Elizabeth Stanway (UW-Madison) Andrew Bunker (Exeter) Star Forming Galaxies at z>5: Properties and Implications for Reionization With: Richard Ellis (Caltech)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Current Topics: Lyman Break Galaxies - Lecture 5 Current Topics Lyman Break Galaxies Dr Elizabeth Stanway
Advertisements

Probing the End of Reionization with High-redshift Quasars Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona Mar 18, 2005, Shanghai Collaborators: Becker, Gunn, Lupton,
Motivation 40 orbits of UDF observations with the ACS grism Spectra for every source in the field. Good S/N continuum detections to I(AB) ~ 27; about 30%
Lyman-α Galaxies at High Redshift James E. Rhoads (Space Telescope Science Institute) with Sangeeta Malhotra, Steve Dawson, Arjun Dey, Buell Jannuzi, Emily.
End of Cosmic Dark Ages: Observational Probes of Reionization History Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona New Views Conference, Dec 12, 2005 Collaborators:
The Galaxy Evolution Science Case for a Large Ground-based Telescope Betsy Gillespie December 4, 2002 Grateful acknowledgements to: Arjun Dey’s “Galaxy.
15 years of science with Chandra– Boston 20141/16 Faint z>4 AGNs in GOODS-S looking for contributors to reionization Giallongo, Grazian, Fiore et al. (Candels.
Kevin Bundy, Caltech The Mass Assembly History of Field Galaxies: Detection of an Evolving Mass Limit for Star-Forming Galaxies Kevin Bundy R. S. Ellis,
Physical Properties of Spectroscopically-Confirmed z>6 Galaxies By Charles Griffin With special thanks to Dr. Eiichi Egami, and Dr. Benjamin Clément NASA.
Collaborators: E. Egami, X. Fan, S. Cohen, R. Dave, K. Finlator, N. Kashikawa, M. Mechtley, K. Shimasaku, and R. Windhorst.
A Bolometric Approach To Galaxy And AGN Evolution. L. L. Cowie Venice 2006 (primarily from Wang, Cowie and Barger 2006, Cowie and Barger 2006 and Wang.
September 6— Starburst 2004 at the Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge Constraints on Lyman continuum flux escaping from galaxies at z~3 using VLT.
Downsizing & Galaxy Formation 2 nd Mitchell Symposium - April 2006 P. McCarthy OCIW Gemini Deep Deep Survey Team.
AGN and Quasar Clustering at z= : Results from the DEEP2 + AEGIS Surveys Alison Coil Hubble Fellow University of Arizona Chandra Science Workshop.
The Near Infrared Background Excess and Star Formation in the HUDF Rodger Thompson Steward Observatory University of Arizona.
N HST ACS UDF Rychard Bouwens & Garth Illingworth Galaxies and Structures through Cosmic Times Luminosity function and SFRs at z=6-10: Galaxy Buildup in.
Exploring the High-z Frontier — Galaxies at z  6 and beyond Haojing Yan (Carnegie Observatories) CCAPP/OSU Seminar April 8, 2008.
Galaxies at High Redshift and Reionization Bunker, A., Stanway, E., Ellis, R., Lacy, M., McMahon, R., Eyles, L., Stark D., Chiu, K. 2009, ASP Conference.
Post GP-WMAP Reionization: the morning after We need quantitative measures of Epoch of reionization (Z reion ) Neutral fractions Volume fraction of ionized/neutral.
The Properties of LBGs at z>5 Matt Lehnert (MPE) Malcolm Bremer (Bristol) Aprajita Verma (MPE) Natascha Förster Schreiber (MPE) and Laura Douglas (Bristol)
