Quality and Gatekeeping Use Cases for the OOR Ken Baclawski and Máximo Gurméndez College of Computer and Information Science Northeastern University.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Open Ontology Repository Ken Baclawski College of Computer and Information Science Northeastern University.

Advertisements

1 Open Ontology Repository Planning Meeting for Ontology repositories: approaches, technologies, collaboration Ken Baclawski June 15, 2009.

Dr. Leo Obrst MITRE Information Semantics Information Discovery & Understanding Command & Control Center February 6, 2014February 6, 2014February 6, 2014.

OOR Use Cases – Take 3 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Discussion Ken Baclawski and Todd Schneider April 1, 2010.

OOR Federation Dan Cerys Jim Chatigny Mike Dean OOR Panel on Coordinating our OOR Software Development 19 February 2010 OOR Panel on Coordinating our OOR.

1 Ontolog OOR Use Case Review Todd Schneider 1 April 2010 (v 1.2)

1 Ontolog Open Ontology Repository Review 19 February 2009.

1 Summary Slides from Enhancing Organism Based Disease Knowledge Using Biological Taxonomy, and Environmental Ontologies Ken Baclawski Northeastern University.

OOR: Vision vs. Current State Mike Dean Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel on OOR Sandbox and OOR Requirements - Comparative Analysis 15 October 2009.

August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 1 Ontology Repository Research Issues Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Discussion Ken Baclawski August 6, 2009.

Coordinating our OOR Software Development Mike Dean OOR Panel on Coordinating our OOR Software Development 19 February 2010.

1 OOR in the Classroom An Experience Report Ken Baclawski Northeastern University.

Copyright © 2007 Vangent, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Example of OOR Architecture Open Ontology Repository Architecture – Some Considerations April 28-29,

Presentation by Priyanka Sawarkar

MOSS 2007 Document Management Adam McCarthy 1 st April 2009.

Ontology Summit Website Development (b) the underlying technology Ken Baclawski College of Computer and Information Science Northeastern University 28-Mar-2013.

Cloud platforms Lead to Open and Universal access for people with Disabilities and for All WP Federating repositories of Solutions.

Direction of Proposals for New Edition (E3) of ISO/IEC 11179

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY The Web Service Catalog Presentation to the SOA-COI Meeting Lico Galindo, OIC April 14, 2010.

CLAG 2004 – April/041 A Workflow-based Architecture for e- Learning in the Grid Luiz A. Pereira, Fábio A. Porto, Bruno Schulze, Rubens N. Melo

PAWN Progress July 06, Overview of changes New flexible environment for setting up and managing interactions between producers and the archive Domains.

Chapter 1: Overview of Workflow Management Dr. Shiyong Lu Department of Computer Science Wayne State University.

Information Architecture Donna Maurer Usability Specialist.

Distributed Software Development

CSCI ClearQuest 1 Rational ClearQuest Michel Izygon - Jim Helm.

Final Report on MFI & MDR Harmonization Hajime Horiuchi May 2010 SC32WG2 N1425.

1 The planned use of DDI 3.0 within a German Research Data Center IASSIST, Session “Tools and Implementations of DDI 3.0”, May 27, 2009 Dana Müller.

Page 1 LAITS Laboratory for Advanced Information Technology and Standards 9/6/04 Briefing on Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC)’s Web Services (OWS) Initiative.

DATA FOUNDATION TERMINOLOGY WG 4 th Plenary Update THE PLUM GOALS This model together with the derived terminology can be used Across communities and stakeholders.

1 Carlos Rueda, Paul Alexander, John Graybeal Marine Metadata Interoperability Project (MMI) Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI) The MMI Registry.

Distributed Software Development VLab project plan.

Ontology Summit2007 Survey Response Analysis -- Issues Ken Baclawski Northeastern University.

IMDB Registration of Survey Variables Dec 19, 2005.

Metadata Registries Workshop April 15, 1998 Slide 1 of 20 ANSI X Douglas D. Mann Stewardship Naming & Identification Classification.

Chapter 1: Overview of Workflow Management Dr. Shiyong Lu Department of Computer Science Wayne State University.

The Final Study Period Report on MFI 6: Model registration procedure SC32WG2 Meeting, Sydney May 26, 2008 H. Horiuchi, Keqing He, Doo-Kwon Baik SC32WG2.

Example of OOR Architecture Open Ontology Repository Architecture – Some Considerations March, 2008 Dr. Ravi Sharma Senior Enterprise Architect Technology.

South Africa Case Study Update Matile Malimabe Executive Manager: Standards Acting Executive Manager: Data Management & Technology.

1 Open Ontology Repository: Architecture and Interfaces Ken Baclawski Northeastern University 1.

Information Asset Registries of Latvia Secretariat of e-government affairs Riga | 26 th October, 2007.

Supporting Researchers and Institutions in Exploiting Administrative Databases for Statistical Purposes: Istat’s Strategy G. D’Angiolini, P. De Salvo,

10/24/09CK The Open Ontology Repository Initiative: Requirements and Research Challenges Ken Baclawski Todd Schneider.

