The Death Penalty in Popular Culture Kenneth Mentor J.D., Ph.D. Criminal Justice Department New Mexico State University
Previous Research: Austin Sarat Austin Sarat Movies as replacement for public executions Movies as replacement for public executions
Key Themes Clean - Mechanical Clean - Mechanical Error Free - Efficient Error Free - Efficient Murder is Dirty in Comparison Murder is Dirty in Comparison Observers Observers
In Film, Death Penalty is Clean
Mechanical
Antiseptic Scene from “Dead Man Walking”
Orderly
Respectful
Caring guide
Morality play - Good vs. evil
Puts viewer in juror role
ERROR FREE
Hollywood vs. reality
Goes wrong only through evil
Media seldom discussed error or shows real images
too distasteful
Murder is Dirty Death penalty is respectful and clean, especially when compared to heinous acts of the condemned Death penalty is respectful and clean, especially when compared to heinous acts of the condemned
Clean murderers are especially crazy Hannibal Hannibal American Psycho American Psycho Ted Bundy Ted Bundy
OBSERVERS
Movie depiction of viewers
Film viewers - voyeur
Televised executions
Little real understanding of process
Move to lethal injection - orderly and clean, just like the movies