Seminar I General research ethics Group 2 Chapter 4 – Handling of research material Ludo, Berrit, TJ, André, Yanran.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SWEDISH AGENCY FOR ECONOMIC AND REGIONAL GROWTH 1 LEARNING through ongoing EVALUATION -Ongoing evaluation of the eight ERDF programs and in major strategic.
Advertisements

Joint Degree Programmes: QA across national borders – ideas and strategies Nick Harris Quality Assurance Agency for HE UK.
Module 1 Introduction to SP. What’s in Module 1  Who are the stakeholders?  Levels of engagement  Participation as human and legal rights  Benefits.
Child Safeguarding Standards
Conservation District Supervisor Accreditation Module 6: Responsibilities and Duties of A Supervisor.
Ethics – Group Project Andreas Sembrant Mahdad Davari Muneeb Khan Nikos Nikoleris.
Joshua C. Farley University of Vermont Community Development and Applied Economics Gund Institute for Ecological Economics sustainability science.
1 Ch. 3: Becoming an Ethical Researcher (pp )
ICS 417: The ethics of ICT 4.2 The Ethics of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in Business by Simon Rogerson IMIS Journal May 1998.
Copyright by Paradigm Publishing, Inc. INTRODUCTION TO BUSINESS CHAPTER 2 Business Ethics and Social Responsibility.
- Union Governance Training - Session 1.2 Conflicts of interest.
CHAPTER 3 THE ETHICS AND POLITICS OF SOCIAL RESEARCH.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم. THE TITLE “INTRODUCTION”
1 SPIRIT Silicon Prairie Initiative on Robotics in Information Technology Engineering Ethics.
©2007 Prentice Hall Organizational Behavior: An Introduction to Your Life in Organizations Chapter 19 OB is for Life.
Ethics and Social Responsibility
UNIT 2: CONTEXT. Chapter 3: Ethics & Social Responsibility.
On a piece of paper… In what ways do large corporations justify an apparent conflict of interest between what it produces and its socially responsible.
DO NOW: Write down 2 ways science has affected society?
Section 2: Science as a Process
An introduction to career development Presented by – Date –
The importance of DART for funding agencies Dr. Ingrid Kissling-Näf.
1 Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 A strategic view.
Chapter 8 Business ethics and social responsibility
Guidance for AONB Partnership Members Welsh Member Training January 26/
The Audit Process Tahera Chaudry March Clinical audit A quality improvement process that seeks to improve patient care and outcomes through systematic.
The Professions and Professional Reliance Objectives Pillars Workshops – March 2009.
INFO4990 IT Research Methods Lecture on Research Ethics (Alan Fekete, based in part on slides by Judy Kay)
Group 3.  Non specific mores for crediting discoveries. It seems only ethical that the person who generated the hypothesis and proved it with experimental.
Concept #8.  How do you think your employer will expect you to behave?
Chapter 5 Managing Responsibly and Ethically Copyright © 2016 Pearson Canada Inc. 5-1.
Case Study: Medical Research Jillian Cudmore Mallory Anne Andrea Currie Amy DeBaie.
3 – 5 years Research oriented Basis for academic careers Individual programs 2 Dr. rer. nat, Dr.-Ing., Dr. rer. pol. … :
EDPQS in 10 minutes: Overview of European Drug Prevention Quality Standards (EDPQS) With financial support from the Drug Prevention and Information Programme.
Swedish Society for Nature Conservation Water framework directive is a European law which aims at good water status in Europe. The law was taken in 2000.
Chapter 4 Ethics and Social Responsibility. MGMT 321 – Chapter 4 Ethics The inner-guiding moral principles, values, and beliefs that people use to decide.
Business Ownership and Control
Strategic Planning Workshop 2 Environmental Scan Stakeholder Engagement SWOT Analysis.
United Nations Education, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation Education for sustainable development aims to help people to develop the attitudes, skills.
Climate Generation Day 3 Practical Stakeholder and community engagement.
An ethical problem in science Hwei-yen Andres Lucie Murielle Jakub Valerie Eryn.
Test 2 Take Home. Take home portion 1. Position paper on the Pharmaceutical Industry Discuss the major issues brought up in class. The paper should not.
Researching your contemporary issue From How to Write an Effective Special Study Dodson, Jarvis & Melhuish.
1 [INSERT SPEAKER NAME DATE & LOCATION HERE] Ethics of Tuberculosis Prevention, Care and Control MODULE 5: INFORMATION COUNSELLING AND THE ROLE OF CONSENT.
Moral problem Accept questionable funding source? Group 3 Senad Apelfröjd Bojan Brodic Reinert Karlsen Ola Eriksson Luka Supraha.
Definition of Public Health Public health is the science and art of organized societal efforts to ensure [and create] the conditions for the highest possible.
PRESENTATION TO PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON WATER AFFAIRS AND FORESTRY Cindy Damons 28 May 2008 The role of municipalities in managing and giving effect to.
What is Facilitation? Facilitation is the process of taking a group through learning or change in a way that encourages all members of the group to participate.
Participatory Development. Participatory Development-PD Participatory Development seeks to engage local populations in development projects or programs.
Setting and Maintaining Standards of Behaviour David Fishel, Positive Solutions
Project Organizing Helen Hill MA MFT. Communication Activities Increase Awareness Increase Knowledge Change Attitudes Reinforce Attitudes Maintain Interest.
In the ideal world… Transportation planning addresses NEPA principles. Collaboration/involvement starts in transportation planning. Planning leads to early.
European Patients’ Academy on Therapeutic Innovation Ethical and practical challenges of organising clinical trials in small populations.
MEDICAL LAW Medical law means the area of law relating to the legal rights and obligations of the medical care providers as well as receivers, i.e. patients.
Seminar II Group 6 Per Fors Luimar Correa Filho Zhen Qiu Fengzhen Sun.
RCUK cross-Council research themes - an overview.
Ch. 5 Research collaboration Group 3: Samar Amini Kaycee Okoli Beatriz Montano Tobias Mattsson.
Seminar 2 IP Right Between Academia and Industry Xubiao Peng Magnus Jobs Shakila Bint Reyaz José Pérez-Loya.
Communities, Protected Areas and Prior Informed Consent Anne M. Perrault Center for International Environmental Law.
 Know how to identify and scrutinise appropriate HR data sources  Be able to conduct small scale research and analyse the findings  Be able to draw.
Ethics course seminar 1 Group 5
Chapter 6 Publishing research results
New challenges for archives in Iceland
Handling of research material Seminar I, Chapter 4
Marine conservation and ecotourism
Handling of research material
Optimist International Leadership Development
Seminar I: Chapter 5 Funding dilemma
Human Participants Research
Ethics of technology and science --Chapter 4: Handling of research materials Group 2 Patrice Godonou, Magnus Hedlund, Jun Luo,
Presentation transcript:

