Parties and Party Systems Final reflections – future directions.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The catch-all thesis Original version of the essay, titled
Advertisements

Party Law Origins & impact. Terms of (dis)Union Confederation 60 Years On Wednesday, April 1, 7:30-9:30pm Inco Lecture Theatre – room IIC-2001 (All Welcome.
The General Education Program at Westmont
The National Voter Registration Act encouraged voting by A. Requiring states to allow election day registration B. Declaring election day a federal holiday.
Readings: Ware CH 2 and D/W CH 5.  What are supporters? Members? Activists?  What role do they play in the functioning of political parties?  How do.
Interest groups and policy- making. Final exam: Saturday, December 8 th 9:00-11:00 AA1043.
Parties and Party Systems Final reflections – future directions.
PRESIDENT PUTIN’S FEDERAL REFORMS Since 2000 – from ‘centered controlled federalism’ to ‘quasi federalism’(?) … the danger of the country disintegration.
“Linkage Institution”
Recently.... The IfA has began a major new initiative to establish an Academic Special Interest Group (SIG) The IfA Registered Organisations Committee.
About half of the people vote in American presidential elections, and even less in off year elections. Many believe it is do to voter apathy, and demand.
Chapter Seven: Interest Groups and Political Parties.
Election campaigning. Terms of (dis)Union Confederation 60 Years On Wednesday, April 1, 7:30-9:30pm Inco Lecture Theatre – room IIC-2001 (All Welcome.
Today’s Topics Parties and Parliamentary vs. Presidential Institutions 1.Electoral systems’ effects on other political values. 2.Political parties. 3.Parliamentary.
Parties today: What good are parties?. Reminder Research papers due Tuesday, March 31 st Research papers due Tuesday, March 31 st Remember that a good.
PS 134AA: COMPARATIVE POLITICS OF LATIN AMERICA, or DEMOCRATIZATION IN LATIN AMERICA Spring 2004 Peter H. Smith.
Parties, elections and the electoral systems Lubomir Kopecek CDK & Educational Initiatives, December 2011.
Related Issue 3 looks at the viability of liberalism So when we look at this related issue, we have to ask ourselves, how well have the underlying beliefs.
Forms of Party Organization Party Types: Why do parties organize in the ways that they do?
Introducing Government in America
JN302 BRITISH GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS NCTJ Public Affairs Central Govt: Joy Johnson Local Govt: Paul Francis
Introducing Government in America
Chapter 1 Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman. Edwards, Wattenberg, and Lineberry Government in America: People, Politics, and.
Writing Prompt Questions
Chapter 8: Political Parties
Parties and liberal democracy Party functions. Reminders/announcements Please sign up for list serv Please sign up for list serv Reserve readings: Reserve.
Thursday June 18th,  Legitimacy: ‘degree to which citizens accept the actions…of government [and] state actors’ ◦ Democratic Legitimacy  Representative.
Parties registered with Elections Canada (contest Canadian federal elections)with Elections Canada Political parties registered with Elections Ontario.
C HAPTER 1. Parties and Politics in America – An Overview American political parties are characterized by a number of contradictions: On the one hand:
Parties in the Canada and the United States Organization and Structure.
Civics Review. The Supreme Court decision referred to by the phrase “one person, one vote” made our state governments fairer by…
Calm Before the Storm? The 2007 Provincial Election and Beyond Wednesday, Oct. 24, 7-9pm, Room EN-2006 (Engineering lecture theatre – All Welcome) An engaging.
Presentation by Dr. Kevin Lasher. Government Intervention in Economy Govt. Intervention in Personal Matters FOR AGAINST AGAINST FOR LIBERALS CONSERVATIVES.
Political Parties and Party Systems Nov. 17. Overview Defining political parties Origins and political cleavages Functions of parties Models of party.
Q1. The politically relevant opinions held by ordinary citizens that they express openly.
Chapter 12: Political Parties by Richard S. Katz
Exchange Opportunities for IBML in Year 4. Welcome! Exchanges Team Elaine Collinson, Director of Undergraduate International Programmes Sheila Mills,
Party Law & the Public Finance of Elections. Final exam Friday, April 17 th Friday, April 17 th 9-11:00 p.m. 9-11:00 p.m. Location: SN2036 Location: SN2036.
Parties today: American parties Parties in new democracies.
Party organization and election campaigning North American and European Comparisons.
POSC 1000 Introduction to Politics Russell Alan Williams.
Chapter 9.  In 2003 Iraq held its first real election in more than 30 years?  Despite threats of terrorism there was a very good turn out to vote...
The Changing Role of Political Parties Answer Review.
Chapter 10 VOTING AND ELECTIONS. Elections and Democracy  Democratic control  Elections are essential for democratic politics.  Elections are the principal.
Both sides now: Party organization & membership: from the top down, from the bottom up.
Elections, Representation and Parliament Weekend 2 : Session 1.
Interest Articulation
POLICY- MAKERS. OFFICIAL POLICY- MAKERS Official policy-makers have the legal authority to engage in the formation of public policy. These include legislators,
Electoral systems and party systems: Further thoughts.
Chapter Five Interest Aggregation and Political Parties.
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman. Introducing Government in America Chapter 1 Edwards, Wattenberg, and Lineberry Government.
Elections, Parties, and the Party System Malcomlson & Myers, Chapter 9 & 10 What should a Parliament look like (not the buildings, the people)? Can use.
Forms of Political Participation Lobbying is the strategy by which organized interests seek to influence the passage of legislation by exerting direct.
Past paper mini essay questions Paper 2 Topic 3 Power.
Forms of Political Participation
Strengths and Weaknesses
Presentation prepared for ANDRAS Conference
Political Parties Chapter 12.
Political Parties Chapter Nine
Forms of Party Organization
When & how do party systems change?
Left-wing parties in European politics Current trends in European politics April 12th, 2018 Heikki Paloheimo
UNIT III- Political Beliefs
PARTY IDENTIFICATION.
Final exam Friday, April 17th 3-5:00 p.m. Location SN3042.
Political Parties and the United States
Political Participation
Although society has become more affluent, voter turnout has declined almost everywhere. Why? What can be done to foster higher turnout?
Political Parties: Introduction.
Presentation transcript:

