1. National Institute of Building Sciences International Alliance for Interoperability Deke Smith, FAIA, Executive Director, buildingSMART alliance December 11, 2008 S608 Developing Guidelines for Determining When to Use ISO 16739 and ISO 15926

2. © 2008 NIBS National Institute of Building Sciences 1974 - Public Law 93-383, Sect. 809 –Bridge between Private and Public Construction –Non-governmental – Unique 501c3 Organization –Unique in that it represents all disciplines in industry Architects, Engineers, Contractors, Insurers, Unions, Manufacturers, Legal, Housing, Vendors, Owners, Consumers, State & Federal Government, Codes & Standards, andTesting –buildingSMART alliance is a council of the Institute –Formerly International Alliance for interoperability NIBS Related Products – –Construction Criteria Base –Whole Building Design Guide –National CAD Standard –National BIM Standard An Authoritative Source of Innovative Solutions for the Built Environment

3. © 2008 NIBS Agenda What are IFC’s (ISO 16739) What is ISO 15926 Why is this important Examples Next Steps and Plans for 2009

4. © 2008 NIBS Not The First To Experience Confusion

5. © 2008 NIBS IFC vs. XML is Not the Issue XML works well for file based exchange Document XML File IFC works better in server base models

6. © 2008 NIBS Background ISO TC184/SC4 This Sub-Committee of ISO is responsible for the development of standards for industrial automation systems and integration. These include: –ISO 10303 (STEP) concerned with product data representation and exchange –ISO 13584 (PLIB) concerned with parts libraries –ISO 15531 (MANDATE) concerned with industrial manufacturing management data –ISO 15926 oil and gas facilities life-cycle data –ISO 18876 (IIDEAS) concerned with integration of industrial data for exchange, access, sharing –ISO 18629 (PSL) defining a process specification language IAI has held A-liaison status with ISO TC184/SC4 since 1998. The IFC model uses several adapted parts of the ISO 10303 series of standards. In November 2002, the IFC 2x Platform was formally approved as ISO PAS 16739 IFC based on the ISO TC184/SC4 N1198 "Procedures for transposing externally developed specifications into ISO deliverables". In July 2008 IFC2x4 was submitted to ISO as a New Work Item for consideration as a full ISO standard and was accepted. It will be voted at some point in the near future.

7. © 2008 NIBS Graphic Relationships

8. © 2008 NIBS Scope of the Real Property Industry IAI-IFC Usage Space Natural Asset Linear Structure Structure Building Facility / Built Theatre / World Sub-Systems System Level Site Real Property Asset Country State / Province County Installation / Region Node Segment Room Space System Level Sub-Systems Room Water / Sea Land / Parcel Underground Air / Space Overlay Components City OGC ®

9. © 2008 NIBS Suggested Areas of Responsibility Space Natural Asset Linear Structure Structure Building Facility / Built Theatre / World Sub-Systems System Level Site Real Property Asset Country State / Province County Installation / Region Node Segment Room Space System Level Sub-Systems Room Water / Sea Land / Parcel Underground Air / Space Overlay Components City GIS TC 211 IFC ISO/PAS 16739 TC184/SC4 Process ISO 15926 TC184/SC4 ISO 16739 – Most buildings and many structures related to smaller scale projects ISO 15926 – Process industry including large infrastructure projects

10. © 2008 NIBS Appropriate Use Approach ISO 16739 (Industry Foundation Class) ISO 15926 (Process Industry)

11. © 2008 NIBS US Construction Snapshot - July 2007

12. © 2008 NIBS Comparison ISO 15926 Process plant related Life-cycle Large scale Infrastructure Used for design and analysis More schematic Oil & Gas related Manufacturers and suppliers Supported by major software vendors ISO 16739 (IFC) Facilities related Life-cycle Human scale Buildings Objects (IFC) Information Exchanges (IDM) Model Views (MVD) Dictionaries (IFD) Manufacturers and suppliers starting to participate Supported by major software vendors While it might be easier to have one standard, that is not practical or realistic as each has its role – Need to support both

13. © 2008 NIBS Product Lineup

14. © 2008 NIBS Think of this as ISO 15926 Refinery photograph by Onno Paap

15. © 2008 NIBS ISO 15926 – Process Analysis Example AVEVA PDMS 12.0

16. © 2008 NIBS ISO 15926 Example Compliments of Bentley OpenPlant

17. © 2008 NIBS ISO 15926 Example AVEVA PDMS 12.0

18. © 2008 NIBS FIATECH Is Leader in ISO 15926 http://ids-adi.org POSC Caesar – FIATECH Intelligent Data Sets – Accelerating Deployment of ISO15926 Realizing Open Information Interoperability Process and Instrumentation overview The model contains three independent representations Flow Topology Materials definitions Process Plant 3D model overview The model contains three independent views Spatial layout Topology Materials definitions

19. © 2008 NIBS ISO 15926 - PI&D Model ADI / IDS ISO-15926 P&ID model – Rev 2.0 – November 2008 © 2008 FIATECH. All rights reserved.