Leo Obrst, Fabian Neuhaus MITRE, NIST An Open Ontology Repository: Rationale, Expectations & Requirements Session.

Our scenario Geographically distributed communities of users Diverse users: ontology developers and software engineers.

"Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?” "That depends a good deal on where you want to get to," said the Cat. -Lewis Carroll: Alice’s.

ESIP Semantic Web Products and Services ‘triples’ “tutorial” aka sausage making ESIP SW Cluster, Jan ed.

Principles of Computer Security: CompTIA Security + ® and Beyond, Third Edition © 2012 Principles of Computer Security: CompTIA Security+ ® and Beyond,

Portal Update Plan Ashok Adiga (512)

1 Registry Services Overview J. Steven Hughes (Deputy Chair) Principal Computer Scientist NASA/JPL 17 December 2015.

Software Configuration Management (SCM) Source: Pressman, R., Software Engineering: A Practitioner ’ s Approach. Boston: McGraw Hill, Inc., 2005; Ghezzi,

1 Ontolog OOR-BioPortal Comparative Analysis Todd Schneider 15 October 2009.

Ontology Evaluation, Metrics, and Metadata in NCBO BioPortal Natasha Noy Stanford University.

CPSC 372 John D. McGregor More EPF Module 2 Session 4.

Joint UNECE/Eurostat/OECD work session on statistical metadata (METIS) APRIL 2006Mar Blanco Frías STATISTICAL METADATA MODEL DEVELOPED IN SPAIN:CURRENT.

1 Developing an Ontology of Ontologies for OOR Preparation for Ontology Summit 2008 Panel Discussion April 10, 2008 Barry Smith and Michael Gruninger.

Collaboration in CDR Erik Brown Unisys Corporation September 19, 2006.

OOI Cyberinfrastructure and Semantics OOI CI Architecture & Design Team UCSD/Calit2 Ocean Observing Systems Semantic Interoperability Workshop, November.

VOX Project Tanya Levshina. 05/17/2004 VOX Project2 Presentation overview Introduction VOX Project VOMRS Concepts Roles Registration flow EDG VOMS Open.

1 Developing an Ontology of Ontologies for OOR Ontology Summit 2008 April 28-29, 2008 Michael Gruninger and Pat Hayes.

Empowering the Knowledge Worker End-User Software Engineering in Knowledge Management Witold Staniszkis The 17th International.

Metadata requirements for archiving structured data Alice Born Statistics Canada Joint UNECE/Eurostat/OECD Work Session on Statistical Metadata (9-11 April.

CPSC 872 John D. McGregor Session 13 Process. Specification and design problem solution specification implementation specification.

Learning Technology Interoperability Standards Lorna M. Campbell and Boon Low CETIS and the University of Strathclyde LMC, SURF Presentation, April 2002.

Witold Staniszkis Empowering the Knowledge Worker End-User Software Engineering in Knowledge Management Witold Staniszkis

Using E-Business Suite Attachments

The GEMBus Architecture and Core Components

TPM and TPM Security Technologies

Report on Eighth Open Forum on Metadata Registries, Berlin, April 2005

Austrian Statistical Datawarehouse (sDWH)

Ken Baclawski OOR Development Meeting 19 February 2010

Presentation transcript:

Quality and Gatekeeping Use Cases for the OOR Ken Baclawski and Máximo Gurméndez College of Computer and Information Science Northeastern University

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 2 Motivation Quality is a major concern  Emphasized at the Ontology Summit 2008  Ontologies are similar to standards and publications  A mechanism for review is necessary Gatekeeping  Ensures minimum level of quality  Allows for many policies and workflows

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 3 Sources of Requirements and Use Cases ISO 11179: Metadata Repository (MDR) XMDR Project: Extended MDR Ontology Summit 2008  Several sessions devoted to requirements  Wiki page for requirements and use cases  What are the requirements?

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 4 Management Requirements Version management Configuration management Provenance and other metadata Metadata validation/authentication  Related to policy issues Ontology ownership and access control

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 5 Administration and Policy Issues Gatekeeping policies and enforcement  Overall policies or left to individual repositories Policy-making bodies  How are they constituted?  How can they interoperate?

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 6 Development of OOR Use Cases Consulted existing examples Assignment in software engineering course Classified all of the examples Developed Use Case Description Ontology Developed OOR use cases as instances of UCDO Available at

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 7 Classification of Use Cases Administer user authorizations and privileges Assign identifiers Define workflows and policies Federate OOR instances Harmonize and map ontologies Publicize ontologies Query metadata Register ontologies Review and evaluate ontologies

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 8 Use Case Description Ontology

April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 9 Prototype Implementation Experimental Web Services Based ISO Foundations JBPM as Workflow Engine

Prototype: User Hierarchies April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 10 Accreditor Registrar Steward Submitter User

Prototype: Process Definitions April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 11

Prototype: Sample Scenario April 1, 2010 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Use Cases Take 3 12 Registrar uploads process definition: “Stewards validates model before it becomes a standard” Submitter uploads new model (Status=PENDING) Workflow Engine notifies Steward (according to process definition) Steward Validates Model (Form Task) Workflow Engine Modifies Status (Status=STANDARD)