Masami Ouchi (Space Telescope Science Institute) for the SXDS Collaboration Cosmic Web Made of 515 Galaxies at z=5.7 Kona 2005 Ouchi et al ApJ, 620,
Andy Bunker(AAO), Laurence Eyles, Kuenley Chiu (Univ. of Exeter, UK), Elizabeth Stanway (Bristol), Daniel Stark, Richard Ellis (Caltech) Mark Lacy (Spitzer),
Cosmological Reionization by Early Galaxies Brant E. Robertson, Richard S. Ellis, James S. Dunlop, Ross J. McLure&Daniel P. Stark, 'Early star- forming.
Large Area Survey of Lyman Alpha Emitters Zheng Yale Center for Astronomy and Astrophysics Yale/WIYN One Degree Imager Survey Workshop Oct 3rd, 2009.
Z > 6 Surveys Represent the Current Frontier Motivation: - census of earliest galaxies (z=6,  =0.95 Gyr) - contribution of SF to cosmic reionization -
Hubble’s Slitless Spectroscopy Patrick McCarthy – Carnegie Observatories HST III Venice, October
Current Topics: Lyman Break Galaxies - Lecture 4 Current Topics Lyman Break Galaxies Dr Elizabeth Stanway
Masami Ouchi (STScI) Progress of the Wide-Field Deep Surveys for Galaxies at z=3-9.
Luminosity and Mass functions in spectroscopically-selected groups at z~0.5 George Hau, Durham University Dave Wilman (MPE) Mike Balogh (Waterloo) Richard.
10/14/08 Claus Leitherer: UV Spectra of Galaxies 1 Massive Stars in the UV Spectra of Galaxies Claus Leitherer (STScI)
1 VVDS: Towards a complete census of star formation at 1.4
Spectroscopic Studies of z~5.7 and z~6.5 Galaxies: Implications for Reionization Spectroscopic Studies of z~5.7 and z~6.5 Galaxies: Implications for Reionization.
Ranga-Ram Chary, Oct ’08 The First Billion Years of Galaxy Evolution Ranga-Ram Chary Spitzer Science Center/Planck Data Center California Institute of.
Observational Properties of z~6 Galaxies Rychard J. Bouwens UCSC Special thanks to Roderik Overzier, Mauro Giavalisco, Haojing Yan for helping me prepare.
Surveying the Universe with SNAP Tim McKay University of Michigan Department of Physics Seattle AAS Meeting: 1/03 For the SNAP collaboration.
Sackler DSI Trustees: 2001, Aug, 01Richard McMahon ( 1 DAZLE: Dark Ages “Z” Lyman Explorer (visiting a Time when Galaxies are Young)
High-Redshift Galaxies in Cluster Fields Wei Zheng, Larry Bradley, and the CLASH high-z search group.
1 Narrow-Band Imaging surveys at z=7.7 with WIRCam (CFHT) and HAWK-I (VLT) J.-G. Cuby (LAM) Collaborators : B. Clément (LAM), P. Hibon (KIAS) J.Willis.
MMT Science Symposium1 “false-color” keV X-ray image of the Bootes field Thousands of AGNs in the 9.3 square degree Bootes field * X-ray and infrared.
Naoyuki Tamura (University of Durham) The Universe at Redshifts from 1 to 2 for Early-Type Galaxies ~ Unveiling “Build-up Era” with FMOS ~
The European Extremely Large Telescope Studying the first galaxies at z>7 Ross McLure Institute for Astronomy, Edinburgh University.
Evidence of a Fast Evolution of the UV Luminosity Function of LBGs beyond z=6 from a wide and deep HAWK-I Survey Andrea Grazian INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico.
Finding z  6.5 galaxies with HST’s WFC3 and their implication on reionization Mark Richardson.