20. © 2008 NIBS ISO 15926 – 3D Model The main hierarchy of the Plant model is as follows: PlantInformation Specification ShapeCatalogue Site CableTray Component Equipment HVAC InstrumentComponent PipingSystem PipingNetworkSystem ProcessInstrument PipeSupport Plate Structure Framework StructuralSection Ceiling Floor Wall ADI / IDS ISO-15926 3D model – Rev 2.0 – November 2008 © 2008 FIATECH. All rights reserved.

21. © 2008 NIBS Think of this as IFC (ISO 16739)

22. © 2008 NIBS IFC Model Relationships

23. © 2008 NIBS IFC Based BIM Example GSA's US Courthouse, Eugene, OR Courtesy of Jeet Mahal, CMG Originally published in the October 2007 issue of Architectural Record.

24. © 2008 NIBS IFC Based BIM Example Rendering courtesy of Holder Construction

25. © 2008 NIBS Business Case: Letterman Digital Arts Center “Despite numerous design layout changes that were required by Lucas Film Ltd. due to company restructuring, the LDAC project was completed on time and below the estimated budget….over two hundred design and construction conflicts were identified, most of which were corrected before construction, resulting in an estimated savings of over $10 million on this $350 million project.” Courtesy of AECbytes "Building the Future" Article (September 30, 2006) Building Owners Driving BIM: The "Letterman Digital Arts Center" StoryMieczyslaw (Mitch) Boryslawski, Associate AIA Founder, View By View, Inc.

26. © 2008 NIBS Case Study: Lucas Films - School of Cinematic Art’s at USC The donor’s vision for the building: Architectural function and aesthetics are the highest priority. The building should exist for the next 100 years. All design should be coordinated through the use of a “3D” model. At completion, USC will have a fully integrated BIM model.

27. © 2008 NIBS Case Study: Lucas Films - School of Cinematic Art’s at USC

28. © 2008 NIBS Proposal Proposed approach –Don’t need to select a winner or loser – identify market segment and make recommendation –Suppliers can provide objects with either standard – not both Depending on the market segment of the product Example a valve manufacturer –ISO 15926 – 50” Gate Valve –ISO 16739 – ½” Hose Bib –Software and models must read and work with both Similar to JPEG, TIFF, GIF, etc. There will be preferred formats for specific tasks just as with graphics.

29. © 2008 NIBS Next Steps Stay the Course –FIATECH Focus on 15926 Harmonizing with IFC as appropriate –BuildingSMART alliance Continue coordination on all fronts relying on expertise of each group Focus on documenting business process and innovative to-be models COMMUNICATION

30. © 2008 NIBS Standard: NBIMS V1 P1 Delivered Dec 27, 2007 International Core National Specific –OmniClass Information Exchange Concepts Standard Development Process Information Assurance Capability Maturity Model References and Appendices Over 30 contributors 380,000+ Downloads

31. © 2008 NIBS Sample Products of the Alliance Products related to the Alliance www.buildingsmartalliance.org Products related to the Alliance www.buildingsmartalliance.org

32. © 2008 NIBS Why Join the Alliance? Participate in projects defining the future Leverage your implementation cost Reduce risk and time in implementation Learn from others successes and failures Obtain the latest practice information Attain a greater understanding of BIM Understand what is possible and what is not Don’t re-invent the wheel Identify others using BIM Lead don’t follow © M.A. Mortenson Company

33. © 2008 NIBS buildingSMART alliance Benefits Over 50 active open standards projects –NBIMS Development –AECOO Testbed (Cost & Energy) –Education baseline and projects –International (ifc, IDM, MVD, IFD) Products are free based on Sponsorships Sponsors $25K and above become International Members Speakers Bureau Conferences Workshops Local Interest Groups Magazine Web Site

34. © 2008 NIBS Questions? Deke Smith dsmith@nibs.org (202) 289-7800

35. © 2008 NIBS Thank You Deke Smith dsmith@nibs.org (202) 289-7800

36. © 2008 NIBS Copyright Materials This presentation is protected by US and International Copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission of the speaker is prohibited. Copyright 2008© AEC Infosystems, Inc | Onuma, Inc. Crate & Barrel | buildingSMART alliance National Institute of Building Sciences McGraw-Hill Construction Faithful & Gould | Reed Construction Data Gehry Technologies | Jacobs Engineering | Mortenson Sydney Opera House Dale Davis, Associate AIA and LEED, Jtec HCM, Inc Wiley, 4Site Press Cannot be used for any other purposes unless authorized by creator