1 A simple method for supporting future landers by predicting surface pressure on Mars Paul Withers Boston University 725 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston MA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SCILOV-10 Validation of SCIAMACHY limb operational NO 2 product F. Azam, K. Weigel, Ralf Bauer, A. Rozanov, M. Weber, H. Bovensmann and J. P. Burrows ESA/ESRIN,
Advertisements

MEX Surface Pressure Measurements Paul Withers Center for Space Physics, Boston University MEX/VEX Radio Science Meeting
Morphology of meteoric plasma layers in the ionosphere of Mars as observed by the Mars Global Surveyor Radio Science Experiment Withers, Mendillo, Hinson.
General Circulation of the Martian Atmosphere: Dynamics and Dust Melissa J. Strausberg 25 August 2005.
Weather in the Northern Hemisphere of Mars: Dust Storms and Baroclinic Eddies David Hinson 1 and Helen Wang 2 1 SETI Institute / Stanford University 2.
Measurements of Winds in the Martian Upper Atmosphere from the MGS Accelerometer Paul Withers*, Steve Bougher, and Gerry Keating 34th DPS Meeting
Mars Odyssey Accelerometer Results Paul Withers 1, Jim Murphy 2, Tina Gueth 2, Steve Bougher 3, Michael Mendillo Boston University 2 – New Mexico.
Upper atmospheric density profiles from the Mars Odyssey Accelerometer: Report on data processing, archiving plans, and scientific analysis Paul Withers.
Errors in Viking Lander Atmospheric Profiles Discovered Using MOLA Topography Withers, Lorenz, and Neumann LPSC 2002 Abstract #1294 Abstract’s Abstract:
Atmospheric Profiles from Spirit and Opportunity Paul Withers Spring AGU, New Orleans, Acknowledgements: MER Atmospheric Advisory.
Analysis of Aerobraking Accelerometer Data from Mars Paul Withers BU CSP Journal Club Monday
New data products from the Mars Odyssey Accelerometer: Report on scientific implications, data processing, validation and archiving Paul Withers
MGS Accelerometer-derived profiles of Upper Atmospheric Pressures and Temperatures: Similarities, Differences, and Winds Withers, Bougher, and Keating.
Theoretical Simulations of the Martian Ionosphere and Comparisons to Observations (How do thermospheric tides and variations in solar flux affect ionospheric.
Determination of upper atmospheric properties on Mars and other bodies using satellite drag/aerobraking measurements Paul Withers Boston University, USA.
Outline Further Reading: Chapter 09 of the text book - climate controls - temperature and precipitation influences - climate classification methodology.
1 Simplifying the martian carbon dioxide cycle: An empirical method for predicting surface pressure Paul Withers 1, Silvia Tellmann Boston University.
Slides 13b: Time-Series Models; Measuring Forecast Error
Slide 1 of 48 Measurements and Their Uncertainty
1 TEC-MTT/2012/3788/In/SL LMD1D v1 and v2 Comparison with Phoenix Flight Data Prepared by Stéphane Lapensée ESA-ESTEC, TEC-MTT Keplerlaan 1, 2201 AZ Noordwijk.
Testing Simple Parameterizations for the Basic Characteristics of the Martian Ionosphere (How does the martian ionosphere respond to changes in solar flux?)
Engineering Means having to deal with failure Missions to Mars as an example of try, try, try again…
1. The MPI MAX-DOAS inversion scheme 2. Cloud classification 3. Results: Aerosol OD: Correlation with AERONET Surface extinction: Correlation with Nephelometer.
Slide 1 of 48 Measurements and Their Uncertainty
Slide 1 of 48 Measurements and Their Uncertainty
ASTRONOMY 340 FALL October 2007 Class #9. Salient Martian Features  R Mars = 3396 km (R Earth = 6378 km)  Higher surface area to mass ratio 
Slide 1 of 48 Measurements and Their Uncertainty
 Drew Wasikoski of NAU Mentored by Dr. Timothy Titus of the USGS.
Early Spacecraft Exploration Viking  “The scientific goal of the Viking missions is to ‘increase our knowledge of the planet Mars with an emphasis on.
Practical issues (This lecture is based largely on: The shape of the gravity anomaly depends not on the absolute.
Mars Rovers By Taylor Sokolovic.
Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology August 4, 2015 Austin Nicholas Landing Site Considerations Related to the Potential Sample.
“I’m ten times better than the Standard system of measurement!”
6/3/2016 SCIENTIFIC METHOD PROCESSES OF SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY.
