The Interaction of Light and Matter Commonly drawn symbol for photon A more physically meaningful symbol for the photon as an energy wavepacket confined in space

Learning Objectives  Wave-like properties of light: Reflection, Refraction, Diffraction, and Interference  Particle-like properties of light: Photoelectric effect Compton effect  Wave-particle duality of light: Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space. Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.

Learning Objectives  Wave-like properties of light: Reflection, Refraction, Diffraction, and Interference  Particle-like properties of light: Photoelectric effect Compton effect  Wave-particle duality of light: Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space. Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Recall that light travels at a speed as predicted by Maxwell’s equation.  Recall also that light waves do not require a medium (a postulated luminiferous ether) in which to propagate.  The speed of light as given by Maxwell’s equation is for light propagating through a vacuum.  In a medium (air, water, glass, etc.), the (phase) speed of light can be smaller than c. As light propagates through a medium, it is absorbed and then reemitted by atoms. The time delay between the light being absorbed and then reemitted causes a slower-than-c speeds in a medium. (Note: that light travels at a speed slower than c in a medium does not violate one of the central hypothesis of special relativity that the speed of light is the same as seen from different inertial reference frames).

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Recall that light travels at a speed as predicted by Maxwell’s equation.  Recall also that light waves do not require a medium (a postulated luminiferous ether) in which to propagate.  The speed of light as given by Maxwell’s equation is for light propagating through a vacuum.  In a medium (air, water, glass, etc.), the (phase) speed of light can be smaller than c. As light propagates through a medium, it is absorbed and then reemitted by atoms. The time delay between the light being absorbed and then reemitted causes a slower-than-c speeds in a medium. (Note: that light travels at a speed slower than c in a medium does not violate one of the central hypothesis of special relativity that the speed of light is the same as seen from different inertial reference frames).

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction Swimming PoolMoon

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction Star Earth Image of Star

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction, diffraction Light diffracted by a straight edge

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction, diffraction, and most convincingly interference as demonstrated by the English scientist Thomas Young in 1803 in his famous double-slit experiment.

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Superposition principle for two (or more) waves travelling through the same medium at the same time: waves pass through each other without being disturbed, such that the net displacement of the medium at any point in space or time is equal to the sum of the individual wave displacements. Superposition Principle + =

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction, diffraction, and most convincingly interference as demonstrated by the English scientist Thomas Young in 1803 in his famous double-slit experiment.

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction, diffraction, and most convincingly interference as demonstrated by the English scientist Thomas Young in 1803 in his famous double-slit experiment.

Wave-Like Properties of Light  Light has wave-like properties. Like sound or water waves, light undergoes reflection, refraction, diffraction, and most convincingly interference as demonstrated by the English scientist Thomas Young in 1803 in his famous double-slit experiment.

Learning Objectives  Wave-like properties of light: Reflection, Refraction, Diffraction, and Interference  Particle-like properties of light: Photoelectric effect Compton effect  Wave-particle duality of light: Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space. Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.

The Photoelectric Effect  In 1887, the German physicist Heinrich Rudolf Hertz observed what is now known as the photoelectric effect.  When light shines on a metal surface, electrons are ejected from the surface: - if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light frequency increases the number of ejected electrons (current) - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons (current) Heinrich Rudolf Hertz, A current flows when one of the metal plates is exposed to light. metal plate evacuated tube

The Photoelectric Effect  Furthermore: -increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons (no need to change stopping voltage to prevent a current from flowing) -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons (need to increase stopping voltage to prevent a current from flowing)

The Photoelectric Effect  The photoelectric effect therefore shows that the energy of light depends on its frequency: -the incident light must exceed a threshold frequency before electrons are ejected -the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons depends on the frequency rather than the intensity of the incident light  In Maxwell’s equations, which describe light as electromagnetic waves, the energy of light depends only on the amplitude of its electric and magnetic fields, not frequency.  The energy per unit time per unit area carried by a light wave is (see §3.3): and if averaged over one cycle:

Blackbody Radiation  To derive theoretically the spectrum of blackbody radiation in 1900, the German physicist Max Planck imagined a perfectly conducting box filled with electromagnetic waves. These waves caused electrical charges in the walls of the box to oscillate. In turn, the oscillating charges radiated electromagnetic waves.  Electromagnetic waves with a frequency ν can be absorbed by an oscillator, causing it to oscillate at a frequency ν. In turn, the oscillator radiates electromagnetic waves at a frequency ν. Planck found that he could not reproduce the blackbody radiation curve if the oscillators were able to absorb or radiate energy of any arbitrary amount. Instead, Planck required the oscillators to only lose or gain energy in chunks, called quanta, of size hυ, for an oscillator of frequency ν.  Planck considered quantization as a purely formal assumption, with no physical implications for the nature of light.  (See Chap. 3 of textbook for a description of blackbody radiation, and notes posted on course website for a blackbody and theoretical work on reproducing the blackbody radiation curve.) Max Planck,

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: Can you now explain why, in the photoelectric effect, - electrons are ejected only if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency? - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons? -above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons? -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons?

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy:

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: Can you now explain why, in the photoelectric effect, - electrons are ejected only if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency? Minimum energy to eject an electron from the metal. - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons? -above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons? -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons?

