PHASE I VACCINATION TRIAL OF SYT-SSX JUNCTION PEPTIDE AND ITS HLA-A*2402 ANCHOR SUBSTITUTE IN PATIENTS WITH DISSEMINATED SYNOVIAL SARCOMA Kawaguchi S, Wada T, Nagoya S, Ida K, Sato Y, Torigoe T, Sato N, Ishii T, Tatezaki S, Yamashita T Sapporo Medical University Chiba Cancer Center Hospital
Synovial sarcoma
Survival rate Guillou L et al., J Clin Oncol, 2004
Peptide vaccination (MAGE-3) Peptide immunotherapy for malignant melanoma Coulie PG, Universite de Louvain, Brussels
Antigenic peptide Tumor cell T cell Dendritic cell Patient T cell Injection T cell Peptide immunotherapy
Gene T cell Protein Antigenic peptide Tumor cell Antigenic peptide HLA TCR Activation
Desirable antigenic peptide 1.Tumor specific expression 2. High affinity to HLA 3. Immunogenicity
Desirable antigenic peptide 1.Tumor specific expression 2. High affinity to HLA 3. Immunogenicity
TumorFusion gene Frequency (%) Synovial sarcoma SYT-SSX1 65 SYT-SSX2 35 Ewing sarcoma EWS-FLI1 85 EWS-ERG 5-10 Liposarcoma TLS-CHOP >95 RMS PAX3-FKHR >75 Clear cell sarcoma EWS-ATF1 >80 DFSP COL1A1-PDGFb >99 Specific fusion gene
Desirable antigenic peptide 1.Tumor specific expression 2. High affinity to HLA 3. Immunogenicity
HLA-A24-binding motif nd Portion Y, F, W, or M 9 th or 10 th Portion F, L, I, W, R, or K HLA-A24 Tumor cell T cell receptor T cell
SYTSSX (1, 2) ……… PQQRPYGYDQIMPKKPAEHAWTHRLRERK Y, W, K, R: HLA-A24 binding motif A : PYGYDQIMPK C : AWTHRLRER B : GYDQIMPKK D : AWTHRLRERK Peptides SYT-SSX peptides
EBVNA24F4.2ABCD Binding affinity to HLA-A24 SYT-SSX peptides
Desirable antigenic peptide 1.Tumor specific expression 2. High affinity to HLA 3. Immunogenicity
Reactivity to circulating T cells ◇◇ ◇◇ T cell (CD8) HLA/Peptide Tetramer FACS 1.17% HLA-A24-positive Synovial sarcoma patients: 16 Other sarcoma patients: 10 Healthy individuals: 10
Synovial sarcoma Other sarcomas Healthy Individuals SYT-SSX A SYT-SSX B SYT-SSX C+D Positive cells (%) Reactivity to circulating T cells
Induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) Peptide stimulation (SYT-SSX B) Mixed Culture Cr release assay 51 T cells Synovial sarcoma Cell line
HLA-A24 SYT-SSX ●Fuji (+) (+) ○HS-SY-II (+) (+) ■SW982-A24 (+) ( ) □K562 ( ) ( ) E/T ratio %Specific Lysis CTL induction Sato et al., J Immunol, 2002
SYT-SSX B peptide 1.Tumor specific expression 2. High affinity to HLA-A24 3. Immunogenicity
SYT-SSX SYTSSX T cell HLA-A24 SYT-SSX B Rationale ・・ PQQRPYGYDQIMPKKPA ・・・
SYT-SSX B peptide Synovial sarcoma cell T cell Dendritic cell Patient T cell Injection T cell Phase I clinical trial
To evaluate (i)Toxicity (ii) Immunological property (iii) Anti-tumor effect of SYT-SSX B peptide vaccine in patients with disseminated synovial sarcoma Purpose
Eligibility 1. Histologically diagnosed synovial sarcoma 2. SYT-SSX positive 3. HLA-A*2402 positive 4. Unresectable tumors 5. One month or more after chemotherapy
Protocol Peptide: SYT-SSX B: GYDQIMPKK Schedule: Every two weeks Dose: 0.1mg in 3 patients 1.0mg in 3 patients
1. Toxicity National Cancer Institute of Common Toxicity Criteria 2. Immunological property (i)Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) (ii)HLA-A*2402/peptide tetramer (iii) In vitro CTL induction 3. Anti-tumor effect CT scan Evaluation
Results
CaseAgeGenderDose No. of immunization 169M0.1mg1 232M0.1mg3 321F0.1mg6 421M1mg6 539F1mg6 Participants 626M1mg4
ToxicityDTH -- -- -- -- Fever (Grade1) - Toxicity and DTH Case -- 6
Before vaccinationAfter 1 st vac. After 6 th vac. HIV tetramer B tetramer Tetramer analysis (Case 4)
Case Pre-vac. 1 st vac. 3 rd vac. 6 th vac N.D N.D Tetramer analysis
Case Pre-vac. 1 st vac. 3 rd vac. 6 th vac. 2 FailureFailureSuccess ND 3 SuccessSuccessSuccess Failure 4 FailureSuccessSuccess ND 5 FailureSuccessFailure Failure 6 FailureFailureFailure ND CTL induction
May 15 June 18 Anti-tumor effect (Case 3)
Anti-tumor effect (Case 5) July 8July 22 Sept 16 Aug 19
Discussion
Clinical trials of fusion-gene peptides Tumor Peptide Adjuvant Remission SSClass I None0/6 ES Class IIL-2 (9x10 6 IU/m 2 ) 1/12 RMS Class I IL-2 (9x10 6 IU/m 2 ) 0/4 CMLClass I QS-21 5/14 Class II
Modification of peptide and protocol 1.Anchor motif substitution 2. Adjuvant and cytokine 3. Class II peptides 4. Protocol at the adjuvant setting
Tumor G D Q I M P K K Y HLA-A24 Anchor motif substitution SYT-SSX B peptide W ( tryptophan ) L ( leucine ) F ( phenylalanine ) I ( isoleucine )
%Specific Lysis Fuji HS-SYII SW982 K E/T=30 E/T=10 E/T=3 Fuji HS-SYII SW982 K562 B peptide K9I peptide CTL induction Ida et al., J Immunol, 2004
Before vaccinationAfter 1 st vaccination Vaccination of K9I peptide HIV tetramer B tetramer
1.The safety and efficacy of SYT-SSX B peptide were evaluated in 6 patients with disseminated synovial sarcoma. 2.A total of 16 vaccinations were carried out, resulting in (i) no serious adverse effects or DTH reactions, (ii) tumor dormancy in 1, (iii) increases in CTL in 3, and (iv) CTL induction from 4 patients. 3.The present trial demonstrated the safety and immunogenicity of the peptide. Subsequent trial using a modified peptide and adjuvants is currently underway. Conclusion