Seminar I General research ethics Group 2 Chapter 4 – Handling of research material Ludo, Berrit, TJ, André, Yanran

Summary of the chapter Handling of research data? –Secrecy / anonymity / confidentiality How to protect sources? How do protection of sources and obligations towards the public collide? How much can researchers promise?

Problem / case: Collection of data from a highly endangered species. A disclosure of location data would give poachers directions on where to find individuals. This would bring the species closer to extinction. It is, however, necessary to publish your findings in order to satisfy obligations towards the funding body, and to share your findings with the scientific community, public, etc.

Solution: In order to protect the species, who needs to know that it still exists and where? Is it really necessary to publish to the general public? => NO. We share with: Selected conservation groups/ agencies Other researchers working on the species => Conservation is more important than advancement of the personal career.

Will there be any ethical problems or conflicts in the context, in the organisation or in the group where your decision will be applied or your solution will be used (e.g. your research findings)? People of different research stages might have different ambitions and may need to publish the data in order to advance their career. E.g. PhD student vs P.I.

Will your decision or solution cause any ethical problems or conflicts? Yes, the general public is not being informed A PhD-student e.g. might have problems earning their degree

Are there any alternatives to your solution? Try publication with very vague locations (might not be accepted by journal) Play with the spectrum of whom you inform: Funding body Local population Publish with full details and hope for the best

What groups, individuals, organisations, etc., will in any way be affected by or have a stake in the development, use, application or mere existence of your decision and solution? (Including Society at large and the environment.) Everyone, even the target species Research group – publication record Funding body – transparency Local population – tourism

What values, interests, duties, standpoints and attitudes are involved in the use of your solution and of the possible alternatives? Conservation (potentially highest good) vs Public access of scientific knowledge What effects will your solution (and the alternatives) have on each of these values? What are the strengths/possibilities and the weaknesses/risks of each solution to each value? Will these solutions fit certain values and conflict with others? What values and how?

What will you do to make sure that the use of the solution will be optimal with regards to ethical aspects? For instance, adapt the design of the product, use of research methods, cooperation with industry, information to stakeholders, etc.? How exactly are you going to succeed with this? Via control of access to the information Problem: Need to find a way to back up the PhD student and ensure his earning of recognition