Star Forming Proto-Elliptical z>2 ? N.Arimoto (NAOJ) Subaru/Sup-Cam C.Ikuta (NAOJ) X.Kong (NAOJ) M.Onodera (Tokyo) K.Ohta (Kyoto) N.Tamura (Durham)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Digging into the past: Galaxies at redshift z=10 Ioana Duţan.
Advertisements

Formation of Globular Clusters in  CDM Cosmology Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan)
Kevin Bundy, Caltech The Mass Assembly History of Field Galaxies: Detection of an Evolving Mass Limit for Star-Forming Galaxies Kevin Bundy R. S. Ellis,
Kinematics/Dynamics  Chemistry/dust  Stellar populations  Searches for z ~ 6-7 « Hot » scientific researches at VLT in cosmology Mass Galaxy formation/gas.
9/19/2014 Claus Leitherer: Lyman Continuum Leakage 1 Lyman Continuum Leakage in the Local Universe Claus Sanch Tim Janice Sally Roderik Leitherer Borthakur.
Life Before the Fall: Group Galaxy Evolution Prior to Cluster Assembly Anthony Gonzalez (Florida) Kim-Vy Tran (CfA) Michelle Conbere (Florida) Dennis Zaritsky.
Searching for massive galaxy progenitors with GMASS (Galaxy Mass Assembly ultradeep Spectroscopic Survey) (a progress report) Andrea Cimatti (INAF-Arcetri)
Dark Halos of Fossil Groups and Clusters Observations and Simulations Ali Dariush, Trevor Ponman Graham Smith University of Birmingham, UK Frazer Pearce.
June 4, 2015Dusty2004 Spitzer Space TelescopeCen A Elliptical and (other) early-type galaxies T. Wiklind ESA/STScI.
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Mass determination Kauffmann et al. determined masses using SDSS spectra (Hdelta & D4000) Comparison with our determination: Relative.
Star-Formation in Close Pairs Selected from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Overview The effect of galaxy interactions on star formation has been investigated.
Gamma-ray Bursts in Starburst Galaxies Introduction: At least some long duration GRBs are caused by exploding stars, which could be reflected by colours.
Exploring the Stellar Populations of Early-Type Galaxies in the 6dF Galaxy Survey Philip Lah Honours Student h Supervisors: Matthew Colless Heath Jones.
Primeval Starbursting Galaxies: Presentation of “Lyman-Break Galaxies” by Mauro Giavalisco Jean P. Walker Rutgers University.
Exploring the Stellar Populations of Early-Type Galaxies in the 6dF Galaxy Survey Philip Lah Honours Student h Supervisors: Matthew Colless Heath Jones.
SFR and COSMOS Bahram Mobasher + the COSMOS Team.
A Wide Area Survey for High- Redshift Massive BzK Galaxies X.Kong, M.Onodera, C.Ikuta (NAOJ), K.Ohta (Kyoto), N.Tamura (Durham), A.Renzini, E.Daddi, L.
First Results from an HST/ACS Snapshot Survey of Intermediate Redshift, Intermediate X-ray Luminosity Clusters of Galaxies: Early Type Galaxies and Weak.
High Redshift Massive Galaxies (BzKs & EIS-Deep3a and COSMOS Xu KONG collaborators :
“ Testing the predictive power of semi-analytic models using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey” Juan Esteban González Birmingham, 24/06/08 Collaborators: Cedric.
C. Halliday, A. Cimatti, J. Kurk, M. Bolzonella, E. Daddi, M. Mignoli, P. Cassata, M. Dickinson, A. Franceschini, B. Lanzoni, C. Mancini, L. Pozzetti,
Dusty star formation at high redshift Chris Willott, HIA/NRC 1. Introductory cosmology 2. Obscured galaxy formation: the view with current facilities,
The Properties of LBGs at z>5 Matt Lehnert (MPE) Malcolm Bremer (Bristol) Aprajita Verma (MPE) Natascha Förster Schreiber (MPE) and Laura Douglas (Bristol)
Evolution of Galaxy groups Michael Balogh Department of Physics University of Waterloo.
Populations of Galaxies and their Formation at z < 7 Christopher J. Conselice (Caltech) Austin, October 18, 2003 Facing the Future: A Festival for Frank.
Dynamical state and star formation properties of the merging galaxy cluster Abell 3921 C. Ferrari 1,2, C. Benoist 1, S. Maurogordato 1, A. Cappi 3, E.
Massive galaxies at z > 1.5 By Hans Buist Supervisor Scott Trager Date22nd of june 2007.
Optical Spectroscopy of Distant Red Galaxies Stijn Wuyts 1, Pieter van Dokkum 2 and Marijn Franx 1 1 Leiden Observatory, P.O. Box 9513, 2300RA Leiden,
FMOS で探る Extremely Red Universe II. FMOS で探る Extremely Red Universe II. Extremely Red Universe Probed with FMOS Extremely Red Universe Probed with FMOS.
The Evolution of Quasars and Massive Black Holes “Quasar Hosts and the Black Hole-Spheroid Connection”: Dunlop 2004 “The Evolution of Quasars”: Osmer 2004.
Wide Field Imagers in Space and the Cluster Forbidden Zone Megan Donahue Space Telescope Science Institute Acknowledgements to: Greg Aldering (LBL) and.
Past, Present and Future Star Formation in High Redshift Radio Galaxies Nick Seymour (MSSL/UCL) 22 nd Nov Powerful Radio Galaxies.
Culling K-band Luminous, Massive Star Forming Galaxies at z>2 X.Kong, M.Onodera, C.Ikuta (NAOJ),K.Ohta (Kyoto), N.Tamura (Durham),A.Renzini, E.Daddi (ESO),