Parties and Party Systems Final reflections – future directions

Final exam Friday, April 17 th Friday, April 17 th 9-11:00 p.m. 9-11:00 p.m. Location: SN2036 Location: SN2036 Format: Format: Part I One essay out of three (30%) Part I One essay out of three (30%) Part II One essay out two (30% Part II One essay out two (30% Part III One essay out of two (40%) Part III One essay out of two (40%) The exam will cover the entire course The exam will cover the entire course Be prepared to Be prepared to Elaborate arguments Elaborate arguments Demonstrate with reference to specific parties and party systems whether they are valid or not Demonstrate with reference to specific parties and party systems whether they are valid or not

The Department of Political Science Presents The (Re)Regulation of Global Finance – Understanding Canada’s Role in the G20 Dr. Russell Williams Department of Political Science Memorial University of Newfoundland Thursday April 9, 2009 SN203312:30-2:30pm

Academic Exchanges The Department of Political Science has academic exchanges with the University of Limerick or the University of Uppsala (Sweden) The Department of Political Science has academic exchanges with the University of Limerick or the University of Uppsala (Sweden) How it works: How it works: You spend one semester at the host university You spend one semester at the host university You pay MUN tuition You pay MUN tuition You transfer the credits back to MUN You transfer the credits back to MUN When? When? fall or winter, fall or winter, Who should go? Who should go? POSC students in their 3 rd year or beyond POSC students in their 3 rd year or beyond Students with an average of B or better Students with an average of B or better How? How? Talk to Dr. Wolinetz, Dr. Croci or Jeff Loder Talk to Dr. Wolinetz, Dr. Croci or Jeff Loder Apply by April 8 th Apply by April 8 th Applications available in POSC Dept. Office Applications available in POSC Dept. Office

Parties and Party Systems Final reflections – future directions

A decline of parties? An argument frequently made by journalists, as well as political scientists who are not parties specialists An argument frequently made by journalists, as well as political scientists who are not parties specialists Vigorously denied by parties specialists…who have a stake in denying it Vigorously denied by parties specialists…who have a stake in denying it

Supposition: Political parties are an ineluctable feature of liberal democracies: If they didn’t exist, someone would reinvent them If they didn’t exist, someone would reinvent them experience of post-communist systems experience of post-communist systems Needed to Needed to organize competition for office organize competition for office organize legislatures organize legislatures organize links between legislatures and the executive organize links between legislatures and the executive

Forms which parties take: Goodbye to the mass party and the party of mass integration Goodbye to the mass party and the party of mass integration Typically parties today are: Typically parties today are: Minimalist organizations Minimalist organizations intermittent and fluctuating membership intermittent and fluctuating membership Citizens and most members are remote Citizens and most members are remote Increasingly professional at the top Increasingly professional at the top May or may not be programmatic, depending on context, demands of members…. May or may not be programmatic, depending on context, demands of members….

Contemporary parties as organizations in tension Tension between Tension between governing functions, and governing functions, and representative & expressive functions representative & expressive functions Parties in government have to compromise, Parties in government have to compromise, In doing so, likely to disappoint followers…. In doing so, likely to disappoint followers…. Provides opportunities for Provides opportunities for Opposition parties Opposition parties New parties left, right, and centre… New parties left, right, and centre…

Otto Kirchheimer’s lament: a premonition? “To the older party of integration the citizen, if he so desired, could be closer. “To the older party of integration the citizen, if he so desired, could be closer. Then it was a less differentiated organization, part channel of protest, part source of protection, part purveyor of visions of the future. Then it was a less differentiated organization, part channel of protest, part source of protection, part purveyor of visions of the future. Now, in its linear descendant in a transfigured world, the catch-all party, the citizen finds a relatively remote, at times quasi-official and alien structure.” Now, in its linear descendant in a transfigured world, the catch-all party, the citizen finds a relatively remote, at times quasi-official and alien structure.”

