1. The current status report for IEEE 3D Human Factor WG(P3333.1.1/2) May 19, 2015 Chair: Sanghoon Lee, Yonsei University Secretary: Jae Keun Kwak, Korea Electronics Association

2. 3D Human Factor Working Group 2

3. Working Group History > Entity-based IEEE-SA PAR submission: Feb. 18, 2011 IEEE-SA CAG approval: Mar. 7 – 8, 2011 IEEE-SASB approval: Mar. 29 – 31, 2011 WG - Call for participation: May. 27, 2011 Type of ballot : Entity Entity members: LG Electronics, Korea Telecom (KT), Korea Electronics Association (KEA), Huawei, Mitsubishi Electronic, Electronics and Telecommunications Research Institute (ETRI) 3  1 st meeting in Seoul (Palace hotel) / June 14, 2011  2 nd meeting in Seoul (Palace hotel) / Sep. 6, 2011  3 rd meeting in Seoul (Palace hotel) / Dec. 19, 2011  4 th meeting in Seoul (KEA) / April, 10, 2012  5 th meeting in Seoul (ETRI) / July, 27, 2012  6 th meeting in Seoul (Kintex) / Oct. 10, 2012  7 th meeting in Seoul (Silconfile) / Jan. 11, 2013

4. Working Group History > Indi.-based Type change of ballot : Entity  Individual (Mar. 6, 2013) Revised P3333.1.1 & new P3333.1.2 approved : Mar. 27, 2014 Current individual members: 17 nations, 71 members  (Active) Korea, UK, France, China, Japan, Malaysia, Taiwan *) For more detailed information, please refer to the WG roster  8 th meeting in Seoul (Masterimage 3D) / Apr. 4, 2013  9 th meeting in Seoul (Yonsei Univ.) / Jun. 11, 2013  10 th meeting in Seoul (KEA) / Sep. 26, 2013  11 th meeting in Seoul (TOZ Center) / Dec. 17, 2013  12 th meeting in Seoul (TOZ Center) / Apr. 16, 2014  13 th meeting in Seoul (TOZ Center) / Sep. 26, 2014  14 th meeting in London (Kingston Univ.) / Oct. 31, 2014  15 th meeting in Seoul (TOZ Center) / Jan. 26, 2015  16 th meeting in Shanghai (Shanghai Univ.) / Mar. 27, 2015

5. Liaison & Collaboration IEEE-SA P3333 and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11 - (Nov. 7)  Establishment of Category C Liaison Video Quality Expert Group (VQEG) - (Nov. 11, 2011) ISO-TC 159 WG12 – 3D Quality Assessment ITU-T SG9  Subjective assessment methods for 3D video quality

6. MarJunSepDecMarJunSepDecMarJunSepDec 201320142015 Subjective 3D test methodology 3D Discomfort Assessment of Stereo Images 3D Discomfort Assessment of Stereo Videos 3D Perceptual Quality Assessment Mod. PAR WD v2.0 WD v4.0 * WD : Working Draft SB : Sponsor Ballot Request AP : IEEE-SASB(RevCom) Approval PB : Publication MT : Standards Maintenance CfP : Call for Proposal AP MT Mod. PAR WD v1.0 SBAP Objective Visual Discomfort Model Evaluation using IEEE-SA Stereo Image Database (Visual Discomfort) CfP P3333.1.1(PAR ) P3333.1.2(PAR ) Objective Visual Discomfort Model Evaluation using IEEE-SA Stereo Video Database I (Visual Discomfort) PAR approved 1 st SB Objective Perceptual Quality Model Evaluation Using IEEE-SA Stereo Video Database II (Perceptual Distortion) 2 nd SB Roadmap (C/SAB/P3333.1_WG) PB

7. Scope Separation of P3333.1(Original) P3333.1.1  Standard for the Quality of Experience (QoE) and Visual Comfort Assessments of Three Dimensional (3D) Contents based on Psychophysical Studies Visual saliency prediction method Visual contents analysis method – Spatial characteristics of 3D contents – Temporal characteristics of 3D contents Subjective assessment method – Continuous assessment methodology – Paired comparison methodology P3333.1.2  Standard for the Perceptual Quality Assessment of Three Dimensional (3D) Contents based on Physiological Mechanisms Saliency variation according to the 3D distortions Quality assessment based on stereopsis, binocular rivalry and suppression 7

8. Publication Ready – P3333.1.1 Root PAR: P3333.1 (31-Mar-2011)  2 nd revised PAR Approval Date: 27-Mar-2014  Previous Title: Standard for the Quality Assessment of Three Dimensional (3D) Displays, 3D Contents and 3D Devices based on Human Factors  Revised Title: Standard for the Quality Assessment of Three Dimensional (3D) Contents based on Psychophysical Studies Project Timeline  1 st Sponsor Ballot: 30-Sep-2014 to 30-Oct-2014  2 nd Sponsor Ballot: 19-Dec-2014 to 03-Jan-2015 (Recirculation)  Submission to RevCom : 06-Feb-2015  IEEE-SASB Approval : 1Q-2015  Preparation for publication : 2Q-2015 (Final Editorial Work) 8

9. Working Items – P3333.1.2 Request new PAR (06-Nov-2013)  PAR Approval Date: 27-Mar-2014  PAR Expiration Date: 31-Dec-2018  Title: Standard for the Perceptual Quality Assessment of Three Dimensional (3D) Contents based on Physiological Mechanisms Project Timeline  Developing a Working Draft: Until 31-Sep-2015  1 st Sponsor Ballot Request: 31-Oct-2015  Recirculation (if necessary): 30-Nov-2015  Submission to RevCom : 31-Dec-2015  IEEE-SASB Approval : 1Q-2016 9

10. New item to be proposed – P3333.1.3 Proposed PAR : P3333.1.3  Title : Standard for the Quality of Experience (QoE) and Human Safety for 3D, HD and UHD contents  Scope : This standard establishes methods of contents analysis for quantifying quality of experience (QoE) and proposes human safety recommendations regarding viewer, display, and viewing environment on 3D, high definition (HD), and ultra-high definition (UHD) contents. The purpose of this standard is to define some objective models for QoE, and establish guidelines for reducing risks to users entertaining realistic contents over 3D, HD, UHD, HMD and portable devices Project Timeline  PAR Request : 30-Jun-2015  PAR Approval : 3Q-2015

11. 3D Video Database Construction Database Server  http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/3dhf/ Please click on the ‘Stereoscopic (3-D imaging) Database’ link. 11

12. 26 indoor and outdoor natural scenes with FHD size Five types of distortion with five levels ① JPEG compression ② JP2000 compression ③ Additive white Gaussian noise ④ Gaussian blur ⑤ Transmission distortion over a fast-fading model Totally, 650 (26 x 25) pairs Stereo Image Database

13. The 17 th IEEE 3D Human Factor WG(P3333.1) Meeting  Date : June 29, 2015  Location: Torino in Italy  Subject : P3333.1.2 & new proposal (1.3) The 18 th IEEE 3D Human Factor WG(P3333.1) Meeting  Date : July 2015  Location: Lisbon in Portugal  Subject : P3333.1.2 & new proposal (1.3) The 19 th IEEE 3D Human Factor WG(P3333.1) Meeting  Date : October 2015  Location: Seoul in Korea  Subject : P3333.1.2 & new proposal (1.3) Next meeting schedule