Abstract: A simple representative model of the ionosphere of Mars is fit to the complete set of electron density profiles from the Mars Global Surveyor.
Measurement. Physics  A branch of science that involves the study of the physical world: energy, matter, and how they are related.
The ionosphere of Mars never looked like this before Paul Withers Boston University Space Physics Group meeting, University of Michigan.
1 The effects of solar flares on planetary ionospheres Paul Withers and Michael Mendillo Boston University 725 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston MA 02215, USA.
Page 1 HEND science after 9 years in space. page 2 HEND/2001 Mars Odyssey HEND ( High Energy Neutron Detector ) was developed in Space Research Institute.
Paul Withers, Steve Bougher, and a cast of thousands Longitudinal structure in the martian upper atmosphere as discovered by MGS Journal Club 14 September.
COMPARATIVE TEMPERATURE RETRIEVALS BASED ON VIRTIS/VEX AND PMV/VENERA-15 RADIATION MEASUREMENTS OVER THE NORTHERN HEMISPHERE OF VENUS R. Haus (1), G. Arnold.
NASA’s Exploration Plan: “Follow the Water” GEOLOGY LIFE CLIMATE Prepare for Human Exploration When Where Form Amount WATER NASA’s Strategy for Mars Exploration.
New Tools and Methods to fully Characterize the Atmospheric Environment for a Martian EDL. Application to the 2016 Exomars Descent Module. François Forget,
First global view of the Extratropical Tropopause Transition Layer (ExTL) from the ACE-FTS Michaela I. Hegglin, University of Toronto, CA Chris Boone,
© Copyright Pearson Prentice Hall Slide 1 of Measurements and Their Uncertainty On January 4, 2004, the Mars Exploration Rover Spirit landed on.
1 Volatile Exchange on Mars Maria T. Zuber MIT David E. Smith NASA/GSFC 16 th International Workshop on Laser Ranging Poznan, Poland 13 October 2008 NASA/MRO/HiRISE.
Preliminary reconstruction of martian atmospheric structure from Phoenix entry measurements Paul Withers and David Catling Abstract P54B-08.
Abstract Dust storms are well known to strongly perturb the state of the lower atmosphere of Mars, yet few studies have investigated their impact on the.
Miniature Probes for Planetary Atmospheric Exploration: Where Less is More Anthony Colaprete ASA ARC.
Determining surface characteristics at candidate MSL landing sites using THEMIS high-resolution orbital thermal inertia data Robin Fergason Philip Christensen.
1 Observations of tides and temperatures in the martian atmosphere by Mars Express SPICAM stellar occultations Paul Withers 1, Jean-Loup Bertaux 2, Franck.
The Orbiting Carbon Observatory (OCO) Mission: Retrieval Characterisation and Error Analysis H. Bösch 1, B. Connor 2, B. Sen 1, G. C. Toon 1 1 Jet Propulsion.
Getting the most out of planetary entry probes Paul Withers Boston University Planetary Science Seminar, Earth and Atmospheric Sciences,
Electron density profile retrieval from RO data Xin’an Yue, Bill Schreiner  Abel inversion error of Ne  Data Assimilation test.
Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer – Application to Martian atmosphere Helen Wang Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory April 2012.
Towards a Robust and Model- Independent GNSS RO Climate Data Record Chi O. Ao and Anthony J. Mannucci 12/2/15CLARREO SDT Meeting, Hampton, VA1 © 2015 California.
An observational study of the response of the thermosphere of Mars to lower atmospheric dust storms Paul Withers and Robert Pratt Boston University – Abstract.
Simulations of the effects of extreme solar flares on technological systems at Mars Paul Withers, Boston University Monday
Using the Mars climate Database for aerobraking ( km)
Accuracy and Precision
Astronomy 340 Fall October 2005 Class #9.
Chapter 1: A Physics Toolkit
PLANET MARS Presented By: Samia Amir & Tauseef Saeed NCBA & E
Exploring the ionosphere of Mars
Comparisons and simulations of same-day observations of the ionosphere of Mars by radio occultation experiments on Mars Global Surveyor and Mars Express.
Scientific Measurement
Recovery of Mars ionospheric electron density profiles acquired by the Mariner 9 radio occultation instrument N. Ferreri, Paul Withers, S. Weiner Abstract.
Variation of Protonated Ions and H2 as observed by MAVEN NGIMS
The Vertical Structure of the Martian Ionosphere
The Mars Pathfinder Atmospheric Structure Investigation/Meteorology (ASI/MET) Experiment by J. T. Schofield, J. R. Barnes, D. Crisp, R. M. Haberle, S.
Presentation transcript:

