1. European Biogas Association Introduction – EBCS Kick-off meeting Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

2. BIO methane as SU stainable R enewable F uel Horizon 2020 project initiated by EBA 7 countries: AT, BE, DE, FR, HU, IT, UK 3 years: 2015 – 2017 To address all important issues related to developing the European biomethane industry and market www.biosurf.eu

3. Three pillars of cross-border biomethane administration 1. Sustainability verification (covering production) prior to grid injection and cross-border transfer of sustainability claim 2. Recognition of the European natural gas network for single logistical facility with regard to biomethane injected into the grid. 3. Mass balancing of injected and withdrawn biomethane in the European natural gas network Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

4. Cross-border transfer of sustainability claims The sustainability verification for biomethane injected into the European natural gas network for export purposes should consist of two steps : 1) the first part of the chain of custody – from raw material supplies through production/upgrading till grid injection – will be covered by one of the established sustainability verification procedures, exactly like in case of liquid biofuels, 2) the second part of chain of custody – from the moment of grid injection till the withdrawal by the end-user – will be covered by the new voluntary scheme applying the mass balancing methodology

5. Proposed solution for cross-border mass balancing and transfer of sustainability claim Special purpose „Non-typical” voluntary scheme Provisional name: European Biomethane Certification Scheme Function: mass balancing of biomethane distributed along the European natural gas network To be recognised by the Commission under the RED Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

6. EBCS will not act on domestic biomethane markets, issue Guarantees of Origin, be involved in certification of sustainability of biomethane production, issue Certificates of Sustainability, be a trading platform of GoO’s. Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

7. EBCS will be the Europe-wide recognised organisation for administering and mass balancing volumes of biomethane virtually distributed along the European natural gas network, rely on the national biomethane registries as primary source of documentation, follow jointly agreed procedures for issuing and cancelling Guarantees of Origin for consignments with export destinations, provide for cross-border transfer of sustainability claims (GHG emission characteristics) attached to the consignments Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

8. From the comments received Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016 … very willing to support any initiate to start a harmonized European market on biomethane (DE) … ready to support the objective of the initiative to enable cross-border trade of biomethane (FI, NL) … ready and willing to collaborate actively on establishment of such a scheme (DK, NL) …interested in active participation in the establishment and operation of the scheme (CH)

9. From the comments received Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016 It must be ensured that the scheme is based upon and developed in close collaboration with existing national registries. (AT, DE, DK, NL) Sustainability certification should be voluntary - not mandatory as proposed (AT, DE, DK) The scheme should facilitate international trade for all end uses of biomethane (DK) We remain prepared to cover our own costs (human resources, travel and administrative expenses, etc.) (CH, NL) The level of commitment depends on the structure and direction EBA and other affiliated partners are choosing (DE)

10. Let’s start exchanging views! Dr. Kovács Attila European Biogas Association kovacs@european-biogas.eu Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

11. Berlin, 19 th January, 2016 Back-up files

12. Three questions to the participants: 1. Readiness to support the initiative? 2. Readiness in active participation in the establishment and operation of the scheme (offering assets, expertise, knowledge)? 3. Readiness to provide financial contribution to the costs of establishment and operation of the scheme? Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

13. Existing biomethane registries AT: Biomethan Register Austria CH: Federation of Swiss Gas Industry DE: Biogasregister DK: Energinet FR: Gaz Réseau Distribution FI: Gasum NL: Vertogas UK: Green Gas Certification Scheme Biomethane Certification Scheme Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

14. Potential partners National biomethane registries National biogas associations European natural gas industry associations Natural gas companies with biomethane activity EBA company members (AD and upgrading technology suppliers) Biomethane trading companies Recognised voluntary schemes involved in certification of sustainability of biomethane production Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

15. Suggested administrative solution As the potential solution the BIOSURF project suggests an Annex to COM 2010/C 160/01 which would address the following biomethane related issues : 1. recognition of the European natural gas network as a closed logistical facility with regard to mass balancing of biomethane injected for export, 2. definition of European natural gas network (with respect to mass balancing), 3. sustainability verification for biomethane to be completed through mass-balancing in the European natural gas network Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016

16. Introduction Value of biomethane: physical (in use) value + intrinsic („bio”) value Physical value: corresponds to prevailing market value of natural gas Intrinsic value: „green”, renewable, sustainable The intrinsic value can be quantified (GHG emission data) The intrinsic value must be realised on the market, in case of international trade it must be transferred cross-border Conditions for biomethane export/import: The „bio” quality must be certified in the producer country The „bio” qualification from the producer country must be acknowledged in the consumer country Berlin, 19 th January, 2016

17. The arts of biomethane trade Berlin, 19 th January, 2016

18. National biomethane registries Are needed in every biomethane producing country Independent, neutral, professional organisations Established through government actions or voluntary cooperation of market players (preferably with government mandate) Track, confirm and document the biomethane transactions along the contractual chain Administrative support in meeting regulative requirements Independent audit controls Assisting development of trade through building market confidence Berlin, 19 th January, 2016

19. European biomethane grid BioCH 4 value = physical value + intrinsic value BioCH 4 grid = NG grid + mass balancing European natural gas grid to bring the physical value to the market + Administrative system for transferring the intrinsic value from the producer country to the consumer country (applying the mass balancing method) Nürnberg, 15 th February, 2016