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: Can you now explain why, in the photoelectric effect, - electrons are ejected only if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency? Minimum energy to eject an electron from the metal. - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons? More photons, more ejected electrons. -above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons? -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons?

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: Can you now explain why, in the photoelectric effect, - electrons are ejected only if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency? Minimum energy to eject an electron from the metal. - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons? More photons, more ejected electrons. -above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons? More photons but no change in energy per photon, so no change in kinetic energy of ejected electrons. -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons?

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: Can you now explain why, in the photoelectric effect, - electrons are ejected only if the incident light exceeds a certain threshold frequency? Minimum energy to eject an electron from the metal. - above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity increases the number of ejected electrons? More photons, more ejected electrons. -above this threshold frequency, increasing the light intensity does not increase the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons? More photons but no change in energy per photon, so no change in kinetic energy of ejected electrons. -increasing the light frequency increases the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons?More energetic photons, more energetic ejected electrons.

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: and explained the photoelectric effect in the following manner: -the incident photons must have sufficient energy (and therefore exceed a threshold frequency) to overcome the binding energy of the electron to the metal before electrons are ejected. What constitutes the binding energy?

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: and explained the photoelectric effect in the following manner: -the incident photons must have sufficient energy (and therefore exceed a threshold frequency) to overcome the binding energy of the electron to the metal before electrons are ejected. What constitutes the binding energy? Electrostatic forces of atomic nuclei.

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: and explained the photoelectric effect in the following manner: -the incident photons must have sufficient energy (and therefore exceed a threshold frequency) to overcome the binding energy of the electron to the metal before electrons are ejected. What constitutes the binding energy? Electrostatic forces of atomic nuclei. Collisions with atomic nuclei/electrons.

The Photoelectric Effect  Einstein, however, took Planck’s idea seriously. In 1905, Einstein proposed that light consists of a stream of massless particles called photons, each of which carries a quantum of energy: and explained the photoelectric effect in the following manner: -the incident photons must have sufficient energy (and therefore exceed a threshold frequency) to overcome the binding energy of the electron to the metal before electrons are ejected -the photon energy above the binding energy is transferred to the kinetic energy of the ejected electron. Increasing the light intensity (the number of incident photons per unit time per unit area) does not increase the kinetic energy, but only the rate, of the ejected electrons. Increasing the light frequency (the energy of each photon) increases the kinetic energy of the ejected electrons

Learning Objectives  Wave-like properties of light: Reflection, Refraction, Diffraction, and Interference  Particle-like properties of light: Photoelectric effect Compton effect  Wave-particle duality of light: Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space. Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.

The Compton Effect  While the interpretation of the photoelectric effect was still being debated, an even more convincing experiment was made showing that light behaves like particles when interacting with matter. Arthur H. Compton,  In 1922, the American physicist Arthur Holly Compton measured the effect of shining X-rays on a block of carbon. He found a fraction of the incident X-ray radiation was scattered at different angles θ, and furthermore that the wavelength of the scattered radiation shifted to longer wavelengths at larger angles θ. This effect is now known as the Compton effect. θ

The Compton Effect  Let us see if there is an explanation for the Compton effect if we describe light as electromagnetic waves.  The energy per unit time per unit area carried by an electromagnetic wave, averaged over one cycle, is 〈 S 〉 = E 0 B 0 /2μ o (see §3.3), and therefore depends only on the amplitude of its electric and magnetic fields. If the electromagnetic wave transfers a part of its energy to an electron, we would expect the amplitude of it electric and magnetic field to decrease, but for its wavelength to remain the same. θ

The Compton Effect  If as Einstein proposed light comprises massless photons, then from the Theory of Special Relativity the (linear) momentum carried by each photon is related to its energy by (c.f., Eq. 4.48, with m = 0).  Compton proposed that the incident photons transferred a part of their (linear) momentum to electrons, resulting in a loss of (linear) momentum and therefore energy, and consequently shifted to longer wavelengths. Recall

The Compton Effect  By applying the principles of conservation of both (relativistic) momentum and energy, Compton showed that the wavelength of the scattered X-rays is shifted by an amount as was observed.

The Compton Effect velocity of electron

The Compton Effect

Learning Objectives  Wave-like properties of light: Reflection, Refraction, Diffraction, and Interference  Particle-like properties of light: Photoelectric effect Compton effect  Wave-particle duality of light: Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space. Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.

Wave-Particle Duality of Light  Thus, light exhibits both wave-like and particle-like properties.  Light – in the form of electromagnetic waves – shows its wave-like properties as it propagates through space.  Light – in the form of photons – shows its particle-like properties as it interacts with matter.  If our eyes detect individual photons, why do we not see the world as “grainy?”

Wave-Particle Duality of Light

 By contrast, in observational astronomy, we are often photon starved: every photon is precious! The X-ray spectrum on the right is of the supernova Cassiopeia A from a 14-hr integration with the Chandra X-ray Observatory. Cassiopeia A Supernova Remnant in X-rays Note: Counts = number of detected photons

Wave-Particle Duality of Light  By contrast, in observational astronomy, we are often photon starved: every photon is precious!  At optical wavelengths, the human eye only detects ~3% (daytime) to ~10% (nightime) of incident photons. The best photographic plates detect ~10% of incident photons. By contrast, Charge Coupled Devices (CCDs) typically detect >90% of incident photons.