1 A simple method for supporting future landers by predicting surface pressure on Mars Paul Withers Boston University 725 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston MA 02215, USA PS08-A021 Thursday :00-12:30 AOGS Meeting, Singapore

How to land on Mars 2 Spirit and Opportunity shown here, similar systems used by other landers

If actual surface pressure is much smaller than estimated 3 Lander does not have enough time to perform steps necessary for safe landing

If actual surface pressure is much larger than estimated 4 Very long time descending slowly on parachute Mass devoted to landing system can be reduced, used for scientific instruments instead

Mars Science Laboratory (MSL, 2011 launch) 5

Surface pressure varies with season 6 Atmosphere of CO 2 freezes onto polar cap in winter hemisphere

Surface pressure varies with position 7 Altitude of surface varies by three atmospheric scale heights or >30 km

Viking surface pressure data 8 7 mbar 10 mbar Ls=0

Estimating surface pressure for MSL’s landing Other scientists are developing very sophisticated climate models I focus on a simple expression for Ps derived from data –Transparent –Easy to use –Quantify accuracy easily –Reality-check for more complex predictions Ls= , z<+1 km, 45S-45N 9

10 Available Datasets LANDERS Viking Lander 1 (VL1) –Multiple years, coarse digitization, 22N Viking Lander 2 (VL2) –Almost one year, coarse digitization, 48N Mars Pathfinder (MPF) –Ls= , same elevation as VL1, systematic error of about 0.1 mbar, 19N Phoenix (PHX) –Ls=76-151, 68N, large and precise dataset –Data from Ls=120 to 151 not yet incorporated into analysis RADIO OCCULTATIONS Mariner 9 –Apparent inconsistencies of 10% Viking Orbiters 1/2 (VO1/2) –Barely 20 pressures reported Mars Global Surveyor (MGS) –21243 profiles, including 297 at Ls= , z<+1 km, latitude=45S to 45N –Extrapolate p(r) to MOLA surface and assign MOLA altitude Mars Express (MEX) –484 profiles, only 5 at Ls= , z<+1 km, latitude=45S to 45N Most useful datasets are: VL1 for seasonal cycle, MGS for validation and testing, Goal is: Simple expression for DIURNAL MEAN Ps as function of season and altitude.

11 Approach Grey line is 360 diurnal mean surface pressure from VL1 Black line is wave-2 fit Optimize with Delta metric, where Delta = (p-pred – p-meas) / p-meas Use expression below to predict surface pressure, Ps zVL1 = km Constant and uniform H0 needed (found on next slide) Eqn 1

12 Finding H0 from MGS Quickly find that H0 12 km have problems at low and high altitudes MGS measurements at z<+1 km and 45S to 45N divide neatly into seven Ls blocks Optimal scale height is: H0 = 11 km Equivalent to T=215 K, which is reasonable

13 Accuracy of Predictions Expect 3% accuracy for MSL landing with 1-sigma confidence level Overbar = Mean S. D. = Standard deviation Only data from z<+1 km and 45S to 45N used for orbital datasets

14 Potential Applications First-order surface pressure estimates for landing site selection Reality-check on predictions from more complex, physics-based models Total atmospheric mass from Eqn 1 is about 10 p 0 R 2 f(Ls) / g. Annual mean value is 2.4E16 kg and difference between maximum and minimum values is 6.6E15 kg, consistent with previous results. Correct orbital gamma ray and neutron spectrometer for atmospheric absorption effects Absolute altitude scales for T(p) profiles measured from orbit, such as MGS TES or Mariner 9 IRIS profiles Theoretical simulations of dust lifting and aeolian modification of surface features, the thermodynamic stability of near-surface liquids, and the surface radiation environment

15 Conclusions A simple expression with 7 free parameters provides surprisingly accurate predictions for surface pressure Expected accuracy of prediction for MSL landing is 3% (1-sigma confidence level) Predictions are least accurate at Ls=240 to 360 when interannual variability (large dust storms) is greatest There are many potential applications for accurate surface pressure predictions