Level 10 Routing: Long Division and Irrational Factions Dave Crocker Brandenburg Consulting MY: +60 (19) 3299 445 www.brandenburg.comUS: +1 (408) 426.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

ICANN Report Presented by: Dr Paul Twomey CEO and President LACNIC, Montevideo 31 March 2004.

Advertisements

The ICANN Experiment ARIN-Calgary 3-April-2000 Borrowed from Andrew McLaughlin by Ken Fockler.

The ICANN Experiment ISOC-Israel 13-March-2000 Andrew McLaughlin.

CcTLD Agreement Update ICANN Public Forum Melbourne, Australia 12 March, 2001 Andrew McLaughlin ICANN Policy Guy.

Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers Louis Touton Presentation to the FTAA Joint Public-Private Sector Committee of Experts on the Internet.

ICANN Plan for Enhancing Internet Security, Stability and Resiliency.

And the Briefing for the ICANN Board Bucharest, Romania June 2002.

The Future of.ID domain Budi Rahardjo ID-DOMREG

Trends in ccTLD’s and models of operation Oscar Robles Chairman of the Board Latin American and Caribbean ccTLDs Kuala Lumpur

ICANN/ccTLD Agreements: Why and How Andrew McLaughlin Monday, January 21, 2002 TWNIC.

The Dance of Co-Opetition Dave Crocker Brandenburg Consulting MY: +60 (19) (408)

Cairo 2 November Agenda  Guidebook overview  Supporting and explanatory materials  Guidebook Module detail  Probable timelines 2.

Public Policy Issues in the Communications and Infrastructure Services Policy area Geoff Huston APNIC June 2011.

Glen de Saint Géry ICANN GNSO Secretariat for Theresa Swinehart Counsel for International Legal Affairs Domain Day Milan.

“ICANN and the Global Internet” ICANN Workshop Wednesday, October 9, 2002 Mexico City.

1 The Internet Introductory material. An overview lecture that covers Internet related topics, including a definition of the Internet, an overview of its.

New gTLD Basics. 2  Overview about domain names, gTLD timeline and the New gTLD Program  Why is ICANN doing this; potential impact of this initiative.

Introduction to ICANN’s new gTLD program. A practical example: the Dot Deloitte case. Jan Corstens, Partner, Deloitte WIPO Moscow, 9 Dec 2011.

1 CS 4396 Computer Networks Lab The Internet. 2 A Definition On October 24, 1995, the FNC unanimously passed a resolution defining the term Internet.

ICANN and the Internet Ecosystem. 2  A network of interactions among organisms, and between organisms and their environment.  The Internet is an ecosystem.

2011 – 2014 ICANN Strategic Plan Development Stakeholder Review 4 November 2010.

1 The Internet Introductory material. An overview lecture that covers Internet related topics, including a definition of the Internet, an overview of its.

Mirjam Kühne 1 ETO, Oct The Internet Registry System presented by Mirjam Kühne.

NRO report Raúl Echeberría Chair NRO Executive Council.

Prepared by The Regional Internet Registries [APNIC, ARIN, LACNIC and RIPE NCC]

- 1 - DPNM The Internet J. Won-Ki Hong Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering POSTECH Tel:

1 Mirjam KühneINET MEA, Cairo, May 2004 Welcome to INET MEA Cairo, Egypt 8 May 2005 Mirjam Kühne, ISOC.

LA ICANN Issues 한구인터넷 정보센터 박윤정. Internet Governance Governance 의 주제들 ICANN 탄생배경 ICANN 구조도 ICANN 과 한국.

ARIN Update June 2000 NANOG 19Albuquerque NANOG 19Albuquerque Overview Organization & Staff Activities Regional News Membership Statistics Regional Policy.

Why ICANN failed Milton Mueller Associate Professor, Syracuse University School of Information Studies.

1 ICANN update Save Vocea APSTAR retreat, Taipei, TW 24 February 2008.

Organizations, Institutions, the Domain Name and addressing system, Internet Governance… D-day 2005 Milan, Italy 24 November 2005 Theresa Swinehart GM,

1 ICANN & Global Partnerships Baher Esmat Manager, Regional Relations Middle East ccTLD Training, Amman Nov, 2007.

Text #ICANN50 #ATLAS2#ATLAS2. Text #ICANN50 The At-Large Advisory Committee (ALAC) An Introduction by Dr. Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond ALAC Chair.

NRO report John Curran Secretary NRO Executive Council.

Mirjam Kühne 1 EC, Oct Policy Development in RIPE & the RIPE NCC Mirjam Kühne RIPE NCC.

GNSO Public Forum Dr Bruce Tonkin Chair, GNSO Council Lisbon, 29 March 2007.

Domain Name Policy in 2001 Boudewijn Nederkoorn Chairman Council of European National TLD Registries.

1 The Internet Introductory material. An overview lecture that covers Internet related topics, including a definition of the Internet, an overview of its.

The challenge of services for new registries Giovanni Seppia Cape Town, November 30, 2004.

1 1 The GNSO Role in Internet Governance Presented by: Chuck Gomes Date: 13 May 2010.

NRO report Raúl Echeberría Chair NRO Executive Council.

NRO report Axel Pawlik Chairman (2010) NRO Executive Council.

IDN UPDATE Tina Dam ICANN Chief gTLD Registry Liaison Public Forum, Wellington 30 March 2006.