The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University.
From Avi Loeb reionization. Quest to the Highest Redshift.
Probing the Reionization Epoch in the GMT Era Xiaohui Fan (University of Arizona) Seoul/GMT Meeting Oct 5, 2010.
Spitzer Imaging of i`-drop Galaxies: Old Stars at z ≈ 6 Laurence P. Eyles 1, Andrew J. Bunker 1, Elizabeth R. Stanway 2, Mark Lacy 3, Richard S. Ellis.
Mark Dijkstra, PSU, June 2010 Seeing Through the Trough: Detecting Lyman Alpha from Early Generations of Galaxies ‘ Mark Dijkstra (ITC, Harvard) based.
Cosmos Survey PI Scoville HST 590 orbits I-band 2 deg. 2 !
A Steep Faint-End Slope of the UV LF at z~2-3: Implications for the Missing Stellar Problem C. Steidel ( Caltech ) Naveen Reddy (Hubble Fellow, NOAO) Galaxies.
High-Redshift Galaxies from HSC Deep Surveys Kazuhiro Shimasaku (University of Tokyo) 1. Galaxy Evolution 2. Dropout Galaxies and Lyman α Emitters 3. Observing.
Did Galaxies Reionize the Universe? Richard Ellis, Caltech CIFAR February 2010.
Galactic Astronomy 銀河物理学特論 I Lecture 3-2: Evolution of Luminosity Functions of Galaxies Seminar: Lily et al. 1995, ApJ, 455, 108 Lecture: 2011/12/12.
Big Bang f(HI) ~ 0 f(HI) ~ 1 f(HI) ~ History of Baryons (mostly hydrogen) Redshift Recombination Reionization z = 1000 (0.4Myr) z = 0 (13.6Gyr) z.
Deep Surveys for High-z Galaxies with Hyper Suprime-Cam M. Ouchi (OCIW), K. Shimasaku (U. Tokyo), H. Furusawa (NAOJ), & HSC Consortium ≲ ≳≲ ≳
Ultra-Deep Spectroscopy of Lyman Break Galaxies at z~6 Elizabeth Stanway University of Bristol (ex-UW Madison) Also: Andy Bunker, Karl Glazebrook, Richard.
A Search for High Redshift Galaxies behind Gravitationally Lensing Clusters Kazuaki Ota (Kyoto U) Johan Richard (Obs.Lyon), Masanori Iye (NAOJ), Takatoshi.
Galaxies at z~6: I- drop Photometric Selection and the GLARE Project STScI May Symposium 2004 Galaxies at z~6 I - drop Photometric Selection and the GLARE.
Star Formation History of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field Rodger Thompson Steward Observatory University of Arizona.
Multiwavelength AGN Number Counts in the GOODS fields Ezequiel Treister (Yale/U. de Chile) Meg Urry (Yale) And the GOODS AGN Team.
Galaxies at z=6-9 from the WFC3/IR Imaging of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field Presented By Kyle Burns AST 494 March 5, 2009.
Galaxies as Sources of Reionization Haojing Yan (Carnegie Observatories) Reionization Workshop at KIAA July 10, 2008 Haojing Yan (Carnegie Observatories)
Mitesh Patel Co-Authors: Steve Warren, Daniel Mortlock, Bram Venemans, Richard McMahon, Paul Hewett, Chris Simpson, Rob Sharpe
Epoch of Reionization  Cosmic Reionization: Neutral IGM ionized by the first luminous objects at 6 < z < 15 Evidence: CMB polarization (Komatsu+2009)
FIRST LIGHT IN THE UNIVERSE
Constraining Star Formation at z>7 Dan Stark (Caltech) Collaborators: Richard Ellis, Johan Richard, Avi Loeb, Eiichi Egami, Graham Smith, Andy Bunker,
Possibility of UV observation in Antarctica
IES Cargesse – 18 September 2012
Probing Reionization with Lyman Alpha Emitters Pratika Dayal
Constraints on Star Forming Galaxies at z>6.5
Presentation transcript:

Elizabeth Stanway (UW-Madison) Andrew Bunker (Exeter) Star Forming Galaxies at z>5: Properties and Implications for Reionization With: Richard Ellis (Caltech) Richard McMahon (IoA), Kevin Bundy, Tommaso Treu, Laurence Eyles, Mark Lacy, Amy Barger, Len Cowie Karl Glazebrook, Bob Abraham & the GLARE team

Outline Galaxies at z=6: I drop Selection Colour selection of galaxies Results from GOODS and the UDF Spectroscopic Follow Up GOODS sources - Results from Keck/DEIMOS GLARE - The Gemini Ly-  at Reionisation Era project Into the Infrared Wide-field Near IR surveys Results from Spitzer Implications for Reionisation The ionising background from i’-drop galaxies Finding reionising sources

Pushing to higher redshift- Finding Lyman break galaxies at z~6 : using i-drops. But problem: low z contaminants can have same i’-z’ colours

By selecting on rest-frame UV, get inventory of ionizing photons from star formation. i’-drops 5.6<z<7 But distant sources are: Faint (=> luminosity bias) Very compact

i.e. i.e. HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE Need:ResolutionSensitivity Low Background

HST/ACS Surveys: GOODS (2003) 300 arcmin 2 in b, v, i’, z’ z’ (10  ) ~ 27 AB ~100 i’-drops to this limit HUDF 11 arcmin 2 in b, v, i’, z’ z’ (10  ) ~ 28.5 AB ~50 i’-drops to this limit

The Luminosity Function of i’-drop Galaxies Use luminosity function to predict numbercounts Folds in selection function and effective volume due to luminosity bias Case 1 - No evolution in LF shape  *=  *(z=3) / 6 Case 2 - L*, ,  * all varying => Best fit LF is steeper, with brighter L*

The UV Luminosity Density History If only the bright end is considered, UV luminosity density falls sharply at z > 4 If integrating over LF, a steeper function gives only small decline in luminosity density with redshift. => Need to better constrain z=6 LF to understand UV photon budget

10-m Keck 8-m Gemini ESO VLTs

Spectroscopy I - Keck/DEIMOS Have targeted > 30 sources in GOODS-N, GOODS-S and HUDF Exposure times ~5-10 hours per mask, ~ ,000Å Redshifts found at 5.6<z<6.4, analysis ongoing Large contaminant fraction in early work - later improved Z=5.99 GOODS-S Source Bunker, Stanway, Ellis et al (in prep)

Spectroscopy II - GLARE in the UDF Gemini/GMOS spectroscopy of i’-drop sources in the HUDF > 35 hours on a single slitmask. ~45 targets. Campaigns in 2003 and 2004 F lim ~1.5x ergs s -1 cm -2 Detects continuum sources, and high EW Ly-  emission sources

The (very tentative) EW Distribution of GLARE Ly-alpha Emitters Detections Limits Note long high EW tail - Two distinct populations?

BlueRed UDF NICMOS - Deep but Small - J and H band - Isolate contaminants - Observed Near- IR => Rest frame Ultraviolet - Many i’-drops are very blue - Very young? - Unusual IMF?

Wide Field Near IR Surveys

Z H J A Survey around the HDFN The Number Density of Low Mass Stars Example candidates: Fields to follow: SSA13, SSA22, A370, LHNW, LH- N amongst others

Spitzer Detections of z=6 Galaxies - z=5.83 galaxy Detected in GOODS IRAC 3-4  m: Eyles, Bunker, Stanway et al.

m 3.6  m (AB) ~24 (~1microJy) For JWST/NIRSPEC: R=1000 S/N>10 in 100ksec Ca H&K, G-band, MgIb (vel disp)

Implications for Reionization From Madau, Haardt & Rees (1999) -amount of star formation required to ionize Universe (C 30 is a clumping factor). Assumes standard IMF, IGM properties etc.

Implications for Reionization To z’ AB =28.5 our UDF data has star formation at z=6 which is 3x less than that required AGN number density is too low. => Is this a puzzle? Solutions: We go down to 1M_sun/yr - but  may be steep (lots of low luminosity sources - forming globulars?) IGM may be warmer, more clumped, escape fraction may be high Cosmic variance can be very large - deep data from UDF IMF could be unusual - top heavy? IGM largely reionised already by this redshift

Narrow Band Imagers e.g. DAZLE - Dark Ages 'z' Lyman-alpha Explorer (IoA - Richard McMahon, Ian Parry; AAO - Joss Bland- Hawthorne Also: UKIDSS, FLAMINGOS, SALT-IR TMT, OWL etc. Next Steps: Further Into the IR

And in the longer term: JAMES WEBB SPACE TELESCOPE successor to Hubble (2013+)