RADIO OBSERVATIONS IN VVDS FIELD : PAST - PRESENT - FUTURE P.Ciliegi(OABo), Marco Bondi (IRA) G. Zamorani(OABo), S. Bardelli (OABo) + VVDS-VLA collaboration.
Conference “Summary” Alice Shapley (Princeton). Overview Multitude of new observational, multi-wavelength results on massive galaxies from z~0 to z>5:
10/14/08 Claus Leitherer: UV Spectra of Galaxies 1 Massive Stars in the UV Spectra of Galaxies Claus Leitherer (STScI)
The Extremely Red Objects in the CLASH Fields The Extremely Red Galaxies in CLASH Fields Xinwen Shu (CEA, Saclay and USTC) CLASH 2013 Team meeting – September.
How Standard are Cosmological Standard Candles? Mathew Smith and Collaborators (UCT, ICG, Munich, LCOGT and SDSS-II) SKA Bursary Conference 02/12/2010.
The Environmental Effect on the UV Color-Magnitude Relation of Early-type Galaxies Hwihyun Kim Journal Club 10/24/2008 Schawinski et al. 2007, ApJS 173,
Naoyuki Tamura (University of Durham) The Universe at Redshifts from 1 to 2 for Early-Type Galaxies ~ Unveiling “Build-up Era” with FMOS ~
The European Extremely Large Telescope Studying the first galaxies at z>7 Ross McLure Institute for Astronomy, Edinburgh University.
The Star Formation Histories of Red Sequence Galaxies Mike Hudson U. Waterloo / IAP Steve Allanson (Waterloo) Allanson, MH et al 09, ApJ 702, 1275 Russell.
How do galaxies accrete their mass? Quiescent and star - forming massive galaxies at high z Paola Santini Roman Young Researchers Meeting 2009 July 21.
Major dry-merger rate and extremely massive major dry-mergers of BCGs Deng Zugan June 31st Taiwan.
Subaru Wide-Field Survey of M87 Globular Cluster Populations N.Arimoto (NAOJ) N.Tamura, R.Sharples (Durham) M.Onodera (Tokyo, NAOJ), K.Ohta(Kyoto) J.-C.Cuillandre.
Cosmos Survey PI Scoville HST 590 orbits I-band 2 deg. 2 !
A Steep Faint-End Slope of the UV LF at z~2-3: Implications for the Missing Stellar Problem C. Steidel ( Caltech ) Naveen Reddy (Hubble Fellow, NOAO) Galaxies.
Submm galaxies and EROs: Expectations for FMOS in the light of OHS observations Chris Simpson (University of Durham)
Clustering of BzK-selected galaxies in the COSMOS field Xu KONG collaborators : A. Renzini, E. Daddi, N. Arimoto, A. Cimatti , COSMOS.
A Wide Area Survey for High-Redshift Massive Galaxies Number Counts and Clustering of BzKs and EROs X.Kong, M.Onodera, C.Ikuta (NAOJ), K.Ohta (Kyoto),
联 合 天 体 物 理 中 心 Joint Center for Astrophysics The half-light radius distribution of LBGs and their stellar mass function Chenggang Shu Joint Center for.
David R. Law Hubble Fellow, UCLA The Physical Structure of Galaxies at z ~ John McDonald, CFHT Galaxies in the Distant Universe: Ringberg Castle.
Formation and evolution of early-type galaxies Pieter van Dokkum (Yale)
SWIRE view on the "Passive Universe": Studying the evolutionary mass function and clustering of galaxies with the SIRTF Wide-Area IR Extragalactic Survey.
Evidence for a Population of Massive Evolved Galaxies at z > 6.5 Bahram Mobasher M.Dickinson NOAO H. Ferguson STScI M. Giavalisco, M. Stiavelli STScI Alvio.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Competitive Science with the WHT for Nearby Unresolved Galaxies Reynier Peletier Kapteyn Astronomical Institute Groningen.
What can we learn from High-z Passive Galaxies ? Andrea Cimatti Università di Bologna – Dipartimento di Astronomia.
What is EVLA? Giant steps to the SKA-high ParameterVLAEVLAFactor Point Source Sensitivity (1- , 12 hr.)10  Jy1  Jy 10 Maximum BW in each polarization0.1.
Galaxy evolution in z=1 groups The Gemini GEEC2 survey Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
High Redshift Galaxies/Galaxy Surveys ALMA Community Day April 18, 2011 Neal A. Miller University of Maryland.
9 Gyr of massive galaxy evolution Bell (MPIA), Wolf (Oxford), Papovich (Arizona), McIntosh (UMass), and the COMBO-17, GEMS and MIPS teams Baltimore 27.
The Genesis and Star Formation Histories of Massive Galaxies Sept 27, 2004 P. J. McCarthy MGCT Carnegie Observatories.
Nature of Broad Line Region in AGNs Xinwen Shu Department of Astronomy University of Science and Technology of China Collaborators: Junxian Wang (USTC)
Epoch of Reionization  Cosmic Reionization: Neutral IGM ionized by the first luminous objects at 6 < z < 15 Evidence: CMB polarization (Komatsu+2009)
Lightcones for Munich Galaxies Bruno Henriques. Outline 1. Model to data - stellar populations and photometry 2. Model to data - from snapshots to lightcones.
Massive galaxies in massive datasets M. Bernardi (U. Penn)
Galaxy Populations in the Most Distant Clusters
Nobunari Kashikawa (National Astronomical Observatory of Japan)
Emanuele Daddi ESO K20 survey PI: A Cimatti (Arcetri) Collaborators:
Presentation transcript:

Star Forming Proto-Elliptical z>2 ? N.Arimoto (NAOJ) Subaru/Sup-Cam C.Ikuta (NAOJ) X.Kong (NAOJ) M.Onodera (Tokyo) K.Ohta (Kyoto) N.Tamura (Durham) VLT/VMOS A.Renzini (ESO) E.Daddi (ESO) A.Cimatti (Arcetri) T.Broadhurst (Hebrew)

Why z ~ 2? 1) A large fraction of the stars in the present- day universe formed ! 2) Bright QSO activity reached its peak ! 3) Rapidly star forming galaxies of compact and disordered morphologies became the normal Hubble sequence galaxies of the z<1 universe ! © Toho Co., Ltd.

Formation of Massive Galaxies Massive galaxies are the product of rather recent hierarchical merging of pre-existing disk galaxies taking place largely at z<1.5 with moderate SFRs (eg, cole et al. 2000). Mass Function Evolution (Baugh et al. 2002) Fully assembled massive galaxies with Ms>1E11Mo at z>2 are extremely rare.

Formation of Massive Galaxies Alternatively, massive galaxies formed at much higher redshifts (z>2-3), through a short and intense epoch of star formation, followed by passive evolution. Ages of Virgo Ellipticals Y.Yamada et al. (2004)

Observational Test Search for high-z Massive Systems Deep Spectroscopic Surveys of Field Galaxies selected in the K-band (Broadhurst et al. 1992) K20 Project (Daddi, Renzini, Cimatti et al.)

A New Population of near-IR bright, z ~ 2 Galaxies K>20 HST/ACS F435W, F850LP & K-band (VLT+ISAAC) A sample of 9 galaxies at 1.7<z<2.23 with bright K-band magnitudes 18.7<K<20 has recently been discovered (Daddi et al. 2003, astro-ph/ ).

Why New Population? Because 1)they lie in the redshift-desert at z ~ where no strong spectral features, 2) they are not LBGs, because UV continuum slope is too red, 3) they are not EROs, because R-K colours are often too blue. The existence of NIR Bright z ~ 2 Galaxies clearly outlines a major failure of semianalytical CDM modeling of high-z massive galaxies.

Nature of NIR Bright Galaxies 1)actively star forming galaxies (> Mo/yr) 2)irregular light distribution, clumpy SF regions, high detected asymmetries, ongoing mergers? 3) low light concentration similar to local starbursts and ULIRGs 4) old underlyings, half light radii ~ 6kpc (large)

z ~ 2? If high SFRs > 100 Mo/yr are really present, it is clear that in a few 100 Myr a full M* galaxy will be assembled. However, high SFRs prevent a fair mass estimate from the photometry. The galaxies appear significantly clustered, similar to EROs and local massive ellipticals. Are these galaxies massive early-type galaxies in the act of their formation?