New Top Level Domains Geoff Huston IAHC. Top Level Domain Names l Country-code name spaces.au.jp.sg.de l Special purpose name spaces.in-addr.arpa.int.mil.

Management of Internet Resources ITU Workshop on Developing a Policy and Regulatory Framework for Developing Economies of the Pacific 1 December 2003 Suva,

Securing Future Growth: Getting Ready for IPv6 NOW! ccTLD Workshop, 8 th April 2011 Noumea, New Caledonia Miwa Fujii, Senior IPv6 Program Specialist, APNIC.

ICANN Regional Outreach Meeting, Dubai 1–3 April Toward a Global Internet Paul Twomey President and CEO 1 April 2008 ICANN Regional Meeting 1–3.

Fostering Multi-Stakeholder Internet Governance Models in the Region Bill Graham, Director, ICANN Board.

Who is Controlling the Internet ? Keith Mitchell Executive Chairman London Internet Exchange Predicts 98+ Conference Paris, 21st Apr 98.

1 The Internet Introductory material. An overview lecture that covers Internet related topics, including a definition of the Internet, an overview of its.

Internet Protocol Addresses What are they like and how are the managed? Paul Wilson APNIC.

1 The Internet Introductory material. An overview lecture that covers Internet related topics, including a definition of the Internet, an overview of its.

The European ccTLD Landscape Peter VAN ROSTE - ICANN Briefing – Brussels - 25 June 2013.

1 Dr. Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond ISOC UK England Chair ALAC Chair at ICANN Presentation at 3 nd Ukraine Internet Governance Forum Kyiv, Ukraine,

1 Domain Name Marketplace Patrick Jones Registry Liaison Manager 29 March 2007.

Update on Consumer Choice, Competition and Innovation (CCI) WG Rosemary Sinclair.

Board of Trustees Report Timothy Denton Chairman.

Keith Mitchellhttp:// RIPE ncc IP Address Space Governance Keith Mitchell Executive Board Chairman, RIPE NCC (Chief Executive, LINX) European.

1 IPv6 Allocation and Policy Update Global IPv6 Summit in China 2007 April 12, 2007 Guangliang Pan.

Domain Day ICANN and Reform Tuesday, 5 November 2002 Milan, Italy Theresa Swinehart, Counsel for International Legal Affairs, ICANN.

1 27Apr08 Some thoughts on Internet Governance and expansion of the Domain Name space Paul Twomey President and CEO 9 August 2008 Panel on Internet Governance.

Copyright (c) 2002 Japan Network Information Center Proposal for IPv6 Policy for Essential Infrastructure in the AP region Izumi Okutani IP Address Section.

Getting started with ICANN

ICANN Multi-Stakeholder Model

Partnership of Governments, Businesses and Civil Society: the ICANN example in coordinating resources and policy making Dr. Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond

One Size Does Not Fit All

Christopher Wilkinson Head, GAC Secretariat

A Proposal for IPv4 Essential Infrastructure

The Internet Introductory material.

Presentation transcript:

Level 10 Routing: Long Division and Irrational Factions Dave Crocker Brandenburg Consulting MY: +60 (19) (408) (408)

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting2 What we will cover  Some history  Some analysis  Some concerns

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting3 Some Internet Moments Technical  Internet operation  NSFNet backbone  NSFNet regionals  Commercial ISPs  ccTLDs, gTLDs  SNMP, IPv6 “wars”  Firewalls, NATs Management  Modern IETF  RIPE, APNIC, ARIN  Overthrow of IAB  Spam  For-profit gTLD charging  Green Paper

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting4 Collisions in name choices Infringement of trademark Monopoly control over registration Reasons for new gTLDs

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting5 The Structure ITU Depository (international and public status) gTLD-MoU (Memorandum of Understanding) IANA / ISOC (founding signatories) Policy Advisory Board (PAB) (220+ supporting signatory organizations) CORE-MoU (database registry) Registrars (85+ organizations for sales & support)

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting6 Active Groups Public Trust Oversight IANA / ISOC Policy Oversight Committee (POC) Policy Advisory Body Council of Registrars (CORE) Registrars BusinessOperations Registries

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting7 (Desired) Effects Competition among registrars Choice of names Resolution mechanism for disputes Stability of registration, operation, evolution

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting8 First principles  Competition  Prohibits undue control over customer  TLD database registry inherently has undue control over name holder  Making Additions  Increment carefully, to avoid instability

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting9 The Factions Support  IETF, etc.  RIPE, etc.  INTA  220+ organizations  Focused critics Opposition  Protecting  Revenue stream  Trademark (extremists)  Seeking revenue stream  Seeking public platform  Crazy  Philosophic disagreement

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting10 Difference in “authority”? IETF, etc  Long history  Extensive hierarchy  Community trust IANA / IAHC  Long history  Fragile hierarchy  Limited community

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting11 The 10-layer stack ApplicationPresentationSessionTransportNetworkLinkPhysical Politics Financial Religion

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting12 Internet Growth  Size since beginning  Six orders of magnitude of growth  Only two to go, to reach everbody on globe  Interoperability required  At all levels of technology, organization  Change does require change  Parental vigilance, individual responsibility

© 1998 D. Crocker, Brandenburg Consulting13 Group process  Communication  Requires shared meaning  Progress  Requires shared goals  Requires action