!!!!! LIGO Lab Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research, Massachusetts Institute of.
LIGO-G M LIGO R&D1 Report of the Optics Working Group Dave Reitze, UF Working Session on Sapphire »Committee to “down select” AdL test mass material:
LIGO-G M LIGO Status Gary Sanders GWIC Meeting Perth July 2001.
Coating Discussion Gregg Harry LIGO - MIT March 2008 LSC/Virgo Meeting March 19, 2008 LIGO-DCC Number.
LIGO-G D Downselect: Silica. What Were We Thinking? Phil Willems, Caltech -representing- the Downselect Committee: David Shoemaker, Jordan Camp,
LIGO-G Z Silicon as a low thermal noise test mass material S. Rowan, R. Route, M.M. Fejer, R.L. Byer Stanford University P. Sneddon, D. Crooks,
LIGO-G R 1 Gregory Harry and COC Working Group Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Technical Plenary Session - March 17-20, 2003 LSC Meeting.
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
LIGO-G D 1 R&D Technical Review LIGO Lab October 8, 2002 Core Optics.
LIGO-G Z 1 Report of the Optics Working Group to the LSC David Reitze University of Florida March 20, 2003.
Optical Coatings for Gravitational Wave Detection Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - August.
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, E. Chalkley 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
LIGO-G D Core Optics Components (COC) Polishing Pathfinder Kickoff Advanced LIGO Project GariLynn Billingsley Caltech.
LIGO-G D Advanced LIGO Systems & Interferometer Sensing & Control (ISC) Peter Fritschel, LIGO MIT PAC 12 Meeting, 27 June 2002.
G R 2004 Plan Update LIGO Systems meeting 22 Jan 04 dhs.
1 Cascina – October 19, 2011 ASPERA Forum Laurent Pinard Substrates, Polishing, Coatings and Metrology for the 2 nd generation of GW detector Laurent PINARD.
LIGO-G v1 Inside LIGO LIGO1 Betsy Weaver, GariLynn Billingsely and Travis Sadecki 2016 – 02 – 23 at CSIRO, Lindfield.
Material Downselect Rationale and Directions Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Technology On behalf of downselect working.
Characterization of Advanced LIGO Core Optics
Thermal Compensation NSF
Steve Penn, Gregg Harry (MIT)
S. Rowan, M. Fejer, E. Gustafson, R. Route, G. Zeltzer
Test Mass Substrate Material Selection for Advanced LIGO:
Overview of Advanced LIGO Coating Status
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
Main Efforts of the Core Optics WG
Modeling of Advanced LIGO with Melody
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
Lowering Mechanical Loss in Fused Silica Optics with Annealing
Presentation transcript:

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Test Mass Material Selection Status GariLynn Billingsley LSC 20 March 2003

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory2 Downselect – not a word From Merriam Webster Online…… Suggestions for downselect: 1. downscaled 2. downscales 3. downscale 4. down-easter 5. downstater 6. down-at-heels 7. down-market 8. dulnesses 9. dullnesses 10. doodley-squat

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory3 Downselect: Choosing a Test Mass Material Committee »David Shoemaker (chair), Jordan Camp, Marty Fejer, Sam Finn, Peter Fritschel, Jim Hough, Peter Saulson, Phil Willems –Input from the COC working group Committee objective »Actively direct and support research needed to make a sufficiently informed decision regarding test mass material selection –Figure of Merit – maximize BNS inspiral range? –Trade against cost and complexity in the final analysis? Tools »Issues described in the “downselect document” – »Links to back up material at –

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory4 Background Sapphire – Advanced LIGO baseline test mass »Greater Astronomical reach (?) »Thermal characteristics »Mechanical properties Fused silica – fall back TM material »Extensive body of knowledge about FS »Large, optical quality sapphire is not yet an “off the shelf” item

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory5 Sapphire - Baseline Status Five experimental growth runs Crystal Systems »Two of five 15” boules are considered good optical quality »Two of five are not »LIGO has bought one “good” and one “not” to test for use as transmissive and non-transmissive test masses –Plan to measure absorption, scatter, homogeneity, Q Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics »Furnace is in place »No large pieces yet Rubicon »Just received 150 mm piece for optical testing, 10 cubes for absorption tests to arrive soon

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory6 Sapphire optical properties Polishing CSIRO and Wave Precision have good results »Microroughness to ~ 1Å »CSIRO better figure (better metrology) More at

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory7 Sapphire optical properties Homogeneity Compensation studies »CSIRO –Fluid jet polishing –Compensating coating deposition –Ion beam etch »Goodrich –Computer controlled polishing

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory8 Homogeneity after Compensating polish at Goodrich

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory9 Sapphire optical properties Absorption Absorption reduction studied at Stanford (Route, Fejer, et. al.) »~10 ppm/cm required in order to obviate thermal compensation »Typically 50 ppm/cm in large samples as received »Isolated observations at 10 ppm/cm, existence proof »Annealing Studies have produced 20 – 30 ppm/cm to date 50 ppm material still useable with active thermal compensation »Lower absorption is easier; especially if there is spatial variation »Dave Ottaway taking over from Ryan Lawrence at MIT »Full cavity experiment at Gin Gin, Western Australia Spatial variation? -Measure full size boule at Lyon 3-03 »Thermal compensation approach depends on these results –

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory10 Sapphire mechanical properties Q Q measurement by Phil Willems »Two 314 mm x 130 mm boules measured »Highest Q ~ 260x10 6 radial antisymmetric mode »Lowest Q ~ 28x10 6 Similar for “good” and “not” substrates »Slightly better for “not!”

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory11 Fused silica A better choice??? Higher Q in FS  performance ≈ sapphire (Harry) »Best choice for TM material may depend on available coating technology Fused Silica surface loss investigations (Penn) »Highest modal Q of a fused silica sample observed to date is approximately 200 million (Syracuse) »Surface loss limit for full size fused silica predicts Q ~ 4x10 9 »presume the bulk loss will dominate at some lower value

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory12 Reducing fused Silica surface loss Flame polish »Proven to improve Q »Probably will not maintain optical surface quality Annealing »Proven to improve Q on FS rod »Significant undertaking for large optics »Not clear what happens to optical surface Ion etch »Not tried for Q improvement - not proven »Does maintain surface finish »May maintain surface figure

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory13 Questions Is BNS inspiral the right FOM? Is scatter, absorption good enough in sapphire? »Testing February-June Can we realize 200M Q or better in large FS? Can we lower coating losses enough to realize the full potential of either material? »10x reduction for sapphire »20x reduction for fused silica

LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory14 Timeline July 2003 decision needed to maintain LASTI schedule »Ideally resolve coating process first, probably not realistic »Decision needed to allow Suspension design to proceed Delivery of first two large sapphire substrates Feb ‘03 »Measurements through June ’03 Need to understand limits on FS Q in this timeframe »substantial progress on large substrates Should be able to recommend material selection at next LSC meeting