Subaru/Sup-Cam Observation K20 52 arcmin^2 FIRES 20 arcmin^2 GOOD-South 160 arcmin^2 Subaru/Suprime-Cam Observations March 2-4, 2003, 0. ” 5-0. ” 7 seeing 1) BRIz ’ +JK 900 arcmin^2 Ks(AB)=22.6(5σ) 400 arcmin^2 z ’ (AB)=26.1, B(AB)=27.7(5σ) 2) BRIz ’ + K 900 arcmin^2 (Daddi-F) Ks(AB)=21.3(5σ) 500 arcmin^2 z ’ (AB)=25.4, B(AB)=27.0(5σ)

VLT/VMOS Observations New populations are easily identified photometrically. Targets: NewPops EROs PEs(z>1.5) FIRES(J-K>2.3) Field : Daddi-F ? We aim at determining redshifts, space densities, and clustering properties of a statistically significant populations of massive starburst galaxies at z ~ 2, such as NewPops, EROs, PEs, & FIRES, in total ~ VLT/VMOS 4 nights in January 2004

Clustering of z ~ 2 Galaxies New Pops & EROs (Daddi-F) New Pops & FIRES (Field-1)

Pilot Exploratory Programs in view of Subaru/FMOS A new population of galaxies appear to have high star formation rate (>100Mo/yr), irregular and possibly merging-like morphologies, large masses, and strong redshift clustering, suggesting that they are massive early-type galaxies in the act of major assembly episodes. 1) VLT/ISAAC NIR Spectroscopy 2.5n 2) Subaru/CISCO/OHS NIR Spectroscopy 4n

Crucial Questions 1) How massive are they? 2) How severe is the apparent conflict with the ΛCDM hierarchical model predictions? 4) What is their SFR? 5) Are they assembling by merging? 3) Are they early-type galaxies in formation?

Subaru/FMOS Observation Targeted Lines: [O II]λ3727, [O III]λ4959, 5007, Hα(λ6563 Å ), [N II]λλ6548, 6584 [S II]λ6717, and possibly Hβ(λ4861 Å ), in the near-IR domain for New Pops and other Galaxies (EROs, FIRES, LBGs) with 1.5<z<2.5. Key Words: Mass, SFR, Metallicity, Merging, AGN

SFRs and Reddening 1)Estimate reddening and SFRs from the observed emission line luminosities. The comparison of UV-band and Hα, [O II], [O III], and possibly Hβ based SFRs will allow an independent and more reliable estimate of the reddenning, thus corrected SFRs for our galaxies. If high SFRs (>100Mo/yr) will be confirmed, it is clear that in a few 100 Myr a full M* galaxy will be assembled.

Metallicity 2) Estimate metallicity of z ~ 2 starburst galaxies from R23 by using [O II], [O III] vs Hβ (or Hα by assuming intrinsic ratio of Hβ/Hα constant) as metallicity indicator. If these z ~ 2 starbursts are progenitors of z ~ 1 EROs and local ellipticals, their metallicity should be high, at least near-solar or more. Metallicity is a good indicator of stellar mass.

Dynamical Masses 3) Derive stringent limits on the dynamical masses of our galaxies, by measuring the intrinsic width of the Hα emission line, deriving in this way the velocity dispersion. Expected masses of our targets are order of one magnitude larger than the observed z ~2 LBGs (Erb et al. 2003). We will obtain Mdyn/L(K) to compare the Mdyn with stellar mass derived from UV-Submm SEDs.

Formation Scenario 5) Compare the masses with the predictions of different models of massive galaxy formation. Baugh et al (2000) predicted ~6 massive galaxies of Mstar=1E11Mo for 1.7<z<2.3 for our total field of 900 arcmin^2. Even a detection of single galaxy with mass larger than 1E11Mo would allow us to set stringent observational constraints on theoretical models of galaxy formation.

Stellar Populations 4) Derive stellar ages and metallicities by measuring line indices such as Hβ, Mgb, CN, G-band, Fe4383, Fe5270, Fe5335, Fe5406, Ca4227, from stacked spectra. In a current cosmology Ho=70km/s/Mpc, Ωm=0.3, Ω λ =0.7, the universe at z=2.3 is 2.8 Gyr old.

Merging? 6) Investigate the presence of merging systems with a help of HST/ACS images. Quite often a few distinct blobs are detected in UV. The secure detection of large velocity separations would give the first direct demonstration of assembling systems at z=2.

AGNs 7) Use [S II]λ6717/Hα and [N II]λ6548, 6584/Hα to check for the presence of AGNs. [N II]/Hα line ratio for abundance and ionization degree. We have XMM images of the fields. Our preliminary analysis shows that there are lots of New Pops detected in X-rays!