Kirchheimer on party functions “The political party’s role … today is more limited than it would appear from its position of formal preeminence. “The political party’s role … today is more limited than it would appear from its position of formal preeminence. Via its governmental role it functions as a coordinator of and arbitrator between functional power groups. Via its governmental role it functions as a coordinator of and arbitrator between functional power groups. Via its electoral role it produces that limited amount of popular support and integration required from the popular masses for the functioning of official political institutions.” Via its electoral role it produces that limited amount of popular support and integration required from the popular masses for the functioning of official political institutions.”

Kirchheimer’s conclusion “No longer subject to the discipline of the party of mass integration… the voters may by their shifting moods and their apathy, transform the sensitive instrument of the catch-all party into something too blunt to serve as a link with the power-holders of society.”

Kirchheimer’s lament, cont’d “Then we come to regret the passing – even if it was inevitable—of the class-mass party and the denominational party, as we already regret the passing of other features of yesterday’s stage of Western civilization.”

Analysis and comment Considerably validity to Kirchheimer’s premonition Considerably validity to Kirchheimer’s premonition Parties, in some respects, are a pale shadow of what they once were Parties, in some respects, are a pale shadow of what they once were Parties remote from civil society Parties remote from civil society But But even if some are down, even if some are down, they are not out… they are not out…

Some things to think about: Many parties spend more money than they did before Many parties spend more money than they did before Many are formidable campaign machines Many are formidable campaign machines U.S. parties & especially their national campaign committees U.S. parties & especially their national campaign committees British parties…. British parties…. But these refer to parties in central offices, not political parties on the ground But these refer to parties in central offices, not political parties on the ground

Contemporary parties Parties on the ground a shadow of what they once were Parties on the ground a shadow of what they once were Difficulty Difficulty attracting and retaining members attracting and retaining members loyalty or affection of supporters loyalty or affection of supporters In contrast, parties in government office continue… and In contrast, parties in government office continue… and

Contemporary parties, cont’d Parties in central office not only thrive, but grow, but… Parties in central office not only thrive, but grow, but… Primarily as electoral-professional organizations (Panebianco) or parties in service to candidates (American national committees and also state parties) Primarily as electoral-professional organizations (Panebianco) or parties in service to candidates (American national committees and also state parties) Distant from their members (Katz and Mair, cartel hypothesis) Distant from their members (Katz and Mair, cartel hypothesis)

Implications for party systems Electorates far more weakly attached to parties than before, with the result that Electorates far more weakly attached to parties than before, with the result that A larger proportion of the electorate available either to A larger proportion of the electorate available either to Other established parties Other established parties New parties of different stripes, e.g. New parties of different stripes, e.g. Left libertarian (New Left, Green Parties…) Left libertarian (New Left, Green Parties…) New Right Populist Parties New Right Populist Parties Others as well Others as well

Consequences: Higher rates of electoral volatility (minimum percentage of the electorate shifting from one party to another between elections) Higher rates of electoral volatility (minimum percentage of the electorate shifting from one party to another between elections) Tendency for party spectra to become more crowded as new(er) parties squeeze in, expanding the range of alternatives available to voters Tendency for party spectra to become more crowded as new(er) parties squeeze in, expanding the range of alternatives available to voters

Is there a crisis? No, in the sense, that parties still operate and perform crucial functions in contemporary political systems Organize elections Organize elections Provide candidates Provide candidates Organize relations between executive and legislatures Organize relations between executive and legislatures

Crisis, cont’d Yes, in the sense that parties in older and newer democracies fail to channel or canalize popular preferences Citizens prefer alternate channels Citizens prefer alternate channels Advocacy groups Advocacy groups New social movements New social movements And potentially available to ‘anti’ parties as well as anti-democratic forces And potentially available to ‘anti’ parties as well as anti-democratic forces

Bottom line: Schattschneider’s dictum: “Without parties, no democracy” E.E. Schattschneider, Party Government Valid…. Valid…. or not? or not?

Final exam Friday, April 17 th Friday, April 17 th 9-11:00 p.m. 9-11:00 p.m. Location: SN2036 Location: SN2036 Part I One essay out of three (30%) Part I One essay out of three (30%) Part II One essay out two (30% Part II One essay out two (30% Part III One essay out of two (40%) Part III One essay out of two (40%) The exam will cover the entire course The exam will cover the entire course Be prepared to Be prepared to Elaborate arguments Elaborate arguments Demonstrate with reference to specific parties and party systems whether they are valid or not Demonstrate with reference to specific parties and party systems whether they are valid or not