1. 68th IETF, Prague, March 2007 Requirements for Manageability Sections in PCE Working Group Drafts draft-ietf-pce-manageability-requirements-01.txt Adrian Farrel (adrian@olddog.co.uk)

2. 68th IETF, Prague, March 2007 Changes Became a working group draft Jan 2007 Updated Feb 2007 –Addressed various comments on the mailing list New explanation “What is Manageability?” Expanded on the details for inclusion in each section Softened the “required” language Fixed typos

3. 68th IETF, Prague, March 2007 What are the Plans? Keep refining –Learn from experience Clarify what should be described in each section Add other recommended sections Retire unwanted sections –Give some concrete examples Strong encouragement to authors to act –Thorough review from chairs Draft might never go to RFC

4. 68th IETF, Prague, March 2007 Ops Area Parallel Work draft-harrington-operations-and- management-00 Advisory effort from Operations Area –Nothing mandated –Based on FCAPS model –Lots of additional advice and information Lots of overlap –Some of the text is identical :-) Lots of differences –May be ideas we can pick up

5. 68th IETF, Prague, March 2007 A Recent Issue for Debate Where do you stop? –Can we “mandate” management facilities that are out of scope for the working group? No, we cannot mandate –But as with security considerations, we should point out issues “This feature will be hard to manage unless something clever is done with the hardware” –We should joint the dots “This feature could be managed effectively by utilising the management features included in X”