BPS First-To-Curtail/Last-To-Curtail Sub Team Conference Call October 05, 2011.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
2 Draft of proposed metrics for the WEQ BPS to conduct analysis and evaluation of the Parallel Flow Visualization pilot project. (PFV Pilot)
Advertisements

Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements NERC ORS Meeting Toronto, Ontario September 23-24, 2009 Jim.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2013.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
Parallel Flow Visualization and Flowgate Allocations Equity Concerns of Non-Market Transmission Owners Equity Concerns of Non-Market Transmission Owners.
First to Curtail – Last to Curtail Examples December 1 – 2, 2010 (Revised based on Requests/Suggestions During Review) 1.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair May 17 th, 2012.
First to Curtail – Last to Curtail Examples December 1 - 2,
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 23, 2012 DRAFT.
Parallel Flow Visualization/Mitigation Proposal
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair November 9 th, 2011.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update IDCWG October 12 th, 2011.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair September 13 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 26, 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair April 4 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 2, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 1, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2012.
WECC - Addressing Commercial Practices Ed Beck Chair, Market Interface Committee.
Western Electricity Coordinating Council Market Interface Committee Report to the WECC Board of Directors December 6-7, 2007 Robert D. Schwermann MIC Chair.
Interchange Scheduling and Accounting Subcommittee Update October 2008 Gary Nolan ISAS Vice-Chair.
FEBRUARY 27, 2013 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS Parallel Flow Visualization Overview 1.
IDCWG Update. September 2013 December 2013 February 2014 April 2014 July 2014 Data Submission WEQ 008 Assessment CO 283 Report GTL CO’s Draft CO’s Development.
Element Definition Process Presented by Peak to ECC Task Force April 28, 2015.
NERC Congestion Management Congestion Management Option 3 Vendor Meeting Julie Pierce – NERC IDCWG Chair.
2-Tier Firm Curtailment: First-to-Curtail & Last-to-Curtail Examples NAESB BPS: August 9-10,
Business Practices Subcommittee
Business Practices Subcommittee Update May 4, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 18, 2014.
Copyright © The OWASP Foundation Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike.
Insert: Title of Improvement Read Out Date:. 2 Objectives for Today’s Session Share results of improvement effort Demonstrate fact-base, analytical approach.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 24, 2015.
Flowgate Allocation Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Parallel Flow Visualization Project NERC ORS Meeting May 4, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting October 20, 2015.
Transmission Congestion Management – IDC Granularity Option 3A Larry Kezele and Jeff Norman June 28, 2005 NERC/NAESB TLR Subcommittee.
NAESB WHOLESALE ELECTRIC QUADRANT BUSINESS PRACTICES SUBCOMMITTEE ACTIVITIES UPDATE TO JOINT ELECTRIC SCHEDULING SUBCOMMITTEE JANUARY 5, 2012 BY ED SKIBA.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
2013 Wind Conference. Congestion Management & Communication Processes CJ Brown.
Generator Prioritization Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update Yasser Bahbaz IDCWG Chair BPS Update September 13 th, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting April 29, 2014.
BPS Two-Tier Curtailment Sub Team Sep 23, 2011 Conference Call Sub team members- – Chris Advena, Art Wolfe, Mike ColbyPJM – Nelson Muller, OATI – Steve.
ECC Task Force Webinar November 13, Peak Anti-Trust Statement Meeting Minutes (June and Sept) Phase 1A Progress Phase 1A External Entity Testing.
ECC Task Force Webinar September 3, Peak Anti-Trust Statement Phase 1A Update webSAS Integration PSE Access Peak and the Task Force Next Steps.
NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz– IDCWG Chair January 5 th, 2016.
NAESB BPS “First-To-Curtail/Last-To-Curtail” Sub Team October 07, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting August 18, 2015.
Parking Lot Item 19. BPS Bert Bressers 10/31/2011 Firm rights of resources that have a Firm priority to what load (Sink area granularity)
WEQ Executive Committee Contract Path Task Force Additional Issues Related To Contract Path Management ( WEQ and WEQ )
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 16, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 23, 2016.
Planning Coordinator - Gap Resolution Team Lorissa Jones – GRT Chair PCC Update March 2016 W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
NAESB BPS UPDATE TO EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AUGUST 21, 2012 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION PROJECT 1.
1 Parallel Flow Visualization Goals NAESB BPS Meeting September 15-16, 2010.
-- Presentation from PWG -- Profile ID Assignment and Annual Review Process November 17, 2005.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update
Consolidated EIM Initiatives from 2017 Roadmap Issue Paper
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Impact Calculation – BPS Issues
Mgr. Interconnection Reliability Initiatives
Review of After-the-Fact (ATF) Tagging Criteria Scheduler’s Meeting May 24, 2016 Raymond will ask the audience what their expectations are in regard to.
Review of After-the-Fact (ATF) Tagging Criteria Scheduler’s Meeting May 24, 2016 Raymond will ask the audience what their expectations are in regard to.
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and WEQ OASIS/BPS Subcommittees
Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Overview
NERC Congestion Management
Alignment of Part 4B with ISAE 3000
Presentation transcript:

