Consent Cease and Desist Order CCC-13-CD-03 and Restoration Order CCC-13-RO-03 Bacara Resort and Spa 8301 Hollister Avenue Goleta, Santa Barbara County 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-031

Regional Location Map Bacara Resort 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-032

CDP Special Condition 3 Avoid development on East Terrace Special Condition 10 Implement system of signs, clearly marking the location of public accessways, public parking areas, and the site’s physical and biological features Special Condition 14 Offer to dedicate easement and record deed restriction for public access and recreation over the property 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-033

Aerial View of Property Bacara Resort East Terrace Public Parking Lot 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-034

East Terrace, 1989 Copyright © 2004 Kenneth Adelman, California Coastal Records Project 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-035

East Terrace, 2013 Copyright © Google, /11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-036

Gate: Deterring use of public access and equestrian trail 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-037

Unpermitted Development 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-038

Definition of “Development” “’Development’ means, on land… placement of any solid material or structure; grading, removing;… or extraction of any materials;… change in the density or intensity of use of land;… construction, reconstruction, demolition or alteration of the size of any structure…; and the removal or harvesting of major vegetation other than for agricultural purposes…” 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-039

Basis for Issuance of Orders COASTAL ACT § (CEASE AND DESIST ORDER) 1.Development occurred without a permit or is inconsistent with any permit previously issued by the Commission COASTAL ACT § (RESTORATION ORDER) 1.Development occurred without a permit or is inconsistent with any permit previously issued by the Commission 2.The unpermitted development is inconsistent with the Coastal Act 3.The unpermitted development is causing continuing resource damage 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0310

Development is Inconsistent with Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0311 § § 30210, 30211, 30220, and (public access and recreation) § (archaeological resources)

Development is Inconsistent with Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act (cont.) 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0312 § (ESHA) § (geologic stability)

Development is causing “Continuing Resource Damage” 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0313

Terms of Proposed Consent Orders 4/11/2013 CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO Remove unpermitted development Cease and Desist from undertaking additional unpermitted development Cap the highly sensitive archaeological area and revegetate and restore impacted areas Resolve civil liabilities in payment of $575,000

Public Access/Signage Plan (within the terms of the proposed Consent Orders) 4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0315 Public Access/Recreation Improvements to Haskell’s Beach Open and maintain public bathrooms Operate public snack bar throughout the year Public Access and Interpretive Signs for: Public parking lot Public access trail system Haskell’s Beach Native plant, coastal bluff and beach habitats Historical presence and cultural significance of Chumash on site Public bathrooms Snack bar Off-site areas, directing public to public parking lot and trails

4/11/2013CCC 13-CD-03 & CCC 13-RO-0316