A New Approach to Measuring Situation Awareness: Theory, Technique, and the SABRE Tool Graham K. Edgar, Helen E. Edgar & Martin B. Curry.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Assessing Student Performance
Advertisements

CHAPTER 9, survey research
Alternative Strategies for Evaluating Teaching How many have used end-of-semester student evaluations? How many have used an alternative approach? My comments.
System Integration Verification and Validation
Mary Jo Sariscsany Assessing Health- Related Fitness and Physical Activity 13 chapter.
CHAPTER EIGHT The General Ledger McGraw-Hill/Irwin Accounting Fundamentals, 7/e © 2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved
Project Management Information Systems A APPENDIX.
FIN 685: Risk Management Topic 5: Simulation Larry Schrenk, Instructor.
LANGUAGE TESTING: Approaches & Techniques
Sensation Perception = gathering information from the environment 2 stages: –Sensation = simple sensory experiences and translating physical energy from.
Evaluation of Different Methods of Online Collaboration/Group Work - A Project Overview Alan Hilliard – Blended Learning Unit Evaluation of Different Methods.
Concept of Measurement
Uses of Language Tests.
SWOT Understanding SWOT Analysis. What’s Coming Up What is SWOT SWOT Overview Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats Examples.
Traditional approaches to the formulation of an accounting theory
PMI Knowledge Areas Risk Management.
Software testing techniques Software testing techniques Testing based on specifications Presentation on the seminar Kaunas University of Technology.
An Educational Computer Based Training Program CBTCBT.
© Crown copyright Met Office Forecasting Icing for Aviation: Some thoughts for discussion Cyril Morcrette Presented remotely to Technical Infra-structure.
Republic of Belarus REPORT on courses development for Eco-BRU TEMPUS Project Zilina, April 2015.
Introduction to Theories of Communication Effects: Emotional Appeals With special emphasis on Fear Appeals A service of the Communication Science & Research.
Publication Bias in Medical Informatics evaluation research: Is it an issue or not? Mag. (FH) Christof Machan, M.Sc. Univ-Prof. Elske Ammenwerth Dr. Thomas.
TYPES: Laboratory Experiments- studies in a closed setting, where experimenter has control over all variables. Natural Settings- Real life occurrences,
Copyright © 2011 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd PPT slides to accompany Event Management: Theory and Practice 1e by Wrathall and Gee 5-1 Chapter Five Event.
Bob Kois PMP MBA Project Management Basics Scope Management EPICPM ®
User Study Evaluation Human-Computer Interaction.
Chapter 6.
Methods and Metrics for Analysis of Sensemaking Dr Karen Carr& Mr Barry McGuinness BAE SYSTEMS Advanced Technology Centre.
Design and Society Lecture 5 Tim Sheard. Reading Thirty-Something (Million): Should They Be Exceptions? 3x5 cards - discussion.
Risk management (lecture). D efinitions of risk General: standard deviation Finance: volatility of return and costs Risk in project management (Lockyer.
Final review - statistics Spring 03 Also, see final review - research design.
What grounded theory is not
W RITING P OWERFUL E XECUTIVE S UMMARIES Presented By B EVERLEY S INCLAIR.
Copyright Catherine M. Burns
1 CHAPTER 2 Decision Making, Systems, Modeling, and Support.
1 Item Analysis - Outline 1. Types of test items A. Selected response items B. Constructed response items 2. Parts of test items 3. Guidelines for writing.
Building Simulation Model In this lecture, we are interested in whether a simulation model is accurate representation of the real system. We are interested.
Assessment. Workshop Outline Testing and assessment Why assess? Types of tests Types of assessment Some assessment task types Backwash Qualities of a.
Sensation Perception = gathering information from the environment 2 stages: –Sensation = simple sensory experiences and translating physical energy from.
Chapter 2: Signal Detection and Absolute Judgement
What is Science? Chapter 1, Lesson 1. Using one or more of your senses and tools to gather information. observing.
Using Bayesian Nets to Predict Software Defects in Arbitrary Software Lifecycles Martin Neil Agena Ltd London, UK Web:
Modelling the Process and Life Cycle. The Meaning of Process A process: a series of steps involving activities, constrains, and resources that produce.
Chapter 6 Attitudes and Intentions Copyright © 2010 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Michelle Hester Advanced Human Factors (PSYC 562)
ME/MECA 238A1 ME/MECA 238A - Mechanical/Mechatronic Design Project I Course notes prepared by G.A. Kallio, based on The Mechanical Design Process, by D.G.
PPA 503 – The Public Policy- Making Process Lecture 8c – How to Inform Policy Makers in a Briefing Memo or Opinion Statement.
Copyright © 2013, 2009, and 2007, Pearson Education, Inc. 1 FINAL EXAMINATION STUDY MATERIAL III A ADDITIONAL READING MATERIAL – INTRO STATS 3 RD EDITION.
Knowing our Parents Ian Rowe General Manager, GL Performance School Committee Member – Newminster Middle School Three Rivers Federation.
QUANTITATIVE TECHNIQUES
Marketing Plan Sports & Entertainment Marketing. What is the Marketing Plan? A written document that provides direction for the marketing activities for.
The effects of workshop participation in scenario-planning workshops on propensity to collaborate Survey findings Lisa Rayle Master in City Planning Master.
Project Management Information Systems
Attitudes and Intentions
Decision Support Systems
Personality, Perception, and Attribution
Knowing our Parents Ian Rowe General Manager, GL Performance
Overview of the Lumbar Motion Monitor
OD Interventions.
Reliability & Validity
Research methods Lesson 2.
Theories of Social Cognition:
Prepared by: Toni Joy Thurs Atayoc, RMT
Chapter 2: Value.
Copyright © 2005 Prentice Hall, Inc. All rights reserved.
Test Process “V” Diagram
Philosopher Buddy Chat
Testing and Inspection Present and Future
True or False True or False
Presentation transcript:

A New Approach to Measuring Situation Awareness: Theory, Technique, and the SABRE Tool Graham K. Edgar, Helen E. Edgar & Martin B. Curry

Actual vs perceived SA ACTUAL SA: Good SA Poor SA Ideal state Danger state Need to verify current SA Need new information Self-assessment “My SA is good” “My SA is poor”

Perception Integration (Comprehension) Projection (Endsley, 1995)

Strength of internal representation of item (“subjective certainty”) Number of items I Weak Strong

Strength of internal representation of item Number of items SA’ Perception Integration etc Weak Strong Probe: Perception x = True or False? Response: - T/F IB’’ PERFECTION!!

Strength of internal representation of item Number of items SA’ IB’’ Weak Strong True information False information Measure of separation between distributions (measure of SA - wider = better) Criterion adopted for accepting as true (“level of risk”) The SABRE method

Examples of probe statements: Perception The SARS virus appeared last winter.T/F Integration SARS reduced the number of air passengers.T/F Projection Fewer people will fly next winter.T/F

Hanover

A B C D

A B C D

A B C D X

General Perception Integration Projection A D Components of SA

CAUTION

Application of SABRE Quick and easy to administer Congruent with task Plain-language record of situation tested Can be used in experiments, field trials and post-hoc analysis Well received in trials Customer has control of situation evaluated

Summary of SABRE capabilities Provides quantitative data Dynamic measure of SA and information bias Analysis of components of SA Indicates when and why things go wrong