BPS First-To-Curtail/Last-To-Curtail Sub Team Conference Call October 05, 2011

Status Check as of Sep 30, 2011 Action Item 54 – 3 of 5 issues completed – COMPLETE – Translate Guidance Document (weqbps080911a17.docx) in PFV Whitepaper (Permanent Solution White Paper - Action Item 54_ docx) – COMPLTE – Cross check guidance document with [Chris Advena] Whitepaper (weqbps080911w10.docx ) – COMPLETE – Business Rules Transparency Matrix for First-To-Curtail/Last-To-Curtail (Permanent Solution White Paper - Action Item 54_ docx) – WORK IN PROGRESS – Parking Lot Item # 24 – WORK IN PROGRESS – Reliability concerns around First-To-Curtail/Last-To-Curtail (articulated in weq_bps080911w11.docx) WORK IN PROGRESS - Verify definition of “First to Curtail” is consistent with PFV Whitepaper WORK IN PROGRESS – Parking Lot Item # 19 WORK IN PROGRESS - Discuss and clarify Parking Lot Items 19 and 24

Oct 5 discussion Parking Lot # 24 – – When coordination agreement exists, transactions will be last to curtail – To the extent all TSPs are evaluating/granting requests ( for drive in, drive out, wheel through) using consistently honor 3 rd party flowgate and any TSP has considered the impacted flowgate in evaluating/granting the request, the tag should be last to curtail. – COMPLTE – PARKING LOT ITEM # 24 (by itself).

Oct 05 “Reliability Concerns” discussions – Question 1: Is this a NERC Issue or a BPS Issue? – This discussion led in to a related discussion of the granularity of GTL calculation and what IDC can support and/or will be able to support in future – Subteam prefers that GTL impact calculation should be more granular that current IDC – Subteam prefers that BPS should have coordinated discussion and problem solution with NERC IDCWG and/or ORS – At present, GTL is only considered in the forward direction, however, the net GTL impact should ideally include the net of the forward and reverse (aka counterflow) component. Tags are only considered as unidirectional impact. This treatment of GTL in forward direction only can raise potential equity and operational issue(s) – Sub team agrees that GTL should be netted, but given the time constraints, we think netting is a large/complex project that deserves consideration as a phase II improvement and/or additional scope. Also consider netting of tags at that point. – NERC groups can give us decision/guidance of granularity and we can develop business rules that compliment NERC’s guidance – Comparability issue – PTP and GTL should receive comparable treatment under first to curtail / last to curtail – SUB TEAM CONCLUDING STATEMENT – Hold coordinated discussions with appropriate NERC groups. BPS to decide on merit of this statement and consider path forward.

Oct 05 – Subteam is done with “reliability concerns”

SUB TEAM CONCLUSION ON DEFINITION OF “FIRST TO CURTAIL” - “First-To-Curtail” are those off-path firm transactions and GTL subject to curtailment due to a lack of coordination agreement between the effected TSPs. “Last –to-Curtail” – only applies to on-path firm transactions and GTL, and those off-path firm transactions and GTL that do not fall within First- to-Curtail THIS ITEM IS COMPLETE FOR SUBTEAM.

FRIDAY OCT 07 – BERT BRESSER’s POWER POINT – STEVE SANDERS’ HOMEWORK FROM SEP 30 – ED DAVIS DATED OCT 05