Analysis of pre-election period advertising and communication funds of local authorities National Audit Office of Estonia Anneliis Arm, auditor Warsaw,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
An Introduction to professional services. The professional services The professional services support businesses of all sizes across the economy, providing.
Advertisements

Internal Control–Integrated Framework
Ms Valerie Vandermeersch National expert, Ministry of Justice.
IRS AUDIT OF TAX RETURN PREPARERS: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly 1.
The 6 th International Conference on Financial Criminology 2014 Rangsit University, Pathumthani, Thailand Friday 5 September 2014 Corruption in the State.
Contractors’ Day, June 2008 to the Framework Partnership Agreement & the Specific Grant Agreement Financial Guidelines for co-ordinators and co-partners.
Discussion on SA-500 – AUDIT EVIDENCE
Control procedures in polish public procurement law Public Procurement Office 2007.
Protected Areas Conservation Trust’s (PACT) Accreditation to the Adaptation Fund Board: The Process and experience. By: Kerry Belisle (PACT)
Revitalization of the Long Beach City Auditor’s Office Presented to the Downtown Lions Club of Long Beach September 8, 2006 Laura Doud, City Auditor, Long.
2012 JANUARY Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
IS Audit Function Knowledge
Expanded Version of COSO a presentation by Steve Wadleigh Expanded Version of COSO a presentation by Steve Wadleigh Standards for Internal Control in the.
18- 1 © 2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved. Chapter 18 Integrated Audits of Internal Control (For Public Companies Under Sarbanes-Oxley.
Regulatory Body MODIFIED Day 8 – Lecture 3.
What are the challenges of implementing ISSAIs in NAO of Estonia? Krista Zibo Audit manager of Financial Audit Department Meeting of Experts of SAIs of.
The Camp Audit “Keep your friends close and your auditor closer”
PAD190 PRINCIPLES OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
Advocacy.
Session 3.11 Risk Identification Presented By: RTI, JAIPUR.
Establishment and Development of the Internal Audit System for the Public Sector in Kyrgyz Republic INTERNAL AUDIT COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE ISTANBUL
Audit of Public Procurement
Audit Committees: practices in the EU Manfred van Kesteren Bucharest, December 4th 2014.
Audit objectives, Planning The Audit
WHAT ARE OMB CIRCULAR A-133 AUDITS? February 3, José E. Díaz Martínez, CPA, CGMA, MBA Orlando R. Torres, CPA David L. Dennis, CPA.
Port of Redwood City Presentation to The Board of Commissioners Port of Redwood City Presentation to The Board of Commissioners December 12, 2012 Presented.
Supervision and Oversight in Procurement as a Tool of Efficient Project Implementation.
The National Audit Office of Finland
Supervision and regulation of banking system duty is given to a autonomous organization called Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency. BRSA is public.
Good practices from and for the EU accountability process Irena Petruškevičienė Vilnius, 17 October 2006.
ISO training courses Developed by DOE and IBRAE RAN and conducted at the Training Center “Emergency Response” of the Institute for Advanced Training.
SAI and Parliamentary Audit Committee Relations – Estonian Experience TÕNIS SAAR Director of Corporate Services National Audit Office of Estonia.
Evaluation of EU Structural Funds information and publicity activities in Lithuania in Implementing recommendations for Dr. Klaudijus.
1 Status of PSC recommendations (January December 2007) Portfolio Committee on Public Service and Administration 14 March 2008.
Organization and Implementation of a National Regulatory Program for the Control of Radiation Sources Regulatory Authority.
Harmonization project CAS project group (Chair, Slovakia, European Court of Auditors) CAS meeting Batumi, Georgia 27th of September 2011.
Workshop on Implementing Audit Quality Practices Working Group on Audit Manuals and Methods March 2006 Vilnius (Lithuania) Hungarian Experiences.
[Hayes, Dassen, Schilder and Wallage, Principles of Auditing An Introduction to ISAs, edition 2.1] © Pearson Education Limited 2007 Slide 7.1 Internal.
T HE DEBT OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS IN P OLAND T HE DEBT OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS IN P OLAND Iwona Zyman, Director of the Regional Branch in Opole.
ISSAI 400 Compliance Auditing
V IRGINIA A SSOCIATION OF S CHOOL B OARD O FFICIALS F ALL C ONFERENCE O FFICE OF THE S TATE I NSPECTOR G ENERAL 1.
Budget of Municipalities - Planning and Execution the Role of the Supreme Audit Office of Poland (NIK) Warsaw, October 2015 Iwona Zyman Director of the.
2011 Calendar Important Dates/Events/Homework. SunSatFriThursWedTuesMon January
Publicity and Transparency in Local Government – the Role of NAMRB Guinka Tchavdarova Executive Director of the National Association of Municipalities.
A RESPONSE RENDERED BY HON V MWALE, PAC CHAIRPERSON, ZAMBIA MPUMALANGA, SOUTH AFRICA, 5 SEPTEMBER, 2012 DEVELOPING MEASURABLE OBJECTIVES IN PERFORMANCE.
Interest Group -A group of individuals with a common interest who seek to influence public policy.
EUROPEAN COURT OF AUDITORS JULIA LINARES. BACKGROUND The European Court of Auditors was established by the Treaty of Brussels of 22 July The Court.
BNAO ROLE FOR EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF PUBLIC FINANCES Tzvetan Tzvetkov, CIA, CGAP, CRMA - President of the Bulgarian National Audit Office.
1 Performance Auditing ICAS & IRAS Officers NAAA 21 Jan 2016.
Briefing to the Portfolio Committee on Police 21 August
CALENDAR 2015: “THIS PROJECT HAS BEEN FUNDED WITH SUPPORT FROM THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION. THIS PUBLICATION [COMMUNICATION] REFLECTS THE VIEWS ONLY OF THE.
Regional Conference Money in Politics Session 5. How to design effective financial monitoring bodies for the enforcement of political finance law? Lina.
Regional Conference on Money in Politics February, 2016 Tbilisi, Georgia Discussion on the challenges to women participation in politics, on the.
July 2007 SundayMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturday
Internal Controls For Municipalities Vermont State Auditor’s Office – August 2008.
Lecturer: Lina Vladimirovna Zhornyak, associated professor.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter 1 The Nature and Purpose of Accounting Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies. All Rights Reserved.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 32 – Financial Control Bilateral screening:
Emergency Preparedness of Estonia Case Study of Performance Audit National Audit Office of Estonia Alina Undrits.
Communication with public via media and social media Anu Ots Communications Manager of Statistics Estonia
© Grant Thornton LLP. All rights reserved Meeting with Management and Those Charged with Governance Communications Related to the Audit of Delphi.
Powered By: Futurenotez.com
PLANNING, MATERIALITY AND ASSESSING THE RISK OF MISSTATEMENT
GDPR support January GDPR support January 2018.
INTRODUCTION TO Compliance audit METHODOLGY and CAM
Internal control - the IA perspective
Chapter 8 Developing an Effective Ethics Program
Regional Round table on Strengthening Integrity in State Authorities & Electoral Processes in All Countries. (Budva Montenegro 16 – 17 April 2019) Special.
2015 January February March April May June July August September
Presentation transcript:

Analysis of pre-election period advertising and communication funds of local authorities National Audit Office of Estonia Anneliis Arm, auditor Warsaw, October 2015

Screenshots of some TV clips

Outdoor media ´Photo: Erakogu/Tartu Postimees Photo: Mihkel Maripuu/Postimees/Scanpix Baltics Photo: Peeter Langovits/Postimees/Scanpix Baltics Photo: Mihkel Maripuu/Postimees/Scanpix BalticsPhoto: Rauno Volmar/Delfi/Eesti Ajalehed

Auditing local authorities  The National Audit Office of Estonia (NAOE) has had the right to audit the use of the municipal assets and money of local authorities since  The NAOE cannot assess the expedience of the activities and use of money by local authorities in order to avoid conflict with the principle of autonomy of local authorities which derives from the Charter of Local Self-Government. In other words, the NAOE cannot conduct performance audits in local authorities.  In connection with conducting compliance audits among local authorities we have started to debate whether the formal compliance with the law is which fulfills NAOE objective or should the compliance with the meaning of the law be assessed?

Analysis of pre-election period advertising and communication funds of local authorities  The NAOE audited the expenses of the information activities of 15 local authorities in 2012 and 2013 in order to obtain an overview of the content and size of these expenses.  Two local authorities (Tallinn, Tartu) were selected on the basis of the analyzed data where the expenses were analyzed in great detail to assess their legitimacy.  The criteria by which the opinion was given was an interpretation of the meaning of the law that the information expenses of local authorities, just like the amounts spent on any other activities, can only arise from public interest. It did not derive explicitly from the law, but nevertheless audited local authorities agreed that it should be this way and herewith the criteria was in place.  The central question was whether the funds of the local authority have been used to advertise politicians and parties before the local elections of Statement of accounts and budgets of local authorities were analyzed by NAOE. Information forwarded through TV clips and posters where assessed by external experts (semiotician, advertising experts). Interviews with officials of local authorities were carried out by NAOE.  In relation to potential advertising we focused on television, radio and outdoor media among the various ways of giving information.

The results of the analysis

1. Use of advertising and communication funds concentrated into pre-election period (1)

1. Use of advertising and communication funds concentrated into pre-election period (2) January February MarchApril May June July August September October November December

2. The unusual behavior of the agencies in the period leading to the elections (1)

2. The unusual behavior of the agencies in the period leading to the elections (2)

What did we conclude on the basis of the audit? (1)  The amount spent from the budget of Tallinn on information that can be construed as election advertising was ca 337,000 euros. The NAOE is of the opinion that this information was not based on the need to act in public interest, but it was intentionally political and its impact was amplified in confluence of different notifications.  In addition to the elements of election advertising in the messages of the information, the NAOE also identified facts in the transactions related to the notifications that suggest the city planned to seek political influence.  It also became evident that on top of adding political nuances to messages, the city also started giving information about events of which the general public is usually not informed on such a massive scale, such as the completion of investment projects.

What did we conclude on the basis of the audit? (2)  In Tartu the evidence collected in the course of the audit gives no reason to claim that the event was supported in order to communicate information that advertised politicians or parties. However, representatives of local authority should avoid situations where they promote events supported by the city via themselves as a person, which makes it look like election advertising.  The NAOE is of the opinion that the laws of Estonia are currently inadequate and cannot efficiently prevent election advertising for the money of public agencies. The NAOE considers it necessary for the Parliament to continue reviewing the laws that regulate advertising and the financing of political parties. The NAOE also advises that the Political Parties Act be amended by giving the PPFSC the status of a body that exercises state supervision with the right to apply the state supervision measures set forth in the Law Enforcement Act

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION!